Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Catherina

(35,568 posts)
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 06:23 PM Jul 2013

Brazilian Senators call on their govt to give asylum to Snowden, cancel state dinner in USA

Translation mine


Senators Call On Brazil To Grant Asylum To Edward Snowden

Álvaro Dias suggests that Dilma Rousseff cancel her trip as head of state to the U.S. in October


By Júnia Gama
Publicado: 8/07/13 - 17h21


Protesters hold signs with a picture of Barack Obama and the American whistelblower Edward Snowden KENZO TRIBOUILLARD / AFP

...

Senator Requião (PMDB-PR) called thewhistleblower of "Hero" and lamented that other countries have offered asylum to Snowden, while Brazil, which was the target of espionage, did not. Senator Eduardo Suplicy (PT-SP) supported his colleague's position.

...

Senator Alvaro Dias (PSDB-PR) was harder and demanded that the Brazilian government ask explanations directly from President Barack Obama, and if they were not satisfactory, argued that Dilma Rousseff needs to cancel her trip as head of state to Washington in October.

This allegation is so serious that it is not enough to question the State Department. President Obama has to be questioned, from head of state to head of state. If the explanations are not satisfactory, Dilma has to cancel her official commitment in October. The reaction of Brazil was very timid and too in-line withprotocol. The Brazilian government which generously gave shelter to foreigners as Cesare Battisti, could also do so now with this American citizen, who may even be useful to unravel the mysteries of this International wire-tapping, he said.

Senator Lindbergh Farias (PT-RJ) also positioned himself favorably to the request to provide asylum for the former intelligence analyst. For the senator, the young man put his life at risk by denouncing the scheme of espionage... The inviolability of communication, the right to privacy, is one of the basic principles of democracy and I think this young man, Edward Snowden, has to be treated differently - Lindbergh said.

...

(The article goes on like that with more Senators speaking up for Snowden)

http://oglobo.globo.com/mundo/senadores-defendem-que-brasil-conceda-asilo-edward-snowden-8962251
24 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Brazilian Senators call on their govt to give asylum to Snowden, cancel state dinner in USA (Original Post) Catherina Jul 2013 OP
You think the rest of the world is pissed off at us? Rex Jul 2013 #1
That was my suggestion from the start Catherina Jul 2013 #3
I would fall out of my chair if the POTUS Rex Jul 2013 #5
Maybe the executive leaders of Germany, France, England, Canada, NZ & OZ KittyWampus Jul 2013 #7
I won't argue that it is completely legal to spy in any of those countries. Rex Jul 2013 #20
Me too. Ahh, here we go, State Dept briefing up. Here's the part about Brazil. More of same nothing Catherina Jul 2013 #9
But the spying is all perfectly legal... R. Daneel Olivaw Jul 2013 #12
Yeah that is what is so crazy, you know I bet it is legal Rex Jul 2013 #18
I agree with Pres Dilma... ReRe Jul 2013 #14
If the USA boycotts the Olympics, it would mean a better chance at more medals Amonester Jul 2013 #21
Well, there's an angle I hadn't thought of... ;-) n/t ReRe Jul 2013 #23
Without even knowing or understanding US laws, this is all of SA's chance to jump on kelliekat44 Jul 2013 #2
In their defense noamnety Jul 2013 #4
Very glad to see action from Brasil. I had my doubts if they'd get on board and they byeya Jul 2013 #6
Snowden SamKnause Jul 2013 #8
Hear! Hear!! ^^^^^^^^^ ReRe Jul 2013 #15
What happens if they don't attend the State Dinner? ProSense Jul 2013 #10
They'll have to cancel the State Dinner, since no one wants to attend? n/t ReRe Jul 2013 #16
LOL! ProSense Jul 2013 #19
Maybe they should give their tickets to Rafael Nunes Amonester Jul 2013 #22
good call! Enrique Sep 2013 #24
This is getting interesting, fun even. longship Jul 2013 #11
U.S.A. = International Pariah State. DeSwiss Jul 2013 #13
DemocracyNow! Glenn Greenwald: "Rogue" Actions of U.S. in Snowden Row Yield Latin American Offers Catherina Jul 2013 #17
 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
1. You think the rest of the world is pissed off at us?
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 06:25 PM
Jul 2013

And instead of playing damage control, the WH is playing CYA which only makes them look more guilty to those outside D.C.

Catherina

(35,568 posts)
3. That was my suggestion from the start
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 06:35 PM
Jul 2013


Anyone who didn't see this coming, who tried to minimize it as *nothing to see here*, did the Democrat Party no favors.

Brazil is already pissed off enough about the Morales Plane incident which their President called “unacceptable” and “embarrassing” in an official statement for UNASUR. And I guarantee you all the information people have linking the US to that has been sent to their FM. When Morales' plane was forced to land, the Spanish Ambassador kept running back and forth to "consult with our friends". Everyone knows what that meant.

I'm not proud at all of how we're mishandling this.

