Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Hissyspit

(45,788 posts)
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 05:00 PM Jun 2013

David Sirota: "New Data Shows School 'Reformers' Are Full of It - Propaganda Has Jumped the Shark"

http://www.salon.com/2013/06/03/instead_of_a_war_on_teachers_how_about_one_on_poverty

MONDAY, JUN 3, 2013 12:30 PM EDT

New data shows school “reformers” are full of it

Poor schools underperform largely because of economic forces, not because teachers have it too easy


BY DAVID SIROTA

- snip -

Meanwhile, despite the fact that many “reformers’” policies have spectacularly failed, prompted massive scandals and/or offered no actual proof of success, an elite media that typically amplifies — rather than challenges — power and money loyally casts “reformers’” systematic pillaging of public education as laudable courage (the most recent example of this is Time magazine’s cover cheering on wildly unpopular Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel after he cited budget austerity to justify the largest mass school closing in American history — all while he is also proposing to spend $100 million of taxpayer dollars on a new private sports stadium).

- snip -

That gets to the news that exposes “reformers’” schemes — and all the illusions that surround them. According to a new U.S. Department of Education study, “about one in five public schools was considered high poverty in 2011 … up from about to one in eight in 2000.” This followed an earlier study from the department finding that “many high-poverty schools receive less than their fair share of state and local funding … leav(ing) students in high-poverty schools with fewer resources than schools attended by their wealthier peers.”

Those data sets powerfully raise the question that “reformers” are so desperate to avoid: Are we really expected to believe that it’s just a coincidence that the public education and poverty crises are happening at the same time? Put another way: Are we really expected to believe that everything other than poverty is what’s causing problems in failing public schools?

Because of who comprises it and how it is financed, the education “reform” movement has a clear self-interest in continuing to say yes, we should believe such fact-free pabulum. And you can bet that movement will keep saying “yes” — and that the corporate media will continue to cheer them as heroes for saying “yes” — as long as public education money keeps being diverted into corporate coffers.

But we’ve now reached the point where the economics-omitting “reform” propaganda has jumped the shark, going from deceptively alluring to embarrassingly transparent. That’s because the latest Department of Education study isn’t being released in a vacuum; it caps off an overwhelming wave of evidence showing that our education crisis has far less to do with public schools or bad teachers than it does with the taboo subject of crushing poverty.

MORE AT LINK[p]
35 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
David Sirota: "New Data Shows School 'Reformers' Are Full of It - Propaganda Has Jumped the Shark" (Original Post) Hissyspit Jun 2013 OP
Slight quibble: The $100 million arena will be used for conventions as well as basketball KamaAina Jun 2013 #1
the city money IS from the hotel tax. mopinko Jun 2013 #29
k&r Starry Messenger Jun 2013 #2
Sirota reiterates what other studies have shown and yet the Plutocracy continues to steamroll byeya Jun 2013 #3
The Plutocrats kids don't go to public schools. Rex Jun 2013 #5
...and they see successful public school kids as (unfair) competition for their kids librechik Jun 2013 #8
Agree, it is how THEY got into the ivy league schools Rex Jun 2013 #9
... Fumesucker Jun 2013 #16
Priced the Ivy League out of reach while an I. L.education remains walking around $$$ for byeya Jun 2013 #27
I remember that dog character from another Dancing Bug toon, the "Lucky Ducky" toon! alp227 Jun 2013 #34
DURec leftstreet Jun 2013 #4
Kick. Nt xchrom Jun 2013 #6
k&r for the truth. n/t Laelth Jun 2013 #7
Hear Hear, Ma'am The Magistrate Jun 2013 #10
Another way of saying it: MyOwnPeace Jun 2013 #24
I have nothing against Private (Charter) Schools, bvar22 Jun 2013 #11
You are more open minded than I am. I'm against them all around TheKentuckian Jun 2013 #20
Every time I hear someone piously saying SheilaT Jun 2013 #12
Ugh. Yes I'm sick of that too. proud2BlibKansan Jun 2013 #14
Sirota's wife ran for school board in Colorado recently proud2BlibKansan Jun 2013 #13
+1000!! lindysalsagal Jun 2013 #15
Excellent! another_liberal Jun 2013 #17
I've grown tired savebigbird Jun 2013 #18
File this under "No Shit Sherlock." Nanjing to Seoul Jun 2013 #19
and those schools who underperform because they already don't have enough funding lose even more liberal_at_heart Jun 2013 #21
the school reform/privatization movement is partly about union busting and NoMoreWarNow Jun 2013 #22
kr HiPointDem Jun 2013 #23
kick nt Hissyspit Jun 2013 #25
Old data showed it, too. LWolf Jun 2013 #26
+1000 This is not new news. From reagan to arne Jakes Progress Jun 2013 #31
yes siree 'ignant an po' begets more ignant an po' what else can we expect, right? azurnoir Jun 2013 #28
Here's what it's all about: blkmusclmachine Jun 2013 #30
Ignore any politicians who say they care about children. Jakes Progress Jun 2013 #32
"It's the plutonomy, stupid." Egalitarian Thug Jun 2013 #33
k/r marmar Jun 2013 #35
 

