Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
73 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Believing in dull, barren, soul-dead Scientific Materialism is everyone's right, but (Original Post) Berlum Jan 2014 OP
Science is dull! zappaman Jan 2014 #1
No. Try reading the OP Berlum Jan 2014 #3
Look out! zappaman Jan 2014 #4
'Tis the Web of Doom! HappyMe Jan 2014 #7
Fuck me, you think you're actually putting forward a properly constructed argument in the OP? muriel_volestrangler Jan 2014 #52
What OP? It's just a picture of bad graffiti seveneyes Jan 2014 #58
EVERYONE agrees...have you taken a 6 billion plus person poll? angstlessk Jan 2014 #2
I could be wrong, but I suspect that this may be a push-poll pinboy3niner Jan 2014 #34
I like the font. A-Schwarzenegger Jan 2014 #5
That font is called Sinistrous Jan 2014 #71
It definitely dances to the nightingale's tune. A-Schwarzenegger Jan 2014 #73
The delusions of the magical thinkers grow less accepted every year. There is no magic. Codeine Jan 2014 #6
really? zappaman Jan 2014 #10
Planet Bacardi has spoken! Codeine Jan 2014 #16
Cuba Libre! HappyMe Jan 2014 #19
Wheat goes up, wheat goes down... you can't explain that! Scootaloo Jan 2014 #49
No dancing fairies? I'm disappointed. Cleita Jan 2014 #12
And you've arrived at your opinion how? Indi Guy Jan 2014 #14
Out of curiosity whatchamacallit Jan 2014 #22
It's mumbo jumbo Shivering Jemmy Jan 2014 #56
thank you God! nt G_j Jan 2014 #28
And what is even more amazing is that mutation can rule... Tikki Jan 2014 #57
No magic? How sad. I think everything is magic. I guess it depends on what your 1monster Jan 2014 #70
Exactly. If there were not people who could think outside Cleita Jan 2014 #8
I've noticed most of DU's "science lovers" whatchamacallit Jan 2014 #9
+1 Matariki Jan 2014 #48
+10! zazen Jan 2014 #54
Post removed Post removed Jan 2014 #69
I think you mean soul-dead Materialism. Science is not a philosophy. It's a process. haele Jan 2014 #11
No, he means Scientific Materialism mathematic Jan 2014 #46
Glad we have to tell us what we agree on. n/t X_Digger Jan 2014 #13
Which is why Noah banned scientists from the ark. sufrommich Jan 2014 #15
There were two scientists on the Ark, Codeine Jan 2014 #17
"But apart from indoor plumbing, modern medicine, travel, communication, and knowledge..." Warren DeMontague Jan 2014 #23
I got this nifty dead and barren soul! nt Codeine Jan 2014 #25
How much does it weigh? Warren DeMontague Jan 2014 #27
That sort of measurement is a classic trap set by the Scientific Materialist Claque. Codeine Jan 2014 #35
I have an itchy red rash Warren DeMontague Jan 2014 #36
And fish derby378 Jan 2014 #18
I'm sorry, i just cant take that font seriously. Warren DeMontague Jan 2014 #20
I save my scientific denialism for books and movies. ProgressSaves Jan 2014 #21
Ha, good shirt! n/t whatchamacallit Jan 2014 #24
Dragons are real, candy is healthier than vegetables, and the moon is made of cream cheese frosting Dash87 Jan 2014 #26
That was why NASA bombed it. Warren DeMontague Jan 2014 #29
It's just another attempt by the government to deny us delicious cake Dash87 Jan 2014 #32
I read that as "cream cheese fisting." Codeine Jan 2014 #37
Well, that's a mental image... Scootaloo Jan 2014 #50
Science is boring! Vashta Nerada Jan 2014 #30
. pintobean Jan 2014 #40
I'm afraid you lost me at "Believing in...." mike_c Jan 2014 #31
I'm with you, Mike. We have to learn to survive. Science is necessary and certainly fascinating. The Wielding Truth Jan 2014 #39
+1 LadyHawkAZ Jan 2014 #47
busted, ghost busted bench scientist Jan 2014 #33
Souls? carla Jan 2014 #38
"...as everyone agrees" cthulu2016 Jan 2014 #41
And you'll hardly find any REAL scientists that think that way either! Matariki Jan 2014 #42
The 50's, when the medical and scientific communities agreed that being gay was a disease Bluenorthwest Jan 2014 #55
Thats what happens when religious belief interferes Bradical79 Jan 2014 #64
You know what is funny nadinbrzezinski Jan 2014 #43
Scientific materialism is surfing the WWW on a new iMac from a warm office, with a good latte. Coyotl Jan 2014 #44
Well, here's this week's DU chair throwing argument. longship Jan 2014 #45
And believing in chemtrails will get you tombstoned... SidDithers Jan 2014 #51
So Sid, back in the 70's, did you agree with the 'science' that gay people had a disease? Bluenorthwest Jan 2014 #59
Bad science is supplanted by better science... SidDithers Jan 2014 #60
First, you did not answer the question. Second, what 'science' was the 'disease' theory based on? Bluenorthwest Jan 2014 #66
That doesn't make any sense Bradical79 Jan 2014 #62
Also, you're describing religion Bradical79 Jan 2014 #63
science didn't "believe" that "back in the 70s gay people had a disease" cali Jan 2014 #67
Absolute balderdash intaglio Jan 2014 #53
The phyisical world discovered throuh scientific method Bradical79 Jan 2014 #61
Noam Chomsky destroyed BF Skinner and his behaviorism decades ago MindPilot Jan 2014 #65
... SidDithers Jan 2014 #68
In all of this chatter about woo Orrex Jan 2014 #72

