Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

xchrom

(108,903 posts)
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 07:25 AM Feb 2015

The Right’s Fear of Education: What I Learned As a (Former) Conservative Military Man

http://www.alternet.org/news-amp-politics/rights-fear-education-what-i-learned-former-conservative-military-man

My first college experience was failing half my classes at the University of Nevada sowed me exactly how not to live, so I started a backward, fumbling and circuitous process of getting my undergraduate degree. In seven years, I attended four community colleges, a university on a military base and attended military journalism school. I pieced the whole mess into a bachelor’s degree from Excelsior College, a credit aggregator that caters to military members.

Modern conservative politics push the notion that people who flip switches, burgers or bedpans don’t need “education.” They instead need “job training.” In Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s budget, someone crossed out this phrase: “to extend knowledge and its application beyond the boundaries of its campuses and to serve and stimulate society.” And added this instead: “to meet the state’s workforce needs.” Walker backed down on the language change when it was exposed, claiming it was a “mistake.” Really it was just one more tired attack on the idea of education as a public good, one that helps people find fulfillment and meaning.

32 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Right’s Fear of Education: What I Learned As a (Former) Conservative Military Man (Original Post) xchrom Feb 2015 OP
I thought this part was particularly well said.. Fumesucker Feb 2015 #1
Absolutely brilliant passage. Explains so much of what bullwinkle428 Feb 2015 #6
+1 n/t LittleGirl Feb 2015 #8
Very good insight from another angle mountain grammy Feb 2015 #15
Education for the rest of us BlueinOhio Feb 2015 #20
On the question of whether it is more important that the economy serves the people truebluegreen Feb 2015 #2
The attitude that education serves only employment is very common in Wisconsin HereSince1628 Feb 2015 #9
Well said. truebluegreen Feb 2015 #10
+100 sinkingfeeling Feb 2015 #16
It didn't used to be. And frankly if he wants MATC (the technical colleges) TBF Feb 2015 #29
My college teaching in WI began in 87 at a comprehensive college HereSince1628 Feb 2015 #30
Nailed it.... daleanime Feb 2015 #3
HUGH K&R Martin Eden Feb 2015 #4
"Really it was just one more tired attack on the idea of education as a public good" phantom power Feb 2015 #5
Adolph Hitler and Education Cary Feb 2015 #7
Hitler was a man of beliefs, therefore confused education with indoctrination mrdmk Feb 2015 #26
And in order to rule our oligarchy needs uneducated people. I think that Thomas Jefferson had jwirr Feb 2015 #28
Now why in the world would you want human beings to become enlightened? vlyons Feb 2015 #11
Empathy and education require energy... the_sly_pig Feb 2015 #12
K&R handmade34 Feb 2015 #13
Agreed nhpunx447 Feb 2015 #14
Welcome to DU Oilwellian Feb 2015 #24
I wish more reformed conservatives spoke out against their old ways of thinking. stillwaiting Feb 2015 #17
One of the Comments Leith Feb 2015 #18
K&R Thespian2 Feb 2015 #19
Some say failing is the begining of learning polynomial Feb 2015 #21
and LWolf Feb 2015 #22
K&R Solly Mack Feb 2015 #23
+1 uponit7771 Feb 2015 #25
I can see why he was a military conservative. All those military oriented schools. My niece was born jwirr Feb 2015 #27
Message auto-removed Name removed Mar 2015 #31
Message auto-removed Name removed Oct 2015 #32

Fumesucker

(45,851 posts)
1. I thought this part was particularly well said..
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 08:06 AM
Feb 2015
After getting a bachelor’s at 27, I went back to graduate school to study 18th century British literature at California State Hayward. I landed a new job in Reno and moved to the University of Nevada, Reno, finishing a master’s in English there. A few years later, I went back again, this time for a master’s of fine arts in creative writing from Antioch University Los Angeles, a school that emphasizes social justice—for many conservatives, a coded phrase that means “liberal.” Even as a libertarian attending a liberal college, people went out of their way to be both kind and tolerant to me. My preconceived notions about the “evil liberals of the ivory tower” looked more ignorant and narrow by the day.

