Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ForgoTheConsequence

(4,868 posts)
Sat Dec 6, 2014, 11:25 PM Dec 2014

So we all know torture happened, yet if we hold people accountable hostages might be killed?

The third-way, conservadem logic is strong on this Torture Report. If being a good Democrat involves covering up Republican crimes, I must not be a Democrat.

32 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
So we all know torture happened, yet if we hold people accountable hostages might be killed? (Original Post) ForgoTheConsequence Dec 2014 OP
K&R 99Forever Dec 2014 #1
i thougt Udall was in favor of releasing it JI7 Dec 2014 #2
Udall is, Kerry is not. ForgoTheConsequence Dec 2014 #4
but Udall is a third way dlc type dem which is why he lost his election JI7 Dec 2014 #14
You can't fix stupid. malokvale77 Dec 2014 #3
Delaying the release is not the same thing as never releasing it. The torture has stopped and Obama okaawhatever Dec 2014 #5
Did people die when Obama admitted to it? ForgoTheConsequence Dec 2014 #6
No, not nonsense. Reality. The fear is for Americans abroad and American hostages, plus the Iran okaawhatever Dec 2014 #7
You don't think those who were tortured already know it? Your logic is a major fail. Scuba Dec 2014 #8
Americans aren't ignorant of it. Obama has admitted it publicly. This report has been in the press okaawhatever Dec 2014 #10
So then what's the difference? ForgoTheConsequence Dec 2014 #11
So why not release it? Scuba Dec 2014 #21
Answer my question... ForgoTheConsequence Dec 2014 #9
Why do you think "most countries" are torturing people? Dragonfli Dec 2014 #12
propaganda propaganda propaganda BrotherIvan Dec 2014 #16
Here's the thing, what the CIA did to detainees is no secret 951-Riverside Dec 2014 #13
They're slow walking it to protect the powerful. neverforget Dec 2014 #15
To protect the guilty powerful and their underlings who actually performed the torture. Tierra_y_Libertad Dec 2014 #17
The leaders of the world never prosecute one another because they know one day it could and liberal_at_heart Dec 2014 #18
This message was self-deleted by its author 1000words Dec 2014 #19
This. LeftOfWest Dec 2014 #20
It was bad enough Bush, Cheney and their merry cohorts weren't prosecuted. Vinca Dec 2014 #22
There might be a good reason to delay release. Vattel Dec 2014 #23
The truth is Kerry is not the impetus, he is the smoke screen reddread Dec 2014 #24
anybody thinks torture has been stopped is just kidding themselves KG Dec 2014 #25
This message was self-deleted by its author 1000words Dec 2014 #32
Holding folks accountable for torture would be like... stone space Dec 2014 #26
Since they always have hostages, nilesobek Dec 2014 #27
I wonder if they're stonewalling and obfuscating because they are KingCharlemagne Dec 2014 #28
Often heroic folks under a lot of pressure sodomize children. Dragonfli Dec 2014 #30
That is some seriously acerbic shit (but well put). I read somewhere back KingCharlemagne Dec 2014 #31
The report has not been released and yet Americans avebury Dec 2014 #29

ForgoTheConsequence

(4,868 posts)
4. Udall is, Kerry is not.
Sat Dec 6, 2014, 11:43 PM
Dec 2014

And the conservative faction of this board thinks that is just dandy. American's don't deserve to know what crimes were done in OUR name.

malokvale77

(4,879 posts)
3. You can't fix stupid.
Sat Dec 6, 2014, 11:37 PM
Dec 2014

One might think, that a dose of honesty and accountability might actually help.

Never mind.

okaawhatever

(9,462 posts)
5. Delaying the release is not the same thing as never releasing it. The torture has stopped and Obama
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:00 AM
Dec 2014

has admitted to it.
Glad to know you could care less if Americans die just so you can view a report that has been 5 years in the making. I guess you're not concerned with the Iran deal either.

ForgoTheConsequence

(4,868 posts)
6. Did people die when Obama admitted to it?
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:10 AM
Dec 2014

You're talking nonsense. Quit hiding behind "American's dying", not only is it terrible logic, it's distasteful.

okaawhatever

(9,462 posts)
7. No, not nonsense. Reality. The fear is for Americans abroad and American hostages, plus the Iran
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:22 AM
Dec 2014

deal. Besides, it's not like all the other countries have released a report on their torture activity and its our turn. One thing that will come from this is a lot of bad press for the US when most countries are doing the same thing. It won't be viewed in that light, though.

 

Scuba

(53,475 posts)
8. You don't think those who were tortured already know it? Your logic is a major fail.
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:24 AM
Dec 2014

They know it, their loved ones know it, only the American people are ignorant of it.

okaawhatever

(9,462 posts)
10. Americans aren't ignorant of it. Obama has admitted it publicly. This report has been in the press
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:32 AM
Dec 2014

how many times over the last 5 years? There have been plenty of news reports on the alleged and then confirmed torture at Guantanamo. Americans are well aware of it. lk

ForgoTheConsequence

(4,868 posts)
11. So then what's the difference?
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:34 AM
Dec 2014

Everyone is doing it and everyone knows about it....Why not release it? What are you scared of? Some of your heroes might come out looking a little dirty?

