General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsLA Times: California animal welfare law could cause higher egg prices countrywide
Also see this post: http://www.democraticunderground.com/10026037997
http://www.omaha.com/money/california-animal-welfare-law-could-cause-higher-egg-prices-countrywide/article_4d805bf5-f644-5e7f-a4db-751a04b7c1a7.html
POSTED: MONDAY, JANUARY 5, 2015 12:30 AM
The Los Angeles Times
LAKESIDE, Calif. If your eggs seem a little pricier, consider the recent changes on Frank Hillikers ranch.
In the last six months, the third-generation egg farmer in central San Diego County has reduced his flock by half and embarked on a $1 million overhaul of his henhouses to make them more spacious. Customers are now paying about 50 percent more for a dozen eggs from Hillikers family business at around $3 a carton.
Its all to comply with a landmark animal welfare law that took effect in California on New Years Day. The law is having a ripple effect into egg operations in Iowa and other big egg-producing states in the Midwest.
No state consumes more eggs than California and about a third of its supply must be imported. Iowa, where laying hens outnumber people 20 to 1, sells about 40 million eggs a day to out-of-state buyers.
FULL story at link.
joeybee12
(56,177 posts)Omaha Steve
(99,660 posts)meow2u3
(24,764 posts)People on fixed incomes cannot afford to shell out extra money for necessities.
MoonRiver
(36,926 posts)joeybee12
(56,177 posts)Otherwise I avoid them.
AtomicKitten
(46,585 posts)petronius
(26,602 posts)but I was glad to see this:
I dont know if the chickens know any better, but its made farming fun again, Hilliker said of the new barn. Its a new challenge, and I feel like it has reinvigorated me.
As a Californian who voted for the law I've been making a particular effort to buy CA eggs (although I slipped up yesterday and grabbed a TX carton). Good to see that other states are considering similar rules...
onecaliberal
(32,864 posts)femmocrat
(28,394 posts)I wonder if it would have any effect nation-wide, however. Didn't some state recently pass a bill making it illegal to take pictures on a farm? "Factory" farmers are not going to conform willingly, I fear.
11 Bravo
(23,926 posts)to ensure humane treatment of egg-laying hens.
Aerows
(39,961 posts)good for the people who tend to them, and good for everyone that consumes eggs to know that there is humane treatment that brought food to their table.
Trillo
(9,154 posts)I'm one of those who generally buys a couple flats of them at a time, prices had doubled. What used to cost $5.99 was about $11.
While I didn't like it, I still bought the eggs. The way the increase in price occurred, all of a sudden, wham, coupled with immediate news releases to explain, suggests little more than a rigged market.
I like the idea the birds are treated more humanely. I don't think I believe the rationale however. I suspect the drought has raised grain prices, and this law is just providing a convenient excuse.
I can't guarantee, if prices remain as high as they are, that I won't find alternatives to eggs. Maybe it's time to find that hummus recipe, and eat that for morning sandwiches instead of egg sandwiches. Hummus is cheap to make when you make it from the dry beans..... It freezes well, you can make a huge batch up ahead of time and keep it on hand.
Gormy Cuss
(30,884 posts)so you're probably right, it's just a convenient excuse to jack up the prices.
BrotherIvan
(9,126 posts)And free range and family farms will be able to compete against factory eggs now too. I buy eggs from our farmer's market for $5 a dozen. Store eggs were $4, so if they increase which is likely, it will be close to the same. But the farmer's eggs are jumbo, golden, often double yolk eggs so they are definitely worth a little more. Plus if you buy two flats, like I do as we eat a lot of eggs for cheap protein, it's a good deal.
Ykcutnek
(1,305 posts)When your Portlandia bullshit starts causing the rest of us pain, it's time to fuck the fuck off.
Omaha Steve
(99,660 posts)Will this really hurt YOU that much?
Gormy Cuss
(30,884 posts)are crammed into tight rows of such cages with other stressed hens can peck at them all day, yep. All that' is WORTH IT for cheap eggs.
G_j
(40,367 posts)haele
(12,660 posts)If not, the pain you might be complaining about "feeling" is the excuse that most grocery stores will use to jack up prices 70% instead of the 12% - 20% increase it might actually cost for the one-time retro-fitting to meet Prop 2 requirements. Also, from what our local (I live 10 miles from the Hilliker's farm that was profiled in the article and regularly buy their eggs from our local IGA/bodega) now cage free ranchers have begun to indicate, the large-scale operations that supply supermarket and corporate eggs have found that hens tend to be healthier and not require as many veterinary visits and antibiotic supplements and do not have to deal with as many sick or replacement hens as they did when the hens were caged - which is currently reflected in the price and quality of the eggs you are getting.
For the record, over this year, soon after the retrofitting, the Hilliker farm eggs have been getting better - they seem tastier, the whites are less runny and the yolks are a bit larger, so they've become better to bake with, and the shells are sturdier; there's less breakage found at the store. Two eggs instead of three are now enough for a moist cake like devil's food or red velvet, and instead of using four eggs to make cheesy scrambled eggs for a four-person family breakfast, I only use three and there's still enough for everyone - because they cook up fluffier and denser. I'm using fewer eggs this year to make the same things I made last year.
Actually, I'm spending less. A 6 x 6 flat of large cream to brown eggs from Hilliker's has only gone up about a dollar at the bodega - $6.99 up from $5.99, but I need about 1/3 fewer for what I'm doing and don't need to purchase the flats anymore.
I'm now getting by with two, sometimes two and a half of the standard 12-cartons a month, and I'm only spending around on average $4.75 to $5.60 on the eggs I use every month rather than the full $5.99 for a flat and perhaps another $2.00 for another 12-carton to make it through that last week-end.
Now, Hilliker's eggs are about $1.00 - $1.50 more at the chain supermarkets (i.e., Vons or Ralphs) than at the IGAs... and that's a corporate mark-up (because they can) issue, not a Prop-2 issue.
Vons and Ralphs are actually getting the eggs cheaper than my local IGA because they're getting volume discounts, but they're charging more... go figure.
Anyway, that's what cage free hens gets you. It's not Portlandia BS.
Haele
DEMTough
(90 posts)Also, this reform was necessary. A little price bump that was taken advantage of by supermarkets.
Sorry,
- A Californian who will not fuck off, and will keep his state right here in the Union.
Recursion
(56,582 posts)Most of the cost of food is getting it from where it's grown to you.