Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Ichingcarpenter

(36,988 posts)
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 12:01 PM Feb 2015

Brian Williams Misleads Viewers in His Apology for Misleading Viewers

News anchor Brian Williams delivered a 60-second apology to his viewers Wednesday night for "mis-remembering" an incident during his reporting on the Iraq War twelve years ago. However, he misled his viewers while apologizing for misleading them.

While explaining that he was not in a military helicopter that had to land after coming under fire as he had been claiming, Williams said:

"I want to apologize. I said I was traveling in an aircraft that was hit by RPG [rocket-propelled grenade] fire. I was instead in a following aircraft."

While it is technically true that Williams was in "a following aircraft," he neglected to explain that he was in an aircraft that followed the one hit by RPG fire by an entire hour. The way Williams phrased it, "I was instead in a following aircraft," makes it sound like he was right behind the copter in question.

According to the military's Stars and Stripes, the organization that exclusively broke the story on Williams' tall tale (emphasis added):

The admission came after crew members on the 159th Aviation Regiment’s Chinook that was hit by two rockets and small arms fire told Stars and Stripes that the NBC anchor was nowhere near that aircraft or two other Chinooks flying in the formation that took fire. Williams arrived in the area about an hour later on another helicopter after the other three had made an emergency landing, the crew members said.

Williams even repeated the "following aircraft" fabrication in greater detail on his Facebook page while apologizing to the troops:

I was indeed on the Chinook behind the bird that took the RPG in the tail housing just above the ramp.

Williams also claimed in his apology, "We all landed after the ground-fire incident and spent two harrowing nights in a sandstorm in the Iraqi desert." But military reporter Steve Liewer, who worked for Stars and Stripes at the time and reported on the incident, writes that crew members Lance Reynolds and pilot Chris Simeone "said they don’t remember seeing Williams again" after his crew took photographs of the wounded chopper.


Williams may have survived this fabrication if he had genuinely come clean in his public apology, but with the revelation of this additional embellishment, NBC News may very well have to make a move.




http://www.truthrevolt.org/news/brian-williams-misleads-viewers-his-apology-misleading-viewers

20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Brian Williams Misleads Viewers in His Apology for Misleading Viewers (Original Post) Ichingcarpenter Feb 2015 OP
While I get trying to CYA and spin the bad to not sounding so bad... (while making it worse) salin Feb 2015 #1
Viewers give more weight to journalists who've come ''under fire.'' Octafish Feb 2015 #3
Why make the claim? former9thward Feb 2015 #13
So why the challenge to the claim now? salin Feb 2015 #16
Following by a large amount of space and time. Octafish Feb 2015 #2
His apology Ichingcarpenter Feb 2015 #4
I followed George Washington on a hiking trail near here Orrex Feb 2015 #6
I followed Julius Caesar and the 13th Legion across the Rubicon.* xocet Feb 2015 #15
I've known Lyin Brian since Katrina. GeorgeGist Feb 2015 #5
All part of the military-media complex. Fred Sanders Feb 2015 #7
You won't misremember this sort of thing jollyreaper2112 Feb 2015 #8
His whole job, his life's dedication is to telling real stories with accuracy. Reporting. What a Ed Suspicious Feb 2015 #9
"I totally lied. I'm sorry." Dreamer Tatum Feb 2015 #10
Except it would not be a case closed. former9thward Feb 2015 #11
Well, he'll have to live with this on his conscience forever, basically. closeupready Feb 2015 #12
Or maybe not. The pilot of the chopper Wiliams was in has offered a different version of events onenote Feb 2015 #14
Yeah, that's the ticket!! deaniac21 Feb 2015 #18
Anybody who was deliberately lying had to know moondust Feb 2015 #17
Ugh Saucepan of Kerbango Feb 2015 #19
The sooner Rush's fanboy is gone from NBC, the sooner I can watch NBC again. Zavulon Feb 2015 #20

salin

(48,955 posts)
1. While I get trying to CYA and spin the bad to not sounding so bad... (while making it worse)
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 12:05 PM
Feb 2015

I don't get the point of making the claim in the first place.

Clearly a member of the we make up the news rather than report form of fake journalism.

To think that once upon a time, I respected this guy.

Octafish

(55,745 posts)
3. Viewers give more weight to journalists who've come ''under fire.''
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 12:08 PM
Feb 2015


Ask Gunga Dan, if only we could.

former9thward

(32,020 posts)
13. Why make the claim?
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 02:40 PM
Feb 2015

Last edited Thu Feb 5, 2015, 03:18 PM - Edit history (1)

To get some 'war cred'. And he got away with it for 12 years. Remember, not only did Williams lie but his news crew that was with him lied by covering it up for 12 years. They knew the truth and they probably told others who then knew the truth.

salin

(48,955 posts)
16. So why the challenge to the claim now?
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 03:12 PM
Feb 2015

one of those someone told someone who told someone.... finally reach someone who could check records and pass it on to the Stars and Stripes?

What a jerk. He didn't need war cred. He needed to be credibly getting stories and interviewing people who were 'on the ground'.

He deserves the mocking he's taking. He owes far more than an apology.

Ichingcarpenter

(36,988 posts)
4. His apology
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 12:10 PM
Feb 2015

His apology was carefully crafted by a bevy of experts attempting damage control in such a way that it will be accepted by those who want to accept it.
In other words, it is complete, fabricated bullshit

xocet

(3,871 posts)
15. I followed Julius Caesar and the 13th Legion across the Rubicon.*
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 03:07 PM
Feb 2015
*Just don't ask me about the interval.


