General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIs Governor Andrew Cuomo a "fascist"? I mean in the literal,
political sense of the word.
Interesting ruminations here from one of NYC's most intelligent edu-bloggers.
>>>>>As one who believes in the primacy of language, I try my best to use words as responsibly and precisely as I can. With that in mind, as a person of the Left, few things have annoyed me more than the promiscuous use of the word fascism by a certain kind of would-be -Leftist who uses the word not as a description of identifiable political policies, but as a verbal bludgeon to bash in the skull of anyone with whom they disagree. Like all words and more so, fascism is a word to be used judiciously.
That said, anyone with knowledge of political systems who has perused Andrew Cuomos proposals on education, and especially his proposals on teacher evaluations for the state of New York, would have to conclude that Cuomo has stepped out of the bounds of known democratic policy and into the realm of fascism. Well into the realm of fascism.
The ideology of fascism has certain very identifiable characteristics, none more so than the consistent invocation of the primacy of the state over both the local and the individual. Bearing that in mind, consider Andrew Cuomos proposal for statewide teacher evaluation.
50 % of the evaluation will come from student test scores.
35% will come from an observation from an independent evaluator hired by the state.
15% will come from the principal of the school in which the teacher works.
I do not wish to discuss here the research that completely discredits the idea of standardized tests scores as anything approaching a fair and adequate criteria for evaluating a teachers ability to teach. Nor do I wish to discuss the enormous sums of taxpayer money that will be needed for the state to hire an independent evaluator to evaluate the hundreds of thousands of teachers in New York state.
What I wish to do here is merely point out the immense amount of professional autonomy Andrew Cuomo is attempting to usurp in one fell swoop from all principals in all communities in all of New York state, and that such massive and contemptuous usurpation of authority has no place in any meaningful democratic policies or traditions.
It does, however, fit perfectly into the fascist belief of the primacy of the state over all things and all people.
It is a profound indictment of the naked degeneracy of our contemporary political climate that such policies have been posed not by some nut job fringe candidate of a white supremacy group like David Duke but from the sitting Democratic governor of New York in his state of the state address, an>>>>>
https://raginghorse.wordpress.com/2015/01/31/andrew-cuomos-idea-of-democracy-is-fascism/
DemocratSinceBirth
(99,716 posts)HappyMe
(20,277 posts)fredamae
(4,458 posts)as "The merger of State and Corporations".
I suppose it's a matter of perspective......but if action and consequence fit the definition we can no longer say: "It'll Never happen in America" as it happens right before our eyes, imo
Donald Ian Rankin
(13,598 posts)DeadLetterOffice
(1,352 posts)Fascist? Probably not.