KamaAina

(78,249 posts)
1. Slight quibble: The $100 million arena will be used for conventions as well as basketball
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 05:05 PM
Jun 2013

it's part of the city's McCormick Place convention complex.

But still, it's a $100 million arena in a city that claims it's broke. Similar projects elsehwere are most often funded by raising the hotel tax.

mopinko

(70,239 posts)
29. the city money IS from the hotel tax.
Tue Jun 4, 2013, 03:28 PM
Jun 2013

and the city is funding is only about 1/3 of the cost.
just sayin'.

 

byeya

(2,842 posts)
3. Sirota reiterates what other studies have shown and yet the Plutocracy continues to steamroll
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 05:12 PM
Jun 2013

the ordinary citizens and his/her needs.
It would seem the Plutocrats never run out of stooges to do their bidding.

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
5. The Plutocrats kids don't go to public schools.
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 05:16 PM
Jun 2013

They hate everything to do with the working class. It pains them that we get anything beneficial in society. Nothing would make them happier then if we all just gave up and signed contracts of indentured servitude.

librechik

(30,676 posts)
8. ...and they see successful public school kids as (unfair) competition for their kids
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 05:39 PM
Jun 2013

and don't mind cutting them off at the knees. After all they pay big money for their kid's education--why should poor kids get the same for nothing? Moochers.

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
9. Agree, it is how THEY got into the ivy league schools
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 05:42 PM
Jun 2013

their mommy or daddy knew someone (or gave a large lump sum of money to the school)...while the kid from a middle class family who worked his/her ass off to get a scholarship...only to find out the wealthy family got priority.

 

byeya

(2,842 posts)
27. Priced the Ivy League out of reach while an I. L.education remains walking around $$$ for
Tue Jun 4, 2013, 08:57 AM
Jun 2013

the poobahs and moguls of the 1%.

The Magistrate

(95,255 posts)
10. Hear Hear, Ma'am
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 06:41 PM
Jun 2013

The best predictors of student performance are and have always been parental income and parental literacy level.

MyOwnPeace

(16,940 posts)
24. Another way of saying it:
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 09:54 PM
Jun 2013

Save the money from all of the "testing" - just drive through the neighborhood where the child lives - it'll tell you everything you need to know.

bvar22

(39,909 posts)
11. I have nothing against Private (Charter) Schools,
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 06:58 PM
Jun 2013
...as long as they don't receive one single penny of Tax Payer Money.
We already have a Public School system.
If it is broken, we need ti Fix It,
and not siphon off the money into already RICH "private" pockets.

...and that is exactly what "Charter" Schools are,
a money making scam.

TheKentuckian

(25,029 posts)
20. You are more open minded than I am. I'm against them all around
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 08:33 PM
Jun 2013

Put little Chase and Colby in with the rest of the kids and shit will change. Keep giving them an escape capsule and they'll ever be back trying to destroy or profit from the public system.

