General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsClorox bleach-scented water
Last edited Wed Oct 10, 2012, 12:22 AM - Edit history (3)
Played a little game in the bleach aisle today. It started when I picked up a bottle of Clorox bleach and it spilled on me, having been opened by someone before. I wiped my hands off, and suddenly had a memory from childhood of spilling bleach on myself. Back then, when you spilled bleach on your hands, you knew you had to rinse them off immediately with water. Your fingers got slippery the way they do when they are assaulted by a strong base, and you worried about your skin. This time? Nothing. It wiped off like water and left only a mild, clean sort of smell. It felt like water....because it was mostly water.
Looked for the concentrations of sodium hypochlorite in the various bleaches. The grocery store brand stated clearly on the label, 6 percent.
Looked at the store "value brand," which was a little more than half the price of the regular store brand. It was a three percent concentration, which means that it was actually *more* expensive for the active ingredients, but those who don't figure that out get to lug home an extra half-gallon of water for their cash.
But the biggest surprise was Clorox, which did not even have the percentages listed on the products on the shelf. Instead, they had a phone number and a nice little note to call if you want to know what is inside.
So I went home and looked up their website. On the pages for each type of bleach, they provide a listing of the ingredients and indicate that they are listed in order of highest to lowest concentration. But they don't give the concentrations there, either.
So I called the Clorox company using a number I found online. There were about eight options for departments, starting with "Investor Relations," but none of them seemed right for getting information about the products. Finally chose one of them and from there was transferred to a customer feedback line, where I spoke to a very nice young woman who informed me that there are "several concentrations" depending on the type of bleach.
The scented bleaches, for example, contain just 2.75 percent sodium hypochlorite. She informed me that bleaches that are "disinfecting" will have the word "disinfecting" on the label, along with a labeled concentration of at least 6 percent. Any bleach without the word "disinfecting" on the label has a lower concentration and does not claim to disinfect.
They are also now selling a (more expensive) "concentrated" brand (about 8 percent) that I suspect is closer to what was sold as regular bleach years ago. The representative said she wasn't sure what the concentrations were years ago.
I let her know my thoughts: that consumers tend to assume that the label "Clorox Bleach" contains a certain product....and that it is a rather slick word game to rely on customers to know that they need to find the word "disinfecting" on the label of a bottle of bleach in order to be assured that it will actually contain what we expect bleach to contain. I suggested that it might be more honest to label all the variations that have been watered down as "DILUTED." At the very least, I told her, the company should put the percentages on all the labels.
And that's the report from your fellow lootee for today.
Grandcanyon99
(3 posts)Thank you for taking the time and letting us know.
immoderate
(20,885 posts)--imm
louis-t
(23,295 posts)I thought bleach was bleach. What was I thinking?
fasttense
(17,301 posts)I noticed the other day my Hellmans mayo was constantly falling off the knife before I made it to the sandwich. I looked inside it it was all runny. I thought I had left it out too long. But the new jar was just as runny. So I did some research on line.
It turns out Hellmans, a premium brand at a premium price, is now increasing the amount of water in the mayo. Look at the ingredients label. The 2nd ingredient is no longer eggs but water. It use to be oil, eggs then water. It is now oil water then eggs.
My husband is Southern and would eat no other mayo. Since I showed him what Hellmans has done, he is on the look out for a better quality mayonnaise. I may have to make it myself.
unc70
(6,114 posts)We always thought Hellmans was runny, even 50 years ago. Thought it was only one step above salad dressing, an insult for most of us.
Anyway, try Dukes and see what you think. It has a slightly different taste that is deliberate. Still has water as third ingredient.
sammytko
(2,480 posts)fasttense
(17,301 posts)Anyway, thanks for the advice about Dukes. I see it has eggs NOT water as its 2nd ingredient.
It is easy to make your own mayo especially if you have your own food processor.
