Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

eridani

(51,907 posts)
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 08:17 AM Mar 2015

Reich: A Tale of Three States: California, Kansas, and Florida

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2015/03/15/1371066/-A-Tale-of-Three-States-California-Kansas-and-Florida

Robert Reich recently pointed out that if you listen to rightwing groups like the Tax Foundation, you would think California is a horrible place for business. These groups rank it in the top 10 worst due to "high cost" and "burdensome environmental regulations". However, these same groups rank Sam Brownback's Kansas as one of the best.

Here's the problem with that:

Kansas is collapsing. In four short years, since the tea party takeover, Kansas has had three credit downgrades along with a billion-dollar budget deficit. They are struggling to fund basic services and their education system is hanging on by a thread, with cutbacks making it almost dead last in teacher quality, pay, student spending and pupil-teacher ratio. It's so bad that REPUBLICAN state Sen. Wint Winter Jr. said Brownback's tax cuts have been a "train wreck".

Yet while the Sunflower state is falling apart, the Eureka State is CRUSHING it.

By any metric you use, California has become the best state in the union for investors. A great Democratic governor (Jerry Brown) and a Democratic-led legislature turned California around in four short years from a 27 billion dollar deficit disaster into a surplus and, according to Bloomberg, an absolute mecca for corporations! California companies in the S&P 500 have delivered returns of 134 percent! (No other state comes close.) These same companies outperformed the S&P 500 by a margin of 23%; and CA tech company sales account for 52% of all the tech sales in America.

So how can California have some of the highest business taxes and regulations in America, and yet be the most successful? The answer is simple. California invested in itself!
47 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Reich: A Tale of Three States: California, Kansas, and Florida (Original Post) eridani Mar 2015 OP
Hmmmm - you mean spending money making the state better makes the state better? el_bryanto Mar 2015 #1
So that is the secret Jon82 Mar 2015 #42
Thank you Jerry Brown and the citizens of California! NBachers Mar 2015 #2
Jerry Brown and our Democratic Legislature faced a $42 billion, not $27 billion dollar deficit BlueCaliDem Mar 2015 #15
But remember, the majority of the good citizens of our state voted to raise our taxes. JDPriestly Mar 2015 #40
RW Ideology is impervious to facts Martin Eden Mar 2015 #3
Yes, and if you explain this all to them (about California that is) dorkzilla Mar 2015 #17
The republican party has caused so much harm to this country, CrispyQ Mar 2015 #21
I know what you mean Populist_Prole Mar 2015 #23
and families ~ hopemountain Mar 2015 #32
Many people who vote for R's are simply misinformed Martin Eden Mar 2015 #24
If she believes that, then she's clueless. Fantastic Anarchist Mar 2015 #25
Fairly clueless about policitcs, yes Martin Eden Mar 2015 #28
+1 F4lconF16 Mar 2015 #44
Fairly clueless about policitcs, yes Martin Eden Mar 2015 #28
She sounds like she gets her news from Faux News. She may be smart but she is just ignorant cui bono Mar 2015 #35
About a decade ago, my sister said they "had found WMD in Iraq" I told her there was not one Thor_MN Mar 2015 #37
My mother beltanefauve Mar 2015 #47
Great Article Gothmog Mar 2015 #4
Guess letting the "job creators" keep their taxes in the hope it will trickle down bigbrother05 Mar 2015 #5
Trickle down economics Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Mar 2015 #8
Piss on you economics Dirty Socialist Mar 2015 #22
Big corporations are not greedy in the least Jon82 Mar 2015 #43
HUGE K & R !!! - THANK YOU !!! WillyT Mar 2015 #6
Wait, what about Phil Mickelson saying California's taxes are to high...... a kennedy Mar 2015 #7
But, But ,,,, But,,,,, Cryptoad Mar 2015 #9
And the asshole Governors of Texas and Florida keep trying to pilfer California businesses. Fuddnik Mar 2015 #10
Kansas is now the 'ideal' model for Tea party run states. Arkansas is being sinkingfeeling Mar 2015 #11
Thats's the GOP mantra in VT also erronis Mar 2015 #12
But,but... Stryst Mar 2015 #13
I can't believe the voters in Kansas & Florida re-elected those two dumbasses. catbyte Mar 2015 #14
Actually, Schwarzenegger and Republicans expanded our deficit to $42 billion, not $27 billion. BlueCaliDem Mar 2015 #16
Schwarzenegger and Republicans are used car salesman. ffr Mar 2015 #18
All the Republican governors are following the Brownback playbook to one degree or another. Enthusiast Mar 2015 #19
There are two very different Californias. Throd Mar 2015 #20
There is nothing in that article that says there isn't poverty. upaloopa Mar 2015 #27
A liberal Democratic governor and state leg hifiguy Mar 2015 #26
Austerity works for no one but the top 1%. TAX THE RICH! Dont call me Shirley Mar 2015 #30
Somebody in CA better figure out a way to synthesize dihydrogen monoxide or all this won't mean jack tularetom Mar 2015 #31
California has also reinstated tax credits the Republicans eliminated from our budget. Kablooie Mar 2015 #33
THIS is the message that Democrats should shout from the roof tops in 2016. bvar22 Mar 2015 #34
The story here is about "the Tax Foundation" campaign of misinformation SleeplessinSoCal Mar 2015 #36
My sister in law lives in Arizona another right wing shit hole kimbutgar Mar 2015 #38
Very happy in Jerry Brown's California. Thank you. JDPriestly Mar 2015 #39
When it comes to road quality... awoke_in_2003 Mar 2015 #41
KnR for my home state. Glad to be here. Hekate Mar 2015 #45
when will people wake up and see this santroy79 Mar 2015 #46