Before college, I voted conservative, hated gay people, loved America and served my country in the armed services. I’ve changed because of many factors, but I know that college and graduate school made a difference. I met people unlike myself and was forced to defend sometimes ugly political positions. The Tea Party thrives on blue-collar “common sense” that is composed of a combination of ignorance, superstition and fear. A literate and educated populace is an existential threat to the kind of thoughtless rage that has consumed the right over the past few years.

When I write about how my politics evolved over a lifetime from conservative to liberal, people in the comments section (note: never read Internet comments) like to point out my “liberal arts degrees.” Even my own friends like to remark on my MFA, usually by asking me to whip them up a “grande cappuccino.” It’s funny, and I go right along with the joke too. I understand the reality of trying to earn a living with an arts degree. At the same time, it’s troubling that educational fulfillment has turned into a punch line, even among those who believe in it.

Some people on the right are very educated. Rick Santorum holds an MBA and a JD (with honors, no less), and his vehement hatred of college seems to stem from his kooky take on religion. Modern politics is drawing bizarre new battle lines between “family values” and a halfway decent education. American Christians may dislike “Islam,” but they share a lot of opinions with the radical Islamic group “Boko Haram,” a name that itself translates into “education is forbidden.” In our own country, we have a massive and growing group of people who would rather have illiterate children than let their kids learn anything that contradicts their most extreme religious views.

mountain grammy

(26,648 posts)
15. Very good insight from another angle
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 10:11 AM
Feb 2015

especially this: "Modern politics is drawing bizarre new battle lines between “family values” and a halfway decent education." So true and so very scary.

BlueinOhio

(238 posts)
20. Education for the rest of us
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 10:50 AM
Feb 2015

You mention Santorum having degree , well so does Romney and just think his children are going to college while he was telling the rest of us our children do not need to go. A long time ago I met the GOP chairman and was talking to him I told him I was just about to graduate from college and what he told me changed my whole political view. He said I did not deserve to go to college. That with a degree I could get a better job than I deserved for my station and was taking a position from one of their children or family members. I would like to say that is wrong but I ended up working at the only place near my home it is completely friends and family, or go to the right church. They are put in place based on relationship but if someone not in the clan put in for the job they get told qualifications and they get longer each time. For instance you have to have a college degree, they hire theology and photo journal degrees but my son who has a medical and science degree I get told they are only hiring people with this degree ( based on physics and science), even better being told that to be eligible for supervisor position you have had to work everywhere on plant site. Be in a lead position for 7 years and not only have a bachelors degree but must be certified. They hire someone who has been there less than 5 years only worked in one building and an associate degree in business. Sorry about getting a little off topic but I do believe this is what is wrong with the whole country. Social filtering.

 

truebluegreen

(9,033 posts)
2. On the question of whether it is more important that the economy serves the people
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 08:20 AM
Feb 2015

or people serve the economy, it is pretty clear where Walker stands, isn't it?

HereSince1628

(36,063 posts)
9. The attitude that education serves only employment is very common in Wisconsin
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 09:23 AM
Feb 2015

And it's pretty much as common among democratic voters as it is in the teahadists.

I did much of my teaching career here in 'comprehensive' colleges. Comprehensive is a term that is intended to suggest programming in vocational carreers, they stand in less and less contrast to "Liberal Arts Colleges". As a consequence I'm more familiar with this attitude than I would like to be.

Kids and parents frequently complained about 'liberal arts requirements' meaning 'general studies requirements'. The argument was that it wasn't stuff that would ever help them on their job. The short version of my response to them was "adult Americans are awake about 105 hours a week, a work week is 40 hours, most people need some education and training for a modern job. But to really appreciate life and contribute to the richness of lives of others, most people need education for those other 65 hours.


