Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Nevilledog

(51,160 posts)
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 12:29 PM Sep 2020

Trump has repeatedly questioned why Americans who served in Vietnam went to war

https://www.cnn.com/2020/09/05/politics/trump-vietnam-war/index.html

(CNN)President Donald Trump has repeatedly questioned why Americans who served in Vietnam went to war, according to someone who has heard him make the remarks.

The President, who received a draft deferment for bone spurs, has suggested in those conversations that Vietnam veterans didn't know how to exploit the system to get out of serving.

Men between the ages of 18-26 had to serve in the military for 21 months under the draft unless they were given a deferment. In January 1973, once the US ended its direct involvement in Vietnam, the US announced it was going to an all-volunteer army. In 1975, President Gerald Ford signed a proclamation ending the requirement for men to register for the draft.

Trump has also questioned, generally, the point of going to war in Iraq and Afghanistan, given his belief those wars were ill-advised. The President has wondered aloud "what did they get out of it?," the same source told CNN.

*snip*


15 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Trump has repeatedly questioned why Americans who served in Vietnam went to war (Original Post) Nevilledog Sep 2020 OP
you are proud of your ignorace arnt you? AllaN01Bear Sep 2020 #1
I Never Had Much Use For People Dodging The Draft, Ma'am The Magistrate Sep 2020 #2
Yup. And it's not like he was a conscientious objector, just couldn't see how it would help HIM. Nevilledog Sep 2020 #3
Like the theme song of his show: MONey.moneymoneymoneyMONey. fierywoman Sep 2020 #4
I, too, question the value of Iraq, Vietnam, and long-term Afghanistan. BUT . . . . . . Hoyt Sep 2020 #5
Incredible thing to ask for one who was there at the time. DFW Sep 2020 #6
Actually. Blue_true Sep 2020 #9
I turned 18 before that DFW Sep 2020 #15
K&R Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Sep 2020 #7
My brother was drafted and sent to Vietnam flotsam Sep 2020 #8
I came from a poor family. Blue_true Sep 2020 #10
I really respect that flotsam Sep 2020 #11
My brother that was a Marine got sprayed with Agent Orange regularly because Blue_true Sep 2020 #13
And this part in particular hurts like hell flotsam Sep 2020 #12
Yes. Every time I relate what he told us, I get angry. Blue_true Sep 2020 #14

AllaN01Bear

(18,318 posts)
1. you are proud of your ignorace arnt you?
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 12:36 PM
Sep 2020

2 words as the artical said , selective service draft . they were ordered to yo goof ball.

The Magistrate

(95,248 posts)
2. I Never Had Much Use For People Dodging The Draft, Ma'am
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 12:36 PM
Sep 2020

I considered the war stupid, pointless and cruel, and joined protests against it. But for everybody who slipped the summons, whether by continued studentry or dummied up medical excuses, some poor greaser or black kid was taken up instead, and without even receiving the bounty an evader had to pay a substitute in the first draft during the Civil War.

 

Hoyt

(54,770 posts)
5. I, too, question the value of Iraq, Vietnam, and long-term Afghanistan. BUT . . . . . .
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 12:46 PM
Sep 2020

Also question those who joined up all gungho to kill Asians and Muslims, particularly the innocent, like they were our enemy.

But, everyone else -- especially draftees in Vietnam -- were victims or misguided politics, militarism, saw the military as a way out of poverty or a better education, etc. They weren't losers of suckers.

DFW

(54,420 posts)
6. Incredible thing to ask for one who was there at the time.
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 12:47 PM
Sep 2020

You didn't have a lot of options.
1. You had a deferment
2. You fled the country, risking certain arrest if you returned
3. You tried to convince the draft board they shouldn't take you (see "Alice's Restaurant" )
4. You got inducted, and went where they sent you
5. You saw they were going to take you, and you pre-empted them by enlisting

I was #1 (last year they allowed college student deferments).
Some guys I knew were category #4.
My brother in law was category #3 (he was German, but they had compulsory military service for men at the time).
One friend of mine was category #5: he flunked out of college (lazy, not stupid), and knew he was going to get drafted. So, he enlisted in the Air Force, and emphasized that he spoke German and Russian (true). They sent him to the military spy school in Syracuse, NY, and posted him in what was then West Berlin to eavesdrop on and record Soviet Air Force radio communications. Some of the things he had to record were out of a George Carlin comedy routine, I swear. They were required to record and transcribe word for word and translate into English the communications they listened in on, and some of them were hilarious. The Soviets may have been dangerous with their nuclear weapons, but their Air Force was sometimes straight from the Keystone Cops.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
9. Actually.
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 07:55 PM
Sep 2020

When a male reached the age of 18, he had to go to the selective service board in his town and register for the Draft. His name went into the Draft Lottery. One of two things happened in the Lottery, a person either got a number that required that they go into a military branch immediately unless they got a deferment, or a person drew a number that put him into an un-drafted reserve status and that 18 year old could continue with life as it was unless his number was activated at some point during the future - so there was a way to not get drafted that didn’t involve a deferment or going to Canada.

