Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

KamaAina

(78,249 posts)
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 02:28 PM Oct 2014

Footage reveals U.S. police shooting homeless man 46 times

http://www.dailysabah.com/world/2014/10/30/footage-reveals-us-police-shooting-homeless-man-46-times

A graphic video has emerged capturing eight white police officers shooting 46 times at a mentally-ill black man in the U.S. state of Michigan. The video, released by the American Civil Liberties Union, accompanies an interview with the mother of Milton Hall, who was shot by eight officers in 2012 for refusing to drop his pocketknife. It shows a confrontation between an anxious looking Milton Hall and eight police officers forming a line with their guns pulled, in a shopping plaza parking lot. Two minutes into the video, the uniformed officers start to fire at the man. They continue shooting at him even after he goes down.

"To have eight people stand in front of one human being and shoot at him 46 times and hit him 14 times... It has been devastating to our family," says mother Jewel Hall in the interview, which was released on Tuesday. Milton was a homeless, mentally ill African-American man living in Saginaw, Michigan. The county prosecutor declined to bring charges against the officers involved, and the U.S. Department of Justice announced a decision in February that the officers would not face federal charges.

Included in the presentation was footage from an interview with his mother, Jewel Hall, who said her son's blood was "running down the street like water. And he wasn't a threat, I mean, he had a little pen knife. He had no idea that those policemen would do that to him."

In declining to prosecute, the cops and U.S. Department of Justice said investigators did not find evidence the officers had demonstrated "willful misconduct."