The more polemic version remains: During those 65 hours we practice citizenship, neighborliness, parenting and act as counselors and advisors to family and friends. General education benefits our ability to function in -all- those roles. And the general education helps us appreciate and enjoy the world around us, whether it's art, music, natural history or an appreciation for the physics involved in the tight spin of an ice-skater, or 'door drafting' in the Daytona 500. General education is a great gift, people who don't acquire it are at a handicap to live well and enjoy the greatest part of their waking life, the part of life that is so precious we want great jobs so we can buy it. But that precious life isn't for sale at WalMart. It's available in a time efficient way through education in general studies.


It's the difference between driving cross country and being bored to death, and driving cross country and being amazed and entertained by reading the landscape of America.

TBF

(32,090 posts)
29. It didn't used to be. And frankly if he wants MATC (the technical colleges)
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 02:59 PM
Feb 2015

and the regional colleges (all the other UW campuses aside from Madison which will get by w/its grant money, high tuition, and alumni bequests) to stay open and provide jobs he should rethink his message.

When I was growing up in the 70s in Wisconsin (in the poor, rural area in the middle of the state) it was not uncommon for someone like me to end up at University. It didn't matter that my parents were high school graduates from small towns who worked in factories - it was a badge of honor that a child from the family would get excellent grades and go to Madison. The campus accepted the top 10% from the state high schools and they charged us reasonable rates (my tuition was under $1000 per semester in the 80s).

I don't even recognize Wisconsin anymore.

HereSince1628

(36,063 posts)
30. My college teaching in WI began in 87 at a comprehensive college
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 07:38 PM
Feb 2015

Reagan's recessions and GHWB recession had students and parents wanting more vocational and less general studies, and that's what the little schools mostly did.

I think many people in WI still want their kids to get a college/university education... but more and more they don't want that education 'burdened' with things that aren't related to working lives.

I'm glad to be beyond it.

Martin Eden

(12,875 posts)
4. HUGH K&R
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 08:37 AM
Feb 2015

This:

The Tea Party thrives on blue-collar “common sense” that is composed of a combination of ignorance, superstition and fear. A literate and educated populace is an existential threat to the kind of thoughtless rage that has consumed the right over the past few years.


And this:
Besides, there is inherent value to education even if someone isn’t paying you for it. I know my life would be less satisfying without it. For instance, if I had turned my back on education, I could have ended up as an ignorant asshole trying to turn back the very hands of human progress, much like the party to which I once belonged.

phantom power

(25,966 posts)
5. "Really it was just one more tired attack on the idea of education as a public good"
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 08:41 AM
Feb 2015

I wish it was a "tired" attack. But they never get tired. That's the problem. The conservative movement has a hyperalloy combat chassis and a 120-year power supply.

Cary

(11,746 posts)
7. Adolph Hitler and Education
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 09:15 AM
Feb 2015
http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/adolf_hitler_education.htm

Hitler’s view on education was that it served a sole purpose – to ensure that a child was loyal to the Nazi state to ensure that the Third Reich lasted for 1000 years. A lot of the Nazi education system also reflected Hitler’s educational experiences. After his failure to get into the Academy of Fine Arts in Vienna Hitler developed a loathing of intellectuals who in his opinion based their teaching on what could be learned behind desks or in lectures halls. Hitler wrote that the first duty of the state was to care for the physical well-being and physical development of the young:



“The whole education in a national state must aim first of all not at stuffing the student with mere knowledge but by building bodies which are healthy to the core.”

mrdmk

(2,943 posts)
26. Hitler was a man of beliefs, therefore confused education with indoctrination
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 02:09 PM
Feb 2015

Education gives you ability to think for yourself and to come up with your concussions for the greater good of the masses.

Indoctrination gives the ability of the few to lead the masses without being questioned.

This is the continuing discussion of what is needed in today's educational service i.e. 'how much do we teach to the test?'

HereSince1628 nailed it with the following:

Kids and parents frequently complained about 'liberal arts requirements' meaning 'general studies requirements'. The argument was that it wasn't stuff that would ever help them on their job. The short version of my response to them was "adult Americans are awake about 105 hours a week, a work week is 40 hours, most people need some education and training for a modern job. But to really appreciate life and contribute to the richness of lives of others, most people need education for those other 65 hours.


