Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 02:20 AM Feb 2015

$7.4M settlement awarded Monday to former mayor of Excelsior Springs, MO for vaccine injury.

http://fox4kc.com/2015/02/24/excelsior-springs-woman-left-with-permanent-brain-injuries-after-vaccinations/

Excelsior Springs woman left with permanent brain injuries after vaccinations

POSTED 6:32 PM, FEBRUARY 24, 2015, BY MELISSA STERN, UPDATED AT 07:19PM, FEBRUARY 24, 2015


EXCELSIOR SPRINGS, Mo. — The federal government awarded an Excelsior Springs man $7.4 million after his wife was left disabled from getting vaccines before a trip. But this man says he’s still very much pro-vaccines.

Back in June of 2011, Carolyn Schutte came to the Clay County Public Health Center to get vaccinations before her trip to Africa. Two days later she had permanent brain damage.

“It`s lonely,” said Jim Schutte, Carolyn’s husband. “Carolyn was not just my wife, she was my best friend, she was the closest friend that I’ve ever had, and now she can`t even speak to me.”

In June, 2011, they were preparing for a trip to Africa, and needed a number of vaccinations for diseases like Hepatitis A, B, Typhoid, and Tetanus.

“We were avid travelers, we went all over the world,” he said. “She was running short on time, so she got all of her vaccines at once.”

Almost 48 hours after getting the vaccines, Carolyn lost consciousness, and collapsed. She suffered permanent brain damage caused by Encephalopathy.

“The world came crashing down on us,” said Schutte.

Carolyn, who was once Mayor of Excelsior Springs, now needs 24 hour a day care. Schutte says all they can do is hold hands and watch TV together.

<>

The settlement, which awarded the Schutte’s $7.4 million, comes from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and was reached Monday. Schutte says the money is to provide Carolyn with the appropriate care.

“The cost of taking care of someone who is bedridden is an enormous expense,” Schutte said.

Schutte’s attorney, Leland Dempsey, says the money comes from the National Vaccine Injury Compensation program, which was set up for cases for people injured by a vaccine.

<>

“What happened to Carolyn is a freak accident,” said Schutte, who has a background in medical research.

He is adamantly in favor of vaccinations, especially for children, despite what has happened to his wife.

