Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
Sat Feb 21, 2015, 10:08 PM Feb 2015

Yes, Obama is different

Rudy Giuliani’s assertion that President Barack Obama doesn’t love his country is absurd on its face, but it’s true that Obama’s view is more nuanced than those of his predecessors.

Sharelines

Obama loves his country, but he's also willing to point out its flaws.

snip

There's no need to litigate this charge; outside of campy political thrillers, no one devotes his or her adult life to national politics — or the presidency, for that matter — without an outsized patriotism and belief in the basic worth of the United States. But if we're feeling generous, we can say that in the course of his rant, Giuliani touched on a real difference between Obama's brand of national exceptionalism and the kind we tend to see from America's presidents.

snip

The obvious question is, why? Why is Obama more circumspect than his presidential peers? Why does his praise come with a note of reservation?

The best answer, I think, lies in identity. By choice as much as birth, Obama is a black American. And black Americans, more than most, have a complicated relationship with our country. It's our home as much as it's been our oppressor: a place of freedom and opportunity as much as a source of violence and degradation. We're an old American tribe, with deep roots in the land and a strong hand in the labor of the nation. But we're often seen as other — a suspect class that just doesn't fit.

As a president from black America, Obama carries this with him, and it comes through in his sometimes less-than-effusive vision of national greatness. He loves this country, but he also tempers his view with a nod toward the uglier parts of our history.


http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/opinion/commentary/ct-giuliani-obama-patriotism-perspec-0223-20150220-story.html

15 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

elleng

(130,974 posts)
1. ANYONE 'willing to point out its flaws' will encounter their wrath,
Sat Feb 21, 2015, 10:14 PM
Feb 2015

they CANNOT accept truth/facts, and they're training the electorate to take that position too.

guillaumeb

(42,641 posts)
2. some thoughts on this
Sat Feb 21, 2015, 10:20 PM
Feb 2015

you write:
The best answer, I think, lies in identity. By choice as much as birth, Obama is a black American. And black Americans, more than most, have a complicated relationship with our country. It's our home as much as it's been our oppressor: a place of freedom and opportunity as much as a source of violence and degradation. We're an old American tribe, with deep roots in the land and a strong hand in the labor of the nation. But we're often seen as other — a suspect class that just doesn't fit.

African slaves were brought to this country almost as soon as there were European colonists here. 400 years of roots in this country and a President who was born in Hawaii is considered not really American. How can that be? How can they be seen as "other" when they have been here longer than most Americans?

Does some of it lie in the fact that Africans did not immigrate but were enslaved?

Does some of it lie in the fact that the English who stole this land intended it to be their own white theocracy and the African slaves tainted the whole thing. I use the word taint deliberately, as I know about the "one drop" theory of race mixing.

Does the intent of establishing a white theocracy explain the genocide that the English committed against the First Peoples?


As to the last paragraph, it seems to me that many Americans are not much for self-awareness.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
8. I don't know the answer to that, guillaumeb.
Sat Feb 21, 2015, 11:31 PM
Feb 2015

I don't understand all the hate and probably never will. Is it that whites feel superior? Yes obviously they do. It is the "why" that I can't answer.

It's about race and who is superior, Hitler showed us that when he did his best to annihilate the Jews. Americans did that with Native Americans, when they slaughtered them and stole their land. I have a small amount of American Indian in me, Mohawk to be exact. You would never know it from looking at me, I am watered down, yet my grandfather and dad, it was there.

As for African Americans it's the same, they were deemed less than people because of there color.

Someone from the AA group could answer it far better than I can.

Cha

(297,323 posts)
3. LOVE President Obama's "difference".. good article
Sat Feb 21, 2015, 10:23 PM
Feb 2015

so far.. it won't let me read the link without registering, though.

Mahalo she

However the Rude Pundit gave us examples the day of Obama actually calling out his love for America..

***********************************************************************************
"Want some examples?

Barack Obama, February 18, 2015: &quot M)ay we all do our part to carry forward the work of perfecting this country that we love."

Barack Obama, February 5, 2015: "May the Lord bless you and keep you, and may He bless this precious country that we love."

Barack Obama, January 28, 2015: "Thank you. God bless you. God bless this country we love."

Wanna keep going? Google is a bountiful bastard...

Barack Obama, September 11, 2013: (We pray for) "our men and women in uniform who defend this country that we love."

Barack Obama, September 11, 2010: "This is how we will preserve and protect the country that we love."

Really, this is just one phrase, not even variations. We could go back further:

Barack Obama, June 3, 2008: (This is) "our time to offer a new direction for this country that we love."

Need it more personal?

Barack Obama, March 18, 2008: &quot T)hey are a part of America, this country that I love."

If President Obama said he loved this country any more, we'd tell him he was smothering us.

meegbear http://www.democraticunderground.com/10026251978

 

glowing

(12,233 posts)
4. If you can't be willing to see the flaws, then how
Sat Feb 21, 2015, 10:37 PM
Feb 2015

Do you go about addressing and trying to fix those problems?

BTW, don't tell me that Republicans aren't whijing every day how much they can't stand the President of this country or Democrats or any "other" they've been told to fear and hate? Aren't they saying their is a flaw with America? If they don't acknow the Presidents 2 election wins by very large margins, aren't they denying the system of democracy?

They are the Kings and Queens of projection!

Thinkingabout

(30,058 posts)
5. I have never heard him indicate he does not love Americn, RW points out he apologized
Sat Feb 21, 2015, 10:40 PM
Feb 2015

To other nations, why, because W has messed up the relationships we had for a long time and still to this day he wants to say he would do anything differently. Obama has taken the weight of a nation on his shoulders, Giuliani only had the weight of NYC. If Obama's agenda been allowed to proceed then we could have seen more evidence of his love for this country.

Journeyman

(15,036 posts)
7. Abraham Lincoln remains the only President to have told the nation that it had sinned. . .
Sat Feb 21, 2015, 11:16 PM
Feb 2015

and that the war they were engaged in was God's punishment -- to both North and South -- for the offense in which they shared culpability, an offense so vile it required the destruction of all the wealth earned through it, and further, that every drop of blood drawn with the lash be paid for by another drawn with the sword?

http://www.bartleby.com/124/pres32.html

KauaiK

(544 posts)
9. If you understand Hawaii, you understand Obama...
Sun Feb 22, 2015, 12:08 AM
Feb 2015

He is very much a product of Hawaii in his temperament, outlook, and manner. I get it. I'm appalled at the GOP treatment of him from both houses of Congress and the racial hate spewed towards Obama.

pnwmom

(108,980 posts)
10. Republicans love their idea of the country, but scorn most of the actual PEOPLE in the country.
Sun Feb 22, 2015, 12:54 AM
Feb 2015

Obama and the Dems care about actual people. That's the difference.

napkinz

(17,199 posts)
15. and since I posted it, more hatred from the right ...
Sun Feb 22, 2015, 09:17 PM
Feb 2015
Bobby Jindal calls Rudy Guiliani to CONGRATULATE him on critical Obama comments, ex-New York Mayor tells CNN
http://theadvocate.com/news/11657082-123/bobby-jindal-called-rudy-guiliani

Scott Walker: 'I Don't Really Know' Whether Obama Loves America
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/02/21/scott-walker-obama-love-america_n_6726960.html

RichGirl

(4,119 posts)
14. Republicans love America....
Sun Feb 22, 2015, 08:11 PM
Feb 2015

But they don't love AMERICANS.

Of course they love America. A country where a simple congressman can become a millionaire thanks to lobbyist money and all he has to do is make laws that make the rich richer.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Yes, Obama is different