“Our government would like to convey our indignation and disapproval of the humiliation imposed on President Evo Morales by some European countries as they prevented his presidential plane from flying through their airspace,” said Dilma's statement.

President Dilma added that the Brazilian government was “surprised and appalled” by what happened, noting that it would negatively affect relations with Europe. “Such a humiliating attitude toward President Morales affects not only Bolivia, but all of Latin America. It harms dialogue and potential negotiations between the two continents. This provocation calls for a prompt explanation and appropriate apologies by the countries involved," she said.

The statement also read, “The alleged pretext for this unacceptable conduct – the suspicion that Edward Snowden was in the president's plane – is fanciful and constitutes a serious violation of international law and practices. [It violates the] rules of civilized relationship between nations. What's even more serious – it put the lives of president Morales and his staff in jeopardy.”

...

http://www.ebc.com.br/english/2013/07/incident-with-morales-harms-dialogue-with-europe-says-brazilian-president
 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
5. I would fall out of my chair if the POTUS
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 06:39 PM
Jul 2013

came on the TVEE and issued an apology to the world.

It is the double standard role in which they invented and have no one but themselves to blame - condemn those that get caught spying; yet when YOU get caught, never admit to spying.

 

KittyWampus

(55,894 posts)
7. Maybe the executive leaders of Germany, France, England, Canada, NZ & OZ
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 06:46 PM
Jul 2013

can all make a joint appearance with Obama and apologize as a group to each country.

Sort of like the political version of the Traveling Wilburys.

With a special guest appearance from the head of Venezuela since they spy too.

China & Russia will have to get their own act. Maybe with Iran.

Now Israel… who would get together with Israel…

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
20. I won't argue that it is completely legal to spy in any of those countries.
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 11:58 PM
Jul 2013

No more so then the US. And absolutely nobody should be shocked that the US is in full CYA mode while trying to chase around a loose cannon.

Water is wet, bears poop in the forest.

If we had a first time for anything, it was that they did it legally now.

Catherina

(35,568 posts)
9. Me too. Ahh, here we go, State Dept briefing up. Here's the part about Brazil. More of same nothing
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 06:53 PM
Jul 2013

QUESTION: Can I ask a question about Brazil?

MS. PSAKI: Sure.

QUESTION: Could you confirm whether, with or without the consent or an agreement with the Brazilian Government, the United States Government has maintained a database of monitoring or a monitoring center in Brasilia or have ever collected data at the Embassy of Brazil in Washington or at the Embassy of Brazil in the United Nations using physical devices installed in computers and using software such as Highlands, Vagrant, and Lifesaver?

MS. PSAKI: Well, as has been our policy, we’re not going to comment publicly on every specific alleged intelligence activity. As a matter of policy, we have been clear that the United States does gather foreign intelligence of the type gathered by all nations. I can tell you that we have spoken with Brazilian officials regarding these allegations. We plan to continue our dialogue with the Brazilians through normal diplomatic channels, but those are conversations that, of course, we would keep private.

QUESTION: To clarify, the physical presence of devices of the United States in consulates or embassies of Brazil anywhere in the world, can you confirm that existence or not?

MS. PSAKI: I do not have anything more for you on that.

Go ahead.

QUESTION: Can I have a follow-up on Latin America --

MS. PSAKI: Sure.

QUESTION: -- and Mr. Snowden --

QUESTION: No, no. Still Brazil?

MS. PSAKI: Okay, go ahead.

QUESTION: Yes, yes. I wonder regarding the reaction of Brazilian officials, among them the Minister of Foreign Relations Antonio Patriota, I wanted to know how much this issue can contaminate the visit of President Dilma Rousseff to United States in October.

MS. PSAKI: Well, clearly, as I mentioned, we’ve been already in touch with Brazilian authorities regarding these allegations and we’re planning to continue that dialogue. We work with Brazil on a wide range of issues and we are hopeful that we can continue to discuss and resolve through normal diplomatic conversations.

QUESTION: Who’s in this side of the diplomatic channel in the U.S. side? Who is talking to the Brazilian Government? Can you tell us?

MS. PSAKI: I don’t have any specific readout of officials for – on that for you.

QUESTION: Secretary Kerry has talked with Minister Antonio Patriota or --

MS. PSAKI: Not that I’m aware of in recent days. I’m happy to check on that for you and see if there has been a call I’m just not aware of.

QUESTION: Is that the first time that the United States have faced these sort of queries from Brazil, these sort of clarifying requests from Brazil?

MS. PSAKI: I’d leave that to you to determine historically if this has been an issue in the past. But obviously, this is a unique case. We all know the history here. We’re in close contact and we’ll continue those conversations.

QUESTION: Since 2001, has Brazil agreed to collaborate with United States in data mining or data reporting?

MS. PSAKI: I just don’t have anything more on this for you.