<>
63 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
$7.4M settlement awarded Monday to former mayor of Excelsior Springs, MO for vaccine injury. (Original Post) proverbialwisdom Feb 2015 OP
one precaution for vaccinations too often overlooked hopemountain Feb 2015 #1
Dr Schutte's grandson is having his childhood vaccinations in spaced out doses. Anyone name-calling? proverbialwisdom Feb 2015 #2
If it was related to multiple vaccines at once, it isn't so much a "freak accident." pnwmom Feb 2015 #5
nothing wrong with having vaccines spaced apart. nt hopemountain Feb 2015 #3
I think that is often a good idea. The only reason children's vaccines are clumped together pnwmom Feb 2015 #4
A possible solution suggests itself KamaAina Feb 2015 #46
That isn't a bad idea. And in drugstores, where they have flu vaccines. pnwmom Feb 2015 #50
Most drug stores are in shopping centers KamaAina Feb 2015 #53
Think again: "Drive Thru Medicine, SIRVA, & the Vaccine Court" proverbialwisdom Mar 2015 #58
The disadvantage is that you are unprotected against certain diseases for longer. The advantage is LeftishBrit Feb 2015 #42
agreed - and your points are well taken. hopemountain Feb 2015 #44
The reaction this woman had may have been from too many vaccines at once KamaAina Feb 2015 #48
But the point you just mentioned is the key point. When there are multiple vaccines pnwmom Mar 2015 #62
Anti-vaxxers at DU should be treated the same as chemtrailers...nt SidDithers Feb 2015 #6
He is not an anti-vaxxer KamaAina Feb 2015 #20
No, but the OP is.... SidDithers Feb 2015 #22
I did not know that KamaAina Feb 2015 #23
IMO, out of context. Actually I'm unfamiliar with Sagan. Here, please judge for yourself. proverbialwisdom Feb 2015 #29
You really don't know who Carl Sagan is? xmas74 Feb 2015 #30
Hey, did I say that? I thought I said I'm unfamiliar with his work except superficially. proverbialwisdom Feb 2015 #32
You said you were unfamiliar with Sagan. xmas74 Feb 2015 #38
What a... KamaAina Feb 2015 #33
I still miss Sagan. xmas74 Feb 2015 #39
A copy of Cosmos was my prize at high school graduation. KamaAina Feb 2015 #40
Now that's a great present. xmas74 Feb 2015 #41
Yup... SidDithers Feb 2015 #34
Well now that Andrew Wakefield has been COMPLETELY discredited zappaman Feb 2015 #45
+1,000,000 ... 000 HuckleB Feb 2015 #51
You ask if anyone is name-calling? trumad Feb 2015 #7
BINGO! What schedule? Go global & define "don't vaccinate their children." What does that mean? proverbialwisdom Feb 2015 #9
Let me put ithe in simple words... trumad Feb 2015 #10
Consider that you might be living in a bubble (reliable info vacuum) & that it's UNSUSTAINABLE. proverbialwisdom Feb 2015 #16
blah blah blah... trumad Feb 2015 #18
are you a medical professional? hopemountain Feb 2015 #24
He played one on TV. 840high Feb 2015 #27
are you an anti-vaxxer? trumad Feb 2015 #28
wrong. hopemountain Feb 2015 #35
I'm not but my aunt is xmas74 Feb 2015 #31
what do you do for a living again? snooper2 Feb 2015 #36
Message auto-removed Name removed Feb 2015 #37
When they say "accident" do they know what caused this? Hassin Bin Sober Feb 2015 #8
It's very rare, but some people can have severe reactions. Avalux Feb 2015 #11
Having travelled to manyundesirable location Telcontar Feb 2015 #14
It is possible to have a vaccine stored under improper conditions, pnwmom Mar 2015 #63
It's a very small risk, but for those who "hit the bad luck jackpot" it is small comfort. Liberal Veteran Feb 2015 #12
Not a bit but it doesn't mean we must insist no one is allergic to penicillin TheKentuckian Feb 2015 #13
Well, we don't. That is why there is a vaccine injury compensation program. Liberal Veteran Feb 2015 #15
I said nothing about going to the drawing board at all but blowing off people's lives, setting up TheKentuckian Feb 2015 #21
I agree. Balance is everything. That is why I usually try to look at the overall picture. Liberal Veteran Feb 2015 #25
Jackpot for him, not so much for his wife. n/t dilby Feb 2015 #17
That's why I called it the "bad luck jackpot". It wasn't referring to the compensation. Liberal Veteran Feb 2015 #19
Andrew Wakefield is still a crank. NuclearDem Feb 2015 #26
Very sad. I wonder if one of the vaccines that she needed for travel was the yellow fever vaccine? LeftishBrit Feb 2015 #43
Do you still think Andrew Wakefield is the next Carl Sagan? zappaman Feb 2015 #47
Do you still think you can ignore the science with one-liners & reframe the issue as ALL OR NOTHING? proverbialwisdom Feb 2015 #49
The vaccine schedule is safe, and this doesn't change that. HuckleB Feb 2015 #52
A multigenerational report of adverse reactions here (link from Twitter). proverbialwisdom Mar 2015 #54
And more of the usual anti-vaccine conspiracy BS. HuckleB Mar 2015 #55
Show some decency, that's absolutely ludicrous. The source is the Charlotte Observer: READ IT. (nt) proverbialwisdom Mar 2015 #56
You never show anyone decency. HuckleB Mar 2015 #57
Anyone who reads can see you're wrong, IMO. (nt) proverbialwisdom Mar 2015 #59
Whoa, huge controversy about recent reporting in Canada's largest daily newspaper, The Toronto Star. proverbialwisdom Mar 2015 #60
Just looking for recent Menendez/autism news on Google and this popped up. Was it reported anywhere? proverbialwisdom Mar 2015 #61

hopemountain

(3,919 posts)
1. one precaution for vaccinations too often overlooked
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 03:09 AM
Feb 2015

and not stressed enough - is the recipient has to be in good health and not have a fever - not even a low grade fever in recent days and not be suffering from herpes simplex virus at the time.

proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
2. Dr Schutte's grandson is having his childhood vaccinations in spaced out doses. Anyone name-calling?
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 03:09 AM
Feb 2015

Last edited Wed Feb 25, 2015, 04:03 AM - Edit history (1)

http://www.kctv5.com/story/28183081/feds-give-family-74-million-over-disabling-vaccines

Feds give family $7.4 million over disabling vaccines

Posted: Feb 23, 2015 11:47 PM PST Updated: Feb 24, 2015 4:30 PM PST
By Betsy Webster, News ReporterCONNECT
By DeAnn Smith, Digital Content Manager


...Despite all the difficulties, Jim Schutte remains a passionate advocate for vaccinations.

"What happened to Carolyn is a rarity," said Schutte. "It's a freak of nature. It happens occasionally. But the chances of it happening to you are minimal compared to the risks of actually contracting the diseases you are being vaccinated against."

He's not just talking Internet research. He has a Ph.D. in human growth development and had done post-doctoral work in biomedical research.

