General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWill Pitt: The Deadly Fraud of "American Exceptionalism"
The Deadly Fraud of "American Exceptionalism"
Thursday, 08 October 2015 09:54
By William Rivers Pitt, Truthout | Op-Ed
Doubtless you have heard more than once the term "American Exceptionalism." It implies, in short, that we are somehow special, different, superior. We are the "city upon a hill" whose freedoms and accomplishments set us apart. Alexis de Tocqueville coined the phrase midway through the 19th century, and it has enjoyed constant deployment by politicians and pundits ever since, because it lights a warm bulb of self-satisfaction in many bellies ... and people feeling good about themselves are easier to convince. Salesmen thrived on this axiom before Babylon's bricks were laid.
For the sake of comparison, here's something exceptional: MÇdecins Sans Frontiäres. Founded in France, the organization is most commonly known in the US as Doctors Without Borders. Made up of more than 30,000 medical professionals, administrators and logistical experts, this organization provides vital health care in places mired in war and strife: Sudan, Rwanda, Sierra Leone, Sri Lanka, Nigeria, Afghanistan ... sadly, the list has included some 70 countries over the intervening years, and does not stop. Military personnel have a saying: "Run to the sound of the guns." Doctors Without Borders volunteers do exactly the same thing.
This past weekend, Doctors Without Borders volunteers were treating people in a hospital in Kunduz, Afghanistan, when the building erupted in fire and screaming. A US airstrike by a massive AC-130 gunship laid an ocean of ordnance on the building at fifteen-minute intervals for more than an hour, and when it was over, 22 people were dead including three children and ten Doctors Without Borders staff members. One nurse who survived recounted how the hospital was all but destroyed, and when the survivors went in to look, they found six patients on fire in their hospital beds.
For its part, the US said it wasn't us, then said it might have been us, then said the hospital was a nest of Taliban fighters - a claim the doctors dispute vehemently - before saying Afghan officials asked us to do it. Yesterday, President Obama personally apologized to Dr. Joanne Liu, the organization's international president, for the attack. Doctors Without Borders is not having it, and is not mincing words. Immediately after the attack, the organization's General Director, Christopher Stokes, said, "We reiterate that the main hospital building, where medical personnel were caring for patients, was repeatedly and very precisely hit during each aerial raid, while the rest of the compound was left mostly untouched. We condemn this attack, which constitutes a grave violation of International Humanitarian Law." The organization's Executive Director, Jason Cone, described it as the "darkest couple of days in our organization's history," before going on to call the attack a "war crime." After the apology, Dr. Liu demanded an independent investigation into the incident. ...................(more)
http://www.truth-out.org/opinion/item/33155-the-deadly-fraud-of-american-exceptionalism
haikugal
(6,476 posts)Helen Borg
(3,963 posts)haikugal
(6,476 posts)11 Bravo
(23,926 posts)I wish he'd rethink his absence. Sure, a few shitheads might heckle from the cheap seats for a while; but on balance I'm confident he would be overwhelmingly welcomed.
MuseRider
(34,112 posts)I had not seen this yet, would have eventually wandered over to TruthOut or saw it posted on FaceBook but this was just the right time to read it. Thank you.
I too wish he would come back but really, I have a hard time coming here anymore so I can't really even consider wanting someone else to come back.
ryan_cats
(2,061 posts)Deadly fraud indeed.
Who invented this worldwide connection of computers?
Where is the French flag located on the moon?
On the plus side, Rove is sure to be indicted soon.
1monster
(11,012 posts)"If you can't say something nice, it's a good day to give your mouth a day off."
You could extrapolate that to "it's a good day to give your fingerd a rest."
ryan_cats
(2,061 posts)That would be wonderful advice if my family could have afforded to send me to school, but I see it as hateful.
1monster
(11,012 posts)no tuition and attendance is state mandated -- unless you are being educated at a private school or are being home schooled? In the U.S.? I'm sorry that you missed out. But it is never too late for education, formal or otherwise.
ryan_cats
(2,061 posts)To be sure, the institution I'm currently 'residing' in has a fine library where my cellys can educate me on the ways of the world.
1monster
(11,012 posts)but if I take it that you are an involuntary guest of the state, then you have time for education. Just choose your curriculum wisely.
Most of those institutions do not allow residents to have an internet connection.
trumad
(41,692 posts)Snarking Will Pitt with the Rove shit.
It's old and worn out.
ryan_cats
(2,061 posts)I should move on. I've already forgiven GWB for 9/11 and Iraq.
trumad
(41,692 posts)daleanime
(17,796 posts)Divernan
(15,480 posts)stupidicus
(2,570 posts)by all means, name us another country with an empire to expand and preserve that leads to BS like that.
and, let's quibble, shall we? http://www.slate.com/blogs/lexicon_valley/2013/09/27/american_exceptionalism_neither_joseph_stalin_nor_alexis_de_tocqueville.html
lark
(23,134 posts)exceptionally wrong and bad when it comes to killing innocent people. I rail about Israel indiscriminately murdering Palestinians, then we do the same, maybe even worse, in Afghanistan. The military people that were actually involved in this committed a heinous crime. If Obama truly cares, heads will roll. Guess we will see if this is just more lip service.
cpwm17
(3,829 posts)Last edited Thu Oct 8, 2015, 02:19 PM - Edit history (1)
Some Americans think that we are the special ones and it should be obvious to everyone. That gives us a special right to commit mass-murder around the world and not be held accountable - because when we do it we mean well, unlike those scary brown foreigners.
Hulk
(6,699 posts)...and it has been a myth or memory ever since.
The U.S. American is no more "exceptional" than the German, French, English, Canadian, Mexican, Chinese, Indian, Afgan, Israeli, etc, etc. it's sickening to even hear such pompous dumb ass holes use this phrase, other than to refer to that brief period of time. In fact, the U.S. American was realistically no more "exceptional" than any other person walking on the earth at that time either. It was just that we enjoyed a prosperity after our involvement in defeating the AXIS powers and bathing in "the American Dream" for a short generation of white population.
It grinds my stomach to hear some of the dumbest, most spoiled and least deserving of any respect embrace this phrase as though it implies they are something more than anyone else. I'll say it again....I've been traveling to Europe since the summers of 1966, '67, '68, '70 and from then on, and I've been downright ashamed and embarrassed by the boastful and pompous attitudes of my fellow countrymen abroad much of the time. This air of superiority is such a pathetic characteristic of an undeserving society.
Something I would expect to ONLY hear about on fox-nonsense.
Zorra
(27,670 posts)sellitman
(11,607 posts)DU is less without him.
Much
Octafish
(55,745 posts)Dulles Brothers saw it as a cowboy movie, where the big rancher really was the law where his ranch resided. Too bad, so sad about the original occupants and their land, buffalo, corn, gold, silver, copper, tin, oil, etc.
pampango
(24,692 posts)not insist on setting and enforcing the rules for the whole world and acting with impunity.
hifiguy
(33,688 posts)Great to see Will's writing on DU again.
Man, I miss him.
gademocrat7
(10,664 posts)I miss Will.
I don't normally read Will a lot, that was very good.