Berlum

(7,044 posts)
3. No. Try reading the OP
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 05:44 PM
Jan 2014

Get a clue the scientific way, and actually read the OP: Scientific Materialism is dead.

muriel_volestrangler

(101,318 posts)
52. Fuck me, you think you're actually putting forward a properly constructed argument in the OP?
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 07:24 PM
Jan 2014

That's hilarious. It's just a mess of name-calling. "Get a clue the scientific way". You are proud of not recognising 'the scientific way'. You haven't a clue about it. That's how you got obsessed with chemtrails, and got banned.

 

Codeine

(25,586 posts)
6. The delusions of the magical thinkers grow less accepted every year. There is no magic.
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 05:53 PM
Jan 2014

There are no "souls." No dancing fairies, no sages, no higher planes of consciousness to which we can ascend. There are no gods, no goddesses, no angels or devils or devas or DMT elves.

There is here, there is now, there is the ground below and the stars above and that's enough, really.

Claque claque.

 

Codeine

(25,586 posts)
16. Planet Bacardi has spoken!
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:01 PM
Jan 2014

Star System 151 will conquer in the name of the All-Powerful Murcielago!

Cleita

(75,480 posts)
12. No dancing fairies? I'm disappointed.
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 05:55 PM
Jan 2014

I must tell them to leave my garden because they don't exist.

Tikki

(14,557 posts)
57. And what is even more amazing is that mutation can rule...
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 07:49 PM
Jan 2014

and random can be beautiful...



Tikki

1monster

(11,012 posts)
70. No magic? How sad. I think everything is magic. I guess it depends on what your
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 09:46 PM
Jan 2014

definition of magic is.

Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.
Arthur C. Clarke

Magic is believing in yourself, if you can do that, you can make anything happen.
Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

I have always been delighted at the prospect of a new day, a fresh try, one more start, with perhaps a bit of magic waiting somewhere behind the morning.
J. B. Priestley

Music is the strongest form of magic.
Marilyn Manson

There is a real magic in enthusiasm. It spells the difference between mediocrity and accomplishment.
Norman Vincent Peale

One man's 'magic' is another man's engineering. 'Supernatural' is a null word.
Robert A. Heinlein

Every great man, every successful man, no matter what the field of endeavor, has known the magic that lies in these words: every adversity has the seed of an equivalent or greater benefit.
W. Clement Stone

Music is about listening, the more you play, the more the magic spreads.
Maynard James Keenan

Art is magic delivered from the lie of being truth.
Theodor Adorno

Disbelief in magic can force a poor soul into believing in government and business.
Tom Robbins

Cleita

(75,480 posts)
8. Exactly. If there were not people who could think outside
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 05:54 PM
Jan 2014

of the box and then experiment with their theories, we would still think the earth was the center of the universe and all matter was made of four humors.

whatchamacallit

(15,558 posts)
9. I've noticed most of DU's "science lovers"
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 05:54 PM
Jan 2014

don't love the method, just the consensus. They're not interested in discovery, they just want handy "facts" to shut you up. Lazy, closed minded egotists.

Matariki

(18,775 posts)
48. +1
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:51 PM
Jan 2014

Nothing at all like the actual science folks I know in real life. They exhibit WAY more intellectual curiosity and openness to possibility until something is empirically proven otherwise. Not to mention the fact that they know that today's 'science' might be tomorrow's quaint silliness.

I've never met someone with a truly scientific mind who treats "Science" as a "Belief".

Response to whatchamacallit (Reply #9)

haele

(12,655 posts)
11. I think you mean soul-dead Materialism. Science is not a philosophy. It's a process.
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 05:55 PM
Jan 2014

Being a skilled craftsman and getting something - usually money - in return for your labor is not the same as investing someone else's money to enrich yourself even more.

Materialism is a philosophy in which everything has a material value, or cost, and the point is to gather as much value for oneself as possible.