One of his fears is that his wife's rare reaction to a vaccine will further fuel the anti-vaccination movement that he is so strongly against.

<>

Because Carolyn Schutte received multiple vaccinations at once, no one knows which vaccine caused her negative reaction.

Jim Schutte does wonder whether part of her reaction came as a result of having multiple vaccines at once. He says the Centers for Disease Control have not addressed the topic, but he reasons that since vaccines trigger an immune response, having multiple vaccines administered at one time could put a greater strain on the immune system. It's with that reasoning that his grandson is getting his childhood vaccinations in spaced out doses, just in case his logic holds up.

<>

The Clay County Public Health Center issued the following statement:

The Clay County Public Health Center expresses its sincere empathy to Carolyn Schutte and her family. No words can truly ease the burden placed on the family over this tragic occurrence. We know that like any medical procedure, vaccination can have some risks. Although these events are very rare, individuals react differently to vaccines and there is no way to predict how an individual's immune system will react to a particular vaccine. We agree with and appreciate Jim Schutte's continued support of vaccines to prevent and eliminate diseases throughout the population.

pnwmom

(108,995 posts)
5. If it was related to multiple vaccines at once, it isn't so much a "freak accident."
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 05:23 AM
Feb 2015

Just a very rare but possible complication.

pnwmom

(108,995 posts)
4. I think that is often a good idea. The only reason children's vaccines are clumped together
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 05:22 AM
Feb 2015

is that doctors are afraid too many parents wouldn't comply with all the vaccinations if they had to bring their child in for repeated appointments.

 

KamaAina

(78,249 posts)
46. A possible solution suggests itself
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 05:05 PM
Feb 2015

offer vaccination clinics in places like schools and shopping centers.

pnwmom

(108,995 posts)
50. That isn't a bad idea. And in drugstores, where they have flu vaccines.
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 08:58 PM
Feb 2015

They could certainly make it easier than they do.

proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
58. Think again: "Drive Thru Medicine, SIRVA, & the Vaccine Court"
Tue Mar 3, 2015, 12:52 PM
Mar 2015
http://www.disabilitytoday.co.uk/drive-thru-medicine-sirva-and-the-vaccine-court-age-of-autism/

Drive Thru Medicine, SIRVA, & the Vaccine Court
By Wayne Rohde and Louis Conte


A continuing series examining the NVICP aka The Vaccine Court

LeftishBrit

(41,212 posts)
42. The disadvantage is that you are unprotected against certain diseases for longer. The advantage is
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 08:35 AM
Feb 2015

that if you do show a negative reaction, it's easier to pinpoint which vaccine was involved, and avoid just that vaccine in the future.

There is no reliable evidence that combining vaccines is itself any more problematic than having them individually, except for the point I just mentioned.

Certainly it's better to have vaccines spread out than not at all.

hopemountain

(3,919 posts)
44. agreed - and your points are well taken.
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 04:56 PM
Feb 2015

some countries delay vaccines for the first year after birth. but, unfortunately, children who are not breast fed the first year have less of the mother's immunities and are already vulnerable.

 

KamaAina

(78,249 posts)
48. The reaction this woman had may have been from too many vaccines at once
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 05:07 PM
Feb 2015

rather than from any of the individual vaccines.

Vaccines are designed to provoke an immune response. Too much immune response can cause autoimmune conditions.

pnwmom

(108,995 posts)
62. But the point you just mentioned is the key point. When there are multiple vaccines
Fri Mar 6, 2015, 07:54 PM
Mar 2015

it is harder to know which one caused the reaction.

 

KamaAina

(78,249 posts)
20. He is not an anti-vaxxer
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 06:18 PM
Feb 2015
One of his fears is that his wife's rare reaction to a vaccine will further fuel the anti-vaccination movement that he is so strongly against.


Nice post, Skinner!

SidDithers

(44,228 posts)
22. No, but the OP is....
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 06:24 PM
Feb 2015

They once posted that they consider Andrew Wakefield to be the Carl Sagan of his generation.



Sid

proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
29. IMO, out of context. Actually I'm unfamiliar with Sagan. Here, please judge for yourself.
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 10:17 PM
Feb 2015
http://www.democraticunderground.com/10024479039
POST 10 and 18 (silly throwaway line)

However, since then AMAZON PRIME has featured Rachel Aviv's New Yorker magazine article on Tyrone Hayes in video format where he is acknowledged as a whistleblower. More here: http://www.democraticunderground.com/10026102949#post42

Also since then (just for clarity or something) the name "Wakefield" has been disparagingly invoked by CDC officials and others in the media in practically every statement regarding the subject at hand. It's almost unreasonable until you wonder whether parents or other professionals are more influenced by that remarkable effort.

