Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

littlemissmartypants

(22,841 posts)
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 02:38 PM Apr 27

Duty to Warn...professionals have agreed Trump shows clear signs of "probable dementia."

This is an unroll by the Thread Reader App of the below quoted tweet thread by @duty2warn

Profile
Duty To Warn
@duty2warn
An association of mental health professionals
warning NOW about TrumpISM. #UNTRUTH
documentary, the follow-up doc to 2020's #UNFIT,
to be widely released soon.
○ United States 2 untruthfilm.com
https://twitter.com/duty2warn?t=Hg-8dFMeZtquJSsfWSa3og&s=09



Quoted thread
1/20 Over 400 licensed medical and mental health professionals have agreed Trump shows clear signs of "probable dementia." But even more persuasive than their signatures on our petition are what they had to say. Only in this long Tweet can you read their words verbatim.
Please hear their voices! (RT)

"I am a neuropsychiatrist and movement disorders neurologist at an academic medical center. There is more than enough reason to suspect Dementia including: worsening thought process, loser connections between thoughts, tangentiality, paraphasias, irritability, paranoia, persecutory ideation, impulsivity and so on; which are clearly different than videos of him from 10 years ago. Without personally examining him, I cannot clarify further, but he appears to at least have a cautious gait. The most plausible disorder would be a mixture of frontal lobe dysfunction (sort of like frontotemporal Dementia or CTE) from a vascular Dementia."
-- Ankur Butala, M.D.

“As an experienced physician who was board certified in Family Medicine, Geriatrics, and Emergency Medicine, it is my professional opinion that Donald J. Trump is unfit for any elected office because he meets all the DSM-5 criteria for narcissistic personality disorder and antisocial personality disorder. In addition, recent observations clearly demonstrate deteriorating cognitive function. His public posture leaning forward when standing, his difficulty walking down a ramp, his holding his palms down on a table as if it would rise in the air, and his increasing speech difficulties are suggestive of frontotemporal dementia. Again, this is all based on public information and my years of experience.
---Thomas C. Long, M.D.

“The evidence for dementia in Donald Trump has become overwhelming. Unlike normal aging, which is characterized by forgetting names or words, Trump repeatedly shows something very different: confusion about reality. For example, he might have confused Obama with Biden once, but his repeated error indicates inability to keep track of the facts. Similarly, he recently said that he won all 50 states in the 2020 election. That is not normal aging, it’s loss of ability to think, reason, and know reality. Further, a normally aging person recognizes the mistake and corrects it. For example, Biden recently saw he’d misspoken and joked it was a “Freudian slip”. Trump doesn’t realize he is making errors because he is too demented to see them. Other obvious examples have been Trump saying that the name of the state of Pennsylvania will be changed, or that the names of George Washington and Abraham Lincoln would be deleted from buildings. That is not loss of word recall, it’s dementia. Trump has always lied, but these are examples that aren’t even part of his delusional grandiosity (like saying he had the largest crowd in history for his inauguration). These are loss of normal cognitive ability seen with dementia. If he were to become President he would have to be immediately removed from office via the 25th amendment as dangerously unable to fulfill the responsibilities of office.
---Lance Dodes, M.D., Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School

Snip... you can read more of the twenty tweet thread here...
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1768567654111932739.html




A duty to warn is a concept that arises in the law of torts in a number of circumstances, indicating that a party will be held liable for injuries caused to another, where the party had the opportunity to warn the other of a hazard and failed to do so.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duty_to_warn


