Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

JI7

(89,251 posts)
Mon Oct 13, 2014, 04:46 PM Oct 2014

Muslim Families Look after Kolkata Synagogues

Generations of Muslim families have been taking care of the maintenance of three synagogues in the eastern Indian city of Kolkata, which was once home to a thriving Jewish community.

Khalil Khan, 71, has been working as caretaker of Beth El synagogue, one of the city's three synagogues, for the past 55 years. His two sons - Anwar and Siraj - have chosen the same job.

Naseer Sheikh landed the job 56 years ago after his uncle left for his native village in neighbouring Odisha state, where all the caretakers come from. He is 80 years old and is still working, and is joined by his son Osim.

According to Silliman, the Jews and Muslims have a common history because of their roots in the Middle East.

"In Kolkata, Jewish families hired Muslim cooks because they ate only halal meat. Hindu families would not want to work in Jewish homes because of the meat being cooked. Our music, food habits are also very similar and people tend to forget that the Arab world is the seat of the Jewish community. Even the early immigrants looked like present-day Arabs, before they began to reflect a Judeo-British identity," she said.

It is no wonder then that the Jewish Girls' School's students are mostly Muslim.



http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2014/10/muslim-india-look-jews-kolkata-synagogues-2014101372153836885.html

2 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Muslim Families Look after Kolkata Synagogues (Original Post) JI7 Oct 2014 OP
It's not uncommon in areas with deep Muslim roots Igel Oct 2014 #1
Great Article. Rhinodawg Oct 2014 #2

Igel

(35,317 posts)
1. It's not uncommon in areas with deep Muslim roots
Mon Oct 13, 2014, 07:26 PM
Oct 2014

and former Muslim governments.

The peoples allowed to practice because they were in receipt of lesser revelations, but still in error because they rejected the best revelation, could self govern in many respects as a kind of contract between religious groups. But they had to pay due obeisance to those at the top of the totem pole, the Muslims. One way of doing this was to have Muslims hold the keys to the church and synagogue buildings, as a sign of supremacy. These weren't high-ranking Muslims, but since any Muslim is superior to any Xian or Jew, typically low-ranking Muslims. The position from Tunisia to India is typically hereditary.

This gets spun in various ways for the Western media. To show cooperation, to show acceptance of People of the Book by Muslims, etc., etc. In some cases it's spun to show Muslims being even-handed in mediating disputes between foolish Xians who can't get along. Even "ISIS" shows a difference between Xians--allowed to leave waqf lands--and Yazidi, who are deemed pagans. Raising a sword against ISIS, however, implies breaking the contract that trades peace and relative autonomy (in your own ghetto) for submission.

This system has been in place at times from Spain to Morocco to Egypt to Iran to India and probably east of India, noted from the 800s to the present. It's not always been enforced, and at times is vestigial or much weakened, but it has the same roots and can easily either fade or be vigorously enforced, depending on the conservatism and piety of the rulers (often driven by popular will as fed by the imams).

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Muslim Families Look afte...