61 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Footage reveals U.S. police shooting homeless man 46 times (Original Post) KamaAina Oct 2014 OP
America: One Nation Under Guns riverbendviewgal Oct 2014 #1
One has to wonder where the other 32 bullets went justiceischeap Oct 2014 #2
I was thinking the same thing. So trigger-happy but so accuracy-sad. arcane1 Oct 2014 #4
A bit OT, but I've heard or read somewhere that soldiers in combat often intentionally fire over the KingCharlemagne Oct 2014 #6
If true, it would be a very, very minority of soldiers. GGJohn Oct 2014 #9
Well that is in todays modern army zeemike Oct 2014 #19
I was that Military. GGJohn Oct 2014 #36
So was I...only 5 years older. zeemike Oct 2014 #49
I agree. GGJohn Oct 2014 #55
I feel like I must defer to your life experience, as I have none in the military. I would, however, KingCharlemagne Oct 2014 #41
Thanks for the link. GGJohn Oct 2014 #56
Please see sarisataka's post #47 in this thread for a more in-depth discussion. Turns out that, by KingCharlemagne Oct 2014 #57
In the past it was true sarisataka Oct 2014 #47
We live in a phucked up society where people think guns joeybee12 Oct 2014 #3
Fucking goons BubbaFett Oct 2014 #5
why taze someone when you can have the pleasure of unloading your weapon into them? spanone Oct 2014 #7
EIGHT cops and not a one of them could come up with some other way to deal logosoco Oct 2014 #8
The man seemed very worried about the barking police dog. They needed to get the dog away Dustlawyer Oct 2014 #14
I didn't even pick up on that. I couldn't watch it with sound, the visuals were bad enough! nt logosoco Oct 2014 #17
These officers are psychopathic. This is what we've come to in America. The Ruling Oligarchs are rhett o rick Oct 2014 #10
Not JUST the officers... FiveGoodMen Oct 2014 #53
It's a Christian nation alright. Enthusiast Oct 2014 #11
Not if you were to ask Christ. rhett o rick Oct 2014 #54
The article says they shot 46 times and hit him 14 times. Even using new math that means rhett o rick Oct 2014 #12
"That's a lot of bullets flying around in public." KansDem Oct 2014 #28
I am reminded of the Cal. police who mistakenly shot up a pickup truck dixiegrrrrl Oct 2014 #46
That case brings up a lot of questions. What kind of policy is in place where rhett o rick Oct 2014 #50
No act of police sadism surprises me anymore. hifiguy Oct 2014 #13
The New Normal. Life is a fuckin' video game. nt valerief Oct 2014 #15
Can't bring myself to watch the video robbob Oct 2014 #16
He had a pen knife Politicalboi Oct 2014 #24
Well, they didn't behead him, so it's not really barbarism. Tierra_y_Libertad Oct 2014 #18
They delivered milk later in the day, so all ok! nt Logical Oct 2014 #20
DUzy! KamaAina Oct 2014 #22
A firing line. Waiting for the order to execute the homeless man. Rex Oct 2014 #21
I'm pretty sure we have our Darren Wilson Award winners for the week. And month. KamaAina Oct 2014 #23
What you're seeing here is an execution. And were afraid of ISIS ?!?!?!?! blkmusclmachine Oct 2014 #25
Cold blooded murder/an execution. And every one of those pigs will walk scot free. blkmusclmachine Oct 2014 #30
I believe this IS ISIS... freebrew Oct 2014 #45
Obvious gun-culture, cop-shoot-first mentality jeffrey_pdx Oct 2014 #26
Yeah, let's focus on hit percentages. blkmusclmachine Oct 2014 #33
Maybe we have a misunderstanding jeffrey_pdx Oct 2014 #61
Imagine if this headline read, "Police shoot wealthy Jewish couple truedelphi Oct 2014 #27
So much for American "justice". TxVietVet Oct 2014 #29
Death by police firing squad sakabatou Oct 2014 #31
Execution by police death squad - nt KingCharlemagne Oct 2014 #43
All he police saw was "another nig**r" or in another situation a "piece of white trash" LiberalArkie Oct 2014 #32
How is the not heaven05 Oct 2014 #34
So sad. Dont call me Shirley Oct 2014 #35
32 missed shots... Man from Pickens Oct 2014 #37
Sickening. blackspade Oct 2014 #38
How disgusting. BeanMusical Oct 2014 #39
Indeed. KamaAina Oct 2014 #52
Reminds me of those WW2 photos of the Nazi pumping shots into the Jews standing in front of a geretogo Oct 2014 #40
After they have shot him and then swarmed his dead body like a bunch of ants, tblue37 Oct 2014 #42
Not just shootings. # of LAPD cops convicted of violating Rodney King's civil rights: 4. Number of KingCharlemagne Oct 2014 #44
Hope i read about a HUGE lawsuit, very very soon. n/t dixiegrrrrl Oct 2014 #48
The military wouldn't be able to do this in Iraq. Spitfire of ATJ Oct 2014 #51
If you have mental illness undergroundpanther Oct 2014 #58
Tell me about it. KamaAina Oct 2014 #59
What? Did they run out of bullets? grahamhgreen Oct 2014 #60

justiceischeap

(14,040 posts)
2. One has to wonder where the other 32 bullets went
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 02:41 PM
Oct 2014

To have missed that many times says that these police officers need to practice more or some were shooting because the others were but didn't want to actually shoot the man.

 

KingCharlemagne

(7,908 posts)
6. A bit OT, but I've heard or read somewhere that soldiers in combat often intentionally fire over the
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 02:59 PM
Oct 2014

heads of their enemies. Apparently, we are not naturally inclined to want to kill our fellow humans and, even after infantry training, some are still unable to bring themselves to do it willfully.

I have no idea how to verify if that is correct or what its source is. But maybe someone who knows more about the subject can weigh in.

GGJohn

(9,951 posts)
9. If true, it would be a very, very minority of soldiers.
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 03:22 PM
Oct 2014

In my platoon, that, AFAIK, never happened, when someone is trying to kill you, you try to kill them first.

zeemike

(18,998 posts)
19. Well that is in todays modern army
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:23 PM
Oct 2014

where they are all volunteers not conscripted from the population.
In your fathers army, the one with conscription you had a cross section of the populous and so there would be more people not so hot on the idea of killing people.

