Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

markpkessinger

(8,401 posts)
Thu Jul 3, 2014, 02:03 PM Jul 2014

A friend's remarkable FB posting: "The Charity of Change"

A friend of mine posted this on Facebook. I thought it was quite remarkable, and so have reproduced it here, with his permission.


[font size=2]Timothy L. Havener[/font]
[font size=3]THE CHARITY OF CHANGE[/font]

Our charitable efforts in this world are both evidence of the nobility within humanity, and, at the same time, evidence of our collective pettiness and greed. The causes of hunger and poverty are systemic, not individualistic. Everything we are coming to understand about human behavior through the fields of psychology and neuroscience contradict the common wisdom that so many of us use to pass blame and condemn others for their condition. Choice has little to do with where so many of us end up, even in a so-called free country like the United States. If you are a child in an impoverished home, the probability of where you will end up in life is drastically impacted by your environment and access to quality education.

It has long been known that poverty, violence, and ignorance are cozy bedfellows linked by causality, yet, in our society driven by 'free' markets, we have created the illusion that self motivation can lift the poor, and that those who are poor stay there because they want it, or deserve it somehow. The pundits and talking heads always seem to leave out the historically driven trends of disenfranchisement, racism, and class based enmity that perpetuate environments where generational poverty hobbles the aspirations of most children born into those homes.

Meanwhile, a little higher up on the ladder, working and middle class families in first world nations chase the carrot on a stick pursuing a dream they will never attain by statistical probability. The higher you go, the levels of wealth become so disproportional on a scale compared to most people that the top 85 wealthiest people in the world have more combined wealth than the the bottom 3.5 billion. Yet, when social policies are brought forward to help end the cycles of poverty and violence in our poorest neighborhoods, those who are barely getting by in the middle class are told that it is the poor who are their enemy, not the ultra wealthy who are hording so much money, and power they can no longer comprehend the struggle of the average person.

Many of us are watching as what is left of even the middle class erodes away in front of us. Those of us who were living comfortably and saving money on a regular basis are living week to week, and those who were barely getting by are treading water trying desperately to stay afloat. The signs are all around you that something is drastically wrong. In the United States, as infrastructure crumbles, our police are being militarized, and our population is being imprisoned at a rate that shames even the most brutal dictatorships. The humorless joke we call a justice system chews up the poor and spits them back out into a broken system waiting to profit again from their misery through privatized prison systems aided by unjust laws that turn everyday people into criminals, and which isolate them from future economic opportunity.

Education, one of the key factors to ending the ignorance that drives poverty and crime, is constantly under assault, while our government spends trillions on global warfare to benefit the interests of the corporations who control our political system through lobbyists and the money they use to buy our elected officials. With no sense of the cruel irony at play, we recruit the disenfranchised, uneducated poor en masse as cannon fodder to fight the poor of other nations who are victims of the same cycle. Adding insult to injury, we label these resource based wars as humanitarian efforts to spread freedom and democracy as we live in a nation that is a functional oligarchy.

This is the place we call home, and unless we start to change how we do things on a global scale, the human race will end up as a giant plantation with most of us serving the needs of a few who live in opulence above the rest of humanity. The time is coming when we will face a choice to accept our would be masters, or stand together to fight for a better world for our children and ourselves. The uncomfortable reality is that change will not come by dropping money into an offering plate, or by donating a small fraction of our incomes to feed the hungry in a world with more than enough food and money for everyone. In the face of a worldwide economic system driven by greed and power, these efforts will amount to nothing more than the alleviation of our own guilt, not the revolutionary ideas required to make charitable actions unnecessary.

Now that you know the state of things, one question remains: What will you do?
3 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
A friend's remarkable FB posting: "The Charity of Change" (Original Post) markpkessinger Jul 2014 OP
'the ignorance that drives poverty and crime' Say what? leftstreet Jul 2014 #1
I don't think he would argue with you on any of those points . . . markpkessinger Jul 2014 #2
My apologies leftstreet Jul 2014 #3

leftstreet

(36,108 posts)
1. 'the ignorance that drives poverty and crime' Say what?
Thu Jul 3, 2014, 02:08 PM
Jul 2014

Capitalism, scarcity, planned obsolescence, inherited wealth....those have nothing to do with it?

??

Nice poster
Shit article

markpkessinger

(8,401 posts)
2. I don't think he would argue with you on any of those points . . .
Thu Jul 3, 2014, 02:11 PM
Jul 2014

. . . and the mere fact that he didn't mention them in this specific instance is hardly grounds for labeling it a "Shit article," IMO. The point of the article was not to provide an exhaustive analysis of the causes of our many problems, but to point out the folly of trying to address systemic problems through individual acts of charity.

leftstreet

(36,108 posts)
3. My apologies
Thu Jul 3, 2014, 02:15 PM
Jul 2014

That was probably too strong

Possibly the author didn't realize what s/he was saying

Education has nothing to do with ignorance

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»A friend's remarkable FB ...