General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsReminder: No One Disputes the Legality of Single Payer
Reminder: No One Disputes the Legality of Single Payer
By: Jon Walker Tuesday March 27, 2012 1:09 pm
With the Supreme Court arguing the legality of the Affordable Care Act, it is a good time to remember that almost nobody disputes that single payer, such as Medicare for All, would be undoubtedly constitutional. Even Michael Carvin, one of the lead lawyers arguing (for the non-state private opponents) that the individual mandate is unconstitutional admitted today that single payer would be clearly legal.
From the Supreme Court transcript:
http://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_transcripts/11-398-Tuesday.pdf
JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR: So the I I want to understand the choices youre saying Congress has. Congress can tax everybody and set up a public health care system.
MR. CARVIN: Yes.
JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR: That would be okay?
MR. CARVIN: Yes. Tax power is -
JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR: Okay.
MR. CARVIN: I would accept that.
http://fdlaction.firedoglake.com/2012/03/27/reminder-no-one-disputes-the-legality-of-single-payer/
polichick
(37,152 posts)...Dems should be able to make the case that single payer is the answer - IF they hire a decent messenging expert and everybody repeats the clear, concise argument in the coming months.
SpencerShay
(72 posts)The republicans dont give a crap about what is legal. The republicans would still run to the supreme court, and have the radical right-wing supreme court strike down a single-payer healthcare law, too. Republicans dont want to hurt the insurance companies, so I find it hard to believe republicans would just sit back and not challenge the law. Plus, the republicans are just assholes. If a single-payer healthcare law was passed, the same lies about government takeovers, and death panels, would start all over, again. The republicans would make up reasons (lies) for why single-payer healthcare is unconstitutional.
Even though people dont like the current law, it is constitutional. The supreme courts decision will be political. And if the current law is struck down, it wont open the door for single-payer healthcare. At least, not any time soon. If the current healthcare law is struck down, we will have to wait decades again, before anybody tries to do anything about the countrys crappy healthcare system. And, a right-wing congress that is brought and paid for by insurance companies is not going to pass a single-payer healthcare law. They didnt even want to pass the current republican healthcare law. Stop being so naïve.