Thank-you HereSince1628 for that thought and reasoning

jwirr

(39,215 posts)
28. And in order to rule our oligarchy needs uneducated people. I think that Thomas Jefferson had
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 02:44 PM
Feb 2015

something to say about that.

vlyons

(10,252 posts)
11. Now why in the world would you want human beings to become enlightened?
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 09:33 AM
Feb 2015

or achieve their full human potential, or open their minds to new possibilities, or use critical thinking to know when they are being BSed, or develop empathy for other sentient beings, or unite in the struggle for equal justice, or learn what history can teach us, or be exposed to dangerous ideas -- ideas that are contrary to religion and laissez faire capitalism? Why indeed?

the_sly_pig

(741 posts)
12. Empathy and education require energy...
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 09:37 AM
Feb 2015

Which path to take? Acceptance and compassion require energy. Base instincts, basic needs, hatred, fear all require little thought. The wise man understands that he is ignorant. Education is an end in itself. I would much rather work with a philosophy major than a 'business' major because philosophy is much more interesting.

Add into the mix that many believe in pre-destination and it's next to impossible to have a thoughtful conversation about a meaningful topic. Are we killing the planet? Of course we are. It's the stupid people that will bring about the destruction of humanity, certainly not the smart ones.

James Inhofe? A senator? Dumb as a bag of hair, but the people of Oklahoma elected him multiple times apparently. Talk about a State where the people are too lazy to think. Educated people don't elect James Inhofe or Ted Cruz or Michelle Bachman (my States contribution) or Scott Walker.

The fact is that in order for a democracy to work, the population has to be educated and involved. Conservative attacks on education and our own citizens apathy have eroded our democracy to the point that now we have an oligarchy.

I used to think I'd see single payer health care in my lifetime. Now I know I won't. Maybe this is what we deserve. Maybe, like drug abusers, we'll have to hit rock bottom before the population decides to exercise its muscle. Certainly during the next reformation, these years will be considered the dark ages. I think Orwell knew a long time ago what the world was heading toward.

"Morans" get bent out of shape because two men want to marry but could care less that the Pacific is dying. Idahoan gun nuts hoard ammunition fully knowing that our own military could kill them from a console room in Florida.

Oh well. I'm telling myself things will be much better under Hillary....

handmade34

(22,757 posts)
13. K&R
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 09:47 AM
Feb 2015
"...if I had turned my back on education, I could have ended up as an ignorant asshole trying to turn back the very hands of human progress, much like the (Republican) party..."





other essays by Lyngar:
http://www.alternet.org/authors/edwin-lyngar


nhpunx447

(4 posts)
14. Agreed
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 09:49 AM
Feb 2015

When I joined the army in the mid 2000's I was a hot headed conservative 19 year old. Fast forward 6 years and a combat tour in Afghanistan I realized the very same conservative "supporters" were the same people not funding the troops when we come home. Main stream conservatism has blinded America into believing the fact that they want a better America. In fact they don't support anything, most importantly education and healthcare. I am out of the Army and am very much a democrat now because in my opinion, in order to have a great strong country, we have to take care of our own.

Oilwellian

(12,647 posts)
24. Welcome to DU
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 11:28 AM
Feb 2015

My father was in the Army in the early 50's and fought in Korea. After returning home with wounds, he took advantage of the newly created GI Bill and earned a degree in chemical engineering.

Our political leaders at the time, including Republicans, understood the importance of education and realized investing in free educations for our returning veterans of WWII & Korea would pay great dividends to the nation in the long run. They were right to believe that because using my father as an example, our country earned back the initial investment they made in his education, and benefited from the high taxes he paid throughout his very successful career.

Imagine what our country would be like if we just took a small portion of our military budget each year, and offered our young adults a free college education. Instead we are witnessing the decline of education and college degrees are quickly becoming a mere pipe dream for most young adults.

I really do fear for your generation's future and hope to see, one day, a concerted push back against our devolving nation.

Leith

(7,813 posts)
18. One of the Comments
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 10:22 AM
Feb 2015

has this quote:

If more people became well educated, the very idea of political conservativism, or at least the American variant would be facing an existential threat.