❤️pants
GOTV!
65 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Duty to Warn...professionals have agreed Trump shows clear signs of "probable dementia." (Original Post) littlemissmartypants Apr 27 OP
So..... FarPoint Apr 27 #1
Past ready. MontanaMama Apr 27 #2
Agreed. Right there with ya, MM. Waiting impatiently. calimary Apr 27 #13
there's been a lot of speculation about the effect of stopdiggin Apr 27 #3
It is speculation based on fact and science. Irish_Dem Apr 27 #4
You missed the point of my post. (again) -(nt)- stopdiggin Apr 27 #11
We don't all think alike. You may have to rephrase your descriptions sometimes if littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #34
I agree 100%! ShazzieB Apr 27 #36
Thanks so much for this, ShazzieB. ❤️ littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #40
My pleasurs! ShazzieB Apr 27 #43
Republicans don't care. His cult won't believe it and Republican leaders may think they can manipulate him more easily. Lonestarblue Apr 27 #5
Exactly. They'll still vote for him... no.matter.what. IcyPeas Apr 27 #18
More proof he's only slightly less stupid than they are. littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #32
He could drop dead of a stroke or heart attack BlueKota Apr 27 #35
We're Not Going To Flip The Cult ProfessorGAC Apr 27 #48
No one will be able to say we were not warned Hekate Apr 27 #6
This is one of the reasons Biden needs to get him on a debate stage KS Toronado Apr 27 #7
Works both ways. I'd rather allow a trusted moderator to figure out the questions erronis Apr 27 #29
I don't tink it woud take much to make him stumble. ShazzieB Apr 27 #44
With the stress he is under hopefully closer to the election he will be Autumn Apr 27 #8
Think about this... littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #30
Think maybe he's medicated to stop him from going ape shit crazy in court? Autumn Apr 27 #33
I don't think that we can make a broad claim that he insists on being littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #37
That makes sense. Never thought of the Adderall doing that. Autumn Apr 27 #39
Well, I have to add this- I'm 75, and have a job where I have to keep moving. If I stop for any length of time, NBachers Apr 27 #53
The more demented he is, Turbineguy Apr 27 #9
At one time, DENVERPOPS Apr 27 #10
Wow! That's a great way to explain it, DENVERPOPS. calimary Apr 27 #22
I have undergone a lot of mental health treatment so I know a bit. BlueKota Apr 27 #41
Malignant narcissism is a personality disorder, possibly a combination of more than one. ShazzieB Apr 27 #42
Thx Shazzie DENVERPOPS Apr 27 #62
And even more thx DENVERPOPS Apr 28 #63
This message was self-deleted by its author ShazzieB Apr 27 #45
I think Dr Butala meant "looser connections between thoughts " WestMichRad Apr 27 #12
I'm sure he did, but the typo definitely works. 3catwoman3 Apr 27 #17
I'm good with "loser." One of the commenters mentioned how he leans forward when standing. brush Apr 27 #31
That forward lean is characteristic... WestMichRad Apr 27 #51
Maybe Dr. Butala is a Republican, and forgot to translate into English DFW Apr 28 #65
Message auto-removed Name removed Apr 27 #14
Welcome to DU! Wednesdays Apr 27 #15
Hello GP6971 Apr 27 #16
Is this one of those "Water is Wet" observations? Ping Tung Apr 27 #19
No, they are exercising their duty to warn. ❤️ littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #24
Once again...I do believe he is demented, an evil being, but he is accomplishing a lot of the evil stuff he is after. Escurumbele Apr 27 #20
Cannon Won't Recuse... GB_RN Apr 28 #64
Guess it's time to put Old Yeller down. Travis, git yer gun. Kennah Apr 27 #21
The 3rd(out of the 3 shown) person'sopinions have at least a couple of things wrong. DontBelieveEastisEas Apr 27 #23
It's not a random review but over 400 doctors and medical professionals and they aren't just giving an opinion... littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #27
Well stated, and I completely agree! ShazzieB Apr 27 #46
You are missing a key component of Trumps style. DontBelieveEastisEas Apr 27 #49
Thank you. ❤️ littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #54
You are missing a key component of Trump's style DontBelieveEastisEas Apr 27 #50
These aren't my observations and I'm not missing anything. littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #52
I made an observation. DontBelieveEastisEas Apr 27 #57
Yes, Cohn gave him that advice, but that's not what's going on now. ShazzieB Apr 27 #58
Yes, your reply is exactly right, in my opinion. DontBelieveEastisEas Apr 27 #59
Thanks for clarifying. ShazzieB Apr 27 #60
I think it will be a matter of a few months. bucolic_frolic Apr 27 #25
There where thousands of memtal health profesionals that said he was doc03 Apr 27 #26
And now that he's worse and declining... littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #28
True, but he's gotten a lot more flagrantly cuckoo, and it's getting worse all the time. ShazzieB Apr 27 #47
Problem is, as i see it bluestarone Apr 27 #38
Forbidden Planet's Monster of the Id is loose among us NBachers Apr 27 #55
... littlemissmartypants Apr 27 #56
Trump has dementia! red dog 1 Apr 27 #61

stopdiggin

(11,399 posts)
3. there's been a lot of speculation about the effect of
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 02:54 PM
Apr 27

an increased stress load, due to cascading legal troubles, etc.