el_bryanto

(11,804 posts)
1. Hmmmm - you mean spending money making the state better makes the state better?
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 08:20 AM
Mar 2015

That's so crazy it just might work. And apparently does.

Bryant

BlueCaliDem

(15,438 posts)
15. Jerry Brown and our Democratic Legislature faced a $42 billion, not $27 billion dollar deficit
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 10:33 AM
Mar 2015

left by Republican Schwarzenegger and filibustering Republican State Senators (they refused to raise taxes on the wealthy).

In little over 5 years, Jerry Brown and strong Liberal Democrats in our Legislature turned that $42 billion dollar deficit into a $4.2 billion dollar surplus...and growing. And part of that surplus has allowed California to reinstate Denti-Cal for adults - something that was removed in 2009 under Schwarzenegger due to Republican coddled deficits.

JDPriestly

(57,936 posts)
40. But remember, the majority of the good citizens of our state voted to raise our taxes.
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 11:06 PM
Mar 2015

We were all behind Jerry Brown -- at least us Democrats.

Love Jerry Brown. We especially appreciate him when we compare him to the Republicans that preceded him -- Schwarzenegger, Wilson and Deukmejian.

dorkzilla

(5,141 posts)
17. Yes, and if you explain this all to them (about California that is)
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 10:44 AM
Mar 2015

They just look at you wearily and shake their heads and say “that’s what the liberals want you to think!”.

CrispyQ

(36,464 posts)
21. The republican party has caused so much harm to this country,
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 11:20 AM
Mar 2015

I'm about at the point of questioning my relationships with all republicans. My politics defines a big part of who I am, my world view. If one is voting for mean-spirited, small-minded assholes, what does that say about them?

Populist_Prole

(5,364 posts)
23. I know what you mean
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 12:26 PM
Mar 2015

The same thing you speak of is severely straining some long time friendships. It makes me wonder; What kind of people are they turning into?

Martin Eden

(12,867 posts)
24. Many people who vote for R's are simply misinformed
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 12:46 PM
Mar 2015

I work with a very smart young lady (mid 30's) who is an excellent industrial engineer with an outstanding work ethic. She's a good person who is not selfish or mean to others. She votes R because she has bought into the perception that Dems are all about giving free handouts to people who are capable of working but lack the work ethic to make the necessary effort to support and better themselves. She's a believer is "small government" and pointed to Solyndra as an example of government overreach.

Like the vast majority of people she was never exposed to the information (until I told her) that the program related to Solyndra has a higher success rate than the average for private business ventures and the program has yielded a net profit for taxpayers. Most people lead very busy lives and don't bother delving into alternate sources of information outside the corporate media. She sees the national deficit as primarily the result of the welfare state and inherent government inefficiency than astronomical military spending and starving the government of funds by letting the uber-wealthy and highly profitable corporations find loopholes & tax shelters to avoid paying their fair share to support the sysytem that allowed them to accumulate such wealth.

Don't give up in friends & family who have been manipulated into voting against btheir own best interests. We can never defeat the Republican Party if we alienate them and push them farther away.

Martin Eden

(12,867 posts)
28. Fairly clueless about policitcs, yes
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 03:29 PM
Mar 2015

Like so many people, her opinions were formed on the basis of very little good information and a big chunk of how she was brought up and what her parents believed. Pretty much zero effort is spent exploring other sources to be better informed. Has a demanding job and a 3-year old at home.

