Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mopinko

(70,120 posts)
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 04:47 PM Jan 2015

would you undergo a serious surgery to save a life?

i have a friend in need of a new liver. these days live donors can give a lobe of their own livers to someone else. that lobe will grow for the recipient, and the donor's will be rebuilt within about 6 months.
my nephew was able to save his father's life with this procedure.

i also had a friend who died recently waiting for a new kidney. he had a hereditary disease. he had received a kidney from a total stranger, but it failed after 10 years. because he was without insurance, he became very ill at that time. it bankrupted him to stay alive for another year and a half. at least THEN he was then eligible for medicaid. he managed to return to work but died unexpectedly a few months later. at least by then he was insured.

i wonder how many people would consider doing something like this.
i am not compatible with my friend, but i would consider it seriously if i were. i am old. i can afford to get rid of a few spare parts.
the liver thing is not that much of a sacrifice. nobody likes surgery, but it is pretty safe.
but i really cannot fathom being a good enough person to give up one of my kidneys for someone i dont even know.

what say you all?

edited to add link for my friend, because some of the best people in the world are on du.
https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=1585688624995061&id=1585679508329306&fref=nf

49 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
would you undergo a serious surgery to save a life? (Original Post) mopinko Jan 2015 OP
i would. unionthug777 Jan 2015 #1
I would do that. CaliforniaPeggy Jan 2015 #2
I would. onecaliberal Jan 2015 #3
Yes. Cooley Hurd Jan 2015 #4
Honestly, no. PeteSelman Jan 2015 #5
Yes Runningdawg Jan 2015 #6
No spinbaby Jan 2015 #7
My good friend's sister malaise Jan 2015 #8
Too old - the cut-off most places is 55 for livers. Ms. Toad Jan 2015 #9
it helps to be young. mopinko Jan 2015 #11
A child recipient? or perhaps a much smaller adult? Ms. Toad Jan 2015 #14
it was his dad. like i said in the op. mopinko Jan 2015 #16
Unless he was significantly larger than his dad, Ms. Toad Jan 2015 #18
i messaged my sister. mopinko Jan 2015 #19
I'll be curious to hear what she says - Ms. Toad Jan 2015 #23
this was 4 years ago mopinko Jan 2015 #25
At that time - Ms. Toad Jan 2015 #40
ok, you are correct mostly. mopinko Jan 2015 #45
My wife gave a kidney to my mother Nevernose Jan 2015 #10
yeah, that's the scary part w kidneys. mopinko Jan 2015 #12
It was only by chance pipi_k Jan 2015 #35
Only for my children. And probably my wife. Xithras Jan 2015 #13
yeah, having small kids makes a difference. mopinko Jan 2015 #17
No. And I wouldn't ask for it, either. mnhtnbb Jan 2015 #15
I'm too old, but in the past imagined I would for a family member. Caution, tho... Hekate Jan 2015 #20
not exactly planning on it. mopinko Jan 2015 #27
I've carried a donor card ever since there were donor cards: over 40 years Hekate Jan 2015 #30
Been there done that FrodosPet Jan 2015 #21
you are awesome. mopinko Jan 2015 #28
My answer is no. I would never ask or want someone else to do it for me. I let the chips fall. BlueJazz Jan 2015 #22
i'd be hard pressed to ask. mopinko Jan 2015 #26
I understand. One of my biggest concern (s) is someone giving me a kidney and then a few years... BlueJazz Jan 2015 #39
No but tabbycat31 Jan 2015 #24
i always have been. my family is well aware. mopinko Jan 2015 #29
Yes. I offered a kidney to a friend many years ago. napi21 Jan 2015 #31
Depends on who. Surgery can have life-threateing complications, from anaesthesia to MRSA to WinkyDink Jan 2015 #32
I would nkt think twice, my sister's kidneys are beginning to fail, I try to stay Thinkingabout Jan 2015 #33
you remind me. my dad mopinko Jan 2015 #46
After 18+ surgeries, Go Vols Jan 2015 #34
I keep trying to donate pipi_k Jan 2015 #36
I wouldn't undergo major surgery to save my own life, let alone anyone else's. nt WhiteAndNerdy Jan 2015 #37
No. LisaL Jan 2015 #38
Sure I would. I lost my mom when I was 3. I know how much it hurts to lose a loved one and if liberal_at_heart Jan 2015 #41
Yes, but only with a likelihood of ~ 4.12e-10 petronius Jan 2015 #42
i would but i don't think i'd be able to. DesertFlower Jan 2015 #43
For a stranger? Not under those conditions. ladyVet Jan 2015 #44
I couldn't JustAnotherGen Jan 2015 #47
I have yet to cross that bridge. I don't know. Xyzse Jan 2015 #48
Yes (nt) bigwillq Jan 2015 #49

CaliforniaPeggy

(149,629 posts)
2. I would do that.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 05:18 PM
Jan 2015

I have a friend who needs a kidney and I would be willing to donate one to help him, but I am the wrong blood type.

