General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forums"Hitler Grandma" Picture Gets Context
[img][/img]
We've all seen the pic at this point, but I really didn't want to really get into it until I had some context. The gent in the picture hsa provided that context now via his FB post:
So here's my story about this picture, and I promise you it's the god honest truth :
my friend Sean Kavanagh and I are walking out of the UIC Pavilion filled with some of the most palpable joy I've ever experienced. We did it. We fought for the truth and for a moment, a brief day, WON.
As we are leaving Trump protestors form small sections, small channels where Trump supporters can pass through to exit (a kindness which isn't quite afforded in the inverse when ya know, people get sucker punched being forced out of Trump rallies).
As people are walking out we're saying things like "Bye racists", "You lost. Please just go home now." bc many are leaving with shoves and shoulder checks, begrudgingly, but most with pent up fury.
The woman pictured with me and what looks to be her husband we're stragglers in the pack, and started responding to people's jeers. Some guy ripped a sign out of the man's hands and another man leapt out of nowhere, encouraging everyone around to respect them and let them leave (again, sometimes America is amazing).
This woman is a human being and although I don't share her views, I start yelling "I will respect my elders. Please. Leave." and a few other great folks and I start to clear the path. I walk right up to her and say "Ma'am we have listened to you. We understand this is all a little wild but we have cleared a path for you to leave *my right hand was constantly swinging in motion, showing her the path out we made for her, as shown in the photo*"
She goes, and I quote "Go? Back in my day, you know what we did-"
Bam. Hail's Hitler.
I go "Ma'am you are endagering your life doing this. LEAVE. TAKE YOUR HUSBAND AND LEAVE." (I mean, anyone who knows me knows I get loud, so you know, sorry about that.)
And she won't. She won't budge. A young woman comes up to me and says "She wants this. Leave her be." looks to her and goes "God bless you. I hope you make it home safe." and I walk away from her astounded.
I have never experienced anything like tonight. To see America rise up for a man who hates so much of it, then for him to get checked so wonderfully by a city I love so much, and then for his followers to scream and cackle to the bitter end.
So many fights were stopped. So many people protected others instead of encouraging mayhem. Don't believe the hype : protestors only stoked a fire in these people that was born long before they had Trump to personify it.
Hate is real my friends. Vicious, hurt you if you aren't watching, worse if they can get away with it indignance was in so many eyes there.
I say that bc know this : hope is real too. Hope that when we stand up against hate from time to time, and collectively, we can defeat it. Or at least silence that beast, for one damn night.
We are at a point in America where those people, Trump supporters, make me sad. But the ones who make me angry? The incredibly intelligent, brightest minds I know, who sit on their hands and do nothing, don't vote, don't volunteer, and pretend as though their knowledge abdicates them from action.
The world is broken, I learned that best from Christianity. But I don't believe even one thing on this Earth is beyond repair, and I learned that from Christianity too.
You don't have to share my belief in Christianity, but I am asking you to stand up against hate. Or this woman's slanted arm never bears a greater weight than her own ignorance. She may never get the shot to understand love, living in the world where that symbol actually rules again.
Don't let that happen. Do something. Please, for the sake of everyone, do something.
Laf.La.Dem.
(2,945 posts)Vote AGAINST the GOP!!!
n/t
SCantiGOP
(13,873 posts)noamnety
(20,234 posts)underpants
(182,883 posts)Blue_Adept
(6,402 posts)So was definitely glad that those involved were able to provide the context. It makes it even more chilling.
3catwoman3
(24,051 posts)...someone who was right there in the thick of it.
Blue_Adept
(6,402 posts)vintx
(1,748 posts)saying it was her and she's a plant from the Sanders campaign.
Rightwing crazies will believe anything to preserve their delusions.
Blue_Adept
(6,402 posts)A lie travels faster, of course.
chade
(103 posts)That was in the afternoon before this picture. If she's a plant she was in it for the long con yesterday.
liberalnarb
(4,532 posts)C Moon
(12,221 posts)hopefully.
