Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
30 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
"The Taliban Says It's Legal - So It's Ok With Me" (Original Post) kpete Dec 2014 OP
Brilliant cartoon! Note that 51% of Americans in a recent Pew Center poll KingCharlemagne Dec 2014 #1
That percentage will probably decline as people begin to understand what the report really JDPriestly Dec 2014 #6
That would be the best outcome, but I don't think so. I think people will go to the ends of jtuck004 Dec 2014 #21
Interesting...thanks for mentioning that poll. xocet Dec 2014 #7
A lot of people polled are idiots. Dark n Stormy Knight Dec 2014 #24
You mean "interrogation methods," don't you? subterranean Dec 2014 #11
You know, now that I think of it, I don't recall the exact wording used in the question. (May have KingCharlemagne Dec 2014 #12
That was the exact wording: Interrrogation methods. subterranean Dec 2014 #14
This message was self-deleted by its author KingCharlemagne Dec 2014 #15
You are absolutely 100% correct. In my haste, I conflated this recent KingCharlemagne Dec 2014 #16
"We will treat our prisoners like you treat your prisoners. You got a problem with that?" DetlefK Dec 2014 #2
Morals can be relative The2ndWheel Dec 2014 #3
K & R - Drone strikes could be treated with the same sort of cartoon. n/t xocet Dec 2014 #4
Yup, USA drone strikes in Pakistan have killed 874 people, 142 of them children. countryjake Dec 2014 #17
K&R. JDPriestly Dec 2014 #5
Taliban go on killing spree at Pakistan school, 132 students dead oberliner Dec 2014 #8
Benazir Bhutto called The Taliban "the Frankenstein Monster" CJCRANE Dec 2014 #18
Don't you mean, "Scores of militants including Al Qaeda's #2 killed by US strike in Peshawar"? 951-Riverside Dec 2014 #19
You aren't trying to say it makes a difference which side does the killing or how it's done are you? A Simple Game Dec 2014 #20
What is this 'School" heavily guarded? Military Run? 1100 people?? happyslug Dec 2014 #22
It was a school on a military base, like any public school, but it catered to the children of MADem Dec 2014 #27
Republicons lack the empathy gene corkhead Dec 2014 #9
"Locked in coffin-like boxes" Depaysement Dec 2014 #10
K&R napkinz Dec 2014 #13
ditto nilram Dec 2014 #23
The Golden Rule is anathema to fascism. True Blue Door Dec 2014 #25
Great cartoon Gothmog Dec 2014 #26
Perfect! Enthusiast Dec 2014 #28
Kick and R. BeanMusical Dec 2014 #29
The depressing reality is... Jerry442 Dec 2014 #30
 

KingCharlemagne

(7,908 posts)
1. Brilliant cartoon! Note that 51% of Americans in a recent Pew Center poll
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 11:07 AM
Dec 2014

approved of the U.S. use of torture. So this cartoon may be closer to the literal truth than might appear at first glance.

JDPriestly

(57,936 posts)
6. That percentage will probably decline as people begin to understand what the report really
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 01:27 PM
Dec 2014

means.

We all assume that our guys, our team is "OK" and on our side.

It takes thought and more information before we can reconsider that assumption and judge fairly.

And that takes time.

A court case would help people understand the evidence about this.

 

jtuck004

(15,882 posts)
21. That would be the best outcome, but I don't think so. I think people will go to the ends of
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 10:15 PM
Dec 2014

the earth to justify this and make it ok to have done it, and would do it again in a heartbeat. I think instead you will see more horrific behavior since this has been justified by so many, and, frankly, we don't seem to care to do anything much about it. After having lived this many years, I have faith in my fellow human's ability to make excuses for ignorant and hurtful behavior 'till the cows come home. They keep proving it.

This country is getting meaner and angrier, (endless war may do that) which I just don't see as an atmosphere in which we become smarter. If that were true people would remember back to Jimmy Carter and how he told us we would be here one day if we didn't back off and start taking care of ourselves, get smarter about economics. We threw his ass to the curb and went on a debt spree, until the banks realized they could steal the proceeds with the government's help. The banks are still running it, and the people are no smarter, and more in servitude, than ever. (Saw a survey the other day in which conservatives are increasing among people who live in poverty, perhaps with good reason). Heck, the people can't even get smart enough to demand justice for themselves from the banks - I doubt they will do it for this.

But perhaps.






xocet

(3,871 posts)
7. Interesting...thanks for mentioning that poll.
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 01:28 PM
Dec 2014
December 15, 2014
About Half See CIA Interrogation Methods as Justified
Democrats Divided over CIA’s Post-9/11 Interrogation Techniques

More Say CIA Interrogation Methods Were Justified than UnjustifiedFollowing the Senate Intelligence Committee’s report on CIA interrogation practices in the period following the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, 51% of the public says they think the CIA methods were justified, compared with just 29% who say they were not justified; 20% do not express an opinion.

