Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

annm4peace

(6,119 posts)
Wed Dec 4, 2013, 11:29 PM Dec 2013

City of Fresno spent $ 13,106,534 for 64 unit apartment for Homeless, ($ 190,000 per unit) Crooks!

Mike Rhodes has been editor for the Community Alliance newspaper, the only progressive newspaper in the Central Valley of CA.
Fresno. The link below is his last article. He has been reporting and documenting on the Homeless and attacks on the Homeless by the City of Fresno. I am often worried for his safety because of his reporting, especially on the police violence against the homeless and the questionable death of homeless woman Pam Kincaid. I have often posted Mike's exposed stories. And always hope these stories make their way to someone in power who can help. I have just post some paragraphs in his last article.

At the end of this is a link to see the long list of articles, each story heartbreaking and unbelievable. Unbelievable that the abuse by the City continues and the State of CA doesn't do anything to stop it.

One of the most amazing is how the Feds gave the City of Fresno millions of dollars to help the homeless, and that money was used to build an apartment with 64 units.. it is estimated there are over 5000 homeless people,, incredible !
Where is the accountability? Mike uncovers the truth or at least some of it. Where is the DA of CA ? Where is the US Attorney General?

Here is his whole article, but you can scroll down to the part on the Homeless.

http://fresnoalliance.com/wordpress/?p=8692

Speaking of the power elite in Fresno and their ability to tell a narrative about an important local issue, the mayor and her allies have a message for you about the homeless. It is a simple message that says homeless encampments in downtown Fresno were destroyed because they were not fit for human habitation and that the encampments should not exist. Permanent housing, they say, is the answer.

The problem with this simple message is that, as the mayor and the city’s elite well know, “permanent housing” to house the city’s homeless does not exist. Worse, there are no real plans to provide housing. The only plan is to destroy encampments, leaving the homeless with no shelter and pushing them further into desperate conditions.



If people in Fresno knew what the official City of Fresno policy was doing to the homeless they would be appalled. They might even be moved to do something about it.


The City of Fresno did destroy all of the homeless encampments in downtown Fresno. That much we agree on. The problem is that destroying the homeless encampments did not mean that the people living in them got housing. The homeless people who got displaced are now living under oleander bushes, in Courthouse Park, on the Fulton Mall and just about every place you can imagine. You have probably even seen them in your neighborhood. Destroying their humble shelters did not solve a thing, and the city has not been involved with building new housing for the homeless since the Renaissance at Santa Clara was opened in November 2012. They have no plans to build any new housing for the homeless.

The city’s elite celebrated the opening of the Renaissance at Santa Clara as a solution to homelessness. But take a closer look. The Renaissance at Santa Clara, built for $13,106,534, houses 69 people in 340-square-foot studio apartments. That is a breathtaking $190,000 per unit! Would it surprise you to know that Tom Richards of Penstar, who got the development contract for this project, is the chairperson of Fresno First Steps Home and was the chairperson of the city’s Ten-Year Plan to End Homelessness committee? Penstar executives contributed a significant amount of money to Mayor Swearengin’s reelection campaign, and Penstar made about $1,000,000 from its role in developing the Renaissance at Santa Clara. Meanwhile, the city’s homeless problem remains essentially unsolved.

Instead of lining the pockets of her political supporters, the city could have provided thousands of homeless people with housing, but they decided instead to put in granite countertops and other perks that cost taxpayers a fortune, while getting a relatively small number of homeless people off the streets.

The attacks on the homeless since the destruction of the encampments have been relentless. The Fresno Police Department (FPD) has an entire task force targeting them. The task force is busy taking homeless people’s property, issuing them citations (declaring their property is trash) and waking them up at dawn to tell them to “move on.”



There are homeless advocates in this community who are demanding that all people be treated with dignity and respect. They argue for a safe and legal place for the homeless to live, where basic public services (toilets, trash bins and drinking water) are available. Once homeless people’s lives are stabilized in these temporary camps, affordable and decent housing must be found. If our economic and political system was working, it would find a way to match all of the abandoned houses and buildings in Fresno with the thousands of homeless people living on the streets of Fresno. If you believe that another world is possible and want to be a part of the solution, then check out www.helpfresnoshomeless.org/ to get involved with others who are seeking positive solutions to end homelessness in this community.