But, again - key word, 'speculation'.

Irish_Dem

(47,616 posts)
4. It is speculation based on fact and science.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 03:00 PM
Apr 27

Trump is seriously mentally ill.
Two personality disorders, narcissism and sociopathy.
Cognitive disability due to dementia.

He is 77 years old, obviously with medical risk due to his poor physical condition.

He is now under a great deal of stress.
Running for president, facing numerous legal and financial problems.

Most of us can add up the risk factors and make some legitimate comments.

littlemissmartypants

(22,841 posts)
34. We don't all think alike. You may have to rephrase your descriptions sometimes if
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 05:46 PM
Apr 27

You want to get a point across and promote understanding. I know there are times when I get confused and have to ask others for clarification.

I also know sometimes it can be very frustrating to be misunderstood. Especially when this is a place designed for promoting the open discussion of complex ideas.

Keep the faith, stopdiggin.

❤️

ShazzieB

(16,590 posts)
36. I agree 100%!
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 06:03 PM
Apr 27

Last edited Sat Apr 27, 2024, 06:54 PM - Edit history (1)

One of the experts quoted in the op noted something very important, which is the extent and rate at which he's deteriorated. It's really very noticeable, once you become aware of the signs, but people miss it, because he's always been so weird.

For example, he's always been a huge liar, so when he says something that is obviously nonfactual, it's easy to shrug it off as "Oh, there he goes lying again, what else is new."

That's just one very small example, only one part of a much larger picture. If you want to know more, I recommend googling Dr. John Gartner, founder of A Duty to Warn. He's done a ton of interviews about this, and it's very easy to find videos of him expounding on it in detail. Here's a very recent one, where he talks about Trump's pre-existing personality disorders and gives examples of how Trump is exhibiting serious signs of dementia and having more and more trouble communicating coherently:

?si=FNSJZfS1TM8L-cVU




ShazzieB

(16,590 posts)
43. My pleasurs!
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 06:42 PM
Apr 27

I've become a Gartner fan of sorts. He's not only very informative but also engaging and entertaining, which is a great combination, imo.

Lonestarblue

(10,125 posts)
5. Republicans don't care. His cult won't believe it and Republican leaders may think they can manipulate him more easily.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 03:20 PM
Apr 27

The authors of the Project 2025 blueprint for destroying the federal government and creating a dictatorship are the ones who frighten me. They have a clear plan for eliminating democracy and centering all power in the executive. Trump craves money and praise, the more the better. So long as the Heritage Foundation extremists keep him happy on those two fronts, Trump will most likely allow them to do anything they want, especially as he descends further into dementia and no longer remembers what he has promised.

IcyPeas

(21,928 posts)
18. Exactly. They'll still vote for him... no.matter.what.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 04:24 PM
Apr 27

He could be in jail
He could shoot someone
He could have another affair
He could be on life support
He could kill a dog live on tv

They will still vote for him

BlueKota

(1,837 posts)
35. He could drop dead of a stroke or heart attack
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 05:48 PM
Apr 27

and they'd still vote for him because they are just that much brain washed.

ProfessorGAC

(65,322 posts)
48. We're Not Going To Flip The Cult
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 07:22 PM
Apr 27

We need to amplify this to the middle.
People without devoted political sensibilities may be interested in pocketbook issues, but might not want a nut in the White House.
We need to solidify the middle-of-the-road vote. We can ignore the cult. They were there in '20, and TFG lost by 4.5% (PV) & by nearly 14%.
If Biden can lock up the middle, he'll win easily.