Science is the process of discovery in which a specified effect is proven to be the result of certain other known states because it can be replicated with those known states. It is not a philosophy. Just as Art is not a philosophy; Art is the means of creating unique effects without the need to provide proof or to replicate exactly.

Sorry to disagree slightly with you there.

I believe in Science (because I depend on it for my survival), however, I also believe that going about putting a cost on everything ensures that nothing ever has value other than that cost. Which is a sad, sad way to live.

Haele

mathematic

(1,439 posts)
46. No, he means Scientific Materialism
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:50 PM
Jan 2014

Materialism, in this context, does not mean what you say. Perhaps this misunderstanding is why so many people are declaring their opposition to scientific materialism recently.

The OP is talking about the philosophical position that the world consists only of natural elements, no ghosts, spirits, gods, or other supernatural elements. Most theists, like Christians, inherently disagree with the most extreme form of this notion but they still might (and usually do on this side of the aisle) agree with a more moderate conception of this idea, where they act as if they live in a scientific materialist world and make special exceptions for their spiritual beliefs as needed, like belief in an afterlife.

The most contentious of the issues between scientific materialism and opposing views is the characteristic of the mind. Simply, scientific materialism says the mind is a function of the physical body. Opposing views say there's a soul, or similar, that exists apart from the physical body that is required for a mind to exist.

 

Codeine

(25,586 posts)
17. There were two scientists on the Ark,
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:02 PM
Jan 2014

but it was these two, unfortunately. No offspring could be had.

Warren DeMontague

(80,708 posts)
23. "But apart from indoor plumbing, modern medicine, travel, communication, and knowledge..."
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:08 PM
Jan 2014

What has science ever given us?

 

Codeine

(25,586 posts)
35. That sort of measurement is a classic trap set by the Scientific Materialist Claque.
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:25 PM
Jan 2014

I won't fall for your tricks!!

Dash87

(3,220 posts)
26. Dragons are real, candy is healthier than vegetables, and the moon is made of cream cheese frosting
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:10 PM
Jan 2014

Science disagrees with me, but I'm right. Don't tell me I'm wrong, because that would make you another anti-woo extremist!

 

Vashta Nerada

(3,922 posts)
30. Science is boring!
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:13 PM
Jan 2014

Who needs rational explanations for things when one can say a magic sky fairy created everything and fairies make rings in people's yards!

mike_c

(36,281 posts)
31. I'm afraid you lost me at "Believing in...."
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:14 PM
Jan 2014

On the other hand, in my soul dead humorless world it's hard to tell whether or not the OP was satire.

The Wielding Truth

(11,415 posts)
39. I'm with you, Mike. We have to learn to survive. Science is necessary and certainly fascinating.
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:42 PM
Jan 2014

I must be too rigid in thought to get this.

bench scientist

(1,107 posts)
33. busted, ghost busted
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:19 PM
Jan 2014

[URL=.html][IMG][/IMG][/URL]

mostly i just wanted to post a pic of Peter Venkman .

sincerely,
future Dr. Bench scientist

carla

(553 posts)
38. Souls?
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:31 PM
Jan 2014

For ass holes...grow up, material is real, so is science and your delusional attempt to paint it as "communist" is just boring. You have no soul, you have a self, a personality and some stupid ideas based on bullshit concepts created by lame minds from eons past.

Matariki

(18,775 posts)
42. And you'll hardly find any REAL scientists that think that way either!
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:46 PM
Jan 2014

It's like being stuck in a high school chemistry class in the 50's. Dull, uninformed, unimaginative.

 

Bluenorthwest

(45,319 posts)
55. The 50's, when the medical and scientific communities agreed that being gay was a disease
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 07:43 PM
Jan 2014

which they could cure with shock treatments or a lobotomy. Great moments in the annals of reason!

 

nadinbrzezinski

(154,021 posts)
43. You know what is funny
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:47 PM
Jan 2014

some of the most philosophical people you will meet are cosmologist, and other scientists. The problem is not the scientists, but folks who treat science as another form of religion, never ever changing, and set in stone. Which is a cardinal sin (sorry for that one, I know it sounds funny) of science.

If there is something that is a given is that science is about solving riddles and mysteries and being in awe at what nature can give you.

This, to me at least, puts all in quite a bit of perspective.

 

Coyotl

(15,262 posts)
44. Scientific materialism is surfing the WWW on a new iMac from a warm office, with a good latte.
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:49 PM
Jan 2014

Not that image!

longship

(40,416 posts)
45. Well, here's this week's DU chair throwing argument.
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 06:50 PM
Jan 2014

Get it right at least.

Science is not a philosophy. It's a set of methods which seem to work pretty damned well. It not only wiped out diseases like Smallpox and provided the framework to do that (germ theory of disease -- thank you Pasteur), but it landed humans on the moon and a science laboratory on the surface of Mars. It found out that all life on Earth is related and subsequently discovered the mechanisms by which that occurred. Science makes predictions of future discoveries, often decades ahead of them, and with astounding precision.