I used to give my blood and platelets but cannot any more.

And I was on the bone marrow transplant list till I got too old.

I do have the sticker on my driver's license that any organs or tissues that are needed can be taken upon my death.

PeteSelman

(1,508 posts)
5. Honestly, no.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 06:01 PM
Jan 2015

I'm not mutulating myself for a stranger. I might consider it for a close family member but even that is iffy. I'd do it for my kids but that's about it.

spinbaby

(15,090 posts)
7. No
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 07:10 PM
Jan 2015

Although I might make an exception for close family. My last two surgeries resulted in major complications, so I wouldn't risk it.

malaise

(269,049 posts)
8. My good friend's sister
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 07:23 PM
Jan 2015

gave her a kidney. It was very brave since their mother was on dialysis for 13 years before she died and their two other siblings also have kidney disease.

I'd do it for a loved one although I doubt doctors would let me at this age

Ms. Toad

(34,074 posts)
9. Too old - the cut-off most places is 55 for livers.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 07:25 PM
Jan 2015

But before that age I began the testing process for an acquaintance (a different donor was selected before they got to me).

Donating a liver portion is a significant event. Normally the process is safe, but it requires about 2 months off work, and around a year to feel back to normal, and the process is worse for the donor than the recipient. The recipient goes from having a non-functional liver to having 2/3 of a fully functional liver. The donor, on the other hand, drops from having 100% of a fully functional liver to having 33% of one (assuming an adult recipient of similar size). The body regenerates the liver pretty quickly - but it takes energy (and there is an adjustment process while the remaining 1/3 of the liver gets used to handling the entire load). And, they are just beginning to use a laparoscopic process to remove the liver segment, so most still involve a "mercedes" scar from around the bottom of your breastbone to the top of your hips (and the muscle interruption which results from that kind of incision).

That is not to discourage DU members from explorating of liver donation. In the past year i have had a half dozen friends and acquaintances die while waiting for a new liver (or die because a new liver was found, but not soon enough). Living donors are desperately needed because there are not enough cadaver donors to fill the need.

But going into it with a misunderstanding about how easy or safe it is doesn't do anyone any good. In terms of impact on the donor if a laparoscopic procedure is available for a kidney donor, the liver donation process is harder on the donor than the kidney donation process.

mopinko

(70,120 posts)
11. it helps to be young.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 07:36 PM
Jan 2015

nephew is in his early 20's and recovered quite quickly.
it was my understanding that they only took 1/3 of his liver.

Ms. Toad

(34,074 posts)
14. A child recipient? or perhaps a much smaller adult?
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 07:52 PM
Jan 2015

For a child they take a portion of the left lobe - they take most of the left lobe for a smaller adult. For an equivalent size adult, they take the right lobe. The left lobe is about 1/3 of the liver, the right lobe is about 2/3.

When I was in the early testing stages, I had a long conversation with a friend of mine who had donated a portion of his liver to a friend of his, who had the same disease my daughter has. I knew I would age out before my daughter needed a liver (she is still going with her factory issue parts) - so I started the donor evaluation process with an acquaintance whose parents were already too old. According to my friend, even though he was back to work in 8-12 weeks, it was a year before he felt normal again. At the time he was 29 or 30.

ETA: If the friend is the silver haired gentleman in the FB pictures it would almost certainly require the right lobe (~2/3 of the liver).

mopinko

(70,120 posts)
16. it was his dad. like i said in the op.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 08:41 PM
Jan 2015

donor in his 20's.
i dont know how long ago that was, but things are changing fast.

Ms. Toad

(34,074 posts)
18. Unless he was significantly larger than his dad,
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 09:18 PM
Jan 2015

it would have been approximately 2/3 of the liver. Things haven't changed much in the last 10 years. I don't think they changed much from the first live donor transplant about 25 years ago - but my personal familiarity only extends back a decade. The process my friend went through was nearly identical to what was described to me.

When they perfect the laparoscopic removal, that will be a significant shift for living donors - those just started within the last couple of years on an experimental basis. (And the even bigger change will come in around 5 years when they perfect the grow-your-own liver process - no more anti-rejection drugs! Currently they have created a functional liver around the size of a walnut.)