That is why in the Anglo world, the political right has declared a war on knowledge. The whole ideology that conservatives revolve around is justification of an aristocracy. Everything else is built on that rationale.

A well educated population would be one that discredited that ideology.



I have thought for a long time that it looked like the US is trying to create an aristocracy. The parallels to England of the 1600s is shocking.

Thespian2

(2,741 posts)
19. K&R
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 10:41 AM
Feb 2015

Without a broad, general education, people can become subject to the ignorant beliefs of the uninformed, misinformed, and brain-washed. I believe destroying intelligence and replacing it with "Republican common sense" is the essential platform of the Republican party. That and their willingness to force their ignorance onto the entire population.

They believe the Senator With The Snowball. Or put another way, ignorance is bliss, making Repugs blisters.

polynomial

(750 posts)
21. Some say failing is the begining of learning
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 11:12 AM
Feb 2015

Some say failing is the beginning of learning, and the American society under the surface is loaded with old world behavior and habits that are not fading fast enough to help Americans move forward.

Actually it is the Conservatives of today that are incorrectly defined. The best example is the University person so embedded in the social structure, so embedded in our government. Think about it, the massive majority are college educated people that run our government.

Then why is it so corrupted, brimming with false positives, our language carries over from the old world referring to Latin an old tyranny is brought to this age.

Americans are swamped with marketing lies, political lies that are not challenged yet a citizen has the right to challenge each other in the court of law.

It’s obvious those political people are building their family fortunes within the context of a super-code built in the legislation by our very University system.

Americans endow the University with billions of dollars in funding via taxes with good connections through our military industrial complex.

Further media professionals denounce Unionism a basic fundamental to the first amendment, yet ignore crime families like Bush that profiteer with arrogance in warring, politics and sacked the treasure for the last century, all college people.

My new endeavor is to study Shakespeare or old English King James and master the iambic pentameter to understand how to interpret language and examine the syntax and semantics. A key reason it is necessary to peel away from the old world fascist mental mind.

We can define that notion of hands on as a first level. However and most important it takes a mental perception of a new degree, a new pedagogy to understand life not taught in the tradition of the last century, or centuries. Mastering an intuitive method is key in the next millennium. Hands on is ok but not good enough.

Many of the learned society know that the mathematics taught of this age by computer is far more comprehensive.

It is exampled by the Calculus taught out of a two dimensional book, or the blackboard, white board, is not as good with a sense perception being able to visualize key concepts to reason.

The days of using words without too much explanation are fading, example words like; thus, let, it follows, further, or we will let the reader work out the proof, are examples of insufficient discussion. Most of all nothing is satisfied in mathematics. And the kicker zero is defined in advanced math.

Especially within a thought process as through computer vision carefully labeled by programming just like the food we eat. We need to know what mental algorithm is in the learning process or what it was mean to be.

This new age of computer based education with new video communications make the old college methods outdated bringing in a new and more ambitious student with teachers that will have far more recognition.

It’s interesting that Da Vinci was the Grandmaster of a secret society, moreover one of the first to study photo diffraction yet music in acoustics of the time, with art and painting was the only audio and visual meter that blended in the senses to help analyze the phenomena. Today with the computer we make a quantum leap.

LWolf

(46,179 posts)
22. and
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 11:14 AM
Feb 2015

Modern Democratic politics push the notion that education is a business to be privatized and run by corporations, because actual educators aren't competent.

jwirr

(39,215 posts)
27. I can see why he was a military conservative. All those military oriented schools. My niece was born
Fri Feb 27, 2015, 02:26 PM
Feb 2015

in Jamaica and lived in one of the poorest areas there. We adopted her when she was 7 and she lived here in very Democratic family. She received a good liberal education. Then she joined the Marines and graduated from the Citadel - first black woman. She came out of that school a died in the wool R. I think she has rethought much of what she was taught there but she and her husband are still connected to the Army.

Response to xchrom (Original post)

Response to xchrom (Original post)

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Right’s Fear of Educa...