KS Toronado

(17,402 posts)
7. This is one of the reasons Biden needs to get him on a debate stage
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 03:29 PM
Apr 27

Figure out questions he would stumble on and show no mercy.

erronis

(15,403 posts)
29. Works both ways. I'd rather allow a trusted moderator to figure out the questions
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 05:24 PM
Apr 27

and hold them both to a very strict regimen on how they can answer.

I'd also like a kill switch and physical booths (with separate air systems). No pacing and perhaps no visual contact.

My best option is to give them both 10 questions to answer in writing one hour before the debate. No toadies/sycophants in the room to help answer. Then during the debate, read the question, and each answer, and ask the candidate to defend their answer. Sharpies allowed.

ShazzieB

(16,590 posts)
44. I don't tink it woud take much to make him stumble.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 06:51 PM
Apr 27

He's already prone to that because of his dementia, and evening (when debates are usually held) is the worst time of day for him. Some of his worst recent flubs have taken place at evevning rallies.

I actually don't think he'll debate Biden, just as he declined to debate his GOP rivals. His handlers are probably well aware that it would be a very bad idea. A debate is a test of one's ability to think and communicate on one's feet, and I think his deficiencies would would become obvious in such a situation.

Autumn

(45,120 posts)
8. With the stress he is under hopefully closer to the election he will be
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 03:34 PM
Apr 27

a drooling, demented person incapable of coherent speech making verbal outbursts and impulsive inappropriate statements to name a few issues. Fingers crossed and personally I hope it's all televised. I guess i better start watching clips of his "appearances" with his idiot fans.

littlemissmartypants

(22,841 posts)
30. Think about this...
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 05:34 PM
Apr 27

He's already falling asleep in court...at HIS OWN criminal trial.

When was the last time we've heard about a criminal trial defendant routinely falling asleep in the courtroom during the proceedings?

Can drooling be far behind?

Autumn

(45,120 posts)
33. Think maybe he's medicated to stop him from going ape shit crazy in court?
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 05:41 PM
Apr 27

It wouldn't surprise me. The lawyers could give it to him on the way in.

littlemissmartypants

(22,841 posts)
37. I don't think that we can make a broad claim that he insists on being
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 06:07 PM
Apr 27

"In control" and then would simultaneously allow for his handlers to sedate him to the point that he can't control his own bodily functions in a situation where his freedom is at stake. It just doesn't make sense.

I'm thinking that he's more likely suffering from a rebound effect brought on by a reduction in his Adderall* dosage. If he's not getting enough to keep him up, as the drug wears off, the rebound would be excessive sleepiness.

That combined with an exacerbation of the dementia would make it very difficult to stay alert without having some substance to help.

*or whatever stimulant he may have been prescribed for his rumored ADHD or whatever substance he has been abusing to stay jacked throughout his adulthood.

NBachers

(17,156 posts)
53. Well, I have to add this- I'm 75, and have a job where I have to keep moving. If I stop for any length of time,
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 09:21 PM
Apr 27

and sit down motionless, I start to get drowsy myself. If I was sitting in *rump's trial table, I may start nodding off, too.

I'm fine with driving; the activity keeps me alert. But if I'm on a long drive and get drowsy, I'll pull off and snooze for awhile.

I'm not saying this to defend the traitor, but if I was at his table, I may exhibit similar nodding-off behavior.

DENVERPOPS

(8,879 posts)
10. At one time,
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 03:46 PM
Apr 27

in psychology class, I asked the teacher: I don't understand the difference between a Neurosis and a Psychosis.....

He said: "A neurotic dreams about sand castles in the sky, the psychotic lives in them"........

I am pretty sure malignant narcism is ranked as a psychosis.............

Maybe someone out there knows???????????

Trump's delusions would probably qualify him for a 72 hour Mental Health Hold under normal circumstances......

calimary

(81,558 posts)
22. Wow! That's a great way to explain it, DENVERPOPS.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 04:49 PM
Apr 27

“At one time, in psychology class, I asked the teacher: I don't understand the difference between a Neurosis and a Psychosis.....

He said: "A neurotic dreams about sand castles in the sky, the psychotic lives in them"........

BlueKota

(1,837 posts)
41. I have undergone a lot of mental health treatment so I know a bit.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 06:28 PM
Apr 27

I have also been told the same about the castles. Most personality disorders can be treated to the point where even if it doesn't go away completely, you can function at a fairly normal level.