Ms. Toad

(34,074 posts)
23. I'll be curious to hear what she says -
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 09:46 PM
Jan 2015

and when the surgery was.

Figure 4 here shows how they generally divide the liver up - with segments 5-8 going to the recipient. Page 504, near the bottom puts the donated right lobe (segments 5-8) at around 60% for most people. It does discuss earlier (less successful) adult operations where they used a smaller portion. That would have been slightly less stressful on the donor, but didn't work so well for more of the recipients.

Ms. Toad

(34,074 posts)
40. At that time -
Mon Jan 5, 2015, 12:46 AM
Jan 2015

almost certainly the right lobe (~60%).

I have acquaintances being treated there - likely some who have been transplanted there. But I'm not specifically familiar with their protocol.

mopinko

(70,120 posts)
45. ok, you are correct mostly.
Mon Jan 5, 2015, 11:04 AM
Jan 2015

did take 70% of donors liver.
nephew was back at work in 3 weeks, tho he sorta regretted it.
both had 85% regrowth in 8 weeks.

Nevernose

(13,081 posts)
10. My wife gave a kidney to my mother
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 07:28 PM
Jan 2015

I would have donated it, but -- to paraphrase Rodney Dangerfield -- I'm giving my body to science fiction.

Ironically, despite the safety, it looks like my wife's one remaining kidney might be failing. They check one particular function every three months, and it's been decreasing rapidly. The next test should reveal whether or not she's hit official "early kidney failure" yet. Hopefully the healthy eating and frequent exercise are helping.

She says she has no regrets and would still donate the kidney.

pipi_k

(21,020 posts)
35. It was only by chance
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 11:41 PM
Jan 2015

that we found out my daughter was born with just one kidney

She had been involved in a pretty serious car crash in 1995


When they did a scan or whatever they do in the ER to make sure there are no internal injuries, that's how they discovered it.

Well, not that the second kidney is completely missing...it's there but only about the size of a peanut (or smaller) and non-functional.

I worry about her all the time, although she just had some tests done recently and the full sized kidney is still operating well.

Xithras

(16,191 posts)
13. Only for my children. And probably my wife.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 07:45 PM
Jan 2015

While complications are "unlikely", they do happen and can be lethal. I wouldn't put my children at risk of losing a parent in order to donate to a stranger. I'd certainly put my life at risk to help one of my children. Blood and marrow donations are one thing, but donations that can kill me are off the table.

FWIW, a sister of one of my sisters friends offered to donate a kidney to another sister a number of years ago (to be clear, there were three sisters in the family...my own sister is friends with one of them, and a second sister offered the kidney to a third sister). She was assured that it was safe, but died on the operating table. She had three kids under 10 at the time . That's sad enough, but it's made even worse by the fact that her kids (now in their 20's) still refuse to talk to the aunt today, and flat out blame her for killing their mother (and bluntly have told her so to her face). The recipient herself has a ton of mental issues because of it all.

My perspective may change a bit when my kids grow up and move out, but for the time being I won't willingly put my family at risk for that sort of thing.

mopinko

(70,120 posts)
17. yeah, having small kids makes a difference.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 08:44 PM
Jan 2015

that is a pretty sad story. ffs, blame the docs, or, correctly, blame fate.

it is tempting to me because my kids are grown, and i dont really have a lot to look forward to in my life.
too old to donate, tho, prolly.

mnhtnbb

(31,392 posts)
15. No. And I wouldn't ask for it, either.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 07:59 PM
Jan 2015

I have, however, indicated I'm an organ donor on my drivers license.

Hekate

(90,714 posts)
20. I'm too old, but in the past imagined I would for a family member. Caution, tho...
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 09:32 PM
Jan 2015

These are serious surgeries for the donors. A friend of mine was a good match for her adult son, but while he made an almost miraculous recovery, she nearly died because her bowel was nicked during the small-incision procedure. A nurse who was making a routine post-op check on my friend arrived just as all her vital signs crashed. She ended up with an extensive stay in the hospital and multiple surgeries. The hospital said they'd never had such an outcome before.

So I would proceed with eyes wide open.

mopinko

(70,120 posts)
27. not exactly planning on it.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 10:48 PM
Jan 2015

not a match for my friend just based on blood type.
shit does go wrong. it would be scary.
but it has me thinking about bone marrow or something.

Hekate

(90,714 posts)
30. I've carried a donor card ever since there were donor cards: over 40 years
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 10:51 PM
Jan 2015

But that's on the theory that I won't need any of my bits once I've breathed my last.

mopinko

(70,120 posts)
26. i'd be hard pressed to ask.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 10:45 PM
Jan 2015

at my age, i am ready for whatever the reaper has in mind, i think.
but i could imagine asking for a loved one, and refusing to let them go.