********** How does the Attorney General of CA, and the US Attorney General ignore this abuse of power, and corruption ? ***



long list but all important articles, many are heartbreaking. Just think if these were your sons and daughters, brothers or sisters, or friends.

http://fresnoalliance.com/wordpress/?p=1313

******

16 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
City of Fresno spent $ 13,106,534 for 64 unit apartment for Homeless, ($ 190,000 per unit) Crooks! (Original Post) annm4peace Dec 2013 OP
not sure how much a studio unit should cost to build but kicking cuz it's story about homeless Liberal_in_LA Dec 2013 #1
Fresno is a cheap place to live annm4peace Dec 2013 #4
k and r niyad Dec 2013 #2
Incase you want to contact Mayor of Fresno, or Attorney Generals annm4peace Dec 2013 #3
send this paragraph to the Attorney General annm4peace Dec 2013 #5
Pope Francis and the homeless annm4peace Dec 2013 #6
K&R, because it really matters. Despicable. nt Mnemosyne Dec 2013 #7
They need to look to the military for ideas on housing designs Revanchist Dec 2013 #8
Ashamed of my old home town. blkmusclmachine Dec 2013 #9
How much do you think it should cost to build? Recursion Dec 2013 #10
About 55k, at a quickly educated guess quakerboy Dec 2013 #11
Fair enough; I'm more familiar with SFO and LA Recursion Dec 2013 #12
Me too quakerboy Dec 2013 #13
There are incredible people in Fresno, they just aren't in charge annm4peace Dec 2013 #14
Homeless people will tell you what they need. hunter Dec 2013 #15
Book of Fresno progressive activists. annm4peace Dec 2013 #16

annm4peace

(6,119 posts)
4. Fresno is a cheap place to live
Wed Dec 4, 2013, 11:43 PM
Dec 2013

the medium house is about 120,000. A condo would be about 70,000.

Fresno wages are low, so there are many working Homeless people.. but I think it would be hard to keep working if your only shelter was torn down, like they did to the homeless camps in the last couple of months.

annm4peace

(6,119 posts)
3. Incase you want to contact Mayor of Fresno, or Attorney Generals
Wed Dec 4, 2013, 11:41 PM
Dec 2013

Ashley Swearengin, Mayor (she is a born again Christian and her husband is a preacher)
2600 Fresno Street
Room 2075
Fresno, CA 93721
(559) 621-8000

or you can email from link: http://www.fresno.gov/Government/MayorsOffice/Default.htm

*************
or contact the Attorney General of CA and ask why does she ignore the City of Fresno abuse of the Homeless and of their human and civil rights.
http://oag.ca.gov/


Mailing Address
Attorney General's Office
California Department of Justice
Attn: Public Inquiry Unit
P.O. Box 944255
Sacramento, CA 94244-2550


or questions regarding the Department of Justice contact

Public Inquiry Unit
Voice: (916) 322-3360 or
(Toll-free in California)
(800) 952-5225
Fax: (916) 323-5341
******************************
or send the article to the US Attorney General

http://www.justice.gov/contact-us.html


Correspondence to the Department, including the Attorney General, may be sent to:

U.S. Department of Justice
950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20530-0001
By Phone
Department of Justice Main Switchboard - 202-514-2000

Office of the Attorney General Public Comment Line - 202-353-1555

link to send abuse of civil rights. http://www.justice.gov/crt/publications/natorigin2.php#law

*******
Maybe if enough of us send the article or parts of it to the Attorney Generals it will make them look into the abuse by the Mayor and other officials of Fresno.

annm4peace

(6,119 posts)
5. send this paragraph to the Attorney General
Wed Dec 4, 2013, 11:45 PM
Dec 2013

** this is the paragraph that really stood out for me. If you read some of the articles from the link of the articles on the homeless.. this paragraph would stand out for you also.

