General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsJosh Marshall: Many "independents" just tea partiers who don't identify as R anymore
Can Romney Win Indies & Lose?...One point to keep in mind here is that we keep this data set of adults rather than registered or likely voters. That makes it somewhat different from the voting electorate. But it also removes swells of voter and partisan enthusiasm from the trend. These are polls which simply ask people over 18, how do you identify in partisan terms. So we get a good apples to apples comparison over time.
A few things jump right out. The big thing is that independent identification skyrocketed and GOP identification plummeted in the Fall of 2010 notably, this started just in advance of the 2010 midterm election.
Now, unless you assume that the US has moved strongly to the left since 2010, it seems pretty clear that what happened was an exodus from the GOP to the right. In other words, a lot of people left the Republican party, in identification terms. But they didnt become Democrats. And it doesnt seem (at least from the politics of the last two years) like they became more moderate of centrist in ideological terms. They simply reidentified themselves as independents. One more thing Id add and this is part is just my supposition. But I think in a lot of cases they actually re-identified because the GOP wasnt right-wing enough, call it a Tea Party exodus from the GOP...
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/archives/2012/10/can_romney_win_indies_lose.php?ref=fpblg
Ikonoklast
(23,973 posts)Ooooh, you're fooling us!
itsrobert
(14,157 posts)and tilting the outcome to Romney?
I can see how that give bad outcome. Bad data in, bad data out.
marlakay
(11,498 posts)People who want to change parties but don't want to tell friends, family and work people.
One set used to be republican, they now vote dem but are independent.
Other set used to be dem but now republican but are independent.
So I think it can go either way....
intheflow
(28,504 posts)Been hearing this line of bullshit for years. It's as wrong as claiming all southerners are conservative. I'm independent, my bf is independent, because the Democratic party isn't far enough to the left for us. This holds true for every independent I personally know.
BeyondGeography
(39,380 posts)Which is another way of saying you missed the point entirely.
PS: The thread title is "many" independents, not all.
Indykatie
(3,697 posts)SalviaBlue
(2,918 posts)_ed_
(1,734 posts)Lifelong independent here. I've voted Green, Libertarian, and Democratic, but I've never voted for a Republican for local, state, or federal office.