Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Omaha Steve

(99,733 posts)
Wed Apr 2, 2014, 07:48 PM Apr 2014

NSAA reverses decision, will let student perform poem on gender identity on TV


http://www.omaha.com/article/20140402/NEWS/140409670/1685#nsaa-reverses-decision-will-let-student-perform-poem-on-gender-identity

Audio: The Bottom Line's Mike'l Severe spoke with Michael Barth's mother, Kim Buchan, on Wednesday before the NSAA reversed its decision. Listen here.


By Joe Dejka

A battle over free speech ended Wednesday with a dramatic finish.

Under pressure from free-speech advocates, the Nebraska School Activities Association backed down, allowing teen speech champion Michael Barth to perform his poem on gender identity.

The association's executive director had initially blocked the Gordon-Rushville High School senior from giving the speech for a television broadcast highlighting state champions from last week's speech contest.

“The intent of my decision was not to stifle freedom of speech, but rather to avoid any negative connotations for individuals within this statewide production,” said NSAA Executive Director Rhonda Blanford-Green. “The NSAA will continue to advocate for all students and promote equitable opportunities through activity participation.”

Read the NSAA's statement (PDF)

FULL story at link.

7 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
NSAA reverses decision, will let student perform poem on gender identity on TV (Original Post) Omaha Steve Apr 2014 OP
Outstanding. That was quick. Brickbat Apr 2014 #1
bump... nt Jesus Malverde Apr 2014 #2
K&R! hrmjustin Apr 2014 #3
K/R. nt NYC_SKP Apr 2014 #4
K & R historylovr Apr 2014 #5
Whose poems caused the kerfuffle? When I first looked at the linked article ... DreamGypsy Apr 2014 #6
K&R - nt Ohio Joe Apr 2014 #7

DreamGypsy

(2,252 posts)
6. Whose poems caused the kerfuffle? When I first looked at the linked article ...
Thu Apr 3, 2014, 01:04 AM
Apr 2014

...I thought that Michael Barth had written and recited/performed a self-written poem:

Under pressure from free-speech advocates, the Nebraska School Activities Association backed down, allowing teen speech champion Michael Barth to perform his poem on gender identity.


So I searched to find the poem he had written. I eventually stumbled onto the fact that

Barth won a first place medal at the state high school speech tournament last week reciting poems.

The Nebraska School Activities Association, however, then deemed the content too controversial to be featured in a public TV broadcast highlighting the best performers at the competition.

Barth performed poems titled “Swingset” and “Same Love”, Blanford-Green said.


Here's Swingset, by Andrea Gibson:



So, I teach in a preschool. Hehe… I make a goddamn difference, now what about you. That’s one point I had to make before I read this poem. The second point is, I usually have hair that is much much shorter than this. That’s all you need to know.

“Are you a boy or a girl?” he asks, staring up from all three feet of his pudding face grandeur, and I say “Dylan, you’ve been in this class for three years and you still don’t know if I’m a boy or a girl?” And he says “Uh-uh.” And I say “Well, at this point, I don’t really think it matters, do you?” And he says “Uhhhm, no. Can I have a push on the swing?” And this happens every day. It’s a tidal wave of kindergarten curiosity rushing straight for the rocks of me, whatever I am.

And the class, when we discuss the Milky Way galaxy, the orbit of the Sun around the Earth… or whatever. Jupiter, Saturn, Mars, and kids, do you know that some of the stars we see when we look up in the sky are so far away, they’ve already burned out? What do you think of that? Timmy? “Umm… my mom says that even though you got hairs that grow from your legs, and the hairs on your head grow short and poky, and that you smell really bad, like my dad, that you’re a girl.” “Thank you, Timmy.”

And so it goes. On the playground, she peers up at me from behind her pink power puff sunglasses and then asks, “Do you have a boyfriend?” And I say no, and she says “Oh, do you have a girlfriend?” And I say “No, but if by some miracle, twenty years from now, I ever finally do, then I’ll definitely bring her by to meet you. How’s that?” “Okay. Can I have a push on the swing?”

And that’s the thing. They don’t care. They don’t care. Us, on the other hand… My father sitting across the table at Christmas dinner, gritting his teeth over his still-full plate, his appetite ripped away by the intrusion of my haircut, “What were you thinking? You used to be such a pretty girl!” Frat boys, drunken, screaming, leaning out of the windows of their daddys’ SUVs, “Hey! Are you a faggot or a dyke?” And I wonder what would happen if I met up with them in the middle of the night.

Then of course there’s always the somehow not-quite-bright enough fluorescent light of the public restroom, “Sir! Sir, do you realize this is the ladies’ room?” “Yes, ma’am, I do, it’s just that I didn’t feel comfortable sticking this tampon up my penis in the men’s room.”

But the best, the best is always the mother at the market, sticking up her nose while pushing aside her daughter’s wide eyes, whispering “Don’t stare, it’s rude.” And I want to say, “Listen, lady, the only rude thing I see is your paranoid parental hand pushing aside the best education on self that little girl’s ever gonna get, living with your Maybelline lips, stairmaster hips, synthetic kiwi-vanilla smelling beauty; so why don’t you take your pinks and blues, your boy-girl rules and shove them in that car with your fucking issue of Cosmo, because tomorrow, I start my day with twenty-eight minds who know a hell of a lot more than you. And if I show up in a pink frilly dress, those kids won’t love me any more, or less.”

“Hey, are you a boy or a — never mind, can I have a push on the swing?” And some day, y’all, when we grow up, it’s all gonna be that simple.


Here's Same Love, by Macklemore & Ryan Lewis



(no transcript; way complicated)


In 1967 I was in high school, on the debate team and competing in speech competitions. I though I was pretty cool reciting selections from Thomas Merton's Raids on the Unspeakable - I don't recall what selections. I didn't change the world.

I now stand in awe of Michael Barth and his motivations, abilities, and courage to confront his state, community, and school cultures with his chosen poems:

As a result of today's controversy, Barth also learned about what he's willing to do in defense of his own personal convictions. If the NSAA hadn't changed its mind, Barth said he wouldn't have changed his performance. "I would have just gone there and been ready to perform whether they wanted me or not, and if they were gonna turn me down, they were gonna turn me down," he said. "I guess I would have turned around and gone back to school. I wasn’t gonna change it. It’s something I’m passionate about."

Barth's performance will be included in the "Best of the Best" program that will air on NET1 on Sunday, April 20, at 9 a.m. and rebroadcast on NET2. The full program will also be available online.


Cool. Thanks for the post, Omaha Steve!
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»NSAA reverses decision, w...