I think the FDR moderates have been proven wrong by the last several decades, there is no dealing with wealthy interests because ever will they seek to eat it all up. Capitalism cannot successfully be leashed other than for a brief moment while they wait for the torches to be extinguished and the pitchforks to dull.

 

SheilaT

(23,156 posts)
12. Every time I hear someone piously saying
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 07:19 PM
Jun 2013

that we can't solve some problem -- usually they're talking about public schools -- by throwing money at it, I think, What about the military? Let's not throw any money there. Our soldiers can provide their own uniforms and weapons. And so on. But no, they are ALWAYS willing to throw money at our military, meaning pay for ludicrously expensive weapons systems, but kids can be 60 to a classroom and that's okay.

proud2BlibKansan

(96,793 posts)
14. Ugh. Yes I'm sick of that too.
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 07:48 PM
Jun 2013

We throw money at lots of things. But the only complaints are about education.

proud2BlibKansan

(96,793 posts)
13. Sirota's wife ran for school board in Colorado recently
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 07:46 PM
Jun 2013

Glad to see him offering his voice to the struggle.

Thanks for posting Hissy!

lindysalsagal

(20,733 posts)
15. +1000!!
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 07:48 PM
Jun 2013

Can I hear an A-men?!!!

And add to that, many of the parents who are not considered under the poverty line are working such long hours, they're not really being good parents anymore, or helping with learning problems, homework, etc.

So everyone is being hurt by this economy, except, say it together now, "The 1% who are making out like bandits."

 

another_liberal

(8,821 posts)
17. Excellent!
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 07:52 PM
Jun 2013

Thank you for posting this material, Hissyspit.

Few things make me angrier than how privately owned educational corporations are turning American children into mere commodities. Some of their CEOs make seven figure salaries from our tax dollars! Public education should not become yet another for-profit racket.

savebigbird

(417 posts)
18. I've grown tired
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 08:13 PM
Jun 2013

of hearing and reading the word "data." So tired that I have decided not to say the word for a while. For the time being, I will be referring to that term as, "assumptions or premises from which inferences may be drawn."

liberal_at_heart

(12,081 posts)
21. and those schools who underperform because they already don't have enough funding lose even more
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 08:34 PM
Jun 2013

funding because they underperform on state standardized tests.

 

NoMoreWarNow

(1,259 posts)
22. the school reform/privatization movement is partly about union busting and
Mon Jun 3, 2013, 08:49 PM
Jun 2013

partly about cowing to big business.

LWolf

(46,179 posts)
26. Old data showed it, too.
Tue Jun 4, 2013, 08:25 AM
Jun 2013

Before the high-stakes testing movement got going, we knew that standardized tests were a reflection of socio-economic status, not "achievement."

Jakes Progress

(11,122 posts)
31. +1000 This is not new news. From reagan to arne
Tue Jun 4, 2013, 04:08 PM
Jun 2013

they all ignored evidence and experience. They tossed out bullshit and knew it was bullshit when they offered it up to a child-hating public.

Anyone can read Donald Graves. And everyone should have read Berliner and Biddle's "Manufactured Crisis" and the ED Week material of Gerald Bracey and Alfie Kohn's stuff. If people read those (and cared about children) we could have avoided the crap that reagan started and Obama is now pushing.

azurnoir

(45,850 posts)
28. yes siree 'ignant an po' begets more ignant an po' what else can we expect, right?
Tue Jun 4, 2013, 03:16 PM
Jun 2013

sad fact is that while everyone weighing in on the righteousness of these stats, what they do not seem to realize is that these stats are used to maintain these stats, by some that are well meaning and some that are not, but it is the truth pure and simple

Jakes Progress

(11,122 posts)
32. Ignore any politicians who say they care about children.
Tue Jun 4, 2013, 04:10 PM
Jun 2013

This is not a country that cares about children. There is no evidence to show that America gives a damn about its children. Our politicians reflect that.

 

Egalitarian Thug

(12,448 posts)
33. "It's the plutonomy, stupid."
Tue Jun 4, 2013, 04:19 PM
Jun 2013

Trillions for Wall Street, nothing for Main Street.

And the beat goes on...

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»David Sirota: "New Data S...