There are lots of video's on line to show you exactly how to do it
HiPointDem
(20,729 posts)woo me with science
(32,139 posts)Thanks for the information. I grow so weary of being cheated, again and again and again...
louis-t
(23,295 posts)They think no one notices when they cut the number of teabags to 20 from 24, or the tuna can goes from 7 oz. to 6.5, to 6, to 5 oz. ("we took out mostly water" I was told-LIARS). I asked "How long until we are buying 1 oz. cans of tuna?"
spanone
(135,838 posts)lpbk2713
(42,757 posts)Ed to add ... I just checked the latest jug of bleach I bought. It is Publix store brand, regular kind (not scented or anything else). The label says it is 6% solution. I guess I'll be buying the Publix store brand from now on. Thanks again, I never thought there was much difference before I read your OP.
sl8
(13,779 posts)Take the rest of the day off.
happerbolic
(140 posts)Last edited Tue Oct 9, 2012, 09:38 PM - Edit history (1)
...if i forget to check labels
BlueState
(642 posts)Thanks for noticing, and for posting. It would never have occured to me that I should check the label.
gkhouston
(21,642 posts)reformist2
(9,841 posts)4_TN_TITANS
(2,977 posts)K/R.
global1
(25,249 posts)The same thing happened with laundry soaps. They are now selling smaller containers for 2 times the amount they've sold for in the past. Hair shampoo companies have become stingy on the ingredient in the shampoo that creates the suds/bubbles. They are hoping that you use more shampoo to get the same sudsy action going on your head and that you go through the bottle faster so you need to buy another bottle quicker.
It's amazing how we're being cheated at the grocery store.
What really irks me is that all marketing is basically deceptive. They are out to pull the wool over your eyes on their marketed products and have their hand in your back pocket.
October
(3,363 posts)As a young student, I remember learning about (false) advertising, etc., from a teacher. Since those days in the 1970's, I find we are cheated more than ever in the last decade. Is there no more "Truth in Advertising" laws any more? I'm not that naive, but, I find it's WAY out of control now.
woo me with science
(32,139 posts)of an entire industry of looting.
It is getting utterly shameless when they can get away with not even putting the information on the labels.
Dish soaps come out of the bottle like water. Hand soaps are smaller and hollowed in shape, goopy, and dissolve within a week, while a bar used to stay hard and last for a month.
It goes on and on...
progressoid
(49,990 posts)Just kidding. I'm mostly bald so I don't use much shampoo.
Blue_Tires
(55,445 posts)grilled onions
(1,957 posts)Most companies are hoping we don't. Mothers towing a couple hungry kids from school doesn't have the time to be a great label reader. Some feel the well known brands are automatically the best so they they read labels either. Finally you have those who feel bleach is bleach and will grab according to price,scent or whim. But so many buy for,say a mold problem, and are getting a fancy version of bleach scented water. Years ago ALL bleach was considered a disinfectant.
While we have consumer web sites I don't think we have really gotten enough info to be a threat against shady business wording,sizes etc.
You have a sheet size cake pan but your cake mix is shrinking. Your cake will not look as high as it should. Recipes that used to call for a pound can are now 14 oz so you have to use a filler for those lost ounces.
I don't see how a family can even afford to buy cereal when you see how little is hidden in one of those boxes. Many offer little more then 3 bowls. If a family of four ate cereal every morning think how many boxes they would have to buy! We used to have sensible size boxes that lasted a week and kiddie cereals even had silly toys inside.
Every time you think you have read all the labels you need to on a shopping trip some manufacturer pulls another stunt and the consumer has been had again but it's always in a way that disguises their dishonesty.
October
(3,363 posts)I'm so tired of being taken advantage of!
woo me with science
(32,139 posts)Even reading the labels wasn't enough in this case to get the necessary information.
lalalu
(1,663 posts)Also, what is the deal with Tide? You need to take out a loan to buy their detergent.
LadyHawkAZ
(6,199 posts)I will be passing this along.