Have you seen the alleged phone text exchange published online between Dr. Andrew Wakefield and Senior CDC Scientist Dr. William W. Thompson, Aug 27, 2014? Is that the unspoken subtext?

Posted before the Disney outbreak:

http://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=5532267
http://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1017&pid=238426

What's changed with any of that?




proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
32. Hey, did I say that? I thought I said I'm unfamiliar with his work except superficially.
Thu Feb 26, 2015, 12:14 AM
Feb 2015

I know he was a famous astronomer and astrophysicist from Cornell. Created programs and wrote books for the general public on space. Correct? That's about it. Not my interest in the past, sorry, although I definitely might learn more someday.

GREAT relevant quotes from Wikiquotes:

"Science is much more than a body of knowledge. It is a way of thinking. This is central to its success. Science invites us to let the facts in, even when they don’t conform to our preconceptions. It counsels us to carry alternative hypotheses in our heads and see which ones best match the facts. It urges on us a fine balance between no-holds-barred openness to new ideas, however heretical, and the most rigorous skeptical scrutiny of everything — new ideas and established wisdom. We need wide appreciation of this kind of thinking. It works. It’s an essential tool for a democracy in an age of change. Our task is not just to train more scientists but also to deepen public understanding of science.
"Why We Need To Understand Science" in The Skeptical Inquirer Vol. 14, Issue 3 (Spring 1990)

"Science is (...) a way of skeptically interrogating the universe with a fine understanding of human fallibility. If we are not able to ask skeptical questions, to interrogate those who tell us that something is true, to be skeptical of those in authority, then we’re up for grabs for the next charlatan, political or religious, who comes ambling along.”
Charlie Rose: An Interview with Carl Sagan, May 27, 1996.

"The truth may be puzzling. It may take some work to grapple with. It may be counterintuitive. It may contradict deeply held prejudices. It may not be consonant with what we desperately want to be true. But our preferences do not determine what's true. We have a method, and that method helps us to reach not absolute truth, only asymptotic approaches to the truth — never there, just closer and closer, always finding vast new oceans of undiscovered possibilities. Cleverly designed experiments are the key."
"Wonder and Skepticism", Skeptical Inquirer 19 (1), January-February 1995, ISSN 0194-6730

"That kind of skeptical, questioning, "don't accept what authority tells you" attitude of science — is also nearly identical to the attitude of mind necessary for a functioning democracy. Science and democracy have very consonant values and approaches, and I don't think you can have one without the other."
Talk of the Nation (3 May 1996)

xmas74

(29,676 posts)
38. You said you were unfamiliar with Sagan.
Thu Feb 26, 2015, 10:34 PM
Feb 2015

I still don't know how that happened. I remember learning about him when I was in school (granted, this was when the first Cosmos had aired). My child knows about him and said they've discussed him before in classes. Heck, in the past year he's been discussed quite a bit because of Neil Degrasse Tyson updating his classic series Cosmos. Cosmos aired on numerous networks and was considered to be one of the best series of the year by many critics.

Carl Sagan was beloved by many. He was a genius. His work still holds and he inspired many young boys and girls to further their studies in science. What I don't understand is why you would throw out a few random quotes by Sagan without understanding a bit about him or the context.

xmas74

(29,676 posts)
39. I still miss Sagan.
Thu Feb 26, 2015, 10:35 PM
Feb 2015

He was one of my idols growing up.

Neil Degrasse Tyson did a great job with the update and I really enjoyed it though, in the end, it wasn't Carl.

 

KamaAina

(78,249 posts)
40. A copy of Cosmos was my prize at high school graduation.
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 01:31 AM
Feb 2015

I would have been valedictorian if my small, private high school had had such a thing (or a prom, for that matter )

xmas74

(29,676 posts)
41. Now that's a great present.
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 08:28 AM
Feb 2015

I would have loved a copy instead of constantly borrowing it from the library.

SidDithers

(44,228 posts)
34. Yup...
Thu Feb 26, 2015, 02:08 AM
Feb 2015
http://www.democraticunderground.com/10024479039#post10


Everything from that anti-vax poster should be viewed through the prism of their belief that Wakefield was unjustly persecuted, and that time will eventually prove him right.

Sid

zappaman

(20,606 posts)
45. Well now that Andrew Wakefield has been COMPLETELY discredited
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 05:02 PM
Feb 2015

This poster will surely take back that comment, right?