 

BlueJazz

(25,348 posts)
39. I understand. One of my biggest concern (s) is someone giving me a kidney and then a few years...
Mon Jan 5, 2015, 12:39 AM
Jan 2015

...later, they develop cancer in their one and only kidney.
Rather silly maybe but that's how my mind thinks..

tabbycat31

(6,336 posts)
24. No but
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 09:50 PM
Jan 2015

I am an organ donor (according to my drivers license). If something happened to me then I would donate my organs.

mopinko

(70,120 posts)
29. i always have been. my family is well aware.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 10:49 PM
Jan 2015

also aware that i dont want to be hanging by an electrical cord until is all rots, either.

napi21

(45,806 posts)
31. Yes. I offered a kidney to a friend many years ago.
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 11:09 PM
Jan 2015

I was much younger at the time and offered my kidney without ever being asked. Unfortunately I wasn't a good enough match. My friend died a few months later.

I say, as long as the donation doesn't have life threatening risks for the donor, it's a wonderful thing to do for someone. You're giving the gift of life and nothing else matches that.

 

WinkyDink

(51,311 posts)
32. Depends on who. Surgery can have life-threateing complications, from anaesthesia to MRSA to
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 11:12 PM
Jan 2015

septicemia to other ill effects.

Thinkingabout

(30,058 posts)
33. I would nkt think twice, my sister's kidneys are beginning to fail, I try to stay
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 11:25 PM
Jan 2015

Healthy if I am needed. I am also listed as an organ donor, we found from the group a 96 year young had donated his kidneys so we all signed up. There are eyes and skin if the donor is deceased in the field, what a blessing to donate to help the living.

mopinko

(70,120 posts)
46. you remind me. my dad
Mon Jan 5, 2015, 11:11 AM
Jan 2015

who dies in 73, used to tell us that if his corneas or anything else could help someone when he died that we should do it. so, he was saying this back in the 60's. i guess that might be why it always seemed like the right thing to do for me.
unfortunately, i dont think anyone remembered those instructions when he passed, tho he was probably not a good donor.

pipi_k

(21,020 posts)
36. I keep trying to donate
Sun Jan 4, 2015, 11:50 PM
Jan 2015

fat, but nobody wants it.


Seriously, though...I really don't know if I'd donate an organ or not while still alive, although I do have a donor sticker on my license.

If they can find anything useful, they're welcome to it

liberal_at_heart

(12,081 posts)
41. Sure I would. I lost my mom when I was 3. I know how much it hurts to lose a loved one and if
Mon Jan 5, 2015, 12:50 AM
Jan 2015

I could help keep someone around for their family I would definitely do it.

DesertFlower

(11,649 posts)
43. i would but i don't think i'd be able to.
Mon Jan 5, 2015, 04:47 AM
Jan 2015

i have CFS/ME and because they don't know how it's transmitted i'm not supposed to give blood or be an organ donor.

ladyVet

(1,587 posts)
44. For a stranger? Not under those conditions.
Mon Jan 5, 2015, 09:56 AM
Jan 2015

I can't afford to be recuperating that much for that long, and at my age (nearly 57) I doubt I'd be a good candidate anyway.

That said, for family I'd give anything and everything, especially for my sons.

I've been an organ donator since I saw an article in an old Reader's Digest, and tore out the card included. I was 17, but I waited to sign it until I was 18. My two best friends witnessed it during study hall. I've been on the bone marrow list for about eight or nine years now. I don't donate blood because I pass out when getting blood samples done, but my mother donated many, many pints, and my youngest son has, too, so I figure they made up for me.

Also, I have some condition that seems like fibromyalgia, so I'm not even sure I could donate anything anymore.

JustAnotherGen

(31,828 posts)
47. I couldn't
Mon Jan 5, 2015, 11:16 AM
Jan 2015

I have an auto immune disease eating away at my spine. . . killing my nerves, freezing me ramrod straight etc. etc.

A simple biopsy my body responds to as an 'injury' which triggers a massive flare. The fewer the flares, the less freezing, the slower my rib cage closes around my lungs.

On the one hand - I know how I'm probably going to die.

On the other hand - I'd like to delay that for as long as I can.

So I couldn't do it - I have people that depend on me.

Xyzse

(8,217 posts)
48. I have yet to cross that bridge. I don't know.
Mon Jan 5, 2015, 11:17 AM
Jan 2015

Most likely I would. Family and friends who I can not imagine not being in my life, I would pretty much do almost anything for them.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»would you undergo a serio...