General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsI'm truly shocked. Some Republicans literally believe Obama is a Muslim
I was just on the phone with a woman I met a year ago at the university we attend. She's 38 years old and has a high (3.7 or 3.8, if I recall correctly) GPA.
She's also an evangelical Christian, and the hundreds of friends she has on her Facebook page are almost all evangelical Christians. She doesn't have a TV signal and doesn't pay a lot of attention to the news, so I'm sure most of her information comes from FB postings, and from conversations she has with other Christians.
On the phone just now we were discussing the presidential race, and she said, "I don't know, there's something about Romney that I really don't like. He seems really untrustworthy, and he creeps me out. But I can't get past that whole Muslim thing with Obama."
I asked if she was serious about the "Muslim thing" -- did she really believe Obama's a Muslim? -- and her answer indicated that she thought it was common knowledge.
Then I asked, "Do you mean he's a 'secret Muslim'? ...that he's really Muslim but pretending to be a Christian, or do you think he actually claims that he, himself, is Muslim?"
The questions apparently confused her. When I didn't get an answer, I asked, "Do you remember Reverend Wright, Obama's Christian pastor, who..." To make a long story short, I covered the whole Wright controversy, but the point I was making to her was that people were having issues over what Obama's Christian pastor had said.
She said she didn't follow the 2008 election closely enough to see any of that. She had never heard of Reverend Wright.
I said, "There are some people who say Obama is secretly Muslim, that he's lying and pretending he's a Christian. Are you saying you think he's actually a professed Muslim?"
She said, "I think it might not be possible to know some of these things."
She's 38, earning a high GPA at a liberal college, but otherwise gets most of her information from Facebook friends who think the way she does. And she can't vote for Obama, even though Romney creeps her out, because of "the whole Muslim thing."
I honestly did not know these people existed. They're living and working among us, connected to the same Internet, and they truly believe we elected a professed (not "secret" Muslim president in 2008.
HERVEPA
(6,107 posts)Populist_Prole
(5,364 posts)Obviously fox news, right wing radio, reading only the IBD and WSJ is rife with mis-information, but they believe absolutely they are on top of events and know what's what more than everybody else. You can tell this because the fact they "know" what's what causes them to want to share it freely with everybody....forcefully and aggressively.
Enrique
(27,461 posts)34% of conservative republicans. 17% overall
http://www.pewforum.org/Politics-and-Elections/Little-Voter-Discomfort-with-Romney%E2%80%99s-Mormon-Religion.aspx
ruffburr
(1,190 posts)Some people can be very intelligent and have 0 common sense,
OldDem2012
(3,526 posts)still_one
(92,193 posts)begin_within
(21,551 posts)geckosfeet
(9,644 posts)what you want to believe than to actually think about it and try to make an intelligent informed decision.
Naturally every decision is tainted with personal bias and subjectivity and information boundaries, but for christs sake it sounds like your friend is in serious denial.
underthematrix
(5,811 posts)has very poor critical thinking skills because it seems she was unable to discern the contradiction in the firestorm over President Obama attending a CHRISTIAN CHURCH - Church of Christ and the bizarre notion that he is also a Muslim. The interesting thing is John Sununu is Palestian and a rightwing nutjob and until 1988 was anti-Israel.
Shampoobra
(423 posts)...and I think she thought I was passing on some sort of unverified, partisan spin.
Had we been together in person, instead of talking on the phone, I could have pulled up the videos of Wright's famous statements.
But today, I think her "might not be possible to know some of these things" comment was because she didn't know how to process this new information.
WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)Democratopia
(552 posts)Because they believe he's a Muslim, and all Muslims are terrorists, and he palls around with terrorists, he was born in Kenya, with a fake birth certificate, he's a socialist, communist, who wants to destroy America, take guns away and he's fully responsible for gas prices, unemployment and the national debt. Worse still, his middle name is the same as that Saddam guy who had WMD.
They actually believe that.
trof
(54,256 posts)Majored in electrical engineering, dean's list.
Career airline pilot.
World traveled.
Best Man at my wedding.
Birther.
And Obama is a Muslim.
Hard for me to deal with this level of stupidity in a guy I used to be very close to.
Shampoobra
(423 posts)He believes Obama's a liar, right? That Obama's keeping his supposed Muslim beliefs a secret?
Because this woman actually believes that we elected a president who openly claims to be a Muslim.
It's as if she saw so many "Obama = Muslim" memes that she took it to be a known, verified fact.
trof
(54,256 posts)He's still full of shit and it's hard for me to come to terms with that.
krawhitham
(4,644 posts)Just the normal GOP race baiting
tarheelsunc
(2,117 posts)These right-wing paranoid schizophrenics need to get out of their bigoted mindset.
blueknight
(2,831 posts)how fucking stupid is she?