People can be very intelligent yet disengaged from real poliitcal involvement & discovery, yet vote nevertheless. Millions of folks like her, who are unlike the rabid teabaggers & bible thumpers. They have the potential to be persuaded, but that possibility diminishes considerably when treated with contempt by those who expect them to know better.

F4lconF16

(3,747 posts)
44. +1
Wed Mar 18, 2015, 12:59 AM
Mar 2015

Know some otherwise wonderful people who are conservative because of bad information and the way they were raised. They support liberal ideas, just vote republican. Part is church, part is affluence. They're not super rich, just well enough not to worry. They're just genuinely misinformed, and they listen to me talk about socialism and the insane right. They actually are trying to learn new ideas, even if they don't necessarily agree with them. Of course, one of them has a sister who brought up Benghazi the one time we met, so apparently they're liberal compared to the family.

Martin Eden

(12,867 posts)
28. Fairly clueless about policitcs, yes
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 03:29 PM
Mar 2015

Like so many people, her opinions were formed on the basis of very little good information and a big chunk of how she was brought up and what her parents believed. Pretty much zero effort is spent exploring other sources to be better informed. Has a demanding job and a 3-year old at home.

People can be very intelligent yet disengaged from real political involvement & discovery, yet vote nevertheless. Millions of folks like her, who are unlike the rabid teabaggers & bible thumpers. They have the potential to be persuaded, but that possibility diminishes considerably when treated with contempt by those who expect them to know better.

cui bono

(19,926 posts)
35. She sounds like she gets her news from Faux News. She may be smart but she is just ignorant
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 07:26 PM
Mar 2015

that they are lying to her. Those beliefs of hers are rw talking points, so if she only listens to rw news/radio then she doesn't hear the truth. That's the problem with allowing Faux to call themselves "news". People who don't really look into politics on their own just assume that they are telling the truth, after all, they are dressed up as a news organization. If you didn't know anything about it and turned on the station you would think they were telling at least some semblance of the truth since they are supposed to be "news".

Perhaps you could ask her where she is getting that information and then ask her to fact check it online.

 

Thor_MN

(11,843 posts)
37. About a decade ago, my sister said they "had found WMD in Iraq" I told her there was not one
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 08:06 PM
Mar 2015

substantiated report, that every breathless report had been walked back in the wee hours a couple days later.

Her response? "Are you sure?"

To this day, she believes Saddam had chemical weapons ready to go.

bigbrother05

(5,995 posts)
5. Guess letting the "job creators" keep their taxes in the hope it will trickle down
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 09:16 AM
Mar 2015

doesn't work as well as a coherent plan to use taxes for the overall betterment of services and infrastructure for everyone.

Jon82

(92 posts)
43. Big corporations are not greedy in the least
Wed Mar 18, 2015, 12:11 AM
Mar 2015

Of course, the idea of trickling down works. Every corporation believes in the long term goal of benefiting others in order to create long lasting benefits for themselves. They would never only look for huge profits that only benefit those in the top. Any idea otherwise is ludicrous.

a kennedy

(29,663 posts)
7. Wait, what about Phil Mickelson saying California's taxes are to high......
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 09:35 AM
Mar 2015

Ugh...... such a whiner.....

Cryptoad

(8,254 posts)
9. But, But ,,,, But,,,,,
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 09:39 AM
Mar 2015

them CA folks are living in Sin and the whole things is going to slide into the Ocean by the Wrath of God

Fuddnik

(8,846 posts)
10. And the asshole Governors of Texas and Florida keep trying to pilfer California businesses.
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 09:47 AM
Mar 2015

I think Rick Scott is out there right now trolling.

erronis

(15,258 posts)
12. Thats's the GOP mantra in VT also
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 09:53 AM
Mar 2015

"Vermont is a horrible place to do business because of all the taxes."

However there are new businesses popping up here and doing quite well (for a state with the population of San Francisco.)

Maybe we can get the remnants of that tattered GOP to move to Kansas. My apologies to Mt. Oread...