"The city’s elite celebrated the opening of the Renaissance at Santa Clara as a solution to homelessness. But take a closer look. The Renaissance at Santa Clara, built for $13,106,534, houses 69 people in 340-square-foot studio apartments. That is a breathtaking $190,000 per unit! Would it surprise you to know that Tom Richards of Penstar, who got the development contract for this project, is the chairperson of Fresno First Steps Home and was the chairperson of the city’s Ten-Year Plan to End Homelessness committee? Penstar executives contributed a significant amount of money to Mayor Swearengin’s reelection campaign, and Penstar made about $1,000,000 from its role in developing the Renaissance at Santa Clara. Meanwhile, the city’s homeless problem remains essentially unsolved.

Instead of lining the pockets of her political supporters, the city could have provided thousands of homeless people with housing, but they decided instead to put in granite countertops and other perks that cost taxpayers a fortune, while getting a relatively small number of homeless people off the streets. "

annm4peace

(6,119 posts)
6. Pope Francis and the homeless
Wed Dec 4, 2013, 11:54 PM
Dec 2013

Last week, when Pope Francis said,, I teared up.. and I immediately thought of Mike Rhodes and the incredible articles that he bravely wrote and took pictures for.
There are a lot of Catholics in Fresno, but there are also a lot of the southern fundamentalist churches in Fresno..
but hopefully the Catholics will heed Pope Francis's words and start open their eyes to what is happening to the homeless and don't blindly listen to the Mayor and the other liars of Fresno (aka KMJ radio and Fresno Bee newspaper) .

Just as the commandment “Thou shalt not kill” sets a clear limit in order to safeguard the value of human life, today we also have to say “Thou shalt not” to an economy of exclusion and inequality. Such an economy kills. How can it be that it is not a news item when an elderly homeless person dies of exposure, but it is news when the stock market loses two points? This is a case of exclusion. Can we continue to stand by when food is thrown away while people are starving? This is a case of inequality.

Revanchist

(1,375 posts)
8. They need to look to the military for ideas on housing designs
Thu Dec 5, 2013, 12:49 AM
Dec 2013

Rooms that are designed for one, two or three people, private bathrooms or one shared by two rooms with separate lockable doors but shared common areas for cooking, laundry etc. It may not be as nice a studio apts that have everything in each unit but it would cut down on costs by reducing the number of stoves, sinks, etc you need to buy for the entire facility.

Recursion

(56,582 posts)
10. How much do you think it should cost to build?
Thu Dec 5, 2013, 02:27 AM
Dec 2013

$190k per unit in a CA city doesn't sound outrageous to me.

quakerboy

(13,920 posts)
11. About 55k, at a quickly educated guess
Thu Dec 5, 2013, 06:43 AM
Dec 2013

The article says the units are 340 square foot.

According to http://www.building-cost.net a 340 SF free standing house, of modest quality, with heating and AC, in Fresno, should cost approximately 42k to build. Not counting land. I would assume that apartments, sharing walls and other structural elements, would cost much less per unit than the equivalent number of houses. Lets say 25k per unit in building costs

The apartments in question are built on .69 acres of land. A quick search of real estate shows that depending on location and zoning, one should be able to find equivalent property in Fresno for between 500k and 2 million. At the upper end, that would be about 30k per unit in land cost.

So, in theory, these units could have been built for 55k. 70k per unit if I am mistaken and building 69 apartment units costs just as much as building 69 free standing homes.

They spent 13 million. For 4 million, they could have bought a 71 unit apartment complex 4 miles away. 2 extra units, a mix of one and 2 bedrooms instead of what I assume are efficiency studios, and 9 million left over which could, using the math above, have been used to build at least 125 additional efficiency studios.

Double checking my conclusions, A quick search of the net shows me I could rent a small apartment in Fresno for about 700/month. Assuming that a small unit cost about 70k to build, it would take about 12 years to pay off if fully rented. If they cost 190k to build, it would take more like 30 years of full rental to get paid off, before a profit could be made. And they are still building new apartments in Fresno.