Xyzse
(8,217 posts)I thought Bleach was Bleach...
Shocking.
bongbong
(5,436 posts)Shampoos, lotions, etc. Chemists call formulas for these types of things "recipes"
https://www.google.com/search?q=chemistry+recipes+common+household
april
(1,148 posts)LynneSin
(95,337 posts)If I had spilled it on me I would be puking in the aisles. Clorox/Chlorine makes me very nauseous. One of the reasons why I can't join the YMCA - they have indoor pools and they overdo the amount of chlorine they put in their indoor pools.
But good research nonetheless
hunter
(38,313 posts)It's much too harsh for household use.
Besides, what do I care about germs?
I sleep with dogs.
awoke_in_2003
(34,582 posts)is just a marketing gimmick to sell more socks. Bleach makes cotton more brittle.
progressoid
(49,990 posts)12AngryBorneoWildmen
(536 posts)lalalu
(1,663 posts)And white vinegar is a great disinfectant that I like to keep around the house.
Bossy Monkey
(15,863 posts)nc4bo
(17,651 posts)caraher
(6,278 posts)For instance, where I teach the chemistry department buys all their stock acids and bases in concentrated form, and dilutes them as needed. You do "pay" in terms of the time and effort to dilute the chemicals but overall there's a big cost savings. By contrast, the biology department buys the same chemicals in the concentrations they actually use. Clearly they're willing go pay a premium for the convenience of not fussing with diluting the chemicals.
Is the biology department getting ripped off? Well, it all depends on the value they place on not having to do that little bit of (simple) chemistry...
zinnisking
(405 posts)I had to use bleach in the pool the last month of summer when stores stopped stocking pool chlorine (12%). The only brand I found without the percentages on the bottle was Walgreens brand.
The online pool forums all said not to use scented Clorox. Now I know why.
woo me with science
(32,139 posts)according to the representative I spoke to.
The problem is that they are suckering customers into buying diluted formulations labeled "Clorox bleach" that contain much less and don't indicate the lower percentages on the labels at all.
zinnisking
(405 posts)First time posting a pic here. hope i did it right. I resized it cuz it was pretty big.
[IMG][/IMG]
Believe me I get your point about them selling the diluted products and not labeling it.
retrogal
(65 posts)It has the same label as yours. I always thought bleach was bleach as many of us have posted
louis-t
(23,295 posts)I will bring my readers to the store next time and read the labels. Sheeeesh!
TahitiNut
(71,611 posts)I had to go check mine (from CostCo) and it's identical to your photo. Mine does, however, say "Cleans & Disinfects" as the OP states.
zinnisking
(405 posts)bleaches that are "disinfecting" will have the word "disinfecting" on the label, along with a labeled concentration of at least 6 percent.
My bottle says "Disinfects" too.
Moosepoop
(1,920 posts)Liberal_in_LA
(44,397 posts)woo me with science
(32,139 posts)You are obviously quicker than I!
lunatica
(53,410 posts)Thanks!
lalalu
(1,663 posts)Liberal_in_LA
(44,397 posts)material. Not anymore. it's WEAKER!
Thanks for this.
woo me with science
(32,139 posts)Safer for clothes! (Maybe they have.)
I remember a few years ago when Clorox was heavily advertising a "special" kind of bleach cleaner that was "safe around food, kids, and pets!"
That was a slick way to market dilution, too...
WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)KT2000
(20,577 posts)They are right there at state legislatures "guiding" the reps and sentors on environmental issues.
They stopped our state from recommending less toxic gardening methods such as putting out a plate of beer to trap slugs, because they had not undergone rigorous testing!
Good work on the bleach bottles issues -
deaniac21
(6,747 posts)Fuddnik
(8,846 posts)It doesn't work anymore. Now I know why.
