Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

1StrongBlackMan

(31,849 posts)
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 10:52 AM Feb 2015

Lawrence O'Donnell just did the best example of intellectual dishonesty ...

I've seen in a long time. He was on Steve Kornacki, condemning President Obama's recent "before we make this about Islam the religion, let's remember, Christians did some pretty horrific stuff in the name of religion, too" comment.

Lawrence's argument was that it was inappropriate for President Obama to include lynching and the slave trade in this context because those committing those acts weren't doing it in the name of Christianity, unlikely ISIS. So we can absolutely point out the "connectivity."

The Black guy destroyed O'Donnell's ahistorical point, and named a number of right wing nuts making the same point as O'Donnell.

Then, O'Donnell did the thing ... even, angrily .... (In sum) "Yeah, I know those nuts are making the same argument I am making; but those nuts are nuts!"

20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Lawrence O'Donnell just did the best example of intellectual dishonesty ... (Original Post) 1StrongBlackMan Feb 2015 OP
Heavens.. the entire history of the KKK was created around a self-proclaimed "Christian" identity hlthe2b Feb 2015 #1
Inappropriate of Obama?..not inappropriate at all. O'Donnells disconnect is telling. n/t Jefferson23 Feb 2015 #2
Does every major media anchorperson in America suffer from white privilege? How uneducated are they? Fred Sanders Feb 2015 #3
What the hell? HappyMe Feb 2015 #4
White privilege. So it is not his fault, and he is also a deeply religious Catholic. Fred Sanders Feb 2015 #5
there's a good argument to be made that ISIS is merely cloaking their acts in religion bigtree Feb 2015 #6
Could be, but it was still done under an umbrella of Christianity . . . brush Feb 2015 #8
gotta say, tho bigtree Feb 2015 #13
That is the point ... 1StrongBlackMan Feb 2015 #19
. bigtree Feb 2015 #20
I tend to agree..Is ISIS truly a group of Islamists? elias49 Feb 2015 #14
I think they do have a core group of 'leaders' bigtree Feb 2015 #18
Yeah, I just replayed his segment and O'Donnell was way off the mark procon Feb 2015 #7
That's disppointing to hear brush Feb 2015 #9
No shit, he's off the mark. Jackpine Radical Feb 2015 #10
This is not an area O'Donnell is comfortable discussing. He'd dislike my examples even more than Bluenorthwest Feb 2015 #11
Wow! They never taught me this in Catholic School. n/t mikehiggins Feb 2015 #12
Of course not. The last one served actually until 1865 and his name was Giovanni Battista Bugatti Bluenorthwest Feb 2015 #17
I totally agree with O'Donnell. People of color were slaughtered, hung and murdered not Ninga Feb 2015 #15
that wouldn't be the first time from him Enrique Feb 2015 #16

hlthe2b

(102,331 posts)
1. Heavens.. the entire history of the KKK was created around a self-proclaimed "Christian" identity
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 10:54 AM
Feb 2015

and the bible was used to justify their bigotry. How quickly some forget.

Fred Sanders

(23,946 posts)
3. Does every major media anchorperson in America suffer from white privilege? How uneducated are they?
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 10:59 AM
Feb 2015

My bet is probably not, but they sure are fucking lazy, because if they actually took the time to listen and absorb what Obama said at the National Prayer Brunch they would know he said the exact same thing in India in an hours long interview with CNN that covered in detail every topical issue of our times.

When no one in the same mass media seemed even aware he was in India, too busy riding around in Blizzardmobiles.

Uneducated, lazy and saddled with the burden of white privilege, it is not just the RW media.

America is being trolled by it's mass media.

Fred Sanders

(23,946 posts)
5. White privilege. So it is not his fault, and he is also a deeply religious Catholic.
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:05 AM
Feb 2015

Being reminded of the brutality and institutional misogyny of his chosen sect of Christianity and its terrorist history under the thumb of psychopathic leaders must be very troubling.

Crusaders were terrorists, hard to wrap ones mind around that, but it is true.

bigtree

(86,005 posts)
6. there's a good argument to be made that ISIS is merely cloaking their acts in religion
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:12 AM
Feb 2015

...not really acting out of a sincere religious belief, but merely exploiting the religion to gain followers; more of a megalomania than a crusade.

That's pretty much how I view the cross-burning racism practiced by the Klan and others. There's really nothing directly associated with religious belief among southern Baptists which dictated the hatred. It was (is?) mostly an opportunistic linkage used by the KKK to lend a social respectability among their peers to their bigotry and race-based violence.

brush

(53,815 posts)
8. Could be, but it was still done under an umbrella of Christianity . . .
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:26 AM
Feb 2015

they burned crosses to terrorize people.

The cross is THE symbol of Christianity.

Sincere or not, religion has been used throughout history to justify violence.