Shampoobra
(423 posts)I'm currently averaging around 3.3, and she's at about 3.7 or 3.8.
I understand people not following politics. What I don't understand is, people with Internet access not thinking: Really? Our president is Muslim? I should see if I can find that backed up by a legitimate source. Instead, she accepts it as fact, and lets that so-called "fact" bother her.
maxsolomon
(33,345 posts)Rain Man could count hella numbers, but I don't think he was "intelligent".
War Horse
(931 posts)Otherwise seemingly functional people actually believe that Obama's on some sort of mission to destroy the U.S. from the inside.
Algebra Palin
(34 posts)with 'so what?' the nonsense would stop.
obama could be a member of the jedi church, and i really wouldn't care.
*shrug*
sarge43
(28,941 posts)"So what?" has been my answer the couple of times I've heard that. Then, I ask "You do know about Section 3, Article VI of the US Constitution?" (Que crickets)
ballabosh
(330 posts)Usually met with a blank stare or apoplexy.
Alekei_Firebird
(320 posts)"Muslim" is just the latest code word to characterize scary Black people who'll take away the White Way of Life.
A-Schwarzenegger
(15,596 posts)Because gambling's been going on back there a long long time.
WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)Shampoobra
(423 posts)I just never expected to hear it from someone who otherwise appears to be intelligent, and who is not saying it in a conspiratorial manner. It makes me wonder how many others (who don't come across as nutjobs) really believe this without questioning it.
A-Schwarzenegger
(15,596 posts)Or wonder wonder.
Separation
(1,975 posts)I have a really good friend who is almost 70, Vietnam Vet, and is very new to the Internet surprisingly. He is a member of his vet unit group, Blue Stars I think, and some of the chain emails he gets are incredible. I believe that if he got an email that said the sky is green and Obama was actually born on Mars, he would believe it. I try my best to try and explain that everything he reads on the Internet isn't real.
Mariana
(14,857 posts)Those e-mails have made me lose any last bit of respect I might have had for conservatives. Do you know what they do when they get one of those e-mails that they know is bullshit? They forward it to everyone anyway, hoping the recipients will be stupid enough to believe it. What kind of person does that? Not one that I want to have anything to do with, that's for sure.
Separation
(1,975 posts)Sadly I think my friend truly believes them. I do all I can to politely give him the other side of the story. But he is older, set in his ways, served with these people and has a gullible/naive look on life.
So I do my part when I can, and shake my head when I can't. He is not an evil/mean person. He was a Huey pilot and is in a losing battle with cancer caused by Agent Orange. He doesn't even realize he isnt the target audience of Romney. He lives on VA disability, I've tried to tell him that he is the %47 that Rmoney wrote off.
spanone
(135,838 posts)WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)Arugula Latte
(50,566 posts)Some exceptions, yeah yeah yeah.
WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)Never gets old.
Dash87
(3,220 posts)She thinks that Obama is a Muslim from Kenya. She's says that we can't elect Obama in 2012 because he'll force us all to become Muslims. She also claims that, if Obama is elected, "The Arabs" (her wording) will invade us and overthrow our government in order to install a Muslim theocracy. She loved that Obama 2016 (or whatever it was called) movie, and is recommending it to everyone.
Douglas Carpenter
(20,226 posts)working to put Americans under Sharia Law. Many of the same people would with equal fervor claim that he is waging a war on religion to make America a secular socialist-atheist state. I don't know how they square those counter claims - but they do and they are serious.
I have been regularly following this YouTube video (note the millions of views) partly just to follow the comments and occasionally try to correct misinformation:
The few comments they extracted to suggest that Obama is deeply anti-Christian comes from this 40 minute speech he gave in 2006- addressing a group of Evangelicals and actually explaining how and why he became a Christian. But even that 2006 speech is being used as proof that he is a Muslim and fiercely anti-Christian
MatthewStLouis
(904 posts)Tennessee Gal
(6,160 posts)There is no reasoning with him. I tried. He persisted. I unfriended him on Facebook. I will not give him any of the space on my new feed to spew that crap.
DavidDvorkin
(19,479 posts)LeftInTX
(25,342 posts)A survey was done of Ohio Republicans and many gave Mitt Romney credit for Osama Bin Laden.
(Not even Bush, but Romney)
porphyrian
(18,530 posts)Shampoobra
(423 posts)and I see no reason for you to call me a liar.
Like I said in up above in another reply, it's not like I was unaware that this BS is rampant. But I never expected an otherwise-intelligent person to be so disconnected from current events and so reliant on FB friends as a source of information that she would actually believe that Obama is a professing Muslim.
