Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

marmar

(77,086 posts)
Sun May 4, 2014, 11:24 AM May 2014

David Sirota: We’re All Just Grenades in the Partisan Wars


via truthdig:


We’re All Just Grenades in the Partisan Wars

Posted on May 2, 2014
By David Sirota


It is hardly controversial to say that one of the big turnoffs about American politics is its disconnect with even the most grim human consequences. No matter how serious the issue, the political class seems pathologically determined to present everything as a fun-and-games, red-versus-blue battle whose only important consequences have to do with the next election. As politicians, operatives and reporters focus primarily on the horse-race discussion of ever-more-grave issues, the life-and-death human ramifications for millions of people are effectively written out of our democratic discourse.

There are plenty of examples of this odious dynamic, but perhaps this era’s textbook case comes from a recent article in Politico magazine about natural gas exploration in Colorado—and more specifically, the extractive process known as fracking.

The context for the article is key: It appeared only weeks after the release of a Colorado School of Public Health study showing a potential link between birth defects and proximity to Colorado fracking sites. That study followed others showing possible links between fracking in Colorado and health hazards such as water and air pollution.

Birth defects and toxic pollution—this is serious and macabre stuff. You might therefore think that politicians would refrain from insinuating that such issues are important only for how they might affect the next election. You might also think that even the most hardened politicos would be sure to at least pay lip service to the idea that actual lives—not just professional politicians’ careers—are at stake.

But, of course, you would be wrong. .................(more)

The complete piece is at: http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/were_all_just_grenades_in_the_partisan_wars_20140502



5 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
David Sirota: We’re All Just Grenades in the Partisan Wars (Original Post) marmar May 2014 OP
we didnt listen to George at our peril randys1 May 2014 #1
du rec. xchrom May 2014 #2
Grenades... House of Roberts May 2014 #3
An excellent article, the "grenades" metaphor is interesting, I rather like it Dragonfli May 2014 #4
+1 xchrom May 2014 #5

Dragonfli

(10,622 posts)
4. An excellent article, the "grenades" metaphor is interesting, I rather like it
Sun May 4, 2014, 02:51 PM
May 2014

It is a bit more narrow than one I have used and more aptly describes the case when politicians use policy as weapons against their opponents and is quite appropriate.

I often use a different metaphor to describe the gamesmanship of the sport they call politics, a game wherein the people whom the policy is supposed to be all about are merely the balls on the playing field and which hold no importance to the players and the fans other than as the objects to be tossed about to win the game that profits only the players leaving the people in the mud after the game is over.

As to the poor - they seem completely oblivious to them and convince themselves that welfare reform didn't harm anybody, it did and does to this day I assure you, it was not a pragmatic solution to a "welfare queen" problem handled well because a Democrat helped to all but destroy it. It will not be a brave pragmatic solution to "earned benefit queens" as they collude yet again with republicans to begin to shred these last vestiges of the new deal and great society.

They cause the poor to become poorer still while applauding the politicians responsible. Their applause and support are what make them just as responsible as their political idols.

They think this is a game, or a sport with my team and their team, not realizing or caring that the ball that is tossed around in this sport is a child that only gets to eat at school and will soon lose that food, or the ball is an elderly widow or widower that can only afford to take their medicine every other day or maybe will freeze to death in a small flat during a winter they could not pay their gas bill (this happens ALREADY).

There are many other balls tossed around for their sport and amusement, too many to list them all here, some are dead or dying, some are living under a tarp in a vacant lot hoping the cops don't roust them or the suburban teanagers don't decide to slum it and amuse themselves by assaulting them while laughing and taunting the "bum" for cell phone footage. Some of these comfortable people give advice to "the poor that in fact do ok". One of them suggested dumpster diving as a viable and reasonable option.

Too many of them applaud policies and politicians that make all these problems worse, they need to get it through their heads, many are dying and more will die of poverty, this is no game and the poor aren't doing ok, they are doing worse all the time with less help available all the time.

It is not serious, pragmatic, or brave to cause more people to suffer and die in poverty because it is referred to flippantly as "eating peas" or "being adult". It is not pragmatic even when the ones shipping away the jobs or destroying welfare "feel your pain". It never was bravery, but cowardice. It is not balanced when an increasing number of people fall into poverty and die while others become wealthier at an exponential rate.

The punditry, politicians, and comfortable may think it is a fun sport full of serious brave adults that make hard decisions.

Cowards all really, making easy decisions, easy because their decisions don't harm them, but rather the poor they barely acknowledge exist for the profit of the wealthy.

http://www.democraticunderground.com/10022668527
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»David Sirota: We’re All J...