Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Dreamer Tatum

(10,926 posts)
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 01:38 PM Feb 2015

Honest, serious question here re: ISIS and their tactics.

Suppose you're chased onto a mountain with your children, with no sun protection, food, or water, and a horde of murderous ideological thugs is bent on killing you and your kind, even if you accede to their conditions and demands.

Or, if that's not to your liking, suppose you've entered a war zone to use your kindness and expertise to help tend to refugees, and you get kidnapped and shoved into an orange jumpsuit. You know what comes next.

As the camera rolls and as you're reading from the script you've been handed, and as you observe a hooded person brandish a knife that will soon sever your head, how likely are you to think the following:

"You know, I'd sort of like to be saved. But then again, something roughly analogous happened 1000 years ago to some other people when the geopolitical roles were roughly opposite. Kind of makes you think that I have this coming to me, huh? And it wasn't me who put panties on an Iraqi prisoner's head and took pictures of it, but gee, it sort of feels like in this instance, not only do two wrongs make a right, but I should be made to pay for every supposed crime of Western civilization. I guess instead of valuing my own life and the lives of other innocents, I ought to be kneeling here thinking of exactly how many more of us should be beheaded or incinerated. Because when you get right down to it, we have this coming".


Not bloody likely, but that's just me.

8 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Honest, serious question here re: ISIS and their tactics. (Original Post) Dreamer Tatum Feb 2015 OP
The Creek Indians in the southern U.S. practiced blood revenge. cheapdate Feb 2015 #1
It is possible RedCappedBandit Feb 2015 #2
"Honest question" usually means "rhetorical question with built in assumptions". CJCRANE Feb 2015 #3
But just claiming it is honest makes it so. Fred Sanders Feb 2015 #4
It's honest because I would genuinely like to know how much world history you'd consider Dreamer Tatum Feb 2015 #5
This message was self-deleted by its author CJCRANE Feb 2015 #6
Fair enough. CJCRANE Feb 2015 #7
Thank you eissa Feb 2015 #8

cheapdate

(3,811 posts)
1. The Creek Indians in the southern U.S. practiced blood revenge.
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 01:55 PM
Feb 2015

If someone caused death or injury to a member of the clan, the clan had an obligation to take equal revenge on the clan that caused the injury, even if the revenge was against someone other than the person who caused the injury.

To the Creeks, it was deeper than simple revenge. It went to thier religious beliefs about maintaining balance in the world. There was an annual ceremony in which outstanding revenge debts were cancelled.

This practice was a major (but by no means the only) cause of tension between Creeks and whites. The whites practiced "blood revenge" in their own way, but it had none of the "balance" of the Creek's practice.

Practices like "blood revenge" still exist. I'm not saying they're good, but they still exist.

RedCappedBandit

(5,514 posts)
2. It is possible
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 02:07 PM
Feb 2015

to acknowledge and consider the historical roots of contemporary issues without justifying recent atrocities, you know.

CJCRANE

(18,184 posts)
3. "Honest question" usually means "rhetorical question with built in assumptions".
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 02:12 PM
Feb 2015

Posted on DU it often feels like it's coming from a RW point of view.

Posted on FR, it would probably feel like it's coming from a LW point of view.

It always imples that the poster thinks they are going against the grain.

Dreamer Tatum

(10,926 posts)
5. It's honest because I would genuinely like to know how much world history you'd consider
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 02:17 PM
Feb 2015

before they cut your fucking head off.

I sincerely hope your head, my head, and all of our heads remain intact forever. How we obtain that seems to be in dispute.

Response to Dreamer Tatum (Reply #5)

CJCRANE

(18,184 posts)
7. Fair enough.
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 02:31 PM
Feb 2015

I agree there are a lot of people making excuses for ISIS. IMO they have no redeeming features. They are just brainwashed nutters.

eissa

(4,238 posts)
8. Thank you
Thu Feb 5, 2015, 03:48 PM
Feb 2015

I find the false equivalencies nauseating. There are communities in that region that are right now being terrorized and brutally murdered, women and children held as sex slaves, and for them to hear "but, but....the Crusades!" helps exactly no one.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Honest, serious question ...