General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe lack of any official condemnation for CIA torture ensures it will happen again
The details shocked. Shackled prisoners were treated like cattle, watched by their CIA interrogators. Testimony from one observer stated that men blindfolded and tied were made to run down a steep hill, at the bottom of which were three throws of concertina barbed wire. The first row would hit them across the knees and they would plunge head first into the second and third rows of wire.
This wasnt CIA torture after the September 11 attacks, exposed in detail in a recent Senate report, but the Phoenix programme, instituted by the CIA and US, Australian and South Vietnamese militaries in Vietnam between 1965 and 1972 to neutralise the Vietcong. The result was more than 60,000 people tortured and killed. No senior politicians, generals or decision-makers were prosecuted for these crimes. A culture of immunity, despite occasional media and public outrage, thrived across the US.
Questioned before a US House operations subcommittee in the late 1960s to investigate widespread Phoenix-inspired torture, future CIA head William Colby used language that sounds familiar today. Its just the official enemy that has changed. The collateral damage was justified, he said. Phoenix was an essential part of the war effort designed to protect the Vietnamese people from terrorism.
In 2007, decades after its cessation, the CIA was still worried that the public felt Phoenix was an unlawful and immoral assassination programme targeting civilians. Instead, they claimed, it was pacification and rural security programmes.
more
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/dec/19/the-lack-of-any-official-condemnation-for-cia-torture-ensures-it-will-happen-again
Man from Pickens
(1,713 posts)odds are it is still happening right now as we speak
yeoman6987
(14,449 posts)Condemn it. Problem is majority either approved of torture or didn't care. You could see that in the coverage too. A day or two after release, it was pretty much a non story. Today most probably forgot all about it. Of course Sony is important to Americans...lol.
sabrina 1
(62,325 posts)country to not allow it to become a non story. To support those who have the guts to keep on talking about it, like Glenn Greenwald, rather than joining the smear campaigns against them, and to keep on expressing horror that we live in a country where TORTURE is acceptable.
But even here on this forum, there are people who refuse to join the Whistle Blowers who reported on torture, see Chelsea Manning eg, and the few real journalists left, see Glenn Greenwald, because their politics are more important to them than JUSTICE.
Doctor_J
(36,392 posts)Every Republican president beginning with Nixon has committed capital crimes, yet none of them has ever been held to account. That's why this just keeps going - getting worse, in fact.
sabrina 1
(62,325 posts)See Clinton, eg, re the Reagan crimes. There were convictions but there could have more, Clinton however, ended any chance of that.
Obama simply 'moved forward' and let them off the hook.
So all are complicit to one degree or another and the system will continue until an overwhelming majority of the people, rather than defending their teams, simply oppose these horrible practices and refuse to be complicit themselves.
librechik
(30,674 posts)Along with everybody else, we have always tortured. All you have to do is watch a few period WWII movies to figure that out (not to mention 24 and every other modern movie and tv show) In our popular culture, torture works, so it is used. Period.
But those desperate fictional heroes always knew torture was wrong, inhuman (when done to us at least) and there would be just punishment (in fiction, usually the torturer dies a heroic and justified death, due to the taint of his breaking the taboo. Maybe he'd get a pardon from the president, but he would have to face the music at some point for his crime.
Bush and Cheney made torture the policy of not even last resort and no punishment or justice. That's how they pissed on us for the next hundred years. At least. It works, so we do it. Try to stop us.
Yes, since we will not bring our own criminals to justice (don't remind me about our enormous heaving prison population--that's social engineering, not punishment) we will continue to be who we have always been. Number one.
JEB
(4,748 posts)that this shit is trickling down to us peons in the form of police brutality and oppression? This is way past the bud stage. There is no nipping it. The tap root must be extracted and destroyed. Anything less is not moving "forward" but condemning us to remain bogged down in the filth.
99th_Monkey
(19,326 posts)Not unless -- as you say -- we take it out by the roots.