The new national survey by the Pew Research Center, conducted Dec. 11-14 among 1,001 adults, finds that amid competing claims over the effectiveness of CIA interrogation methods, 56% believe they provided intelligence that helped prevent terrorist attacks, while just half as many (28%) say they did not provide this type of intelligence.

Partisan divides on these questions are wide. A large majority of Republicans (76%) say the interrogation methods used by the CIA after 9/11 were justified. Democrats are divided – 37% say the methods were justified, while 46% disagree. About twice as many liberal Democrats (65%) as conservative and moderate Democrats (32%) say the CIA’s interrogation techniques were not justified.More Interest in Police Protests than CIA Report

Overall, the public expresses the most doubt not about the CIA methods and program itself, but about the Senate committee’s decision to release its report: as many call the decision to publicly release the findings the wrong decision (43%) as the right decision (42%).

...

http://www.people-press.org/2014/12/15/about-half-see-cia-interrogation-methods-as-justified/

subterranean

(3,427 posts)
11. You mean "interrogation methods," don't you?
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 02:02 PM
Dec 2014

The results might have been somewhat different if the poll had actually used the word "torture." Though even if it had, I suspect a majority of Republicans would still approve.

 

KingCharlemagne

(7,908 posts)
12. You know, now that I think of it, I don't recall the exact wording used in the question. (May have
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 02:25 PM
Dec 2014

been a euphemism like 'harsh interrogation techniques' or some such). I saw another poll by Pew in 2011 discussed on fivethirtyeight.com that got similar results and actually used the word 'torture'. (Entire article is worth the read, imo):

http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/senate-torture-report-public-opinion/

subterranean

(3,427 posts)
14. That was the exact wording: Interrrogation methods.
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 02:41 PM
Dec 2014

The questions didn't even use the terms "harsh" or "enhanced."

Response to subterranean (Reply #14)

 

KingCharlemagne

(7,908 posts)
16. You are absolutely 100% correct. In my haste, I conflated this recent
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 02:49 PM
Dec 2014

Pew Center poll (which, as you note, uses only 'interrogation methods') with its 2011 predecessor (which used the word 'torture').

Apologize for any confusion occasioned by my sloppiness. And thanks for sticking with it until I could get off my duff!

The2ndWheel

(7,947 posts)
3. Morals can be relative
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 11:18 AM
Dec 2014

No shock. People can rationalize many things depending on who's doing it. That's why the world is such a messy place.

countryjake

(8,554 posts)
17. Yup, USA drone strikes in Pakistan have killed 874 people, 142 of them children.
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 06:35 PM
Dec 2014
US drone strikes kill 28 unknown people for every intended target, new Reprieve report reveals

http://www.reprieve.org/us-drone-strikes-kill-28-unknown-people-for-every-intended-target-new-reprieve-report-reveals.html

Reprieve’s assessment is the first to provide an estimate of the number of people – including in some cases children – who are killed each time the US apparently attempts to assassinate a ‘high value target.’ Due to the US Government’s refusal to publish any information relating to the programme, or the ‘Kill List’ said to determine its targets, the analysis is limited to existing, publicly-available data from media reports and The Bureau of Investigative Journalism.


Seems that rationalizing such disgusting tactics away has boiled down to tit for tat, echoing that insane religious meme of an eye for an eye.
 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
8. Taliban go on killing spree at Pakistan school, 132 students dead
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 01:34 PM
Dec 2014

(Reuters) - At least 132 students and nine staff members were killed on Tuesday after Taliban gunmen broke into a school in the Pakistani city of Peshawar and opened fire, witnesses said, in the bloodiest massacre the country has seen for years.

More than eight hours after militants slipped into the heavily guarded compound through a back entrance, the army declared the operation to flush them out over, and said that all nine insurgents had been killed.

The attack on a military-run high school attended by more than 1,100 people, many of them children of army personnel, struck at the heart of Pakistan's military establishment, an assault certain to enrage the country's powerful army.

Wounded children taken to nearby hospitals told Reuters most victims died when gunmen, suicide vests strapped to their bodies, entered the compound and opened fire indiscriminately on boys, girls and their teachers.

http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/12/16/us-pakistan-school-idUSKBN0JU0JO20141216

CJCRANE

(18,184 posts)
18. Benazir Bhutto called The Taliban "the Frankenstein Monster"
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 07:30 PM
Dec 2014

that we helped create.

The War on Communism was so urgent that we had to create religious fundamentalists to fight them. Communism's gone and now we're fighting the fundamentalists. When they're gone I'm sure we'll find something else to fight.

 

951-Riverside

(7,234 posts)
19. Don't you mean, "Scores of militants including Al Qaeda's #2 killed by US strike in Peshawar"?
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 07:35 PM
Dec 2014

Because that's what the headline would be if the US did this with a drone.

