General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsCandy Crowley, jobs, and ‘facts’
Posted with permission.
http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/political-animal/2012_01/candy_crowley_jobs_and_facts034775.php
January 16, 2012 8:35 AM
Candy Crowley, jobs, and facts
By Steve Benen
There was an interesting exchange on CNNs State of the Union yesterday, when Candy Crowley pressed David Axelrod on one of Mitt Romneys favorite talking points.
To establish the context, the Romney campaign released a memo on Saturday, insisting that nearly 1.7 million jobs have been lost since President Obama took office. CNNs Crowley relied on this claim to ask the Obama advisor whether it explains Romneys lead in polls on the economy. From the networks transcript:
AXLEROD: Candy, lets have you know what, Im happy to have that discussion. Do you know that, when he was campaigning for president in 2007 and 2008, Governor Romney had nothing but praise for the economic policies that were in place at that time, as America was sliding into the worst recession since the Great Depression, after eight years in which we
CROWLEY: But this isnt Romney. This is a fact.
Well, not exactly. Crowley has embraced the Romney campaigns line without scrutiny, and the result is fact that misleads the public.
Consider this: in the first six months of 2009, the U.S. economy lost 3.89 million jobs. Thats not an exaggeration from January 09 to June 09, 3.89 million American jobs vanished. Thats jaw-dropping, of course, and its evidence of an economy that was facing an extraordinary crisis with no modern precedent.
For Candy Crowley and Mitt Romney, President Obama deserves to be blamed for those losses, even though hed just taken office, even though his policies hadnt taken effect, even though his economic team was not yet in place. Obama took office when the global financial system was on the brink of collapse, inheriting a recession that began a year before his inauguration, but for Republicans and the establishment media, it makes sense to count the job losses from Obamas first six months in office against him. (This even includes January 2009, and Obama didnt take the oath until the month was two-thirds over.)
By any fair standard, this is ridiculous. Indeed, even in early 2009, no sane person thought this way. It was simply understood three years ago that the president had walked into a catastrophe that was not of his making. Blaming him for the job losses of early 09 simply doesnt make any sense.
And guess what? If one excludes those first six months of 2009, when the nation was hemorrhaging jobs due to a crisis the president wasnt responsible for, Barack Obama has overseen a net gain of 1.4 million jobs. In the private sector, its 1.97 million jobs.
Those are just facts and theyre part of a context Republicans and many in the media prefer to ignore.
Media professionals have to know better. As Greg Sargent, who first flagged Crowleys misleading claims, explained yesterday:
Its time for journalists to pick up their game. Romney, whos already demonstrated a commitment to post-truth politics, is going to try to spin a lot of reporters over the next 10 months. Theres no reason for media professionals to allow themselves to be played for fools.
Crankie Avalon
(5,261 posts)...in order to further an ideological agenda? She's a FOX correspondent who happens to be broadcast out of CNN.
spanone
(135,855 posts)baldguy
(36,649 posts)Snotcicles
(9,089 posts)HughBeaumont
(24,461 posts)Surely he knows that "fact" is utterly ludicrous on it's face.
Why did he not call her on it?
BumRushDaShow
(129,228 posts)From here: http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1201/15/sotu.01.html
(I left the next question in after his response to denote how quickly his response had to be dispatched with by Creepy Crawly so no one could lock on to it! )
CROWLEY: But this isn't Romney. This is a fact.
AXELROD: ... after which we squandered the -- a $2 trillion surplus.
The worst month that we've had of job loss was the month that this president took office from the last administration, and since that time, we've created 3 million private-sector jobs.
If you look at the chart, the chart's going like this. We've had 22 straight months of private-sector job growth.
Now, we need to accelerate that. But the fact is Governor Romney praised the policies that got us into this mess. He wants to go back to those policies, and he assigns everything that's gone wrong in our economy to the president, and he says everything that's gone right has nothing to do with him.
CROWLEY: Let me talk a bit about Bain Capital, where Mitt Romney, you know, ran the company.
surfdog
(624 posts)And mitt Romney is her pimp , is anybody surprised ?