ForgoTheConsequence

(4,868 posts)
9. Answer my question...
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:26 AM
Dec 2014

Did people die when Obama admitted that "we tortured some folks"? By YOUR logic they should have.



Good job breaking out the old "everyone else is doing it" argument. When all else fails, debate like an 8 year old.

Dragonfli

(10,622 posts)
12. Why do you think "most countries" are torturing people?
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:45 AM
Dec 2014

I find it to be both shocking and bizarre that you make such an assumption.

Our criminal activity is widely known (Bush and co. made quite a splash) as indeed are the criminal antics of various tyrants in the world which in many cases are even worse, but I thought it was well established that civilized countries do not commit torture. Hence our moral imperative a few years back to stop doing so.

Why do you believe such a thing? Do you know any facts that I am simply unaware of? Or is this belief a defense mechanism meant to assuage the guilt you feel for supporting the continued sweeping under the rug of heinous acts and the sheltering of war criminals and torturers by telling yourself everybody is doing it?

 

951-Riverside

(7,234 posts)
13. Here's the thing, what the CIA did to detainees is no secret
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:52 AM
Dec 2014

Water boarding, inducing hypothermia, testing experimental drugs, smearing inmates with menstral blood, beatings, force feeding and even bringing in children has been known for years.

We've all heard the stories from whistle blowers, reporters and guards.

Just release the damn thing and get it over with.

neverforget

(9,436 posts)
15. They're slow walking it to protect the powerful.
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 01:21 AM
Dec 2014

I hope Senator Udall reads the report into the Congressional Record and those assholes involved in this atrocity are prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.

liberal_at_heart

(12,081 posts)
18. The leaders of the world never prosecute one another because they know one day it could and
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 04:17 AM
Dec 2014

would be them being prosecuted.

Response to ForgoTheConsequence (Original post)

 

Vattel

(9,289 posts)
23. There might be a good reason to delay release.
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 09:48 AM
Dec 2014

It's hard to say without knowing what Kerry knows. That being said, I don't trust Kerry. He has proven himself a tool.

 

reddread

(6,896 posts)
24. The truth is Kerry is not the impetus, he is the smoke screen
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 11:10 AM
Dec 2014

and we should, for once, try to keep our eye on the ball.
or the pea. whatever it is.

Response to KG (Reply #25)

nilesobek

(1,423 posts)
27. Since they always have hostages,
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 11:58 AM
Dec 2014

this excuse can be used in perpetuity. There will NEVER be a "good time," to release the torture report. The criminals and their cohort coverup cleanup men are running out the clock.

Who is the sick maniac sadist that decided to smear America forever by introducing torture? I want to know who suggested it, who ran the program and how long we have to live under the tyranny of evil men.

This is no longer the country I was raised in...disgusting!

 

KingCharlemagne

(7,908 posts)
28. I wonder if they're stonewalling and obfuscating because they are
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:04 PM
Dec 2014

afraid the righteous fury of the American people, slow to awaken but once awoke unquenchable, will ignite.

If, for example, the report documents that American military personnel or intelligence assets (or mercenaries in the U.S. employ) were sodomizing Iraqi children in front of their parents in order to compel parents to inform on the Iraqi resistance, do you think that revelation might be enough to arouse the vast majority of working-class Americans from their moral torpor?

Dragonfli

(10,622 posts)
30. Often heroic folks under a lot of pressure sodomize children.
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 02:59 PM
Dec 2014

These patriots must be protected not only from laws that would unjustly imprison them, but from getting their feelings hurt by the mean population that does not understand what heroic action looks and sounds like when expressed in the screams of small children being raped. Luckily, the President and his SOS understand their plight and are glad to aid and protect them after the fact.

 

KingCharlemagne

(7,908 posts)
31. That is some seriously acerbic shit (but well put). I read somewhere back
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 03:35 PM
Dec 2014

when the shit initially hit the fan that Sen. Lindsey Graham had looked at some of the photos and video that wasn't released and he was visibly shaken. That tells you there is some seriously dreadful shit in there.

The fallacy of course is assuming that people in the Middle East (and the developing world) aren't already well aware of exactly what transpired in the Gulag Americanus. As one example, there were apocryphal stories out there in 2004-06 that women detained in Abu Ghraib were smuggling messages out to the Iraqi resistance begging for the female wing to be mortared because Americans (intelligence and mercenaries, mixed in with military) had brought those women such indelible shame. Now that is some seriously fucked-up shit.

avebury

(10,952 posts)
29. The report has not been released and yet Americans
Sun Dec 7, 2014, 12:09 PM
Dec 2014

and other western hostages are being killed by their captors anyway. Their argument holds no weight. What gets hostages killed is our behavior in the Middle East and absurd belief that you can achieve a victory in the "War on Terror" which has about as much chance of success as our "War on Drugs."

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»So we all know torture ha...