And pool chlorine used to be a lot cheaper than Clorox, so I used it for cleaning around the pool,and cage. But, now Clorox ix a lot cheaper, and less effective for a reason.
awoke_in_2003
(34,582 posts)with a little bit of dish soap. Anyone who sells canning supplies should have the 10% strength (kitchen strength is 5%)
HockeyMom
(14,337 posts)When I worked in a group home and they used bleach everywhere, I wore thick gloves and my skin still broke out in bleeding hives.
I do not go swimming in pools either. Clorine in pools does the same thing also. When I want to disinfect anything, I use WHITE VINEGAR. I don't get the same reaction from that.
They have been doing something with my tap water too in Florida. It now smells like BLEACH too. Although I buy water for drinking, I am very, very woried about taking showers and bathes with this.
They want to kill us off.
HopeHoops
(47,675 posts)Just mention cloth diapers. That's the easiest way to fish them out.
Note: All three of our daughters were cloth diaper babies. The eldest is 21 now and we still have a lot of the diapers. They make great dust rags and we used one as a burial shroud for our rabbit.
Up2Late
(17,797 posts)Making extra profits by protecting us from ourselves has become how American Corps do business.
But really, why would anyone buy scented bleach and not expect them to replace some of the bleach with the scent?
I always by the regular old 6%, unscented Clorox Bleach, but anyone who would buy the scented kind is most likely doing so because the unscented stuff smells "too bleachy."
Ever looked at the label of Clorox Clean-up with Bleach? It only has 1.84% with 98.16% "Other Ingredients," not sure what they mean by "Yields 1.75% available Chlorine" thought.
Want another shock, try to find a toilet bowl cleaner that works these days!
Ever since they took out most or all of the old active ingredient that actually worked (Hydrogen Chloride), most hardly make a dent in a dirty toilet anymore.
Lysol Toilet Bowl cleaner used to have 10-15% of Hydrogen Chloride, now most of the ones that "Cling" or that are scented have, at most, 8% Hydrogen Chloride if they have any at all. I now buy "the cheep stuff" called "the Works" which has 20% Hydrogen Chloride in it.
Warning: "the Works" with 20% Hydrogen Chloride WILL burn your skin if you don't wash it off pretty soon after exposure.
Btw, I'm not some sort of chemical geek, I just learned about this stuff when I worked at several Pro Photo Labs over the years. We used to use Lysol Toilet Bowl Cleaner to clean the photo processing machines about once a month, but about 10 years ago I noticed that it was getting a lot harder to clean the gunk off the machines when the boss gave us some of the scented toilet bowl cleaners. That was when I checked the ingredients percentages on the bottles and made the switch to "the cheep stuff" called "the Works."
woo me with science
(32,139 posts)It's good to know.
I posted upthread a little about Clorox's big campaign a while back for their "special" bleach cleaning product that is "safe around food, kids, and pets." (I remember filing it away in my mind alongside the new "whipped" yogurt and chocolate brands as one more example of companies' finding ways to charge us more for products diluted with air or water.)
Homeopathic "medications" that are 99.6 percent water also use the safety argument. It's shameless.
Smilo
(1,944 posts)and it lives up to its name.
Up2Late
(17,797 posts)...but I'm not sure, it just says it's "Sold by" a Georgia Company.
defacto7
(13,485 posts)Mixed about 3 to 1 Works to Hydrogen Peroxide. It eats the copper right off the PC board.
Muriatic Acid which is very strong Hydrogen Chloride bleach works a better. You can buy it in any hardware store and it's 32% Hydrogen Chloride.
Mix a quart of Muriatic Acid 1 to 3 w/ water and you have 1 gallon of very powerful 8% chlorine bleach for about 2 bucks. I'd be careful with it though.
Up2Late
(17,797 posts)...if you do it too quickly. I had to do that a few times, diluting H2SO4 (Sulfuric acid), we used it to lower the pH of one of the Chemicals in the E-6 process.