 

trumad

(41,692 posts)
7. You ask if anyone is name-calling?
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 11:05 AM
Feb 2015

The only name calling is for dumb shits who don't vaccinate their children.

proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
9. BINGO! What schedule? Go global & define "don't vaccinate their children." What does that mean?
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 03:41 PM
Feb 2015
https://olis.leg.state.or.us/liz/2015R1/Downloads/CommitteeMeetingDocument/47661

PAGE 36-43
TESTIMONY: Senate Committee on Health Care, State of Oregon, SB 442
February 18, 2015, 3pm


...In 1983, attached as Exhibit A, the 1983 (CDC) immunization schedule for children by the age of 6 recommended 10 vaccines (DTP, Oral Polio, DTP, Oral Polio, DTP, MMR, DTP, Oral Polio, DTP, Oral Polio).

In 2015, attached as Exhibit B, by the age of 6, the CDC now recommends 37 vaccines for children before the age of 6. (Hep B, Hep B, Rotavirus, DTaP, Hib, PCV, IPV, Flu, Rotavirus, DTaP, Hib, PCV, IPV, Rotavirus, DTaP, Hib, PCV, IPV, Flu, MMR, Varicella, Hep A, Hep B, DTaP, Hib, PCV, Flu, Hep A, DTaP, IPV, Flu, Flu, Flu, Flu, Flu, MMR, Varicella). Because this is so confusing, I’ve attached the CDC schedule with my handwritten notes to count the total vaccines.

Interestingly, as opposed to the 37 we have, many other first world countries give far fewer vaccines to children by the age of 6: Iceland (11), Sweden (11), Singapore (13), Japan (11, and pulled the MMR vaccine due to high injury rate), Norway (13), Hong Kong (13), Belgium (18), Austria (19), Israel (11), Denmark (12), Netherlands (20). Please note that every country listed has a lower under-5 mortality rate than the U.S.

I don't know personally but read recently that 1% of American children are completely unvaccinated (unverified, no link) - odd considering the MSM reporting.

Objectively speaking, the 2015 US CDC schedule is an extreme outlier (see above), BUT DO NOT QUESTION ANYTHING say the name-callers, in fact, legislate fuzzy mandates at the state level tying compliance (defined exactly as what?) to public school access.

Link from Twitter last night (below), FYI. It would be nice to see some follow-up research, agree? Or maybe you're in the camp that would shut down further science?

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3170075/

Hum Exp Toxicol. 2011 Sep; 30(9): 1420–1428.
doi: 10.1177/0960327111407644
PMCID: PMC3170075
Infant mortality rates regressed against number of vaccine doses routinely given: Is there a biochemical or synergistic toxicity?

Neil Z Miller and Gary S Goldman

Abstract
The infant mortality rate (IMR) is one of the most important indicators of the socio-economic well-being and public health conditions of a country. The US childhood immunization schedule specifies 26 vaccine doses for infants aged less than 1 year—the most in the world—yet 33 nations have lower IMRs. Using linear regression, the immunization schedules of these 34 nations were examined and a correlation coefficient of r = 0.70 (p < 0.0001) was found between IMRs and the number of vaccine doses routinely given to infants. Nations were also grouped into five different vaccine dose ranges: 12–14, 15–17, 18–20, 21–23, and 24–26. The mean IMRs of all nations within each group were then calculated. Linear regression analysis of unweighted mean IMRs showed a high statistically significant correlation between increasing number of vaccine doses and increasing infant mortality rates, with r = 0.992 (p = 0.0009). Using the Tukey-Kramer test, statistically significant differences in mean IMRs were found between nations giving 12–14 vaccine doses and those giving 21–23, and 24–26 doses. A closer inspection of correlations between vaccine doses, biochemical or synergistic toxicity, and IMRs is essential.

<>

Conclusion
The US childhood immunization schedule requires 26 vaccine doses for infants aged less than 1 year, the most in the world, yet 33 nations have better IMRs. Using linear regression, the immunization schedules of these 34 nations were examined and a correlation coefficient of 0.70 (p < 0.0001) was found between IMRs and the number of vaccine doses routinely given to infants. When nations were grouped into five different vaccine dose ranges (12–14, 15–17, 18–20, 21–23, and 24–26), 98.3% of the total variance in IMR was explained by the unweighted linear regression model. These findings demonstrate a counter-intuitive relationship: nations that require more vaccine doses tend to have higher infant mortality rates.

Efforts to reduce the relatively high US IMR have been elusive. Finding ways to lower preterm birth rates should be a high priority. However, preventing premature births is just a partial solution to reduce infant deaths. A closer inspection of correlations between vaccine doses, biochemical or synergistic toxicity, and IMRs, is essential. All nations—rich and poor, advanced and developing—have an obligation to determine whether their immunization schedules are achieving their desired goals.
 

trumad

(41,692 posts)
10. Let me put ithe in simple words...
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 04:52 PM
Feb 2015

Anti-Vaxxers are fucking morans. ...no hold on...I mean fucking douchebags.....no no...I mean... mental idiots...nope nope...that's not what I meant.... ok...I think I got it.... they are 21st century assholes.

proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
16. Consider that you might be living in a bubble (reliable info vacuum) & that it's UNSUSTAINABLE.
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 06:04 PM
Feb 2015

Unquestionably, time will tell, won't it? Meanwhile, you might wish to temper your intolerance. You're including the vast majority of people from around the world in that "antivaxxer" mischaracterization if not being in 100% compliance with the 2015 US CDC Recommended Schedule is how you define the term.

