General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Road to Dystopia
http://bluntandcranky.wordpress.com/2014/10/27/the-road-to-dystopia/Source info at the link.
Your humble correspondent and his amazingly tolerant spouse spent last weekend with family, preparing for all manner of family-altering events. In the course of that, we were exposed to Cable News of various flavors (we dont typically watch that kind of crap at chez Blunt and Cranky) on family members TeeVees, as they keep those channels on during waking hours. This was a depressingly revelatory experience, and it explained a lot about how America has would up so close to becoming a Dystopia on the order of Brave New World, 1984, or one of such.
What this writer saw was a load of propaganda, innuendo, speculation, dissimulation, distraction, obfuscation, panic-mongering, manipulation, and outright lies: call it 90+% of the programming. Any actual news appeared at random and infrequently. This, whether one was subjected to Fox, CNN, or MSNBC. The vast majority of airtime was swallowed up by panel discussions, analysis, and members of the the Punditocracy doing their Pundit thing.
So this morning, listening to the Beeb on the car radio, all one heard was the Brit Flavor of the same programming. Perhaps a bit more news there, but not by a lot. And it brought home the pervasiveness of the phenomenon: we are getting the same sort of near-as-no-matter brainwashing as described by Huxley or Orwell. Big Brother may not be watching us 24/7/365 yet, but He is most certainly doing His very best to control our thinking. And having great success at it, too.
Ebola? Be afraid, shun the infected!
A mass shooting? Be afraid, buy more guns and hide!
Terrorists? Be afraid, elect authoritarians!
People of Color in our country? Be afraid, vote to take away their rights!
On and on, on nearly every topic (except the occasional cat video), fear was the product being sold. And a neo-Fascist, authoritarian approach was the lone solution being presented as the only way to be safe.
America has gone down this road before: the Redskins, the Yellow Peril, and the Red Scare are just a few examples of how the powers that be use the media to manipulate us, mislead us, and bit by bit, enslave us. By pitting us against the Other du jour, we are led down a twisted road to a Dystopian nation, in which we will all be at risk of being Othered if we dont stay in line.
One bright spot: our President doesnt watch cable news: http://www.mediabistro.com/tvnewser/jay-carney-president-obama-is-various-reader-of-print-does-not-watch-cable-news_b243577 One very dark spot: this is presented as a very unusual and possibly negative thing. By, of course, cable news:
STELTER: Is it true the president doesnt watch any cable news?
CARNEY: It is true, which doesnt mean that he doesnt get news, in a real time basis. He does. Hes a voracious consumer of the printed word, even the electronic printed word, and but he doesnt he doesnt watch cable news. I have spent, you know, countless hours with him on Air Force One, especially, in the conference room where we always had the TV on, and it was never in any of the trips I ever took with him, tuned in to cable news.
So hey, cool, the Prexy isnt getting the full brainwash treatment. Yay. Hes not peddling as much fear and loathing as most DC Politicos. But of course, most people dont like him much, so who cares what he has to say?
I know most people dont like Obama; after all, I heard it on CNN this weekend
Wellstone ruled
(34,661 posts)Been bitching about this Stockholming of America for years. It's the same shit on every channel except Faux,in their case,it's total propaganda 24/7. For one who gets my news from print and electric print,noticed that any Disney related station has gone total hyper Fauxsational. CBS and NBC are total corporate F---ups,should expect it since they both have Frank Luntz as a media consultant or propaganda specialist.
riqster
(13,986 posts)Bluenorthwest
(45,319 posts)that shows which are devoted to commentary, punditry and opinion feature those things. Those are not news programs, they are opinion programs. 'I tuned in to NASCAR and there was almost no opera singing, what the fuck? Where's the opera?'
riqster
(13,986 posts)The problem is, millions of Americans actually DO think they are "news" sources.
Bluenorthwest
(45,319 posts)In this nation of 316 million people, you'd be hard pressed to find a day when eve 2% of them watch cable news. Not sure that has ever happened. Maybe on election nights. It's not 'many millions' at all. It's a few million total. To be blunt, it is difficult to actually be on national TV and have such small audiences. Almost the whole of America has never seen nor heard of 'Morning Joe' for example.
riqster
(13,986 posts)http://stateofthemedia.org/2011/cable-essay/data-page-2/
I will edit to say "millions" instead of "many millions".
The Traveler
(5,632 posts)... much like to News what "Sports Entertainment" (a.k.a. Professional Wrestling) is to martial arts.
However, it would be irresponsible to compare cable news' personnel favorably to professional wrestlers. Professional wrestlers are some of the world's most amazing athletes and stuntmen. They risk death or serious personal injury on a routine basis. (Hey, if Undertaker ever blew the "pile driver" finishing move stunt, his partner would suffer a broken neck. Think about it. 'Taker's job was to make it look real, and keep the other fella from being injured or crippled for life.) They travel constantly, train incessantly, and continue to perform while perpetually recovering from a never ending series of plaguing injuries.
Clearly, professional wrestlers routinely display a courage, devotion to craft, and integrity of purpose that is seldom or never demonstrated by the average cable news talking head.
Trav
**edited to clean up typos**
riqster
(13,986 posts)As bad as rugby, roller derby or field hockey.
greatlaurel
(2,004 posts)Great essay, thanks!