Brian Williams' apology leaves out key details of Iraq incident
News anchor's apology met with cynicism from servicemembers who were there

By Travis J. Tritten
Stars and Stripes
Published: February 5, 2015

WASHINGTON — Apologies by NBC Nightly News anchor Brian Williams Wednesday for his false claim of being on a helicopter forced down by Iraqi rocket fire in 2003 left out key details and made misleading claims about his proximity to the incident, according to soldiers who were there at the time.

Williams admitted on air that he was not on the Chinook that was struck by enemy fire, saying he was “instead on a following aircraft” and writing a Facebook apology to soldiers saying “I was indeed on the Chinook behind the bird that took the RPG.” But Army flight crews told Stars and Stripes the NBC anchor was actually flying with a different helicopter company altogether — in a different direction, and linked to the attacked unit by radio only.

The wording appeared to be another example of the anchor muddling the facts or providing misleading details of the incident that he covered in the opening days of the Iraq invasion. Since the 2003 incident, he has written that he “came under fire” and implied that his Chinook was forced down due to an attack, while soldiers said it was landed amid deteriorating weather conditions during a sandstorm.

“I think it is misleading” for Williams to say his aircraft was following behind the Chinook hit by two rocket-propelled grenades and small arms fire, said David Luke, a retired soldier from Texas who was a flight engineer with a company of the helicopters under the 159th Aviation Regiment, which was known as Hercules and based out of Savannah, Ga.

...

http://www.stripes.com/news/us/brian-williams-apology-leaves-out-key-details-of-iraq-incident-1.327935


Williams' claim and apology seem to have the same truth value as Hillary Clinton's claim that she took sniper fire in Bosnia:


Hillary Clinton calls Bosnia sniper story a mistake
By Jeff Mason
GREENSBURG, Pennsylvania Tue Mar 25, 2008 8:01pm EDT


(Reuters) - Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton said on Tuesday she made a mistake when she claimed she had come under sniper fire during a trip to Bosnia in 1996 while she was first lady.

In a speech in Washington and in several interviews last week Clinton described how she and her daughter, Chelsea, ran for cover under hostile fire shortly after her plane landed in Tuzla, Bosnia.

Several news outlets disputed the claim and a video of the trip, showed Clinton walking from the plane, accompanied by her daughter. They were greeted by a young girl in a small ceremony on the tarmac and there was no sign of tension or any danger.

"I did make a mistake in talking about it, you know, the last time and recently," Clinton told reporters in Pennsylvania where she was campaigning before the state's April 22 primary. She said she had a "different memory" about the landing.

...

http://www.reuters.com/article/2008/03/26/us-usa-politics-clinton-idUSN2540811420080326

jollyreaper2112

(1,941 posts)
8. You won't misremember this sort of thing
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 01:01 PM
Feb 2015

Hillary lied about being under fire landing in Kosovo. You don't get this shit wrong by accident, it's on purpose. Thing is, it's not like saying you took sniper fire at the latrine with no one around. You're on an aircraft with crew. They take fire with a big-name VIP, they'll remember! And if nothing like that ever happened, they'll remember that, too. WTF? Seriously.

Ed Suspicious

(8,879 posts)
9. His whole job, his life's dedication is to telling real stories with accuracy. Reporting. What a
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 02:17 PM
Feb 2015

colossal fuck up.

 

closeupready

(29,503 posts)
12. Well, he'll have to live with this on his conscience forever, basically.
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 02:38 PM
Feb 2015

If there were such a thing as journalistic malpractice, this would qualify, in my personal opinion. Oh well.

onenote

(42,714 posts)
14. Or maybe not. The pilot of the chopper Wiliams was in has offered a different version of events
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 02:51 PM
Feb 2015

One that actually supports some aspects of Williams' version. In particular, the pilot of the chopper in which Williams was riding has explained that the chopper that was hit by RPG and the chopper that Williams was in (along with a third chopper) were flying in formation when the RPG and small arms fire began. When the lead chopper was hit, the other choppers (according to the pilot) took evasive action, completed its task (dropping off materials) and then re-united with the other choppers on the ground 45 minutes later.

If true, then Williams' statement about being in a following aircraft that was under fire (albeit not the one hit by the RPG) would be accurate. His other characterizations of the event -- including all four choppers landing quickly -- are not supported by the version of the pilot of his chopper.

I'm sure we will hear from others who were part of that mission before this is over. And I won't be surprised if there are more versions.

http://money.cnn.com/2015/02/05/media/brian-williams-iraq/index.html

moondust

(19,992 posts)
17. Anybody who was deliberately lying had to know
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 03:17 PM
Feb 2015

that eventually the truth would surface on the Internet or other media. In a serious situation like that you simply can't expect all the witnesses to keep lying for you. Why would they? I think Williams is smart enough to know better. But I don't know how or why the story got twisted. Maybe some semantic confusion over "we" (as in "our group&quot came under fire or chaos of battle or something?

Weird.

 
19. Ugh
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 03:26 PM
Feb 2015

Completely lost respect for Williams. What pisses me off worse is that the crew of that helo has been listening to him brag and had to choke on it. I'm glad they finally dropped a dime on him.

 

Zavulon

(5,639 posts)
20. The sooner Rush's fanboy is gone from NBC, the sooner I can watch NBC again.
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 04:28 PM
Feb 2015

The lie was bad enough, but his "apology" and excuses were a fucking insult. Dan Rather lost his job for a lot less.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Brian Williams Misleads V...