A Simple Game

(9,214 posts)
20. You aren't trying to say it makes a difference which side does the killing or how it's done are you?
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 09:04 PM
Dec 2014

I remember reading quite a while ago a quote about war but I can't remember who said it. But I believe it to be 100% accurate.

It went something like this: "The rules of war are written by the winners." We better hope we never lose.

OK I used the Google to check on the quote, it seems there are lots of different people given credit, some real and some fictional, for many variations of the quote. The quotes also use the word history and/or rules interchangeably.

 

happyslug

(14,779 posts)
22. What is this 'School" heavily guarded? Military Run? 1100 people??
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 11:35 PM
Dec 2014
"We selected the army's school for the attack because the government is targeting our families and females," said Taliban spokesman Muhammad Umar Khorasani. "We want them to feel the pain."


This school was picked NOT because it was a School, but for one of two reasons:

1, and the one a favor, the officers leading the Pakistan Military had their children in that school. OR

2. The students in this school were to become officers in the future, they were the military elite being given military training.

I lead to #1 given the statement by the Taliban Spokesman, it was an Army School where the children of Army Officers went and the Taliban are feed up with their children being killed by US Drones strikes. This was a demand for the Pakistan Army to do something, either go to the Taliban and fight them OR stop the US drone strikes. Either would please the Taliban. The Pakistan army going after the Taliban means the Taliban will be on the defensive, but in the defense they can cause more injuries to any attack force.

Please note it is December, which means winter in Afghanistan. Snow covers the mountain passes but as a whole Pakistan has cool dry Winters and Springs.

The Monsoon ended in September but closer to the end then the norm which is September 1 for Pakistan:



http://www.downtoearth.org.in/content/monsoon-begins-withdraw-india

On the other hand the Mountains of Pakistan follows Afghanistan Weather patterns:

Mostly, the precipitation takes place from December to April. Highlands experience snowfall during December-March and the lowlands experience intermittent rainfall from December to May.

http://www.mapsofworld.com/afghanistan/weather-in-afghanistan.html


You have to also realized the Winter Wheat crop is in, and thus the Afghans and Taliban in Pakistan can go out and fight right now, till harvest time

“One of the things he wrote about was how a rural society like Afghanistan can’t farm and fight at the same time, so when it’s harvest season or there are other major agricultural activities going on, you’ve go to stop fighting to do that,” Kilcullen said. “So he sort of invented this idea that there’s a fighting season and a farming season, and people tend to do one or the other, but it’s very hard to do both.”

Read more here: http://www.mcclatchydc.com/2013/03/18/186197/cyclical-nature-of-afghan-fighting.html#storylink=cpy


Winter Wheat is planted between September and November and left over winter. It is harvested from July to September. It needs at least 30 days of temperatures below 5 Degree Celsius, 41 degrees Fahrenheit to germinate in the spring, thus little fighting in Afghanistan between August and November. You can NOT Farm and Fight at the same time:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_wheat

Thus from now till August fighting will increase in Afghanistan for the Taliban has planted it crops and called back its soldiers.

Yes, the Taliban are at their maximum Strength right now, the US has officially withdrawn from Afghanistan, thus this attack is an attempt to provoke a Pakistan response. If Pakistan is smart, they do nothing and wait till Summer when Taliban soldiers have to go home and harvest their wheat crop. On the other hand, politics do come into play even in the Military and internal military politics may force a military response that the Taliban are set for. Lets see what happens.

MADem

(135,425 posts)
27. It was a school on a military base, like any public school, but it catered to the children of
Wed Dec 17, 2014, 06:47 AM
Dec 2014

military personnel--from the very young to high school. We have the same sorts of schools on military bases ourselves, both in USA (at large enough bases) and overseas.

It wasn't just for "officers' children" it was for anyone living/working on the base.

Depaysement

(1,835 posts)
10. "Locked in coffin-like boxes"
Tue Dec 16, 2014, 02:00 PM
Dec 2014

In 1939, just after Britain and France declared war on Germany, the NYT cited a report by British counsul at Dresden detailing the camp conditions at Buchenwald.

Among other things, that report revealed that one of the means of torture used was to lock prisoners in coffin-like boxes called "sweat boxes."

True Blue Door

(2,969 posts)
25. The Golden Rule is anathema to fascism.
Wed Dec 17, 2014, 06:37 AM
Dec 2014

And, in fact, not even comprehensible to fascists.

The idea that their own actions can ever, in any possible way, be analogized to the actions of anyone else is beyond their ability to understand. They are inherently superior to all other life.

Rules do not apply to them, and do apply to others. Period.

Jerry442

(1,265 posts)
30. The depressing reality is...
Wed Dec 17, 2014, 11:01 AM
Dec 2014

...that when there's an incident in the future involving the "enhanced interrogation" of Americans, people in this country will be no less outraged. Ultimately, the argument is "It's a crime when they do that to us because we're us. It's not a crime when we do it to them because they're them."

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»"The Taliban Says It...