Like everything humans do, science is not perfect, but that idea is also part of science. So it has built in self-correcting mechanisms. Yes, those too can be rickety and slow, but as Bill Nye said, "We get 'er done!"

Above all, science is a way of knowing things which is answerable, not to any personal authority or opinion, but to nature herself. And as anybody working at the cutting edge of science could tell you, Mother Nature can be a real bitch.

Those who would malign science, or characterize it by some made up shit, don't really understand what it is, and what it is not.

 

Bluenorthwest

(45,319 posts)
59. So Sid, back in the 70's, did you agree with the 'science' that gay people had a disease?
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 07:54 PM
Jan 2014

That's what they believed. They had no evidence, they did not look for any for about 150 years of prisons, madhouses, shock treatments and lobotomies for the 'community' to take a look at it's own behavior. That entire time they were unable to see the natural reality in front of them because they had a set of assumptions running and running hard. Hard to differentiate such actions from those of religious folks, who assume things not in evidence, for generations no matter what the cost to others. Very stupid, very brittle and dogmatic. Lobotomies, to cure the disease. Until 1973.
Not quite witch burnings, but the next best thing, and it was 'medicine' that did it, not religion, until I was nearing voting age. They were gunna cure us with science fact!
Like a bunch of Baptists, only less humble and not as empathetic. 'They are diseased!'. I grew up reading this crap. I'll never forget it, nor will I forget what the 'science and medical community' has so recently been capable of.
Lobotomies, to cure the gay. Until 1973. Science!!!!!!!!

SidDithers

(44,228 posts)
60. Bad science is supplanted by better science...
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 07:57 PM
Jan 2014

That's how science works.

You do understand that, don't you?

Sid

 

Bluenorthwest

(45,319 posts)
66. First, you did not answer the question. Second, what 'science' was the 'disease' theory based on?
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 08:22 PM
Jan 2014

What 'evidence' did they use? Answer, none, they elevated assumption to the state of fact, gnawed that bone hard for generations and when people were walking on the moon, these folks still held that gay people had a disease.
What qualified these beliefs as 'science'? The degrees of the nuts who promoted them? Sorry, but I grew up hearing 'medicine' and 'religion' spout the same obviously false bullshit about gay people. The 'science' was just religion in a lab coat. Mumbo jumbo. Fakery. Magical thinking posing as actual established fact.
So 'science' stopped teaching that gays are diseased about the same time Mormons stopped teaching that black people carry the curse of Ham, early 1970s. Both teachings were based on nonsense, dogma, bigotry and no evidence at all.
I guess that's how religion works too, when a belief becomes untenable in the face of fact and reason, jettison it and take up the current modes.
A group of professions that thought gay was a disease in 1973 has no standing to whine about other people holding silly false beliefs. Those professions harmed others by taking their crappy beliefs into practice in the name of science. Their concern should be that they never commit such atrocities out of ego and assumption again.

 

Bradical79

(4,490 posts)
62. That doesn't make any sense
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 08:04 PM
Jan 2014

If there is no evidence for something then its not the least bit scientific.

 

Bradical79

(4,490 posts)
63. Also, you're describing religion
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 08:09 PM
Jan 2014

getting in the way of the scientific method. A pre-determined belief pushed by religion and irrational thought certainly isn't the fault of "science" and has monstly persisted through the rejection and manipulation of scientific study by religious organizations.

intaglio

(8,170 posts)
53. Absolute balderdash
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 07:25 PM
Jan 2014

Look up at the night sky, look at a snowflake through a microscope, listen to a nightingale, smell a rose ... and think how lucky it is you are alive at those moments to experience those things.

Would you prefer it if everything had been arranged for you by some all powerful entity for a purpose that will never be explained to your living mind?

 

Bradical79

(4,490 posts)
61. The phyisical world discovered throuh scientific method
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 08:00 PM
Jan 2014

requires a an incredibly flexible mind to comprehend. It's more often belief in religion and magic that traps people in a narrow minded bubble of ignorance. Fantasy often applies very simple rules to our world that simply don't exist in reality. I know how that is comforting as a former evangelical, but it's probably better for you to educate yourself with an open mind rather than lash out with hatred and anger when reality begins intruding on the fantasy world you have created for yourself.

 

MindPilot

(12,693 posts)
65. Noam Chomsky destroyed BF Skinner and his behaviorism decades ago
Sun Jan 5, 2014, 08:15 PM
Jan 2014

Your party has been over for a while.

Oh, and genetics is in fact real science.

Orrex

(63,212 posts)
72. In all of this chatter about woo
Mon Jan 6, 2014, 12:35 AM
Jan 2014

I'm disappointed that no one has used the "scientistic" buzzword.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Believing in dull, barren...