Narcissistic personality disorder, however, is an exception primarily because the person thinks they are perfectly fine, and there is absolutely no need for treatment. They of course aren't, but they will never be convinced differently.

There is also temporary psychosis which can happen to people who struggle with recurrent depression, which is normally considered a neurosis! If the depression gets to a severe enough state they can fall into a psychosis stage, but that can usually be treated with a med prescription or a change in meds, if the person is already in treatment but no longer responding to their current regime.

Trump's is not temporary from the opinion most of my own treatment team whom I've asked. They always qualify it with they can not offer an official diagnosis since they aren't treating him. They can only say his behavior is typical of Narcissistic PD.

I have severe recurrent depression which is treatable which makes me very lucky, even if it is not completely curable.

ShazzieB

(16,590 posts)
42. Malignant narcissism is a personality disorder, possibly a combination of more than one.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 06:37 PM
Apr 27

Last edited Sun Apr 28, 2024, 05:24 PM - Edit history (1)

It's not a psychosis, but a person doesn't have to be psychotic to be delusional, and Trump definitely appears to be delusional. One of the experts quoted in the op used the phrase "delusional grandiosity" in describing him, and I think that's very fitting.

Here's a description of malignant narcissism that I think is pretty thorough (not coincidentally, it sounds EXACTLY like Trump ) https://www.simplypsychology.org/malignant-narcissism.html

According to Dr. John Gartner, a psychologist who has written and talked a lot about Trump's mental problems, when someone with a severe personality disorder develops dementia, the personality disorder gets worse as the person becomes more and more confused and disoriented. Not a pleasant thing to contemplate, especially in Trump's case!

DENVERPOPS

(8,879 posts)
62. Thx Shazzie
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 11:44 PM
Apr 27

It is especially troubling and even more unpleasant to think of him getting back into power.

I think it is important that we remind everyone that NOTHING about Trump would be possible without the Republican owned Media, The Republican Senators and House Members, Fox News, RW Radio, and a shit load of money from the U.S. Uber Wealthy Republican Oligarchs..........

DENVERPOPS

(8,879 posts)
63. And even more thx
Sun Apr 28, 2024, 12:35 AM
Apr 28

for the website to explain..............

Most interesting, was the description in the article, made me reflect on the countless number of CEO's of major companies that it described perfectly, along with most of the executives under those CEO's.

I often thought, when watching those individuals, that thankfully the Corporate World gave them a place where their behavior was "socially acceptable", other wise they would be in a prisons somewhere............I am serious........What they would do to their employees and customers when making corporate decisions was beyond despicable........most took glee and great pleasure in bragging about what they had done!!!!!!!!! As if it was a badge of honor, and would fit well on their resume, to get them a bigger and better position with another Corporation.......

It is no wonder that all these corrupt Republican Politicians worship the corporations...........and are successfully able to work towards the destruction of ALL Gov't regulatory agencies.......Reagan, HWBush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Trump etc all championed that cause, and accomplished the destruction of untold regulatory laws......

Again, thank you, I love it when someone shares their knowledge with all of us.......

Response to DENVERPOPS (Reply #10)

brush

(53,957 posts)
31. I'm good with "loser." One of the commenters mentioned how he leans forward when standing.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 05:37 PM
Apr 27

I chuckled at that and thought that observation must have come early in trump's admin before it was common knowledge that the orange turd wears lifts to appear taller, and that's what causes his forward tilt.

Wonder if that commenter would make that same diagnosis today?

DFW

(54,467 posts)
65. Maybe Dr. Butala is a Republican, and forgot to translate into English
Sun Apr 28, 2024, 10:37 AM
Apr 28

See highlighted text:

EXCERPTS FROM THE OFFICIAL DICTIONARY OF REPUBLICANESE

In Republicanese, many words that sound alike may be spelled differently at random. A few prominent examples:

In Republicanese, the following words may be spelled at random using any of the three ways given:

A.) Two, Too, To
B.) Their, They're, There
c.) Your, Yore, You're

The Republicanese version of Robin Hood therefore starts with "In days of you're...."

The only rule is that the correct use of them as in English is never permitted twice in a row.