These freaks so often do that.
tblue37
(65,488 posts)people tend to flock with those who share their deepest values and beliefs, but beyond her racist, ate-filled circle, she will be vilified, and the internet is forever.
I hate the way people attack and bully others online--and even carry their online attacks out into the real world--no matter how awful the person being attacked has behaved. But I predict that this woman's life is about to become a living hell.
3catwoman3
(24,051 posts)And if so, she hill have earned every minute.
Spitfire of ATJ
(32,723 posts)It needs to go home, it's drunk.
Dont call me Shirley
(10,998 posts)mountain grammy
(26,655 posts)I hear it from my Christian in laws.
Jenny_92808
(1,342 posts)They were....up is down...right is wrong...wrong is right...hateful idiots!
I am glad I divorced that guy who later murdered his 5th wife (I was his 1st wife).
MisterP
(23,730 posts)passiveporcupine
(8,175 posts)From a pure clean slab of concrete a weed can grow.
But I prefer your usage of it.
Loki
(3,825 posts)when hatred comes so up close and personal. A sick feeling in your stomach and a soul shaking fear that it could happen here, it could happen again. Being silent isn't an option anymore.
DesertRat
(27,995 posts)madamesilverspurs
(15,809 posts)The man standing right behind her -- is he wearing a yarmulke? If so, it's a remarkable counterpoint to her gesture.
awoke_in_2003
(34,582 posts)denvine
(802 posts)I had copied the picture from a previous post because, pictures are worth a thousand words, but to have the context is even more chilling.
flamingdem
(39,328 posts)hardcore white supremicist? Doing a Hitler salute? Can these really be?
PatrynXX
(5,668 posts)well that was rather fitting. how is Donald Hitler doing. Naturally blame the jews. that went well. Now Republicans are stuck with someone they don't want but fully approved by Faux.
Bernardo de La Paz
(49,043 posts)Ilsa
(61,698 posts)Identify them and boycott their businesses and ostracize them socially. We need to let them know that they don't represent God, Jesus, or anything decent with their hate.
Lifelong Protester
(8,421 posts)About the context I expected. Unfortunately.
ConsiderThis_2016
(274 posts)Christianity is simply the child of religion in general, so to are all the other faiths based on faith instead of facts. If you're going to point fingers at somebody's belief that rests on faith alone and disregards the facts, you have to accept the fact that others will embrace a different viewpoint. There are a lot of thoughtful and caring believers the world over... as many as a faith can manifest. When many of the religious power brokers get behind the Trump organization with their support, you may then understand why the numbers just don't add up.
This clip is from some very intelligent former Christian faithful, some folks will refer to them as "Back-Sliders". I respect your creator's gift of thought, as long as it benefits all humanity. TY
progressoid
(49,999 posts)Duval
(4,280 posts)Bestuserever
(95 posts)Skwmom
(12,685 posts)"As people are walking out we're saying things like "Bye racists", "You lost. Please just go home now." bc many are leaving with shoves and shoulder checks, begrudgingly, but most with pent up fury."
There are a lot of issues in this country which need to be fixed (especially in the black community). To do this we need to get as many people as possible on board. Race should never be used a political tool.
To call someone a racist that you don't even know is unbelievable. There are racists that support Democrats and Republicans. To accuse unknown individuals of racism does NOTHING to heal this nation or move it forward. And when real incidences of racism occur that need to be addressed, people won't be so inclined to believe them. It's the same with the way Clinton has used sexism to try to score political points.
Note: And all of the Bernie supporters I know that are "real" Bernie supporters would also think these kind of actions are not okay.
MuseRider
(34,120 posts)when I read it. Anger must at times take a back seat. They already won by stopping the rally so why inflame them more? I can't imagine someone who is not a racist supporting Trump at this point but in order to become the society we want we have to lead and that means controlling our own impulses at times. I don't think that is real popular right now, especially at a Trump rally. They will learn. I cannot say that I blame them. They will learn.
21st Century Poet
(254 posts)But shutting a rally down and then expecting the rally attendees to be nice to you is more than a little strange, even if you keep insisting that you respect your elders.