Recursion

(56,582 posts)
12. Fair enough; I'm more familiar with SFO and LA
Thu Dec 5, 2013, 07:10 AM
Dec 2013

I didn't realize Fresno was that much cheaper. What a scam...

quakerboy

(13,920 posts)
13. Me too
Fri Dec 6, 2013, 06:05 AM
Dec 2013

But you asked, and I was in the mood to do some research, lest my brain get too rusty.
And thats the kick, because I do think more people should take notice of this kind of thing.

annm4peace

(6,119 posts)
14. There are incredible people in Fresno, they just aren't in charge
Fri Dec 6, 2013, 11:22 PM
Dec 2013
http://fresnoalliance.com/wordpress/?p=8688


Eco Village Project and Dakota EcoGardenJoin Forces to House Fresno’s Homeless



I'm just post the 1st few paragraphs of the article:


The Eco Village project began as the brainchild of celebrated local architect Arthur Dyson. Dyson’s original idea was to create green, sustainable eco housing that would provide the homeless with an uplifting, dignified, harmonious and aesthetically pleasing living environment. The original concept involved creating communities of people with similar skills living and working together.

Perceiving an immediate need, however, in 2009, the original board (Dyson, Gerry Bill, Mike Rhodes, Dixie Salazar, Bill and Marla Hartman, Al Williams and Cynthia Greene) pooled their resources to develop a homeless drop-in center. This project, for many reasons, did not come to fruition; however, Cynthia Greene, who was formerly homeless, was able, with the group’s help, to buy the property, with the plan of helping her homeless friends.

After going through a few organizational changes, the board (currently consisting of Dyson, Bill, Salazar, Nancy Waidtlow, Alicia Andrade and Bev Fitzpatrick) has shifted its concentration to the Eco Village Project, which has a mission to provide safe, sanitary and dignified housing for the homeless in an environmentally sustainable manner. In 2010, the Eco Village Project, through Bill and Salazar’s efforts received 501(c)(3) status.

With a meandering pathway of housing units, arboreal landscaping, an organic garden and personal garden spaces around each individual unit, the Eco Village will promote a healthy, peaceful and enriching environment. Each dwelling will be approximately 110 square feet, with geothermal and convection cooling and solar heating. Other features will include rainwater catching and gray-water recycling systems. Communal aspects such as kitchens, laundry, showers, bathrooms, dining areas and workshops will foster an atmosphere of cooperation and a sense of investment in a shared living space.

Each village will have an economic and self-sustaining component such as an organic garden, solar chimney production, bicycle and auto repair, carpentry or sewing and garment repair and reconstruction. These aspects of the project will promote self-fulfillment and renewal to help the homeless transition into longer-term living situations, as well as eventual permanent housing. Mentoring and apprenticeship will be integral to the project, as well as community involvement.

Fresno State and Fresno Pacific University will work closely with the Eco Village residents in providing vital counseling and tutoring for the residents. Tree Fresno will assist in providing a park-like setting for the residents and surrounding neighbors.

hunter

(38,312 posts)
15. Homeless people will tell you what they need.
Sat Dec 7, 2013, 12:06 AM
Dec 2013

The architecture is not nearly as important as establishing a community that works.

First thing everyone needs is a safe place to simply exist.

A person doesn't even have that if the police are always harassing them and taking their stuff.


annm4peace

(6,119 posts)
16. Book of Fresno progressive activists.
Sun Dec 8, 2013, 01:15 AM
Dec 2013

( just saw this on progressive Fresno newspaper Community Alliance website )

Hidden in Plain Sight

This new book by Community Alliance newspaper writer Richard Stone is now available on Amazon.

Margaret Hudson. Gloria Hernandez. Rev. Floyd Harris. George & Maia Ballis. These are a few of our community stalwarts to be found in Hidden in Plain Sight: profiles of Fresno’s progressive activists, a just-published compilation of 72 profiles and 5 articles written by Richard Stone and originally printed in the Community Alliance. The book is intended both to honor the subjects of the profiles, and to remind readers of the scope and history of our local progressive movement over the past few decades.

It is also a fundraiser for the Alliance, with all profits coming to us. Handsomely designed by Tim Savage, and including photos of all the subjects, it is available as a paperback for $15.

Here is the link on Amazon:
http://www.amazon.com/Hidden-Plain-Sight-Progressive-Activists/dp/149424182X/ref=sr_1_11?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1386432084&sr=1-11&keywords=hidden+in+plain+sight

We will also have copies available at the WILPF Crafts Faire (Saturday, December 14)

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»City of Fresno spent $ 13...