General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsBlackfish: the Science Behind the Movie (movie on captive killer whales)
By Naomi Rose marine mammal scientist for the Animal Welfare Institute in Washington, DC. and
Chris Parsons, whale and dolphin researcher
September 18th, 2013
The Oscar-winning documentary The Cove told the story of the dolphin hunt in the Japanese town of Taiji. Dolphins there are driven into a shallow cove and killed for meat and other products, with a select few set aside alive for sale to dolphinariums. Many are now saying that this years documentary on killer whales (Orcinus orca) in captivity, Blackfish, will be nominated for next years Oscar. Documentaries rarely get many viewers in movie theaters, but Blackfish, which cost only $76,000 to make and was initially released at only five movie theaters, has already grossed about $2 million nationwide and has been ranked among the 10 best performing nature documentaries, which include March of the Penguins and the much vaunted IMAX-friendly Earth and Oceans documentaries.
Blackfish focuses on the four people who have been killed by captive killer whales, bad corporate behavior by marine theme parks (especially SeaWorld) and the ethics of keeping killer whales in captivity. The film focuses particularly on the story of Tilikum, a 12,000lb male killer whale who was captured from Iceland in the early 1980s, has been living at SeaWorld of Florida since 1992, and to date has been involved in the deaths of three people. His last victim, his trainer of six years Dawn Brancheau, was brutally dismembered after he pulled her into the tank with him on February 24, 2010.
The stars of the film are people who have worked for marine theme parks, either as trainers or as collectors who captured killer whales from the wild. An interview with one of the latter is especially moving, as he testifies about accidentally killing several juveniles during a capture operation in Washington State; the distressed behavior these animals exhibited during the captures; trying to hide the bodies by sinking them with stones; and the guilt he still feels decades later. Many of the assertions of the film are supported by interviews with those involved, video footage, or reference to autopsy reports and court testimony.
Several whale and dolphin biologists are also interviewed. They provide information about killer whales in the wild, to allow the audience to contrast the situation described by former trainers who worked only with whales in captivity. We note that some of the information in these segments is a bit overstated. For example, one expert states that no orca has ever attacked a person in the wild. In fact there have been at least three attacks reported (in the entire course of history!), although none of them resulted in serious injury or death. The whales broke off their attacks, presumably when they realized the people they were targeting werent appropriate prey. So while it is a key point that killer whales only kill people in captivity, wild whales are not entirely benign.
full article
http://www.southernfriedscience.com/?p=15500
Blackfish Trailer, in movie theatres now and on CNN October 24th
Octafish
(55,745 posts)They must be sentient, in that they go crazy when denied their freedom.
Boy's orca encounter short, scary
Whale researchers say it was highly unusual for a killer whale to bump a 12-year-old boy splashing in shallow water near Ketchikan. Ellis Miller found himself...
By The Associated Press
KETCHIKAN, Alaska Whale researchers say it was highly unusual for a killer whale to bump a 12-year-old boy splashing in shallow water near Ketchikan.
Ellis Miller found himself face-to-face with an orca charging at him in 4 feet of water Saturday in Helm Bay. The animal, estimated to be more than 25 feet long, bumped but did not bite him.
"I looked underwater and there was this huge head right in front of me," Ellis told the Ketchikan Daily News.
SNIP...
The whale bumped Ellis on the left side of his chest and shoulder, then arched around him.
"Ellis was in the middle, and he was totally surrounded," Kathy Arntzen said.
She reached forward and grabbed Ellis as the pressure wave caused by the whale's rapid advance swept them toward the beach.
"Within a second we were on the shore," Kathy said. "We got out fast."
The episode lasted about five seconds, they said.
As the orca returned to deeper water, six more killer whales surfaced near the beach.
They swam along the beach for 100 yards or so and then returned. They swam back and forth several times. On the last pass, the largest orca rolled onto its side, raised a pectoral fin and smacked the water about five times. Then it hit the water with its tail. The other whales followed in a line and began doing the same.
"It was like the whole bay was boiling at this point," Kathy Arntzen said. "They were up and down and making noise. ... It was like they were signaling us."
CONTINUED...
http://seattletimes.com/html/localnews/2002445380_orca19m.html
Perhaps in the future we can provide more humane systems for those under study. As for the aquariums that use them to perform, run a movie. There's no replacing the infinite possibilities that a single human life represents.
Beringia
(4,316 posts)and the movie, there is no actual scientific study going on with the captive whales. The activists advocate using aquariams like SeaWorld to rehabilitate sick and beached whales and use that as education. The main thing aquariums have learned about killer whales is how to keep them in a sterile pool and extend their lives as long as possible and also how much they eat and how long their gestation period is.
"There's no replacing the infinite possibilities that a single human life represents." (What does this refer to?)
Octafish
(55,745 posts)It's a phrase I use to describe what each human life represents. Of course, I would include dolphins, whales, the great apes and other animals if they are shown to possess that special spark that makes human beings so special.
hatrack
(59,592 posts)Will definitely see it.
joeybee12
(56,177 posts)I wish SeaWorld would go out of business.