Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

abelenkpe

(9,933 posts)
Sun Aug 9, 2015, 11:00 AM Aug 2015

Homme de Plume: What I Learned Sending My Novel Out Under a Male Name

Homme de Plume: What I Learned Sending My Novel Out Under a Male Name


http://jezebel.com/homme-de-plume-what-i-learned-sending-my-novel-out-und-1720637627

The plan made me feel dishonest and creepy, so it took me a long time to send my novel out under a man’s name. But each time I read a study about unconscious bias, I got a little closer to trying it.

I set up a new e-mail address under a name—let’s say it was George Leyer, though it wasn’t—and left it empty. Weeks went by without word from the agents who had my work. I read another study about how people rate job applicants they believe are female and how much better they like those they believe are male.

(snio)

I sent the six queries I had planned to send that day. Within 24 hours George had five responses—three manuscript requests and two warm rejections praising his exciting project. For contrast, under my own name, the same letter and pages sent 50 times had netted me a total of two manuscript requests. The responses gave me a little frisson of delight at being called “Mr.” and then I got mad. Three manuscript requests on a Saturday, not even during business hours! The judgments about my work that had seemed as solid as the walls of my house had turned out to be meaningless. My novel wasn’t the problem, it was me—Catherine.

I wanted to know more of how the Georges of the world live, so I sent more. Total data: George sent out 50 queries, and had his manuscript requested 17 times. He is eight and a half times better than me at writing the same book. Fully a third of the agents who saw his query wanted to see more, where my numbers never did shift from one in 25.

(more at link)

19 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Homme de Plume: What I Learned Sending My Novel Out Under a Male Name (Original Post) abelenkpe Aug 2015 OP
What you report is not surprising. MineralMan Aug 2015 #1
Very interesting. mnhtnbb Aug 2015 #2
Wow, really? abelenkpe Aug 2015 #6
I'd say it's, at the very least, a factor. OriginalGeek Aug 2015 #18
One day, many years ago, I received in the mail, CrispyQ Aug 2015 #19
A few years ago I was perusing the library & saw they had 5 copies of "Cuckoo's Calling" CrispyQ Aug 2015 #14
Interesting post. smirkymonkey Aug 2015 #3
It's the same in the world of art lunatica Aug 2015 #4
I had lunch with a client that stunned me. progressoid Aug 2015 #7
yup. mopinko Aug 2015 #8
CG animation isn't exactly dominated by women either abelenkpe Aug 2015 #11
I would say millions of women, not just hundreds or thousands lunatica Aug 2015 #12
Me too abelenkpe Aug 2015 #17
George Eliot and Robert Galbraith would never resort to such trickery Orrex Aug 2015 #5
Neither would Andre Norton Hekate Aug 2015 #13
So fucking depressing..... Adrahil Aug 2015 #9
Yep abelenkpe Aug 2015 #10
Interesting article & not surprising. CrispyQ Aug 2015 #15
Please do :) nt abelenkpe Aug 2015 #16

MineralMan

(146,333 posts)
1. What you report is not surprising.
Sun Aug 9, 2015, 11:15 AM
Aug 2015

I'm a writer, as is my wife. I've seen the bias, and have seen it overcome in the end. Both of us have been successful with our work, which is 100% non-fiction. Neither of us has had much luck with fiction, although I've had a few short stories published.

A very good post. Thanks.

mnhtnbb

(31,405 posts)
2. Very interesting.
Sun Aug 9, 2015, 11:20 AM
Aug 2015

Made me look up J K Rowling. Turns out her publishers asked her to use initials--
because they thought her target audience would be young boys--and having a woman
author wouldn't help to sell the books.

abelenkpe

(9,933 posts)
6. Wow, really?
Sun Aug 9, 2015, 11:54 AM
Aug 2015

Do men choose books by gender? Don't think i've ever taken that into consideration.

Article was super interesting and a bit disheartening. i have a name that could be for a boy or a girl. When accepted to graduate school my acceptance letter was addressed to Mr. My Name. Was very nervous about traveling across country for my first day. Happened twice when being called in for job interviews, too. Can't help wondering now how many opportunities were denied me based on gender.

