General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsMitt Romney IS Dolores Umbridge!
http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/roiphe/2012/10/harry_potter_presidential_campaign_romney_is_umbridge_obama_is_dumbledore.htmlIt started in the last debate when she said of Mitt Romney, after hearing him talk for a few minutes: Hes Umbridge! And of course I saw exactly what she meant, the brittle, lacquered, self-satisfied smile of the ambitious Dark Arts professor and passionate ministry bureaucrat, Dolores Umbridge. The saccharine, almost-girlish chuckle. The proclamations she issues at Hogwarts, the self-important talk about the ministry this and the ministry that. The classes doomed to read out loud instead of learning the spells they desperately need. The moment where she makes Harry write lines into his own skin with a pen that draws real blood, all the while smiling that fake and brittle smile. Then of course there is her interest in Muggle Registration, and protecting pureblood wizards from the dilution and compromise of human blood.
Last night at the end of the debate, when Anne Romney came up onstage in her green-patterned, 1950s-style skirt, with her anxious expression and pained smile, Violet saw Petunia Dursley, that manic perversion of 50s housewifery, meanly maternal, protective of the wrong people.
Of last nights moderator, the sweet-seeming and dignified Bob Schieffer, she said, Professor Slughorn, which I thought was a little unfair. Schieffer seemed so civilized, so mannerly, so decent. Professor Slughorn is all those things, but also a little pompous, a little networky, a little hail-fellow-well-met. I did see how Schieffer was a bit bemused, like Slughorn, as if the modern world had taken a few confusing and unfortunate turns. And his attempts to control the debate, to keep the two candidates on the ostensible topic of foreign policy, were reminiscent of Slughorns efforts to keep the future Voldemorts explorations into dark magic totally theoretical.
MassedPole
(242 posts)She is such a bitch in Order Of the Phoenix.
She could not fight her way out of a paper bag.
LongTomH
(8,636 posts)During the Bush years, Ms. Rowling was becoming very subtly political. The fascism of the Ministry of Magic was reminiscent of what we were seeing from the Bush administration.
Hekate
(90,829 posts)Post WW II there was a small genre of kid-lit featuring kids who fought back against the Nazis in various countries in Europe. Naturally I cannot recall a single author or title, but I do remember the plots and characters, and they influenced me a lot. Fascism was evil, and even children could fight back.
One reason I love Phoenix is that it will present an opportunity for my grandson to learn the same lesson, not from a political science course or a history book, but from reading and thinking about this story.
My grandson is not quite 8 years old yet, but we have been slowly working our way through the movies and both I and his mother have been reading the books to him bit by bit. He's too young for politics per se, but the life/death, good/evil, ethical questions have provided a lot of fodder for my conversations with him as he questions what goes on. He'll get there in time, I think when he reads through the books on his own....
And yes, this country is developing a strain of fascism all our own. I want him to know it when he sees it.
Hekate
backscatter712
(26,355 posts)Then it will be the Republicans running Voldemort for President...
Hekate
(90,829 posts)Read the whole thing at Slate -- excellent article.
backscatter712
(26,355 posts)Myrina
(12,296 posts)"Don't question me, you mere mortal!"
glinda
(14,807 posts)that look on Romney's face last night when describing it to my husband.
backscatter712
(26,355 posts)glinda
(14,807 posts)backscatter712
(26,355 posts)Does this mean Mitt Romney is Belloq?
Response to glinda (Reply #18)
backscatter712 This message was self-deleted by its author.
demwing
(16,916 posts)Mitt should listen to her advice...
backscatter712
(26,355 posts)Cha
(297,722 posts)I haven't read Harry Potter but it's uncanny how they resemble each other in look and personality disorder!
Thanks backscatter~
glinda
(14,807 posts)backscatter712
(26,355 posts)backscatter712
(26,355 posts)hifiguy
(33,688 posts)A slimy, sneaking, utterly unprincipled little man who will do or say anything to advance the cause of his evil master(s).