General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSomething is rotten in the state of Michigan: American Austerity Politics
6/12/15
This post first appeared at TomDispatch.
Something is rotten in the state of Michigan.
One city neglected to inform its residents that its water supply was laced with cancerous chemicals. Another dissolved its public school district and replaced it with a charter school system, only to witness the for-profit management company it hired flee the scene after determining it couldnt turn a profit. Numerous cities and school districts in the state are now run by single, state-appointed technocrats, as permitted under an emergency financial manager law pushed through by Rick Snyder, Michigans austerity-promoting governor. This legislation not only strips residents of their local voting rights, but gives Snyders appointee the power to do just about anything, including dissolving the city itself all (no matter how disastrous) in the name of fiscal responsibility.
If youre thinking, Who cares? since what happens in Michigan stays in Michigan, think again. The states aggressive balance-the-books style of governance has already spread beyond its borders. In January, New Jersey Governor Chris Christie appointed bankruptcy lawyer and former Detroit emergency manager Kevyn Orr to be a legal adviser to Atlantic City. The Detroit Free Press described the move as a state takeover similar to Gov. Rick Snyders state intervention in the Motor City.
And this spring, amid the hullabaloo of Republicans entering the 2016 presidential race, Governor Snyder launched his own national tour to sell the Michigan story to the rest of the country. His trip was funded by a nonprofit (fed, naturally, by undisclosed donations) named Making Government Accountable: The Michigan Story.
...As the governor jaunted around the country, Ann Arbor-based photographer Eduardo García and I decided to set out on what we thought of as our own two-week Magical Michigan Tour. And while we werent driving a specially outfitted psychedelic tour bus we spent most of the trip in my grandmothers 2005 Prius our journey was nevertheless remarkably surreal. From the southwest banks of Lake Michigan to the eastern tips of the peninsula, we crisscrossed the state visiting more than half a dozen cities to see if there was another side to the governors story and whether Michigan really was, as one Detroit resident put it, a massive experiment in unraveling US democracy....
For the 5 stops on the "tour", please read more~
http://billmoyers.com/2015/06/12/michigan-a-magical-mystery-tour-of-american-austerity-politics/
A Flint resident at the march demanding clean water.
The Marathon tar sands refinery in southwest Detroit.
Residents march during a #BlackLivesMatter protest on May 1, 2015, in Ann Arbor to call for an independent investigation into Aura Rossers death.
The smashed glass of the front entrance of Martin Luther King Jr. Elementary School, which closed after students fled the charter school district.
1939
(1,683 posts)Counties, cities, towns, and villages are not "sovereign" in the sense that states are. Depending on the wording in the individual state constitutions, the state has the ability to create (i.e. incorporate) its political subdivisions. With the decline in the Michigan economy, many of its urban and rural government entities are in financial trouble. Should a state just let them go smash? Should a state step in and try to save the entity?
RiverLover
(7,830 posts)That debt and deficit fear-mongering success led to the election of so-called fiscally responsible and austerity-minded governors in 2010 that promptly used every means at their disposal to enact Draconian spending cuts; not to reduce state debts and deficits, but to fund tax cuts for corporations and the rich. One of the means employed by Michigan Governor Rick Snyder to impose austerity on the state was appointing emergency financial managers to run cities like dictators with unchallengeable power.
Today there are numerous Michigan cities and school districts run by one state-appointed Koch acolyte under Michigans emergency manager law enacted by governor-turned-dictator Rick Snyder; all under cover of every economys death knell austerity. Of course, it is austerity meant only for government and the population; not the rich or corporations. The idea of imposing harsh cost-saving measures is a nothing more than cover for a democracy-killing fascist coup by Koch Republican Governor Rick Snyder.
Some Americans may recall that Snyders dictatorial power-grab under the guise of Republican austerity does much more than abolish democracy by stripping residents of their local voting rights and voices; it gives Snyders appointed demi-gods unquestioned power to do any and everything that strikes their fancy including, but not limited to, eliminating a citys charter, dismissing democratically-elected officials, shuttering schools, and ending services the emergency manager deems too costly such as delivering safe drinking water. It is, according to Snyder, all in the name of good old Republican fiscal responsibility and austerity politics; something Snyder traverses the nation to spread to all 50 states....
http://www.politicususa.com/2015/06/10/koch-republican-austerity-killing-michigan-democracy-poisoning-residents.html
Its a big FAIL.
Its just too bad no one encouraged companies to keep making products in the US, or MI & other states wouldn't be so broke. We could have enacted laws protecting jobs in the US. Our trade deficit in one month is around $40 Billion.
Imagine what that money could do if it was spent for US made products. But no, we had to make stockholder's profits more important than US communities.
And now they're making things worse with their austerity...
1939
(1,683 posts)US defense spending and trade policy are not the provinces of governors and legislatures. They have to deal with "what is" and not what, in a perfect world, they would want it to be. The major case in point was the Detroit bankruptcy. Detroit was going bankrupt both as a result of tax paying industries moving out, white (and black) tax payer flight out of the city, a bloated city work force, and a kleptocratic government that would put a third world country to shame. Mr Orr, a Democrat, came in and arranged the bankruptcy so that the bondholders took a haircut, the water and sewer system was saved, and the retirees had their cost of living increases capped. There was not the political will on the council nor in the office of the mayor to do anything but close their eyes and cover their ears. As soon as things were cleared up, Mr Orr turned the city back to elected officials and they are running the city with the books cleaned up. Think of it as the financial equivalent of martial law where the Natl Guard comes in when the local police force is overwhelmed.
The point in my post wasn't that it was the wise thing to do (which it was) but the fact that states have the power to revoke corporation charters (municipalities are incorporated by the state). Here in Florida, we are just celebrating the 100th anniversary of the state removing what is now Broward County from Dade County and creating a new county. States have a lot more authority over their subdivisions than the federal government has over the states. States can divide cities, consolidate cities, incorporate new cities, etc..
Autumn
(45,108 posts)Rec