QUESTION: Jen, is that (inaudible) Turkish Government --

MS. PSAKI: Hold on, let’s finish on Brazil and then we can go to you next, if that’s okay.

http://www.state.gov/r/pa/prs/dpb/2013/07/211603.htm#BRAZIL

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
18. Yeah that is what is so crazy, you know I bet it is legal
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 11:56 PM
Jul 2013

in all the other countries that play the game. Or they could just yell, 'Simpson's did it first' and start now. Crazy shit.

ReRe

(10,597 posts)
14. I agree with Pres Dilma...
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 09:49 PM
Jul 2013

Treating him with disrespect, in cahoots with other nations, was one thing. But damn'it, they could have run out of fuel up there and crashed to the ground. Was that the real reason the USA pulled the trick in the first place? Believing that Snowden was on board, could they have wanted Evo's plane to crash? I wouldn't put anything past this sick secret government we have.

Shame on PO for letting the NSA run roughshod out of effing control. They are giving him a black eye (no pun intended) on the international stage now. I will stop there. Yes, I'm self-censoring, so as not to bring down the roof on this thread. In the name of peace, for Christ's sake!

And another thing no one is remembering... isn't the Olympics coming up in Brazil? Will the USA boycott the Olympics, if Evo allows Snowden to come there? Maybe I''m getting my countries mixed up? I do get things mixed up these days... too damn much to keep up with for this old girl.

Amonester

(11,541 posts)
21. If the USA boycotts the Olympics, it would mean a better chance at more medals
Tue Jul 9, 2013, 12:06 AM
Jul 2013

for Brazil...

Not something they would be mad about... I presume!

 

kelliekat44

(7,759 posts)
2. Without even knowing or understanding US laws, this is all of SA's chance to jump on
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 06:28 PM
Jul 2013

the US which they have wanted to do for some time. And it satisfies all those folks with tax haven in SA, EU, and the CRB that they can claim a reason other than just plain greed and disloyalty for stashing their wealth elsewhere while reaping all the benefits from the US economy.

 

byeya

(2,842 posts)
6. Very glad to see action from Brasil. I had my doubts if they'd get on board and they
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 06:41 PM
Jul 2013

still may not take as much action as they could.

SamKnause

(13,108 posts)
8. Snowden
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 06:51 PM
Jul 2013

THANK YOU Brazil !!!!

This U.S. citizen is VERY grateful !!!!!

It is apparent that me and my fellow citizens can not get our government to abide by the rule of law.

They flaunt their lawlessness in our faces at every opportunity.

They are brazen about it and bold with their lies and propaganda.

They will aid, abet, and enable Wall Street to continue their thievery.

The MIC, NSA, CIA, DEA, ATF, FBI and Homeland Security are in the business of selling fear, and business is good.

They hold out their hands for our tax dollars and our government fills them with no questions asked.

We have torturers who write books and appear on TV stating they would do it again.

Our government has sold the future of this country to global corporations.

The agencies that are suppose to protect us have been totally useless.

I appreciate any outside help and welcome the brave whistleblowers.

Our flag should be flying upside down because our country is in great distress.

ProSense

(116,464 posts)
10. What happens if they don't attend the State Dinner?
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 07:00 PM
Jul 2013

China is making noise too.

Snowden affair clouds U.S. attempts to press China to curb cyber theft
http://www.democraticunderground.com/10023202232

Amonester

(11,541 posts)
22. Maybe they should give their tickets to Rafael Nunes
Tue Jul 9, 2013, 12:12 AM
Jul 2013

Rafael Nunes, the “Ridiculously Photogenic Homeless Guy.”

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/26/ridiculously-photogenic-homeless-guy_n_2007113.html

I'm sure he would appreciate their royal fest.

Catherina

(35,568 posts)
17. DemocracyNow! Glenn Greenwald: "Rogue" Actions of U.S. in Snowden Row Yield Latin American Offers
Mon Jul 8, 2013, 09:53 PM
Jul 2013

DemocracyNow! Glenn Greenwald: "Rogue" Actions of U.S. in Snowden Row Yield Latin American Offers of Asylum


Published on Jul 8, 2013

http://www.democracynow.org - Venezuela, Bolivia and Nicaragua have opened the door to granting asylum to National Security Agency whistleblower Edward Snowden in a standoff with the United States. The offers came after a plane carrying Bolivian President Evo Morales was forced to land in Austria after France and Portugal barred it from their airspace over false suspicions that Snowden was on board. The United States has refused to confirm or deny whether it was responsible. We discuss the latest with Guardian journalist Glenn Greenwald, who broke the NSA surveillance story based on Snowden's leaks last month. In his latest scoop, Greenwald has revealed the NSA has systematically tapped into Brazil's telecommunication network and indiscriminately intercepted, collected and stored the email and telephone records of millions of Brazilians for years. "The U.S. government has been its own worst enemy in this entire episode," Greenwald says. "The idea they would pressure their European allies to block the plane carrying the president of a sovereign state is a really radical and extreme act. It smacks of rogue nation status and the kind of imperialism and colonialism that Latin America has long chafed at. I think that's the reason you're seeing so much support for Snowden in Latin American governments and among the populations as well."
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Brazilian Senators call o...