General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe (right-wing) conspiracy theorists who have taken over Poland
Jarosław Kaczyński has convinced Poland that it is threatened by a shadowy leftwing cabal and become the countrys most powerful manWith a penchant for conspiracy and a vituperative speaking style, Jarosław Kaczyński routinely brands his opponents gangsters, cronies, and reds. Before the parliamentary elections in October 2015, he claimed that migrants from the Middle East were bringing cholera and dysentery to Europe, risking the spread of various parasites and protozoa. More recently, he implied that people demonstrating against the Law and Justice government were the worst sort of Poles an epithet they have adopted as a badge of honour.
Commonly labelled conservative or nationalist, Law and Justice blends the religious and patriotic rituals of Polands long history of resistance to foreign oppression with hostility to free-market capitalism and a heavy dose of conspiracy regarding the machinations of Polands enemies. It is the vanguard of a movement that goes far beyond the party itself, supported by sympathetic smaller parties, ultra-Catholic media, nationalist youth organisations and an assortment of cranks and cynics who share a hostility to liberalism in all its guises. As foreign minister Witold Waszczykowski told the German tabloid Bild, his government only wants to cure our country of a few illnesses, such as: a new mixture of cultures and races, a world made up of cyclists and vegetarians, who only use renewable energy and who battle all signs of religion What moves most Poles [is] tradition, historical awareness, love of country, faith in God and normal family life between a woman and a man.
And yet a significant minority of Poles believe that Poland and Polishness remain subject to foreign control and malign internal forces. It is a belief rooted in Polands traumatic past and the chaos and controversies of its post-communist transition encouraged by Jarosław Kaczyńskis consistent assertions that this transition was, in fact, a sham. Polands present turmoil is the story of how anger at Polands liberals mutated into a war on liberal democracy itself.
It is an assertion that depends on the notion of Poland eternally under siege. There is no consensus as to precisely who or what poses a threat it could be Russia or the European Union, it could be multiculturalism, it could be homosexuality, it could be western consumerism, it could be Jews or reds under the bed. What matters is the idea that Polands liberals, with their commitment to the nations existing institutions and nostalgia for its cosmopolitan past, are doing nothing about it. It is not nationalism in the traditional sense but something less coherent, more akin to a mood than an ideology a narrative of righteousness, victimhood, and self-pity from which anyone can pick their prejudices as they see fit.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/feb/16/conspiracy-theorists-who-have-taken-over-poland
bemildred
(90,061 posts)When you try to change too much, you get reactionary movements. We have several here, so does Poland, ISIS is a reactionary movement. People who want change mostly want change that goes back to something, people who like novelty and disorder are unusual, and dangerous, and useful.
Reactionary movements, as the article notes, generally don't make a lot of sense. But they don't care because they think they remember what they think they want.
This has much to do with the repeated failures of the liberal interventionists and their utopian gambles wherein one rips out the old order in some benighted foreign country and starts anew, as for example Bremer's Folly in Iraq, which has produced precisely the results that everybody said it would at the time.
pampango
(24,692 posts)True. And change from the established order risks disadvantaging those who currently benefit from the established order, e.g. majority ethnic and religious groups, the economic elite, etc. They have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo.
Well said. The 'good ol' days' always seem to be better than they actually were because people "remember what they think they want". Our republican base does exactly that in reaction to "too much change" although I am not sure what "too much change" they are reacting to other than a Black president and 'too many' minorities in the US. I don't see that the 'too much change' that Poland's and our reactionaries hate includes 'liberal interventionism'. Too many of them seem to be arguing for more 'interventionism' at least of the military variety.
bemildred
(90,061 posts)Generally, people like new tech, up to a point, new weapons, tools, or toys, but they don't like having their economic and social arrangements disturbed. And the older they get, the more they feel that way.
And once again, reactionaries don't make sense, arguments based on logic will not work. They want what they want. On the other hand, if you don't get in a hurry, the old farts die off and the kids are more open to new ideas, so if you take it slow, you do things that are downright impossible if you try to hurry them.