But when you have a volunteer army it is out of balance with the cross section of the people and so there will be a higher percentage of them that are there for that reason, because they want to kill people...because it is fun, and exciting and gives them a adrenalin rush, and because they have seen how on the TV those are our heroes.

And once out of the army there next logical career move is to be a cop, where they still have that license to kill...but with the need to make an excuse for why.
The violence in this country will not stop until we recognize this and change.

GGJohn

(9,951 posts)
36. I was that Military.
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:52 PM
Oct 2014

I'm 66 years old, so you can guess which military adventure I was associated with.

 

KingCharlemagne

(7,908 posts)
41. I feel like I must defer to your life experience, as I have none in the military. I would, however,
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 05:26 PM
Oct 2014

like you to take a look at this site if you get the time:

http://www.military-sf.com/Killing.htm

GGJohn

(9,951 posts)
56. Thanks for the link.
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 08:39 PM
Oct 2014

Makes for some interesting and thought provoking reading.
All I can tell you is from my personal experience, it didn't happen in my platoon, maybe in others, but in mine, AFAIK, no one purposely missed when we were in a firefight.

 

KingCharlemagne

(7,908 posts)
57. Please see sarisataka's post #47 in this thread for a more in-depth discussion. Turns out that, by
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 08:53 PM
Oct 2014

the time of the Vietnam War, military training was already aware of this and devising ways to condition troops not to intentionally miss. So it looks like your personal experience does trump my spotty memories of what I read, at least as far as Vietnam is concerned. That's as it should be, I suppose. Still, sarisataka's post also makes for some interesting reading on this question.

sarisataka

(18,779 posts)
47. In the past it was true
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 05:53 PM
Oct 2014

most of the research on this comes from the book On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society by Dave Grossman (an excellent book which I strongly recommend to anyone with an interest in the subject)

The site you reference below summarizes many of the points Grossman makes. In WW2 the rate of troops effectively engaging the enemy was between 15-20%. The rest would either intentionally shoot to miss or volunteer for jobs to keep them from having to shoot e.g. caring for wounded, retrieving ammo etc.

Since this phenomenon was discovered training has been altered to counteract the natural inclination to avoid killing. In Korea the estimate is 55% would effectively engage and by Viet Nam the number was 90+%.

I have not seen more recent numbers but my experience is that the percentage is still very high.

 

joeybee12

(56,177 posts)
3. We live in a phucked up society where people think guns
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 02:47 PM
Oct 2014

are the solution...police in another country would have handled this differently.

logosoco

(3,208 posts)
8. EIGHT cops and not a one of them could come up with some other way to deal
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 03:18 PM
Oct 2014

with this man, who seemed more mentally ill than he seemed actually violent.

Are there no other crimes or police work that this group could have been doing that they had to have EIGHT of them there? Do police actually have any specific training with dealing with mentally ill people? This reminds me of the shooting in St. Louis city where the cops pulled up to the scene of the guy with a knife and within SECONDS shot him dead. Didn't even talk to him or try anything else to diffuse the situation. They don't even seem to be trying anything. It's like they look at everyone as a violent criminal and the only tool they have is a gun.
This is insane. This is murder.

Dustlawyer

(10,497 posts)
14. The man seemed very worried about the barking police dog. They needed to get the dog away
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:00 PM
Oct 2014

and then try talking to him. Problem is, they really didn't want to, they wanted to shoot. Like someone already said, a tazer was made for this situation. They just didn't care about him or look at him as a human being. What is wrong with them!

 

rhett o rick

(55,981 posts)
10. These officers are psychopathic. This is what we've come to in America. The Ruling Oligarchs are
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 03:28 PM
Oct 2014

laughing their heads off.

FiveGoodMen

(20,018 posts)
53. Not JUST the officers...
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 06:42 PM
Oct 2014
In declining to prosecute, the cops and U.S. Department of Justice said investigators did not find evidence the officers had demonstrated "willful misconduct."