Stryst

(714 posts)
13. But,but...
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 10:19 AM
Mar 2015

If California spends all that money instead of giving it to billionaires, then how will it trickle down to us peasants? /sarcasm

BlueCaliDem

(15,438 posts)
16. Actually, Schwarzenegger and Republicans expanded our deficit to $42 billion, not $27 billion.
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 10:35 AM
Mar 2015

Just like his good friend, G.W. Bush, Schwarzenegger and California Republicans kept the true numbers off the books until Jerry Brown became governor and Californians elected more Democrats to unseat Republicans in our Legislature.

ffr

(22,670 posts)
18. Schwarzenegger and Republicans are used car salesman.
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 11:09 AM
Mar 2015

Actually, they give used car salesman a bad name with their bait-n-switch election slogans. My significant other at the time fell for it. I explained to her that electing Schwarzenegger would result is more chaos, but she did so anyway. She believed in their campaign rhetoric. It didn't help that as times got worse, with the budget shortfalls and dear-in-the-headlights look on Arnold's face that I would rub it in. "See!! I told you so."

Enthusiast

(50,983 posts)
19. All the Republican governors are following the Brownback playbook to one degree or another.
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 11:15 AM
Mar 2015

What a country!

Throd

(7,208 posts)
20. There are two very different Californias.
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 11:17 AM
Mar 2015

Sometimes they are only a mile apart. California is one of the leaders in poverty and income inequality. I think the people who write these rosy articles have never been more than 15 miles from the coast.

upaloopa

(11,417 posts)
27. There is nothing in that article that says there isn't poverty.
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 03:26 PM
Mar 2015

But we are not afraid to use government to offer services to the poor.

 

hifiguy

(33,688 posts)
26. A liberal Democratic governor and state leg
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 03:15 PM
Mar 2015

turned Minnesota around nicely. The multi-billion dollar defecit left by Timmeh the Tool Pawlenty is now a $2 billion surplus and the economy is bouncing along nicely save for Target. Education has been dramatically re-funded. Taxes were raised on the 1%. It all works, people. We look across the river at Snotty Scotty's Wisconsin and laff our asses off.

tularetom

(23,664 posts)
31. Somebody in CA better figure out a way to synthesize dihydrogen monoxide or all this won't mean jack
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 04:16 PM
Mar 2015

Kablooie

(18,634 posts)
33. California has also reinstated tax credits the Republicans eliminated from our budget.
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 07:25 PM
Mar 2015

Movie and TV tax breaks are back which means the runaway productions that have been shooting anywhere but California will be able to move back.

The reason they are needed is that the movie and TV industry is different from most industries. Most manufacturing companies have to pick a location and deeply invest to settle there. Movie productions are mobile and can be shot just about anywhere in the world. They are short term and don't need capital to build permanent facilities so they go where ever they can get the best deal.

Tax breaks were eliminated from California so productions have been leaving the state in droves along with the myriad of support jobs. Now that they are back, carpenters, electricians, painters, drivers, caterers, and many other jobs will return to our state.

(A side note: There was a production I know of who's story took place in modern Salem Mass. It was found to be too expensive to shoot there so they looked at other states that would be cheaper. Then they found Canada would be still cheaper to shoot in. But finally they settled on New Zealand. It would be cheaper to build a whole American town from scratch there than to shoot in the real location. Movie economics are weird. )

bvar22

(39,909 posts)
34. THIS is the message that Democrats should shout from the roof tops in 2016.
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 07:25 PM
Mar 2015

Do you think they will plaster this across America?


...I don't think so because that message would upset their Republican friends.


Its all a big club,
and YOU ain't in it.
-- George Carlin

SleeplessinSoCal

(9,120 posts)
36. The story here is about "the Tax Foundation" campaign of misinformation
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 07:52 PM
Mar 2015

Why aren't they exposed for peddling bullshit?

kimbutgar

(21,148 posts)
38. My sister in law lives in Arizona another right wing shit hole
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 09:12 PM
Mar 2015

She told us that they are cutting school funding do bad that schools will be open only 4 days a week and they will no longer be funding junior colleges in their new budget. My sister in law said when her youngest graduates high school in 3 years she's leaving the state. She now appreciates Jan Brewer and my Mother in law who retired there calls the new governor a douche bag. She is 84 and rarely ever uses terms like that. The tea bag governor is also slashing funding for seniors. The area my mother in law lives near is tea bag heaven Surprise, Az. A lot of tea bag seniors are going to get literally teabagged by the governor. My mother in law will be ok but I feel bad for my two sisters in law who are struggling.

JDPriestly

(57,936 posts)
39. Very happy in Jerry Brown's California. Thank you.
Tue Mar 17, 2015, 11:03 PM
Mar 2015

You get what you pay for.

Yes, even those of us who don't earn a lot of money pay high sales and other taxes. But what we get makes it worthwhile.

We could do better, but we are far ahead of most other states.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Reich: A Tale of Three S...