I'm not defending that woman's actions at all but this gentleman comes across as a bit too sanctimonious for my liking. If people wanted to be home, they would have stayed home in the first place so being nice to them while telling them to go home doesn't quite cut it.
This man is a good man fighting for a good cause but I'm sure that he would have been none too happy if protesters shut down a Clinton or Sanders rally and then nicely told him to go home.
I think the best option would have been, as someone else on Democratic Underground has suggested, a large but silent protest outside the arena. In my opinion, this would have got the media's attention without getting the bad press.
Tikki
(14,559 posts)Think that choice through.
Tikki
21st Century Poet
(254 posts)The Nazi salute is awful but, quite frankly, so is calling random people racist. The former might never have happened without the latter first taking place.
Tikki
(14,559 posts)Tikki
Warren DeMontague
(80,708 posts)The fact that you're falling all over yourself with "but" here, is interesting.
rockfordfile
(8,704 posts)Not surprised the Republican supporters are racist because the republican candidates are racists.
21st Century Poet
(254 posts)My post is less about the salute and more about this gentleman's story, personal portrayal and expectations.
So let's look at it from a rally attendee's point of view: It's a cold Friday night but you make the effort of driving a long way and waiting in a long queue to attend a political rally to listen to what a presidential candidate has to say, as is your democratic right.
Then, while you are waiting for the event to start, a group of people who you have never met in your life enter the venue, call you a racist, take a political sign out of your hand and rip it up and create an atmosphere which results in the cancellation of the rally.
While others are celebrating the cancellation of the political rally you were keen to attend, a man who portrays himself as a saviour of old ladies nicely tells you to go home. What do you do? Do you tell him "Thank you, kind sir, for having had a hand in ruining my evening's plans and spoiling my chance to listen to what this presidential candidate has to say. I will do as you ask and quietly go home." or do you tell him to take a walk?
The Nazi salute is the wrong reaction but if you cannot understand why the rally attendees were furious at having the rally shut down, then you have no empathy. When assessing a situation, always try to imagine what the situation for people on the other end of your own is like. How this man is expecting rally attendees to be grateful after having had a hand in shutting down the event they were keen to attend is beyond me.
In my opinion, the protest was worthy but it should have been done in a way which gets the message across but does not disrupt other people's plans.
gollygee
(22,336 posts)I assure you that it is much worse to be racist than to call someone racist.
21st Century Poet
(254 posts)When you raise your hand in the air, you are doing something.
When you vocalise and project words out of your mouth, you are doing something as well.
Both are public gestures directed at others and neither of them is very nice. One could argue that one is worse than the other but don't delude yourself into thinking that one is 'doing' and the other is 'not doing'.
gollygee
(22,336 posts)And in many cases it is a justifiable accusation.
Jackie Wilson Said
(4,176 posts)OneGrassRoot
(22,920 posts)is that this paragraph needs to be read again:
They weren't calling all attendees racists as they left the building; they were responding to people spewing racial slurs and even being physical.
IsItJustMe
(7,012 posts)Millions of Jews died and that salute was at the center of it. Calling someone a racist far less egregious, by orders of magnitude. I don't think you argument and comparison is appropriate at all.
nichomachus
(12,754 posts)That was the way US schoolkids saluted during the Pledge of Allegiance until WW2. Maybe that's what she meant by "back in my day."
OhioBlue
(5,126 posts)More likely, her family was involved in the Klan.
pansypoo53219
(20,997 posts)BeatleBoot
(7,111 posts)SujiwanKenobee
(290 posts)The way you wrote it, I am thinking that she was calling you and the protesters Little Hitlers, the way that some people will do a mock salute and Ja Wohl, mein Fuhrer. It was likely a well of feeling from being frustrated from having a rally and perceiving the cause to be the protesters pushing their own view, preventing the Trumpettes from having their own day in Illinois. I do think also, that not everyone attending goes for the most base reasons. So
some just want to see what the carnival show is like, they're curious. Others just don't want to be Democrats. So I think "'Bye Racists" just was inflammatory and threw fuel on the fire.
rockfordfile
(8,704 posts)As I said before, not surprised racist Republican supporters go to a racist Republican candidate rally. The Republican party is a fascist political party.
felix_numinous
(5,198 posts)to run for president. Anyone who knows him must know how racist and emotional volatile and unstable he is, so I consider it irresponsible.
