General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsHow can journalists be objective when writing about dead children?
Giles Fraser
Its a controversy as old as the fifth century BC. Man is the measure of all things, said Protagoras. No, replied Plato. Nothing imperfect can be the measure of anything. And there we have the essence of a philosophical squabble about the possibility of human objectivity that is as alive in modern newsrooms as it was in the Athenian agora. For when a visibly shaken Jon Snow stepped out from behind the supposed neutrality of his newsreaders desk to present a piece to camera on his recent trip to Gaza, it felt like he was crossing a journalistic fourth wall, thus allowing the audience to recognise his anger, his passion and his opinion.
I cant get these images out of my mind, said Snow, describing a small girl he met in hospital, terribly crippled by shrapnel that had penetrated her spine. Was that objective, some asked?
Well, I admit it: I have been losing my cool. During the week, I decided that it didnt make sense for me to write about Gaza any more. I was no longer interested in sitting calmly at my desk turning out more apparently ordered sentences, purporting to run smoothly from one solid proposition to another. At times, I feel shut down by the sheer horror of it all, encased in some bitter despondency, unable properly to process the frustration.
And then, by contrast, I worry that I am going to blurt out something that I will come to regret. Maybe I did that in this column last week, floating the possibility of what I called just terrorism. My friend, UN spokesman Chris Gunness, broke down during an Al-Jazeera interview. He managed the words the injustice of it all is enough to make any heart burst before he sank sobbing into his hands, unable to say any more.
On yesterday morning, the Guardians leader-writing team were talking together, entirely calmly and sensibly, about the way forward: we discussed Binyamin Netanyahus inaction, lost opportunities for peace, the problem of attack tunnels. But my mind wandered off and the conversation became distant chatter. All this being cool about it didnt work for me. I think of the remains of that two-year-old boy that our Jerusalem correspondent Peter Beaumont was presented with in a plastic bag. And the kids packed into that UN school, sleeping on mattresses, expecting that a blue flag would keep them safe. My focal point wouldnt extend past that horror. I see it up close and personal.
more
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/belief/2014/aug/01/journalists-objective-writing-dead-children
Tierra_y_Libertad
(50,414 posts)Without compassion, anger, awe, sadness, guilt, remorse, etc "journalism" might as well be handled by computers.
closeupready
(29,503 posts)A journalist's job is to present the facts and truth as clearly as possible. A constructive way to respond if one's career is journalism but one's objectivity is being pushed to its limit, would be to continue covering stories about the set of circumstances surrounding the death of these children.