That's ridiculous.

xmas74

(29,676 posts)
31. I'm not but my aunt is
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 11:12 PM
Feb 2015

and she would have flown down to beat my ass if I chose not to vaccinate my child.

I worked for years in a state hospital. (Maybe that makes me a formal medical professional?) I saw patients not vaccinated for one reason or another whom contracted various diseases. It's sad and infuriating to think about what their lives would have been like if only they'd been vaccinated.

Response to trumad (Reply #10)

Hassin Bin Sober

(26,339 posts)
8. When they say "accident" do they know what caused this?
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 11:12 AM
Feb 2015

Is it a "bad dose"? Or is it just a fluke reaction the body has to a good vaccine?

Or do they not know?

Is there such a thing as a bad dose?

Pro vax here, btw. I just got my first flu shot ever. Figured I'm not getting any younger and now we have little kids in the building. Don't want to make them sick or get sick from those little petrie dishes if I can help it.

Avalux

(35,015 posts)
11. It's very rare, but some people can have severe reactions.
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 04:58 PM
Feb 2015

It's the same for anything foreign being introduced into the body, be it a regulated drug, a supplement, or even a food product. 100% safety cannot be guaranteed.

It may have been a specific component of one of the vaccines, or her body couldn't handle all of them at once. It's difficult to say.

This is not a case in support of not vaccinating. This was, as described, a very unfortunate accident.

 

Telcontar

(660 posts)
14. Having travelled to manyundesirable location
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 05:20 PM
Feb 2015

And having two vaccine booklets filled, my guess is it was too much at once. I've had my shots spaced out a bit. Sickest I have ever felt after a vaccine was when I had to get eight all in one day.

pnwmom

(108,995 posts)
63. It is possible to have a vaccine stored under improper conditions,
Fri Mar 6, 2015, 07:55 PM
Mar 2015

which might affect the potency of the vaccine.

Liberal Veteran

(22,239 posts)
12. It's a very small risk, but for those who "hit the bad luck jackpot" it is small comfort.
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 05:05 PM
Feb 2015

I think of things like this in terms of penicillin. When you think how many lives have been saved and put that against those who have died due to anaphylactic shock after taking it, can we say penicillin is a bad thing?

TheKentuckian

(25,029 posts)
13. Not a bit but it doesn't mean we must insist no one is allergic to penicillin
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 05:15 PM
Feb 2015

and just tell everyone to take penicillin instead of figuring out what is causing the issues and coming up with alternatives even though it is an exception rather than a rule.

Liberal Veteran

(22,239 posts)
15. Well, we don't. That is why there is a vaccine injury compensation program.
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 05:24 PM
Feb 2015

There is no way you are going to make a vaccine or medication 100% safe for everyone 100% of the time.

There comes a point where the cases of bad reactions are so few, there is no justification to go back and say "Since there is a 1 in 10 million chance of serious injury, we should go back to the drawing board until we get this sorted out."

TheKentuckian

(25,029 posts)
21. I said nothing about going to the drawing board at all but blowing off people's lives, setting up
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 06:19 PM
Feb 2015

a kitty, and calling it a day is just a little closer to the "cost of doing business" mentality that all too often leads to dangerously detached and amoral recklessness that rolls over the actual human beings.

I said to keep exploring possibilities while continuing to vaccinate and I'm not going to back off or apologize for thinking that way even if it introduces economic inefficiency or complicates the narrative.

Liberal Veteran

(22,239 posts)
25. I agree. Balance is everything. That is why I usually try to look at the overall picture.
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 06:39 PM
Feb 2015

In many facets of life, medicine being one, it is important to maintain perspective.

That is why I brought up penicillin. There are approximately 400 deaths in the US annually due to penicillin allergy, but in the larger picture it has been a true wonder drug. It is small comfort to those who are seriously injured by it however.

In these days where information is so prolific, a certain detachment is necessary because we often get bogged down in the anecdotal or rarity.

It doesn't diminish my empathy toward what this couple has gone through.

Liberal Veteran

(22,239 posts)
19. That's why I called it the "bad luck jackpot". It wasn't referring to the compensation.
Wed Feb 25, 2015, 06:14 PM
Feb 2015

It was referring to the odds being against having such an extremely bad reaction. She was the one that hit the "bad luck jackpot" I was referring to.