Words with single letters that change meaning when that letter is doubled must never be used in correct English context. The classic example is “lose” vs. “loose.” In Republicanese, if you do not win an election, then you “loose” that election. Conversely, if your (Republicanese: you’re) belt is too tight, you need it more “lose” in order to be comfortable. Another example would be the Republicanese, “I met Donald Trump, and he was rudder than I imagined,” vs. “I grabbed the ruder and was able to steer the boat to shore.”

Response to littlemissmartypants (Original post)

Ping Tung

(752 posts)
19. Is this one of those "Water is Wet" observations?
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 04:24 PM
Apr 27

Psychologists will be looking at Trump's paranoia, narcissism, and other forms of pathology for decades trying to figure out who was crazier. Him or the blockheads who voted for him.

Escurumbele

(3,407 posts)
20. Once again...I do believe he is demented, an evil being, but he is accomplishing a lot of the evil stuff he is after.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 04:25 PM
Apr 27

The corrupt Supreme Court seems to be going the way of granting the SOB immunity, the corrupt judge Cannon is working her way to dismiss, or at least prolong the documents trial (why hasn't Jack Smith done what he should to have Cannon recuse herself from the trial?), now it seems there is a juror in NY who is leaning (maybe got paid or planted) to be the one person to hung the jury, his numbers for the presidency have not suffered much if anything, they should be zero but, they remain the same, the $600 million bond was reduced to $175 million which he still has not paid, and so on, and on...so, is he demented or is he a genius who has been able to scare (maybe by compromising) the entire republican party, to keep his base almost intact, to convince Latinos like Venezuelans that he is the only one who can help Venezuela get rid of the regime, even though in John Bolton's book it is described how Putin told him to not do anything to help Venezuela, that Maduro is "strong and intelligent", which trump repeated to Bolton, and thus Bolton's plans were canned.

My question is, do people who seem to be in the cult care that he is suffering from dementia? I don't think so, and thus news about his dementia don't change anything, he is still there corrupting the system, breaking the rules on his gag orders and no one puts him in jail or make him suffer enough for him to stop, he keeps insulting people, and nothing changes.

I wonder if what is happening is that most of us who lean to normality, as well as the many doctors who find him demented, find his actions as signs of dementia, but he is fooling us all by continuing with his demented behaviour which may be in fact his modus operandi to accomplish as much as he has, and continues doing?

Democrats need to be become more aggressive towards the Supreme Court and other institutions to make things happen, if repubs don't like it? too bad, but it always seems like republicans accomplish what they are after, but Democrats exist in a reactive mode, that has to change.

Came back to EDIT this post because there is an article here in DU, with the appropriate link, that kind of corroborates what I just wrote. here is the DU link:

[link:https://www.democraticunderground.com/100218901295|

GB_RN

(2,395 posts)
64. Cannon Won't Recuse...
Sun Apr 28, 2024, 10:10 AM
Apr 28

And asking her would needlessly antagonize her. She’s already hostile enough.

Smith can’t go to the 11th Circuit Court and ask she be removed because she hasn’t quite crossed that line…yet. Had she not reversed her decision on making witness names public, Smith could have gone to the 11th for an appeal and demanded she be removed based on her long-running hostility and egregious decisions that the 11th has already had to overturn. She was probably advised she’d kinda fucked herself with the original decision and his appeal to her let her pull her own bacon out of the fire.

23. The 3rd(out of the 3 shown) person'sopinions have at least a couple of things wrong.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 04:57 PM
Apr 27

Last edited Sat Apr 27, 2024, 09:32 PM - Edit history (1)

"a normally aging person recognizes the mistake and corrects it."

Trump is not your average guy. He believes admitting mistakes is weak, he always has. It did not take dementia for him to show this trait. When he says something wrong, he pivots or continues forward on purpose.

If this guy knew trump decently well, he would know this

"Other obvious examples have been Trump saying .............the names of George Washington and Abraham Lincoln would be deleted from buildings."

Trump is playing on the concept that this comes under the umbrella of being "woke" and "Politically correct"
That the "Left" will carry those concepts to extreme, because we are 'crazy' and having these names taken down is within the possibilities of the crazies, that is just how crazy they are.

