Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I have likely a dumb question, but why is Hungary trying to stop the asylum-seekers (Original Post) RKP5637 Sep 2015 OP
Probably a few reasons HappyinLA Sep 2015 #1
Thanks!!! n/t RKP5637 Sep 2015 #6
Because Germany is not ready to accept them YET. Mass Sep 2015 #2
Thanks!!! n/t RKP5637 Sep 2015 #7
If you have the time, read this blog. It describes the difficulties these countries have Mass Sep 2015 #8
It is, it is so sad. n/t RKP5637 Sep 2015 #12
Prime Minister is from national conservative party. dogman Sep 2015 #3
yup, nicely summarized. MBS Sep 2015 #4
This accounts for how they are treated, not why they cannot leave for Germany. Mass Sep 2015 #5
Probably want to stop the flow dogman Sep 2015 #10
It isn't a dumb question at all. Years ago, the EU created what was called the Schengen Zone LittleBlue Sep 2015 #9
Thank you very much! I was really getting confused! RKP5637 Sep 2015 #13
Serbians have been generous to them and welcomes them to settle there. Aerows Sep 2015 #11
Thanks Aerows! RKP5637 Sep 2015 #14
"They want to go to Germany and Scandinavia because they believe they will get free houses, free pampango Sep 2015 #15
If that is a back-handed way of calling me Aerows Sep 2015 #17
Here's a novel idea, defund the weapons industry so people can live in peace. Fuck the war industry. Dont call me Shirley Sep 2015 #16
One little spinning ball of dirt we all live on in a far corner of the universe and many RKP5637 Sep 2015 #18
Not all humans are blood thirsty genocidalists, just a few rotten apples ruin it for the whole bunch. Dont call me Shirley Sep 2015 #19
So true! It's usually a few of TPTB that drag down entire nations. n/t RKP5637 Sep 2015 #20

HappyinLA

(129 posts)
1. Probably a few reasons
Fri Sep 4, 2015, 03:58 PM
Sep 2015

What happens if the train gets to the German border and Germany says no? Hungary is stuck with folks it's not equipped to deal with.

What happens if the train gets to Germany and now every goes "we can escape through Hungary" and they're swamped with refugees that they aren't equipped to deal with.

Or folks just go, "Hungary is far enough, we'll stay here".

They're in a pickle where they don't have the resources to handle a major influx of refugees and are scrambling to stop it from turning into a flood. Sadly, they don't seem to be getting help from their neighbors.

Mass

(27,315 posts)
2. Because Germany is not ready to accept them YET.
Fri Sep 4, 2015, 04:00 PM
Sep 2015

Yes, they have announced they will accept 800,000 people during the next year, but not yet.

Now, what do we do with these people as they are here NOW? That should be the question.

Also, Hungary does not have a border with Germany



They would have to go through Austria or Slovenia. I am not sure whether these countries agree.

Mass

(27,315 posts)
5. This accounts for how they are treated, not why they cannot leave for Germany.
Fri Sep 4, 2015, 04:07 PM
Sep 2015


The fact that there is no border between Germany and Hungary may be part of the problem, among other things.

This New York Times seems to point to this direction

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/cp/reporters-notebook/migrants/hungary-treatment-refugees

The trains to Gyor pulled out about an hour late. Some believed they were going to Germany. Others realized they would not go beyond the border towns, but said that was good enough. They would just get out there and walk across the border.

About half an hour later, the first train stopped. It was not at Gyor. It was at Bicske, the site of a migrant camp, only about 25 miles from Keleti station. The police were waiting. They surrounded the train.

“I don’t want to stay,” one woman shouted at the police through a train window. “Let me off. I want to go back to Syria.”

The clever ones, and the lucky ones, had stayed behind. Slowly, they drifted back to the underground concourse at Keleti station and took up their positions again, as if nothing had happened. The children played ball; the men played cards; the women waited.

dogman

(6,073 posts)
10. Probably want to stop the flow
Fri Sep 4, 2015, 04:37 PM
Sep 2015

without being stuck with the people. Seems like another way to achieve self-deportation. If you look at the right wing in this country you realize that their belief is reason enough.

 

LittleBlue

(10,362 posts)
9. It isn't a dumb question at all. Years ago, the EU created what was called the Schengen Zone
Fri Sep 4, 2015, 04:23 PM
Sep 2015

by a treaty called the Schengen Agreement. This created a free area of travel and work mobility. Someone from Poland, for instance, could now job-seek in France. It's a good system, but one of the pitfalls is that many nations did away with border immigration checks. After all, the Schengen Zone wanted to make a common border across the many countries so the people within could move freely. Why spend billions policing the outdated national borders? So the border checks occur on the border of the zone, not the borders of individual countries within.




As you can see, Hungary guards the Schengen Zone's southeastern border. If an immigrant gets by Hungary, he/she has virtual free movement between countries due to the change in border procedures.

So to answer your question, Hungary is obligated to police the borders of the zone for all other members of the zone. Not just Germany, because everyone else is affected

 

Aerows

(39,961 posts)
11. Serbians have been generous to them and welcomes them to settle there.
Fri Sep 4, 2015, 04:39 PM
Sep 2015

So far, only 500 have taken them up on the offer.

Hungary has offered then asylum, too, but since they are part of the Schengen Area, the refugees take advantage of that to move to Austria and Germany. They don't want to settle in Serbia or Hungary. If I was a refugee, practically, I'd want to go to the place where I thought I would benefit the most.

The problem is that there aren't enough resources to go around, and these folks have no intention of going home once they arrive in Europe.

They want to go to Germany and Scandinavia because they believe they will get free houses, free cars, etc. by virtue of being there.

I have to honestly admit that I have to question why they don't want to transform their own country into a place worth living in rather than go to a place that is kind but overburdened already.

pampango

(24,692 posts)
15. "They want to go to Germany and Scandinavia because they believe they will get free houses, free
Fri Sep 4, 2015, 05:30 PM
Sep 2015

cars, etc. by virtue of being there. "

Do you have evidence that this is why "they want to go to Germany and Scandinavia" and that "these folks have no intention of going home once they arrive in Europe."

That sounds like typical RW rhetoric that refugees are either "welfare moochers" if they don't work or "job stealers" if they do. At least they are not depicted as "rapists and drug dealers".

If liberals view the refugees this way, I can hardly imagine how conservatives must view them. They might as well go back to Syria and take their chances with Assad and ISIS.

I hope I am never a war refugee.

 

Aerows

(39,961 posts)
17. If that is a back-handed way of calling me
Fri Sep 4, 2015, 05:42 PM
Sep 2015

an isolationist or a racist because I state whatSyrian refugees have also stated, then go right ahead.

There are all manner of reflections on the refugee crisis, not the least done by those that are refugees themselves. It's a horrible situation - they can't go home, and the places where they are cope with a strained system to help them.

I don't have a solution for how to aid them, and sending them back to be murdered in their homelands is also not an option.

It's a messed up situation.

RKP5637

(67,112 posts)
18. One little spinning ball of dirt we all live on in a far corner of the universe and many
Fri Sep 4, 2015, 05:57 PM
Sep 2015

spend their lives perfecting weapons to better kill others and on a more massive scale. Just WTF is mankind trying to accomplish. So much of our world is sick!

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I have likely a dumb ques...