How do I know that stuff? I was one of 9 male kids in my family. I was the oldest of the four youngest males. Of my five older brothers, four got drafted, two failed the physical and two served, one as a Paratrooper and one as a Marine. I turned 18 just as the US was heading toward ending the Draft, but because that had not happened, I had to register and have my name put into the Draft Lottery, I drew a deferment number, which made my Mom happy because she wanted me to go to college (which I did, going on to earn an Engineering Degree). Even though I drew a deferment number, the letter from the Draft Board advised me to keep the number with me, because I could get called in the future - that didn’t happen, the Draft and every thing associated with it ended less than a year later.

DFW

(54,420 posts)
15. I turned 18 before that
Sun Sep 6, 2020, 03:54 AM
Sep 2020

I got my S2 deferment in 1970, and it's a good thing, because with a number of 53 for guys born in 1952, I was sure to get inducted the moment I graduated, and I was class of 1974. Fortunately, the draft ended a year before I graduated. Just in case, by that time, I was near-fluent in Swedish, and might well have made use of it.

flotsam

(3,268 posts)
8. My brother was drafted and sent to Vietnam
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 07:05 PM
Sep 2020

There he was sent to the far north and spent a year in combat with the 101st Airborne...
Why did he go? Well his father and 5 of 7 uncles served in WW2 and Korea. One more was too young and the other had a heart condition. My family was middle class without connections...It was serve or run to Canada disgracing the family. He fought and killed not for an abstraction but for the survival of the guys on either side of him.
What did he get out of it? Simple pride and friends he still talks with after 50 years. Also he tells me the right to piss on Trump's grave should he outlive him.
Good enough, Donnie?

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
10. I came from a poor family.
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 08:17 PM
Sep 2020

But two of my uncles had served in the military, one in the Army as a young Black draftee guarding German POWs that were treated better than him. The other was younger and didn’t see wartime service, but got drafted and did his hitch with the Navy. Four of my five older brothers got drafted, two failed physicals legitimately, two served. The two that served were in when Trump was getting deferments, the younger of the two did 4 combat tours in Vietnam as part of a Marine forward howitzer crew. I have three younger relatives that are in the military now, all of them career, one is a Master Sargent in the Army, a second a Master Chief in the Navy and the third youngest of the three in Army Officer Candidate School.

flotsam

(3,268 posts)
11. I really respect that
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 08:33 PM
Sep 2020

The guy who did four tours is insane and I hope he was rewarded with a ton of promotions and a great career. My brother was the family guy in the sweet spot to get hosed. He came home whole but changed. He turned the thing into a 30 year career as a firefighter. I joined for 2 years with a promise to stay in the states and it worked. I maxed their tests and turned wrenches on Hueys in the Rockies...But only because two years of having my ass owned was what you chose when the possible alternative was worse. I don't regret it but I do resent that Donnie didn't have to make the choice most of our generation had to. It helped make him the garbage heap of a human he is. Your entire family is to be commended.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
13. My brother that was a Marine got sprayed with Agent Orange regularly because
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 08:45 PM
Sep 2020

of his job, sometime because pilots may have wanted to get kicks out of spraying gunnery crews and other forward troops. No one knew how dangerous that stuff was. My brother passed away 21 years ago as a man in his forties after years of physical and mental decline, all the while with the Pentagon denying that Agent Orange was responsible for killing troops that were exposed to lots of it.

I am very proud of my younger relatives also. I am not anti-military, though I believe that we can and should be spending a lot less of some aspects of it while properly supporting troops and Vets that enlist and serve.

flotsam

(3,268 posts)
12. And this part in particular hurts like hell
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 08:36 PM
Sep 2020

"one in the Army as a young Black draftee guarding German POWs that were treated better than him." I pray were going to an America that is better than that.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
14. Yes. Every time I relate what he told us, I get angry.
Sat Sep 5, 2020, 08:54 PM
Sep 2020

But he was never bitter, he realized those times were different than the ones he eventually lived. I see that things are better now, two of my younger relatives are at the second highest enlisted rank in their respective branches now and a third was encouraged by his superior officers to go to Officer Candidate School. So things are better, stuff like that is why I take a nuanced view of our nation’s history, it has been really bad and there is systemic racism now, but the lot of Black people is a lot better now than it was for my uncle when he was young and for a good part of his early adult life.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Trump has repeatedly ques...