Btw, to anyone reading this, adding acid to water is the correct way to dilute acid, not the other way around, just do it slowly and carefully. Doing it the other way, adding water to acid, is very dangerous. Hint:
Most of the time we used NAOH, a very strong Base (and a great drain cleaner) to raise the pH, but that came in crystal form which we mixed with water, I was always amazed how hot it made the water when it was mixed.
We also used glacial acetic acid as a stop bath in B&W photography.
defacto7
(13,485 posts)I do this so much I don't even think about it. Thanks for clarifying it.
Do what you aughta, and acid to wata!
Muriatic acid is hydrochloric acid . Diluting it with more water gives you a more dilute hydrochloric acid.
Various things are called bleach, but the stuff the OP is talking about (Chlorox, et. al.) is a solution of sodium hypochlorite (NaClO), which is a very different thing.
You definitely don't want to mix laundry bleach with any acid, except under very controlled circumstances, as you'll be generating chlorine gas. I know you didn't suggest this, but it seemed an appropriate place to throw in a warning.
tridim
(45,358 posts)My right hand, a long rubber glove, a green scrubby and soap.
I clean almost everything with just soap and water. Most households don't need 90% of the chemicals they have under the sink.
Oh, and spray down the whole toilet inside and out with hot water from the shower. Then use the puddle of water on the floor to mop with.
Spitfire of ATJ
(32,723 posts)It can make ya feel really sick. If you get the fumes up your nose you can experience head cold like symptoms. Just getting it on your hands can cause intense nausea and headaches.
Speaking of,...toss all of your Teflon pans. If they get too hot on your stove and you breath the fumes you will experience flu like symptoms. The fumes kill birds dead.
Bozita
(26,955 posts)Shrike47
(6,913 posts)GreenPartyVoter
(72,377 posts)jmowreader
(50,557 posts)and then I found this...
http://www.thecloroxcompany.com/downloads/msds/petcare/freshstepcatlitter.pdf
In case you ever needed a cat litter MSDS, there ya go. (And yes, Clorox makes cat litter. SHITLOADS of cat litter.)
For any Clorox MSDS, go to:
http://www.thecloroxcompany.com/products/msds/
woo me with science
(32,139 posts)Wednesdays
(17,376 posts)They'll be sure to publish this.
K & R.
raccoon
(31,111 posts)(what happened to
?)
City Lights
(25,171 posts)Thanks for researching this and sharing here! I use Clorox Bleach to disinfect my litter boxes, and I'm probably using the diluted crap! I will look for the disinfecting bleach from here on out.
tridim
(45,358 posts)I did it once when I was a kid, and once is all it took to never do it again.
So maybe the new low concentrations are a result of lawsuits over the years?
HiPointDem
(20,729 posts)MsFlorida
(488 posts)concentration is higher, it can be diluted. and just recently I've noticed its not being called chlorine anymore its being called "bleach."
louis-t
(23,295 posts)I used to have a pool and ruined a couple of shirts with the stuff. Hard to find in the winter, but....
BlancheSplanchnik
(20,219 posts)Luna Bars are the "women's version" of Cliff Bars. (health food bars)
Lunas are smaller and cost more than Cliffs. Double whammy, just for us gals. *feh*
Historic NY
(37,449 posts)nadinbrzezinski
(154,021 posts)WHO recommended bleach. We used it straight from bottle as recommended by WHO.
You are correct, it's not what it used to be. We used to leave the rig open for a couple hours so it could ventilate
Thanks for the research
HiPointDem
(20,729 posts)joshcryer
(62,270 posts)Was using Sun laundry soap for years but I would go through a big jug of the stuff in a few months. Switched to Tide because I needed to break a hundred one time (it's expensive, $7 for the largest Sun brand, $18 for the largest Tide) and amazingly a little cup of the stuff was all that was needed to actually get the clothes clean.
3 months later and I still have half a jug. So it seems that it'll last 3 times longer than the Sun brand which comes out to about $1 less for the whole jug.