It's no difference whether it be the klan or ISIS.

bigtree

(86,005 posts)
13. gotta say, tho
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:45 AM
Feb 2015

...just as it's not right or correct to conflate all of Islam or Muslim theology with terrorism; the same dissonancy should apply to Christianity (mostly southern Baptist, in this case) and the Klan.

I can't regard burning a cross as particularly 'Christian', although Klan members may well have believed their god approved. I see it as a mostly cynical, opportunistic appropriation, though, not one that was inextricably linked with any church doctrine on racism; unlike Mormon theology which drew analogous references from the bible to claim superiority of whites over blacks.

 

1StrongBlackMan

(31,849 posts)
19. That is the point ...
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 02:00 PM
Feb 2015

President Obama was making. The problem seems to be westerners seem to be applying this view to to the acts of outlier Christians, while denying outlier status to those of the Islamic faith committing the atrocities.

 

elias49

(4,259 posts)
14. I tend to agree..Is ISIS truly a group of Islamists?
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:48 AM
Feb 2015

or are they just f***** psychopaths?
But something else is happening. How do you keep 30,000 savages from self destructing?
I'm not aware, either, of there being any particular "leader". Who or what unites them?

bigtree

(86,005 posts)
18. I think they do have a core group of 'leaders'
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 12:07 PM
Feb 2015

...but, like al-Qaeda, their membership is attracted and enhanced by the prospect of a head-to-head fight with Americans, represented by the U.S. military forces. I'd have to admit there is at least an exploited belief driving the followers. Iraq is the holy caliphate; the land where they fight Americans for their delusions of blessed victory over the infidels. Still, it's a perversion of Islam which is being promoted, exploited by their leadership to cull a following.

procon

(15,805 posts)
7. Yeah, I just replayed his segment and O'Donnell was way off the mark
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:25 AM
Feb 2015

He was trying to rewrite history by saying the Jim Crow era was only about racism and Christianity was not a player because only blacks were killed. He totally ignored how the KKK and others used the cover of religion as a justifiable excuse for their crimes.

Then he goes on to say that its all about the numbers, "the scale", since the armies under ISIS are bigger than the membership of the KKK, they are the baddest of the bad based on the headcount.

My eyes are still spinning...







brush

(53,815 posts)
9. That's disppointing to hear
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:30 AM
Feb 2015

O'Donnell seemed to be very enlightened about these issues.

I even donated to his campaign to furnished school desks for young African students, and he was (don't know if the still is) in a relationship with POC woman.

Maybe his Christianity is clouding his judgment on this.

Jackpine Radical

(45,274 posts)
10. No shit, he's off the mark.
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:35 AM
Feb 2015

ISIS has, according to Fox's wildest estimate, 35,000 fighters (or whatever the Hell they are), while the Klan has had as many as 8 million members.

Hey Larry, which is the bigger number--35,000 or 8,000,000?

 

Bluenorthwest

(45,319 posts)
11. This is not an area O'Donnell is comfortable discussing. He'd dislike my examples even more than
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:35 AM
Feb 2015

Obama's. The Papal Executioner, for example, an office that existed until 1862 and lopped the heads off of people found guilty of civil crimes in the theocratic Papal States. The final holder of that office chopped off 516 heads each on the order of the Pope. This practice ceased only when the Italian Republic seized control of those territories. 516 heads cut off by the command of the Vicar of Christ.
This information often upsets those who still dig the Popes, so I usually point out that at that same time, the US was just dismantling the Slave Nation and an economy based on brutality and force.
It is pretty easy to draw equations between both the Papal States and Slave Era US and that which is done by Isis. Too easy to be of comfort to anyone who has not very seriously confronted the factual history of this country, of the RCC, of the UK, of France, Belgium....Leopold the Second anyone?

 

Bluenorthwest

(45,319 posts)
17. Of course not. The last one served actually until 1865 and his name was Giovanni Battista Bugatti
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 12:00 PM
Feb 2015

He kept excellent records. Charles Dickens described one execution by him in his 'Pictures From Italy' in 1864.
Before 1816, they used the axe and noose but also some burning alive. The invention of the guillotine was a boon, but they also did drawing and quartering and a method which involved crushing the head with a mallet then slitting the throat.
Back in the 1500's, Pope Sixtus V lined the bridges with the heads of pickpockets, it was said to be more heads than there were melons in the market.....

Ninga

(8,276 posts)
15. I totally agree with O'Donnell. People of color were slaughtered, hung and murdered not
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:56 AM
Feb 2015

because of their religious beliefs....but because of the color of their skin.

The perps hid behind their religious beliefs, used them to justify.

Enrique

(27,461 posts)
16. that wouldn't be the first time from him
Sat Feb 7, 2015, 11:59 AM
Feb 2015

but how did the black guy destroy O'Donnell's point? I'm asking this as someone who is glad Obama said what he said. I think he's right and it took courage for him to say it, but it is definitely something worth debating.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Lawrence O'Donnell just d...