What exactly DOES count as willful misconduct?
 

rhett o rick

(55,981 posts)
12. The article says they shot 46 times and hit him 14 times. Even using new math that means
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 03:32 PM
Oct 2014

they missed at point blank range 32 times or 70%. That's a lot of bullets flying around in public.

On another thread while responding to someone that claimed that just because the police fire so many shots so fast does not mean they are shooting out of control. These officers must have had their F'n eyes closed.

They committed murder.

KansDem

(28,498 posts)
28. "That's a lot of bullets flying around in public."
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:33 PM
Oct 2014

And notice the cars passing in the background? There could very easily have been more than one death from this shooting.

dixiegrrrrl

(60,010 posts)
46. I am reminded of the Cal. police who mistakenly shot up a pickup truck
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 05:50 PM
Oct 2014

in which 2 women were using to deliver newspapers. They were lying flat in the pickup bed, out of their minds with fear, as the cops
mistook their truck, which was parked in their driveway, for a bad guy's.
Truck ended up looking like swiss cheese, the women were not injured, and the following lawsuit resulted in them getting a new truck on top of whatever else they got.

 

rhett o rick

(55,981 posts)
50. That case brings up a lot of questions. What kind of policy is in place where
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 06:16 PM
Oct 2014

they just start shooting. If I remember correctly the truck wasn't the same type or color. Whose brilliant idea is it to have so many different shooters? Is it really the idea to just point at the vehicle and empty your gun? How do they know when to stop shooting?

This case proves that they really don't have a clue as to what they are doing.

 

hifiguy

(33,688 posts)
13. No act of police sadism surprises me anymore.
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 03:33 PM
Oct 2014

Not in the least. Not even this.

The kind of people who really want to BE cops are the last peole in the world who SHCOULD be given the job. Police departments draw from the sick, twisted psycho part of the population more than any other employer, with the possible exception of high-level finance.

Militarization has only made it worse.

robbob

(3,538 posts)
16. Can't bring myself to watch the video
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:05 PM
Oct 2014

but is there any indication that the victim posed any threat to the police? That really pisses me off, cops can execute you for not doing what they tell you. "Drop the penknife....no? BLAM". "Put your hands in the air....no? BLAM". "Stop filming me....no? BLAM"

Obey us or be killed.

Did this man pose ANY threat to them? Charge them, wave the knife at them?

Sickening.

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
21. A firing line. Waiting for the order to execute the homeless man.
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:27 PM
Oct 2014

And the state and feds approved of their actions. Par the course for a nation in love with guns and death.

freebrew

(1,917 posts)
45. I believe this IS ISIS...
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 05:37 PM
Oct 2014

the US brand. Soon they will report only to their masters, the rich, if they don't already.

Private goons hired by local law enforcement agencies, it gets all mangled. There is no justice for the poor or non-white. But there will be. It's inevitable. Corrupted power has never stood forever. But it will hurt.

jeffrey_pdx

(222 posts)
26. Obvious gun-culture, cop-shoot-first mentality
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:30 PM
Oct 2014

But seriously, 42 shots and only 14 hit at that range? I'm not a gun nut, but I've shot guns. Thats pathetic. At that distance I can put all my shots in a 2 inch diameter or less.

jeffrey_pdx

(222 posts)
61. Maybe we have a misunderstanding
Fri Oct 31, 2014, 12:59 PM
Oct 2014

It seems to me that these cops took it upon themselves to fire until their clips were empty.

truedelphi

(32,324 posts)
27. Imagine if this headline read, "Police shoot wealthy Jewish couple
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:31 PM
Oct 2014

46 times, outside synagogue."

The news media would be abuzz with it for a month.

But our poor and our homeless are the "parasites" and the "vermin" of the Fourth Reich.

I grew up in a time when "It can't happen here" was endlessly promoted as a meme.

As ws, "Never forget."

And it all depends on whose definition of "It can't happen here," or "Never forget" is being used.


LiberalArkie

(15,729 posts)
32. All he police saw was "another nig**r" or in another situation a "piece of white trash"
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:40 PM
Oct 2014

really that is all they see when there is more than 2 officers present.