I thought that crowd was limited to two types: liars, and those with very low IQs who fell for the lies. And even then, I thought both groups were limited to the "he's a secret Muslim" line.
porphyrian
(18,530 posts)I didn't call you a liar. I just don't believe anyone can be really shocked by this after four years of it unless you've lived on an island, are very young or drank the Koolaid until now. I'm sorry that it's such a sensitive topic for you.
Shampoobra
(423 posts)WTF did I just say in my reply to you?
It's not a "sensitive topic" because it's never once been an issue with me until thirty minutes before I typed the OP.
I don't start many threads, but I started this one after calling a number of people on the phone, none of whom had ever heard of an otherwise-intelligent person who believes an openly-Muslim candidate was elected president of the post-911 United States. This was a series of shocking moments for me.
My sensitivity results not from the subject of Obama's religion, but from being flat-out accused (by you) of not believing what I'm saying. That sounds exactly like being called a liar.
porphyrian
(18,530 posts)and thanks for your concern
rbrnmw
(7,160 posts)in this day and age They don't believe that they only know he's black and they can't come out and say that's why they hate him so much they use birtherism or say he's a Muslim which is Religious discrimination and just as wrong as any other type of discrimination
Response to Shampoobra (Original post)
rbrnmw This message was self-deleted by its author.
B Calm
(28,762 posts)don't give a shit! That's what republicans do. They make a big mess when they are in power, then when they are out of power they sit on their big fat hemorrhoidal buttocks, make up shit, and then point their brown stained fingers at democrats for not cleaning up their mess fast enough.
Douglas Carpenter
(20,226 posts)insisted that was the case and seemed to be unaware that this was no longer common knowledge. I know a majority of Americans believed that in March 2003 and about 70% or more of those who voted for George W. Bush in 2004 still believed it then. But I found it it mine boggling to learn that a serious number of Republicans still believe it - even now.
Javaman
(62,530 posts)I knew many fellow students when I was in college that had high GPA's but were as stupid as a mud fence.
EasyGirl
(89 posts)ronnie624
(5,764 posts)NOLALady
(4,003 posts)Even if he were a Muslim, that has nothing to do with the fact that he's the best qualified candidate for 2012. Geez!
Hitler was a Christian.
Shampoobra
(423 posts)But this encounter revealed to me the extent of what Rachel Maddow calls "the bubble" that so many conservatives have come to occupy. Before yesterday, I assumed "the bubble" meant things like Fox, Limbaugh, and Free Republic.
But this conversation yesterday completely floored me. This is a woman who once decoded Descartes for me (on the fly, and without any previous exposure to his work) when I couldn't understand any of that. And now I'm suddenly learning that she appears to consume and regurgitate all her "news" from her church friends' Facebook posts.
Douglas Carpenter
(20,226 posts)are among the most insular little worlds one will ever find. Of course, in such a group you might have doctors, lawyers, accountants and lots of otherwise educated people. But one of the social dynamics of fundamentalist church groups is that fellow believers are really the only people who hold opinions that count. There is a suspicion borderlining on paranoia about the world of non-believers. Thus there is a strong tendency to discount any information that does not come from believer sources. If you accept that your band of believers holds a special truth about the nature of the universe that the world cannot comprehend and only the true fellow believers can comprehend - one is going to end up knowing all kinds of things for certain that simply are not true.
hamsterjill
(15,220 posts)I get emails on a daily basis for idiots trying to persuade me that Obama is a Muslim. This morning's buffet of emails including (yet again) the picture from 2008 where Obama is holding the book about "post America". They're still screaming about that one!
get the red out
(13,466 posts)I think people have a lot wrapped up in their identity, especially folks who identify as evangelical Christian. They have a lot riding on being accepted by their group and believing the "right" things. I think that they will "believe" what they are told because it is literally a part of who they work hard to project to the world. The Republicans have done a masterful job at taking over evangelical Christianity and molding it for their own purposes. An evangelical Christian will be applauded for believing a thrice married drug addict when he lies about our Christian President who is a devoted husband and father. Their group acceptance, social support, and identity depend on it.
TeamAmerica
(4 posts)Shampoobra
(423 posts)...but I guess occasionally wearing clothing styles that originate from outside dominant U.S. culture is part of the job. I don't think wearing this outfit makes him Vietnamese.
Proud Liberal Dem
(24,412 posts)that even if he was, it doesn't matter one iota. The Constitution- which many of them claim to revere- forbids religious tests for public office. End of story.
GoCubsGo
(32,084 posts)Being an evangelical Christian, she's likely one of the millions of people who believe the human race began with a couple of naked people who conversed with a talking snake. NOTHING these right-wing nutbags say or believe surprises me any more.
Vattel
(9,289 posts)Bottom line: people can convince themselves of anything.