General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forums"Don't Blame Robots For Declining Wages -- Blame Dissolving Unions"
Don't Blame Robots For Declining Wages -- Blame Dissolving UnionsTali Kristal at Talking Points Memo
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/cafe/dont-blame-robots-for-declining-wages-blame-dissolving-unions
"SNIP...................................
Some scholars argue that one explanation for this gap is technological changes, including the widespread introduction of computers into the workplace, which over the past few decades left workers less productive than machines and other equipment. This in turn, the argument goes, encouraged firms to reduce their hiring and curb wages and benefits for their employees. Other analysts disagree with this blame-the-robots angle and stress the role of political forces especially the weakening of labor unions, which has left workers with less power to fight for their own interests.
Until now, there has been no statistical analysis that directly compares these two opposing approaches to explain workers falling economic fortunes. I designed my research to address this debate head on. Using decades-long data, I found that broad economic trends masked big differences in various industrial sectors.
The largest declines in the share of income going to workers happened in industries like manufacturing and transportation where unions were once powerful. In other industries like finance, trade and private services, where there was never much of a union presence, the share of economic gains going to workers either remained steady or slightly increased.
In other words, I found a large decline in labors compensation and a hefty increase in corporate profits only in sectors that once had high rates of union membership. This suggests that a decline in union membership which led to disempowerment of workers when bargaining with employers was the main factor allowing the executives and owners in those sectors to grab the lions share of the fruits of economic growth.
..................................SNIP"
K lib
(153 posts)unfortunately we have too many people who can benefit from a union who rant against it, vote against it, or try to stop a strike when they themselves make only 10 dollars a hour. Real shame when some can't see the bigger picture.
FreakinDJ
(17,644 posts)Brigid
(17,621 posts)"Matewan" and "Harlan County USA."
This is what unions are about, and why they came into being in the first place.
Glassunion
(10,201 posts)IIRC the percentage of those employed in manufacturing and who are members of a union is pretty static over the past 15 years. However we have lost about 7 million manufacturing jobs in the same time frame.
ananda
(28,860 posts)Due to globalization, outsourcing, and movement of vast amounts of money
offshore, unionization is rendered more and more irrelevant.
And robotics is simply taking away jobs from people who get slave/serf
wages, the last holdout for the job market.
badtoworse
(5,957 posts)Today, most manufactured goods can be made in a significant number of countries. American labor is now in the position of having to compete with workers elsewhere in the world who are willing to do same the job for less money. Labor is no different than any other commodity in that competition will drive down the price.
duffyduff
(3,251 posts)it is the trade policies and other destructive D.C. policies that favor the tiny number of financial elite over everybody else that's the problem.
Egalitarian Thug
(12,448 posts)But most of all, never forget who did it and how it was done.
mstinamotorcity2
(1,451 posts)3.8 Trillion dollars out of an economy you must blame robots, aliens, abortions, liberals, violent video games and no fathers in the blah community