Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

madfloridian

(88,117 posts)
Thu Jul 3, 2014, 10:59 AM Jul 2014

Teachers from Hawaii and New York sound off in righteous rants about Arne's ed reform.

Alan Isbell is a fourth-grade teacher at the Wailuku Elementary School in Wailuku, Hawaii. He is a delegate from the Hawaii State Teachers Association at this week's National Education Association convention in Denver.

School reform is just another advertising campaign

No Child Left Behind. Race to the Top. Everything's Better with Blue Bonnet on It.

Notice the similarities between government education reform programs and other advertising campaigns? They both have catchy slogans. They both employ exaggeration, statistical deception, and cockamamie claims to sell their products. As a result, many in high places make hay, assumedly without experiencing a twinge of guilt over the campaign's spewing of lies.

Thousands of teachers have converged upon Denver this week for the National Education Association's annual convention. A great many of those educators, when it comes to government reforms in education, are mad as hell, and are not taking it anymore.

....Why? Because it is so much political doggerel. Teachers know it. Principals know it. District superintendents know it. The emperor wears no clothes.

The emperor referred to here is none other than U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan.


And from New York a blog called Opine I Will.

Yes, I do quote education bloggers. Of course I do. They blog about education because they know what they are talking about....unlike the mainstream corporate media spouting talking points from billionaire reformers.

Ashamed to be a teacher today

Today was the first day I was ever ashamed to be a teacher.

Today I finished administering the sixth day of New York State Common Core assessments. I was a facilitator in a process that made my 10 year old students struggle,to the point of frustration, to complete yet another 90 minute test. I sat by as I watched my students attempt to answer questions today that were beyond their abilities. I knew the test booklets I put in front of them contained questions that were written in a way that 95% of them had no chance of solving. I even tried to give my students a pep talk, in hopes of alleviating their angst, when I knew damn well they didn’t stand a chance. Today I was part of the problem.

As I watched my students, I was angry that my efforts to stop this madness were not successful. I was angry at my students’ parents for not opting out their children. I was angry at my administrators for not stepping up to the plate and attempting to end this madness. I was angry at Governor Cuomo, NY Education Commissioner King, the Board of Regents, my state senator, my state assemblyman, President Obama, and even my state union. I was angry that my students were victims in the abusive game to drive a political agenda.

I lost it today. I lost a little bit of my self esteem. I lost my faith in my Party. I lost my faith in my ability to protect my students. I lost my faith in our future.

I watched my students valiantly attempt math questions that most adults could not answer. These questions were wordy, and purposely confusing in a warped way to prove some vulgar point about our public education system. Historically, my students excel on standardized tests, often finishing near the top of our district and state. Today I witnessed , no I was part of!! students enduring an abusive situation.


And also the words of the former assistant Education Secretary under George HW Bush.

We are living in an era when the very idea of public education is under attack, as are teachers' unions and the teaching profession. Let's be clear: these attacks and the power amassed behind them are unprecedented in American history. Sure, there have always been critics of public schools, of teachers, and of unions. But never before has there been a serious and sustained effort to defund public education, to turn public money over to unaccountable private hands, and to weaken and eliminate collective bargaining wherever it still exists. And this effort is not only well-coordinated but funded by billionaires who have grown wealthy in a free market and can't see any need for regulation or unions or public schools.

In the past, Democratic administrations and Democratic members of Congress could be counted on to support public education and to fight privatization. In the past, Democrats supported unions, which they saw as a dependable and significant part of their base.


This is no longer the case. Congress is about to pass legislation to expand funding of charter schools, despite the fact that they get no better results than public schools and despite the scandalous misuse of public funds by charter operators in many states.

Diane Ravitch at Huffington Post

4 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Teachers from Hawaii and New York sound off in righteous rants about Arne's ed reform. (Original Post) madfloridian Jul 2014 OP
Can't be healthy for a party to have so many stressed out teachers upset with them. madfloridian Jul 2014 #1
Our younglings get into post-secondary schools, chervilant Jul 2014 #2
Yes, 1st they need the rote and memorization. madfloridian Jul 2014 #3
An example. 7x3=21, and then tell them why and how. Use the groups of 7 and 3 then. madfloridian Jul 2014 #4

chervilant

(8,267 posts)
2. Our younglings get into post-secondary schools,
Thu Jul 3, 2014, 11:12 AM
Jul 2014

particularly community colleges, with virtually no math skills. I've had students exclaim, "why didn't anyone ever show me/tell me that?!?" When they grasp why they're doing certain math 'problems' (have always disliked that term), they do better on homework and exams.

Now, I do think that our math teachers have been telling our students how to play math, but we've had a long history of marginal math skills, and it's gotten much worse.

I've seen a few of the "common core" methods of "teaching" math. I suspect that the progenitors of this initiative want our children to hone their critical thinking skills, but that's not how our students perceive these 'problems.' They are already overwhelmed by the rote, relentless all-day assault on their brains, and we expect them to be able to think critically?!?

We're mewling around in the muck at the bottom of the abyss. Something's gotta give...

madfloridian

(88,117 posts)
3. Yes, 1st they need the rote and memorization.
Thu Jul 3, 2014, 11:28 AM
Jul 2014

Then comes the new math stuff. During the last new math time....a couple of decades ago I remember teaching virtually the same stuff as the common core method they are using today. I had kids in tears then trying to learn a difficult way to understand something they needed to memorize first.

madfloridian

(88,117 posts)
4. An example. 7x3=21, and then tell them why and how. Use the groups of 7 and 3 then.
Thu Jul 3, 2014, 12:35 PM
Jul 2014

But I learned from experience to make sure they knew the number fact, then hit them with the why and how. Use blocks, etc then to show grouping.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Teachers from Hawaii and ...