This reviewer just doesn't get it, his opinions hold no water for me.

littlemissmartypants

(22,841 posts)
27. It's not a random review but over 400 doctors and medical professionals and they aren't just giving an opinion...
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 05:17 PM
Apr 27

They are fulfilling what is their "Duty to Warn" for which I provide the definition.

This is a prime example of his dementia exacerbating as given by you.

When he says something wrong, he pivots or continues forward on purpose.


It's called confabulation which is a symptom of dementia. When faced with a situation that may make a person seem confused the person will just make something up on the spot because they aren't capable of anything else in that moment.

So, you have just given an example of one of the symptoms that he's been exhibiting for years that supports the duty to warn hypothesis.

49. You are missing a key component of Trumps style.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 07:45 PM
Apr 27

Google
"roy cohn" "trump" "never admit"

You will see this is part of who he is, not part of dementia.


https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/documentary/president-trump/transcript/?

TIMOTHY O’BRIEN: Roy Cohn taught Donald how to come out punching, how to use lawsuits like machine gun bullets and take a no-prisoners approach to City Hall, to your business opponents, to anyone else who might get in your way. And I think Donald reveled in that.

NARRATOR: But with damning evidence of racial discrimination, the company was forced to settle. Nevertheless, Trump didn’t admit any wrongdoing and even declared the outcome a victory.

TONY SCHWARTZ: This is a classic example of where Trump begins to demonstrate something he talks about all the time today, which is he’s a counter-puncher. So somebody comes after him and says that he’s done something nefarious and horrible, and he just goes back at them with all guns blazing. You know, boom, boom, boom! And admits nothing. Never admit anything. Never say you made a mistake. Just keep coming. And if you lose, declare victory. And that’s exactly what happened there. He lost as clearly as you can lose, but he loudly proclaimed his victory.
50. You are missing a key component of Trump's style
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 07:46 PM
Apr 27

Google
"roy cohn" "trump" "never admit"

You will see this is part of who he is, not part of dementia.


https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/documentary/president-trump/transcript/?

TIMOTHY O’BRIEN: Roy Cohn taught Donald how to come out punching, how to use lawsuits like machine gun bullets and take a no-prisoners approach to City Hall, to your business opponents, to anyone else who might get in your way. And I think Donald reveled in that.

NARRATOR: But with damning evidence of racial discrimination, the company was forced to settle. Nevertheless, Trump didn’t admit any wrongdoing and even declared the outcome a victory.

TONY SCHWARTZ: This is a classic example of where Trump begins to demonstrate something he talks about all the time today, which is he’s a counter-puncher. So somebody comes after him and says that he’s done something nefarious and horrible, and he just goes back at them with all guns blazing. You know, boom, boom, boom! And admits nothing. Never admit anything. Never say you made a mistake. Just keep coming. And if you lose, declare victory. And that’s exactly what happened there. He lost as clearly as you can lose, but he loudly proclaimed his victory.

littlemissmartypants

(22,841 posts)
52. These aren't my observations and I'm not missing anything.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 08:56 PM
Apr 27

But I can see how one might believe that they know him better than the trained more than a few professional experts in the fields of medicine and psychology with years of experience and education when trying to make a point that's completely counter to the main narrative here.

The fact is that as a person ages, any person experiences a reduction of the ability to control features of that which is considered a base personality. Some might call it who we really are deep down. We all become less able to inhibit and control our most basic personality traits. It's not an either or situation.

This becomes more important when a person has documented mental illness prior to the onset of dementia. Dementia exacerbates the previously diagnosed conditions and is compounded by them at the same time.

Your presumption isn't even related to the topic except for the fact that it attempts to explain past behaviors while completely ignoring the effects that brain diseases have on those behaviors as a person ages.

I'm quite familiar with his history but I appreciate you sharing it for others that may not have been aware. Even though it doesn't really relate to this discussion some people may find it interesting.

57. I made an observation.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 09:37 PM
Apr 27

The 3rd professional, out of the 3 shown, made some obvious errors.

I pointed them out.

You say you are aware of the history. You, no doubt, clearly see the errors he made.
Why make such of an issue about it, other than to say that it is a small thing, there are 399 other professional opinions to look at.