Hekate
(90,824 posts)All Trump needs at this point is a little arson at the Reichstag, because he's been fomenting violence for months. He's not afraid of it -- he wants it, he just won't be there in person when it happens.
He must be stopped.
Sienna86
(2,149 posts)Thanks for sharing.
Uncle Joe
(58,424 posts)Thanks for sharing, Blue_Adept.
IronLionZion
(45,534 posts)who fought against the nazis and fascists.
steve2470
(37,457 posts)"I make the point that they are demonstrating something they had no knowledge about," she said. "If you want to do it right, you do it right. You don't know what you are doing."
It was then that she gestured in a Nazi salute.
"Absolutely I'm not a Nazi, no," she said. "I'm not one of those.
This is her version of events.
powergirl
(2,393 posts)So, nothing to see here.
Diclotican
(5,095 posts)powergirl
She could have had parents who was a tiny bit involved in the former regime, after all in 1946 it was just a year after the end of the war - and right up to the end of the war, had Hitler an iron clad support by many germans - including in Berlin, who other vice was rather "un-friendly" to the nazi-ideology even after 12 years of the nazi-rule.. It is a reason Hitler wanted to tear down Berlin, and rebuild it as Germanica after the war... And it was not just because he wanted to make an expression of himself to the future....
Many germans was never "denazifized" in the general term of the world - or was just deemed to have been "follower but not a criminal" and therefore just kept off the hook easy enough.... Even if their harbored nazi-ideology for the rest of their lifer's - and many of them, emigrated later on to other parts of the world - including USA, who in the aftermath of the war, had some soul-searching to work on - as many who had german decent in USA, had been more than just a little sympathetic for the nazi cause...
Diclotican
forest444
(5,902 posts)Regardless of how careful most of them are from being quite this visual about it.
PatrickforO
(14,592 posts)Protesters are being forcibly removed, and he is blaming Bernie supporters for any violence. Trump is calling Bernie a communist and agitating the crowd against he and his supporters.
If you'll recall, in Germany in the 1930s, followers of Adolph Hitler hit the streets and terrorized people. They met the left wing in bloody riots and ended up winning because they were willing to lie more and be more violent. Then, when they took power, we all know what happened.
The rest of the civilized world could not tolerate them, and they started a great war. It took 12 years and 80 million lives to get rid of Hitler.
What, we wonder, will it cost us to get rid of Trump and his white supremacists?
raging moderate
(4,309 posts)In fact, selah!
tclambert
(11,087 posts)ghostsinthemachine
(3,569 posts)"'We Aren't Nazis' Says Husband Of Woman Who Saluted At Trump Rally" - http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2016/03/12/trump-rally-nazi-salute-husband_n_9448092.html
nadinbrzezinski
(154,021 posts)ScreamingMeemie
(68,918 posts)1936 anymore.
AgadorSparticus
(7,963 posts)0rganism
(23,970 posts)Skittles
(153,193 posts)nxylas
(6,440 posts)Bill Corbett (Mystery Science Theater 3000, Rifftrax) tweeted last night that he'd never imagined Carla from Cheers to be a Nazi. Now I can't unsee that.
Blue_Adept
(6,402 posts)rhett o rick
(55,981 posts)Establishment (The Ruling Class). We ignore this at all of our peril. If Clinton runs against an anti-Establishment Republicon candidate SHE WILL LOSE. We will all lose. Don't let the smug hubris of the Establishment push Clinton into the General.
We are fighting a war against the corrupt Establishment that has drained our (the People's) resources for 30 years to fill their wallets. Why would a sane Democrat support the Establishment. They don't love you they love wealth and power.
lark
(23,156 posts)Beautiful moving post. Be safe!