 

heaven05

(18,124 posts)
34. How is the not
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:42 PM
Oct 2014

'willful misconduct"? So much for holder's department caring about some of amerikas citizens. Some yes, you guess, some no, still your guess. It's just not right. This one is sad.

Dont call me Shirley

(10,998 posts)
35. So sad.
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 04:43 PM
Oct 2014

The police in albuquerque were attacking and shooting the mentally ill and homeless. The DOJ stepped in and the shootings have slowed down.

It's so very sad police recruits are not chosen who have compassion, empathy and sympathy.

geretogo

(1,281 posts)
40. Reminds me of those WW2 photos of the Nazi pumping shots into the Jews standing in front of a
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 05:20 PM
Oct 2014

trench . These incidents are becoming common place . I guess it's just part of the collapse of
Empire and the beginning of a new police state .

tblue37

(65,490 posts)
42. After they have shot him and then swarmed his dead body like a bunch of ants,
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 05:30 PM
Oct 2014

one grabs his leg and drags him, another shoves his body with a foot, and then yet another one uses his foot to shove the body. They treat his body like old trash that is in the way but that they didn't want to touch.

He didn't look threatening before they shot him--he looked scared of the dog. He was hunched down in a self-protective stance and even the way he was holding his little knife looked like he was trying to keep it between himself and the dog, in case the dog attacked him. He wasn't close enough to hurt any of them, not even when they started shooting.

That was a combination mob action and firing squad. People should be enraged by the way those cops behaved, absolutely enraged.

I do think, too, that whenever there are multiple cops, as soon as one shoots, they all start shooting, and as far as I can tell, once a cop starts shooting, he doesn't stop until his weapon is empty--and not even then in many cases, since we have seen videos in which some of them reload and keep shooting long after their target is down.

Use of force regulations in war zones are stricter than what the cops follow in this country. There seem to be no limitations on when, where, or why they get to shoot at us, and they clearly have no concept of excessive or unjustifiable force.

Obviously they view citizens as the enemy, not as citizens whose taxes pay their salary and whom they are supposed to serve and protect.

 

KingCharlemagne

(7,908 posts)
44. Not just shootings. # of LAPD cops convicted of violating Rodney King's civil rights: 4. Number of
Thu Oct 30, 2014, 05:34 PM
Oct 2014

LAPD cops present during part or all of the Rodney King beat-down: 21.

At the risk of sounding like one of those squishy, touchy-feely liberals (and not the hard-boiled Socialist I fashion myself), I'll simply say there's not enough reverence for life in these parts.

Your post really captures what's going on, I think.

 

KamaAina

(78,249 posts)
59. Tell me about it.
Fri Oct 31, 2014, 12:05 AM
Oct 2014
http://www.ktvu.com/news/news/community-calls-for-police-accountability-in-shoot/nKhZ7/

Members of the San Jose community gathered Tuesday afternoon alongside the family and friends of a mentally ill man who was fatally shot by police on Mother's Day to call for police accountability in his killing.

A coalition of community-based organizations stood outside City Hall under a banner declaring "Justice for Daniel Pham." Laan Do, her face sullen and her eyes downcast, held a portrait of her son. Beside her stood her husband Vinh Pham wearing an equally grim expression....

Daniel Pham, 27, was armed with a knife when he was shot and killed by Officers Brian Jeffrey and Matthew Blackerby in the backyard of his home on Branbury Way on the morning of May 10, police said. They had responded to a report of a stabbing at the residence and upon arrival had found Pham's brother, Brian, 29, in the front lawn, bleeding from a cut across his neck.

The officers spotted Daniel Pham, the suspect, in the home's fenced-in yard, holding the knife and smoking a cigarette. According to police reports, Jeffrey pointed his gun at Pham and ordered him to drop the knife, but Pham "glared" at Jeffrey and continued to smoke his cigarette.


Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Footage reveals U.S. poli...