If you see a professional make an obvious mistake, you don't need to blindly follow them just because you are not a professional.

ShazzieB

(16,590 posts)
58. Yes, Cohn gave him that advice, but that's not what's going on now.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 11:09 PM
Apr 27

Trump is advanced enough in his dementia that he is making ridiculous factual errors (mixing up Nikki Haley with Nancy Pelosi and Jeb Bush with his father, etc.) and showing no sign that he even realizes he said something odd.

It's true that Trump has always been a liar. He's never hesitated to lie when it suited him and worked to his advantage. His lying has always been purposeful and intentional and often done with a specific goal in mind.

He's never been one to admit he's wrong about anything, mainly because his narcissism includes the belief that he knows more than anyone else and therefore can't ever be wrong. I'm sure Cohn's advice made perfect sense to Trump, because it dovetailed perfectly with his natural inclinations.

None of that matters now, because that's not what going on. His mind is turning into mush, and he's spouting all kinds of weird stuff that is divorced from reality because he's so confused he doesn't even know where he is half the time.

In the video I posted above, John Gartner gives lots of examples of how Trump’s current behavior is showing signs of advancing dementia. I hope you'll watch it, because Gartner explains the whole thing a hell of a lot better than I can.

59. Yes, your reply is exactly right, in my opinion.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 11:19 PM
Apr 27

It's true that he is making mistakes without realizing it.

That is true and the fact that it is happening so often and repetitively is a sign of dementia.
And that pro did emphasize those various things. I was attracted to the one flaw in that line of thinking when he said,
"a normally aging person recognizes the mistake and corrects it", because it is well known that looking at it from that perspective showed a lack of awareness of how Drumph's personality functions.

I agree that he shows signs of dementia, and the repeated mistakes are a symptom of that dementia.

ShazzieB

(16,590 posts)
60. Thanks for clarifying.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 11:38 PM
Apr 27

I am glad you agree that Trump is showing signs of dementia. That was not clear to me before, and I appreciate the clarification.

I don't see that as a "mistake" on that expert's part, though. I think Trump's current behavior is a reflection of his dementia more of than any advice Cohn gave him, and in that sense the expert was not wrong, imo.

bucolic_frolic

(43,427 posts)
25. I think it will be a matter of a few months.
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 05:07 PM
Apr 27

The stress of trial will not help that condition. Nor will hot weather.

doc03

(35,417 posts)
26. There where thousands of memtal health profesionals that said he was
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 05:13 PM
Apr 27

Coo coo years ago yet he was still elected.

littlemissmartypants

(22,841 posts)
28. And now that he's worse and declining...
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 05:21 PM
Apr 27

We could end up with "Weekend at Bernie's" in the Oval.

Weekend at Bernie's is a 1989 American dark comedy film directed by Ted Kotcheff, written by Robert Klane, and starring Andrew McCarthy, Jonathan Silverman, Catherine Mary Stewart, and Terry Kiser. It tells the story of two young insurance corporation employees who discover that their boss Bernie is dead after arriving at his house in The Hamptons. While attempting to convince people that Bernie is still alive until they can leave to prevent them from being falsely suspected for causing his death, they discover that Bernie had ordered their assassinations to cover up his embezzlement.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weekend_at_Bernie's


bluestarone

(17,101 posts)
38. Problem is, as i see it
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 06:16 PM
Apr 27

TFG is the monster that brought out ALL the low life CULTIST TRAITORS. (Supreme Court included) These no good bastards have made their move and decided to GP FOR IT!! They are in charge NOW. The Supreme Court could RULE on anything THER WA, and what are we gonna do about it? We can do NOTHING because THEY and their religion has taken our country down THEIR path. Even if TFG dies tomorrow this doesn't stop. I worry this election that THIS Supreme Court COULD and possibly WILL steal our election AGAIN. BE READY!

red dog 1

(27,889 posts)
61. Trump has dementia!
Sat Apr 27, 2024, 11:42 PM
Apr 27

"Dr. John Gartner explains why it's absolutely clear that Donald Trump has dementia"
https://democraticunderground.com/100218902763








(Link is to same video in reply # 36)

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Duty to Warn...profession...