OriginalGeek

(12,132 posts)
18. I'd say it's, at the very least, a factor.
Mon Aug 10, 2015, 11:50 AM
Aug 2015

I can only speak of my personal experience which is that I was a voracious reader of Sci-Fi starting from the first Robert Heinlein book my dad gave me when I was in 5th grade. I had a public library card and I wore it out. There are some absolute powerhouses in the field of female Sci-Fi authors. If I look back honestly at my younger self I am pretty sure I skipped female authors until I had nothing else to read. To my detriment of course.

Thankfully I got over that and I don't think I was even consciously avoiding female authors - I would just go to the library and start whatever series caught my eye. I often checked out 5~10 books at a time and since this was in the days before internet I had no real way to get reviews of anything. I picked based on title or cover art or maybe a friend's recommendation.

I have no idea if I was a typical 11 year old boy - from about that point on is when my mother got remarried and religious so I didn't have a lot of social contact outside of church. But I was always allowed to read and was encouraged to go to the library (I could get to it on my bike easily). A boy left alone with little guidance but armed with a library card and a thirst for anything to escape into but too dumb to know yet that you can't judge a book by its' cover. Or author.

CrispyQ

(36,527 posts)
19. One day, many years ago, I received in the mail,
Mon Aug 10, 2015, 05:37 PM
Aug 2015

an application for a green American Express card addressed to Ms. CrispyQ & an application for a gold American Express card addressed to Mr. CrispyQ.

CrispyQ

(36,527 posts)
14. A few years ago I was perusing the library & saw they had 5 copies of "Cuckoo's Calling"
Mon Aug 10, 2015, 11:07 AM
Aug 2015

by Robert Galbraith. I'd never heard of him & I thought, "Five copies of a book by someone I've never heard of?" I read the jacket & discovered Galbraith is actually J K Rowling. The book was just okay.

lunatica

(53,410 posts)
4. It's the same in the world of art
Sun Aug 9, 2015, 11:33 AM
Aug 2015

And in too many other professions. I'm old enough to remember having serious conversations with men about women's intelligence compared to men's.

The idea was/is that men are superior because of their hormones and women are inferior because of theirs.

The remark made by Trump regarding Megan Kelly was common back then.

sigh... the more things change the more they stay the same...

progressoid

(49,999 posts)
7. I had lunch with a client that stunned me.
Sun Aug 9, 2015, 12:02 PM
Aug 2015

Three men, including the owner, manager, me and one woman in marketing. The owner of the establishment had never met me before. I was the only one not on his payroll but he talked to me rather than to the female marketer. She was in charge of the whole campaign. He never even made eye contact with her.

It was sickening.

mopinko

(70,239 posts)
8. yup.
Sun Aug 9, 2015, 12:06 PM
Aug 2015

gave up seeking fame and fortune in the art world knowing that a woman in her 50's had a snowballs chance. even tho i stand by the work i did, and it was new and groundbreaking in an area (clay) where there is little new under the sun.
the fact that my paintings were about motherhood and my life didnt help.

abelenkpe

(9,933 posts)
11. CG animation isn't exactly dominated by women either
Sun Aug 9, 2015, 02:53 PM
Aug 2015

Once had a supervisor come to my desk late one evening during crunch time and tell me he owed me an apology. I asked why. He said he didn't hire me at first because I was a girl and he figured I had help with my reel. (I was hired two weeks after several of my male friends and former coworkers.) He said he was wrong, I was a strong employee and he'd reconsidered his opinion of female animators as a result. I was floored. Very glad that my male friends changed his mind and gave me that chance. Wonder how many talented women don't get that chance though?

lunatica

(53,410 posts)
12. I would say millions of women, not just hundreds or thousands
Sun Aug 9, 2015, 03:00 PM
Aug 2015

Not all men get a chance either though. I've seen some breathtaking talent in young men passed over too.

CrispyQ

(36,527 posts)
15. Interesting article & not surprising.
Mon Aug 10, 2015, 11:12 AM
Aug 2015

Loved this part:

He is eight and a half times better than me at writing the same book.




Mind if I cross post this in the Writing forum?
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Homme de Plume: What I Le...