The compensation was irrelevant to point I was making.

LeftishBrit

(41,212 posts)
43. Very sad. I wonder if one of the vaccines that she needed for travel was the yellow fever vaccine?
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 08:37 AM
Feb 2015

That is known to carry more risk of neurological reactions than most vaccines do, and caution is recommended especially for children and people over 60. Obviously, it is more dangerous to get the yellow fever itself!

proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
49. Do you still think you can ignore the science with one-liners & reframe the issue as ALL OR NOTHING?
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 07:09 PM
Feb 2015

Check it out: http://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=5507853

http://www.pressherald.com/2014/09/02/maine-voices-breakdown-in-accountability-at-heart-of-decline-in-vaccinations/

Maine Voices: Breakdown in accountability at heart of decline in vaccinations
Opposition to the current U.S. vaccination program is based on its failures, denial and bad law and policy.

BY GINGER TAYLOR
September 2, 2014


BRUNSWICK — I was interviewed for an Aug. 9 front-page article by Joe Lawlor, titled "More Maine families are skipping or delaying childhood vaccines." What was published was a complete misrepresentation of the interview I gave him.

As I told Mr. Lawlor, I’m neither anti-vaccine nor opposed to vaccination, and I vaccinated my children. My opposition is to the current U.S. vaccine program, which has become corrupted by bad law and policy, the failure to disclose known risks to families, the failure to pre-screen children who are showing symptoms that they are at risk for vaccine reactions and the denial of vaccine injury cases – rather than the proper recognition, diagnoses and treatment of vaccine-injured children.

In 1986, Congress gave liability protection to all vaccine interests – pharmaceutical companies, government agencies, doctors, nurses, etc. – so no one in this country can sue for vaccine injuries or deaths. As a result of this disregard of Americans’ Seventh Amendment rights, a vaccine injury case hasn’t been brought before a jury in almost 30 years, there is no longer accountability in vaccine safety and the vaccine program has fallen into massive corruption.

The effectiveness of vaccines is overstated, safety claims made are overstated and parents no longer get accurate risk information. Instead, vaccine consumers are offered a single sheet of information in the doctor’s office that leaves out almost all of the side effects listed on the vaccine package insert, on the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Vaccine Injury Table and the disorders that HHS has concluded can be caused by a given vaccine.

<>

http://www.hrsa.gov/vaccinecompensation/vaccinetable.html
COMMAND F: Encephalopathy (or encephalitis)

OTOH, your views are supported by Dr. Paul Offit (below):

http://touch.latimes.com/#section/-1/article/p2p-81833623/

Doctors learn to push back, gently, against anti-vaccination movement
BY ERYN BROWN
October 31, 2014, 4:00 a.m


The doctors shifted nervously in their seats as the sharp-tongued questioner scanned the room.

Dr. Paul Offit, a University of Pennsylvania pediatrician and the nation's most outspoken childhood vaccine proponent, had come to the UCLA lecture hall to subject several dozen physicians to a faux parental grilling.

He wanted to give them the kind of pushback doctors have come to expect in affluent parts of Los Angeles and California, where increasing numbers of parents are refusing to inoculate their kids against contagious, even life-threatening diseases for fear of complications.

<>

If Offit, a rock star in his field, could give these doctors more factual ammunition — and a little practice on their delivery — could they help convince resistant parents that science is simply not on their side?

The salt-and-pepper-haired Offit slipped straight into character and zeroed in on one young doctor.

"I know you doctors keep telling me that vaccines don't cause autism. If that's true, then why is it on this package insert?" he asked, playing the role of a parent who had read the blogs and heard the celebrities who connect the two.

Shifting in her seat, the designated victim shot Offit an unsure look.

Then she began citing studies and said that drug packaging inserts include many "temporally associated symptoms" that weren't necessarily caused by the vaccine.

"Why?" Offit pressed. "Why would they put that there — just to scare me?"

The doctor kept trying. "They're required by law," she said. "I actually didn't know the answer."

Offit broke character to explain: Drug companies must list any condition known to have occurred within six weeks of a vaccination, whether the medication caused the condition or not, and even if it occurs at the same level as with a placebo.

Package inserts are legal documents, not medical documents, he said, calling them "the bane of (his) existence."

"If you look at the original package insert for chicken pox vaccine, it says, 'Broken leg has been associated with this drug,'" he added.

Studies have firmly debunked the notion that vaccines cause autism. Yet that is one of the most common claims made by a persistent national anti-vaccination movement that treats Offit as public enemy No. 1.

