Subsidies and the China Price
Usha C.V. Haley and George T. Haley
Many assume that Chinas cost advantage in manufacturing comes from cheap labor. But in Chinas burgeoning steel industry, our research suggests, massive government energy subsidies, not other factors, keep prices down. These subsidies have broad implications for how companies compete and collaborate with Chinese businesses.
In 2005, Beijing designated steel as a pillar industry for the Chinese economy. China was the worlds largest producer of steel, with 27% of global production, but until then it had imported 29 million tons of steel annually. That year, China suddenly transformed itself from a net steel importer to a net steel exporter. In 2006, the country became the worlds largest steel exporter by volume, up from the fifth largest in 2005. Today it remains the worlds largest consumer and producer of steel, with 40% of global production. How did China make these astonishing gains so quickly and manage to sell steel for about 19% less than steel from U.S. and European companies? Labor accounts for less than 10% of the costs of producing Chinese steel, and Chinese steel doesnt appear to rely on scale economies, supply-chain proximities, or technological efficiencies to lower its costs.
Our research revealed that energy subsidies to the steel industry were paid to the energy sector and passed on through lower energy prices, which suggests that the energy supplied to Chinas other manufacturing industries is subsidized as well. The steel industry may benefit disproportionately from energy subsidies because of its voracious appetite for coal, but the energy subsidies obviously help other industries too.
http://hbr.org/2008/06/subsidies-and-the-china-price/ar/1