Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

leveymg

(36,418 posts)
Sat Nov 28, 2015, 02:09 PM Nov 2015

Turkey unilaterally moved border 5 miles south into Syria in '12 prompting shootdown of Russian jet

One major fact has been ignored in most western coverage of the Turkish attack on a Russian jet since the shoot down earlier this week.

There is a reason a Russian pilot ignored Turkish warnings that it was approaching Turkish airspace. That is because the Russian plane was operating within Syrian airspace until just 17 seconds after the Russian jet crossed the actual border. The missing context to this incident is that for three years the Turkish military has been threatening to fire on aircraft that enter a unilaterally declared no-fly zone that extends five miles into Syrian territory.

Most Americans never learned the fact, as The UK Guardian reported, that Turkey has set up a no-fly zone into Syria which the Russians have now challenged: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/26/russia-turkey-jet-mark-galeotti

In 2012, the Syrians shot down a Turkish jet which had entered its airspace, and Erdoğan’s furious response at the time was that “a short-term border violation can never be a pretext for an attack”.


McClatchey was one of the few exceptions in the U.S. media to have reported this important fact. That wire service reported on October 4 an incident on the Syrian border with Turkey near where the shootdown of a Russian SU-24 occurred last Sunday. The article highlighted the risk of further incidents of this sort involving Russian aircraft operating against opposition encampments on the border. Three years ago, Turkey unilaterally claimed a no-fly zone five miles deep into Syria, and has since maintained its threat to shoot down aircraft that approach the border. Opposition groups fighting to overthrow the Syrian government have taken this as an opportunity to set up camps along that de facto border safe zone.

Turkey has maintained a buffer zone five miles inside Syria since June 2012, when a Syrian air defense missile shot down a Turkish fighter plane that had strayed into Syrian airspace. Under revised rules of engagement put in effect then, the Turkish air force would evaluate any target coming within five miles of the Turkish border as an enemy and act accordingly.

Al Yamdiyyah hosts a tent camp for internally displaced Syrians and a hospital, run by the French-based Doctors Without Borders. The bomb struck in the village just a few hundred yards from the actual border, wounding several townspeople, local residents said. The Doctors Without Borders hospital, which is about 50 yards from where the bomb landed, was damaged and evacuated.

The town, in a mountainous region of northern Latakia province, has been a prime route for smuggling people and goods between Turkey and Syria and reportedly has functioned as a key entry for weapons shipped to Syrian rebels by the U.S.-led Friends of Syria group of Western and Middle Eastern countries.

Read more here: http://www.mcclatchydc.com/news/nation-world/world/article37739349.html#storylink=cpy
5 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Turkey unilaterally moved border 5 miles south into Syria in '12 prompting shootdown of Russian jet (Original Post) leveymg Nov 2015 OP
Love that Erdogan quote from 2012! Comrade Grumpy Nov 2015 #1
Conclusion doesn't follow from the premise. Igel Nov 2015 #2
Erdogan clearly triggered the conflict with Russia riderinthestorm Nov 2015 #3
Very nice bit of obfuscation. elias49 Nov 2015 #5
Kick LiberalArkie Nov 2015 #4
 

Comrade Grumpy

(13,184 posts)
1. Love that Erdogan quote from 2012!
Sat Nov 28, 2015, 02:47 PM
Nov 2015

Turkey is a bad actor in all this. It's an ISIS enabler. It would rather fight Kurds than ISIS. And it has been deeply involved in trying to overthrow the government of its neighbor, Syria, and not for any good reasons.

Igel

(35,374 posts)
2. Conclusion doesn't follow from the premise.
Sat Nov 28, 2015, 03:36 PM
Nov 2015

We had a no-fly zone in Libya.

It wasn't "US airspace." The border in Syria wasn't moved by Turkey any more than the Libyan border was by Obama or Berlusconi or Hollande.

No-fly zones are also tricky things. NATO had a Libyan no-fly zone, the US/allies had an Iraqi no-fly zone. Oddly, things flew in the no-fly zone without being shot down. Not all identified flying objects are downed. No-fly zones are typically goal-specific, but in this case it's thoroughly decontextualized, allowing us to feed into the zone whatever meaning we wish.


Warnings aren't just given after a border is crossed. Warnings are given when they're approached and the plane's course, if continued, would take it over the border. It's giving the other side the benefit of the doubt.


As for the 2012 quote, it's cherry-picked--good for feeding confirmation bias, not so good for feeling syllogisms and well-grounded arguments. What's the context? Was it after the Syrians gave the Turks a number of warnings during one incident? Was it after the Syrians gave the Turks a number of warnings spread out over several incidents? Had the Syrians said that the next incursion, specifically across their border, would be met per the rules of engagement?


Inquiring minds want to know.

Those not so inquiring, not so much.

 

riderinthestorm

(23,272 posts)
3. Erdogan clearly triggered the conflict with Russia
Sat Nov 28, 2015, 03:48 PM
Nov 2015

similarly, they unilaterally extended "their" airspace five miles into Syria. That's not a "no fly zone", that's Turkey deciding to create their own artificial buffer (in order to protect the smuggling lines it supports for ISIS).

Turkey seems to be the bad actor in all of this. Erdogan is every bit as megalomaniac as Putin it seems.

 

elias49

(4,259 posts)
5. Very nice bit of obfuscation.
Sat Nov 28, 2015, 05:53 PM
Nov 2015

IMO, this is important information.
You're just picking different cherries.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Turkey unilaterally moved...