<>

proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
54. A multigenerational report of adverse reactions here (link from Twitter).
Sun Mar 1, 2015, 05:28 AM
Mar 2015
http://www.charlotteobserver.com/living/health-family/article11620775.html

Former Mooresville child compensated by federal ‘vaccine court’
BY KAREN GARLOCHKGARLOCH@CHARLOTTEOBSERVER.COM
02/28/2015 5:32 PM 02/28/2015 11:48 PM

Related: http://www.democraticunderground.com/1016115541#post8

HuckleB

(35,773 posts)
55. And more of the usual anti-vaccine conspiracy BS.
Sun Mar 1, 2015, 12:46 PM
Mar 2015

What are you going to pay to all those who die and suffer disabilities in your fantasy world where vaccines do not exist?

HuckleB

(35,773 posts)
57. You never show anyone decency.
Sun Mar 1, 2015, 04:32 PM
Mar 2015

You repeatedly post things with bogus claims, and multiple links, most of which have nothing to do with the claims you make. Your anecdote here does not change the very clear reality that vaccines are safe and effective. You are promoting death and disease. Either stop doing so, or own it.

proverbialwisdom

(4,959 posts)
61. Just looking for recent Menendez/autism news on Google and this popped up. Was it reported anywhere?
Fri Mar 6, 2015, 07:50 PM
Mar 2015
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:0uzpKMt1F4EJ:www.aap.org/en-us/my-aap/materials/ACBOFA/ACBOFA%2520Agenda%2520January%25202015.pdf+&cd=4&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=safari#47

MANAGEMENT REPORT (AAP)
Advisory Committee to the Board on Federal Affairs (ACBOFA)


Wednesday, January 25, 2015
Elk Grove Village, IL

<>

Page 46
President Signs Sudden Unexpected Death Data Enhancement and Awareness Act


In December, President Obama signed the Sudden Unexpected Death Data Enhancement and Awareness Act (H.R. 669) into law. The law directs the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to continue surveillance efforts around sudden unexpected infant death (SUID) and Sudden Unexplained Death in Childhood (SUDC). The law also outlines suggestions for improving the quality, consistency, and collection of data on these deaths.

In addition, the law also calls for CDC to continue collaboration with the Department of Justice, state and local health departments, and other experts to provide consistent information on death scene investigations and autopsies to promote consistent reporting on the cause of death. The law also calls on CDC to share this information with the public, health care providers, and other stakeholders. AAP endorsed an earlier, broader version of the legislation, which was amended several times in both the Senate and House; the original version included funding to both support and expand these activities, and also provided funding to support the work of child death review teams. AAP will continue closely monitoring this work within CDC and advocating for strong public policies that support the prevention of SUIDs and SUDCs.


Page 44
38 CDC “Whistleblower” Controversy


In August, a paper was published in the journal Translational Neurodegeneration, alleging that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has manipulated data from a study about vaccines and autism entitled, "Age at First Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccination in Children with Autism and School-Matched Control Subjects: A Population-Based Study in Metropolitan Atlanta,” that was published in Pediatrics in 2004. The author of the paper, Dr. Brian Hooker, asserted that, based on information from an anonymous tipster from the CDC, proved that the CDC had purposely excluded certain participants from the study in order to achieve a desired outcome in the data.

The paper has since been removed, and the tipster was discovered to be Dr. William W.Thompson, an epidemiologist from CDC, who issued a public statement stating that he felt the paper back in 2004 omitted data that suggested that African American males who received the MMR vaccine before age 36 months were at increased risk for autism. He went on to say that “decisions were made regarding which findings to report after the data were collected, and I believe that the final study protocol was not followed.” He also went on to say that he believes “vaccines have saved and continue to save countless lives. I would never suggest that any parent avoid vaccinating children of any race. Vaccines prevent serious diseases, and the risks associated with their administration are vastly outweighed by their individual and societal benefits.” His main concern was the “decision to omit relevant findings in a particular study for a particular sub group for a particular vaccine. There have always been recognized risks for vaccination and I believe it is the responsibility of the CDC to properly convey the risks associated with receipt of those vaccines.”

Following these revelations, numerous epidemiologists and biostatisticians have stood behind the CDC’s initial data, stating that the exclusion of participants without valid birth certificates was methodologically and scientifically appropriate. In addition, the editors of Pediatrics reviewed the 2004 article and confirmed its findings.

In the wake of the controversy, Congressman Bill Posey (R-FL) has stated that he will take action to “hold the CDC accountable.” Though he has not announced plans at this time, the Department of Federal Affairs is closely monitoring the situation, and is prepared to combat any misinformation that will be disseminated if Congressman Posey holds ahearing or takes other action.
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»$7.4M settlement awarded ...