General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNYT: Why Do We Feed Wild Animals? (Americans spend over $3 billion each year on food for wild birds)
Sustenance 79, from a series titled Sustenance, shows a scene near the photographers balcony in Framingham, Mass. Credit Neeta Madahar
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/10/magazine/why-do-we-feed-wild-animals.html
On Nature
By HELEN MACDONALD JAN. 6, 2016
White-haired, with a faintly aristocratic glamour, Mrs. Leslie-Smith lived alone in a wooden bungalow full of books and glossy houseplants a few doors from my childhood home. One warm autumn evening more than 30 years ago, she invited my mother and me to watch her nightly ritual. She scattered broken cookies outside her garden doors, where they glittered dustily under the light of an outside lamp. We sat in the darkened room and waited. A striped black-and-white face appeared at the edge of the illuminated lawn. Then, out of the night, two badgers trundled across the grass to crunch up the cookies, so close to us that we could see their ivory teeth and the patterned skin on their noses. They werent tame if we had turned on the light, they would have bolted but I wanted to press my hands to the glass to get closer to them, to somehow make them understand I was there. The space between us in the house and these wild creatures in the garden was filled with unexpected magic.
We didnt feed badgers in my childhood home, but we fed the birds in our garden. So do a fifth to a third of all households in Australia, Europe and the United States. Americans spend over $3 billion each year on food for wild birds, ranging from peanuts to specialized seed mixes, suet cakes, hummingbird nectar and freeze-dried mealworms. We still dont clearly understand how supplementary feeding affects bird populations, but theres evidence that its enormous increase in popularity over the last century has changed the behavior and range of some species. Many German blackcaps, for example, a kind of migratory warbler, now fly northwest to spend the winter in food-rich, increasingly temperate British gardens rather than flying southwest to the Mediterranean, and feeding may be behind the northward spread of northern cardinals and American goldfinches.
Putting out food for birds in your backyard can attract predators, and virulent diseases like trichonomosis or avian pox can be spread through contaminated feeders. But even if its impact is not always positive for wildlife, it is for us. We give food to wild creatures out of a desire to help them, spreading cut apples on snowy lawns for blackbirds, hanging up feeders for chickadees. The British nature writer Mark Cocker holds that the simple, Franciscan act of giving to birds makes us feel good about life, and redeems us in some fundamental way. This sense of personal redemption is intimately tied up with the history of bird-feeding. The practice grew out of the humanitarian movement in the 19th century, which saw compassion toward those in need as a mark of the enlightened individual.
In 1895, the popular Scottish naturalist and writer Eliza Brightwen gave instructions on how to feed and tame wild red squirrels to become household pets of their own free will. In Britain, garden feeding was popularized by the formation in the late 19th century of the Dicky Bird Society, a childrens organization that required members to take a pledge to be kind to all living things and to feed the birds in wintertime. The society was highly influential, even receiving letters from workhouse children explaining that they saved crumbs from their own meals to feed to the birds outside.
FULL story at link.
gollygee
(22,336 posts)She loves to sit in the window and watch the birds.
Fresh_Start
(11,330 posts)in the spring and summer its for our family's (including cats) pleasure.
I also put out plants for butterflies and bees.
bluedigger
(17,086 posts)And I do mean in the window.
Fast Walker 52
(7,723 posts)We actually get a fair amount of bird and small critter traffic even without a feeder though.
ScreamingMeemie
(68,918 posts)Bella got to him before I could, and he sacrificed a rear leg and too much of his tail for it to grow back properly. I saved him with a water glass and took him out back. To this day, I swear he runs out to greet me (he's fast on those two legs) every day when I come out. He also taunts the cats, safely, from the other side of the window now.
We feed the feral cats
Fast Walker 52
(7,723 posts)There's a bird feed store next to a dance studio I go to regularly, and it's freaking unbelievable how much business that place does all the time, people walking out with huge bags of feed. It's got to be messing with our wildlife.
LeftyMom
(49,212 posts)Calista241
(5,586 posts)farleftlib
(2,125 posts)NO matter what I do they still get into the bird seed feeder I use.
I guess I feed the birds because then all the pretty ones come to my yard. Nothing
against the sparrows but the cardinals and gold finches really make my day.
2naSalit
(86,628 posts)massive habitat loss from development, monocrops, forest harvest and war... it might be good that they can find food in our feeders, besides, it makes us feel better that they come to our homes rather having to figure out where they live. Convenience and all that.
hunter
(38,313 posts)From there the birds go off to eat insect pests in my yard.
The smallest birds don't eat from the feeder, but I think having other birds around makes them feel more secure as they go about their usual business of eating aphids and scale insects.
The starlings don't eat from the feeder either, they are too busy searching for snails. Both starlings and snails are invasive species from Europe. Before the starlings showed up here snails had always been a very annoying garden pest.
womanofthehills
(8,710 posts)plus the other birds. I love having ravens in my yard (I live out in the country). At times I've had about 50 ravens all caw cawing - plus I love the way they walk around. They walk like little penguins. I've had a few problems with them going in my house if I leave a door open. They can mess up things really fast. They love mirrors and tossing stuff. My dog loves to chase them but my cats could care less.
FSogol
(45,487 posts)If I don't get up (to put something out for him) by 7, he'll attempt to wake me up, by cawing and looking in my bedroom window. He follows me to work on certain days and follows me to the local library, sitting on the soft top of my jeep while I am inside.
stage left
(2,962 posts)I'm particularly fond of the woodpeckers and the goldfinches.
So Far From Heaven
(354 posts)RobinA
(9,893 posts)We like to watch them. That's why I feed the birds, anyway.
As to why I feed the nonexistent Baltimore Orioles, I don't know. This is my third year of trying to attract them, they are around, just not on the feeder. However, I do enjoy the catbirds that also like grape jelly and orange slices.
FSogol
(45,487 posts)enjoyment out of watching them. I get over a hundred types of birds in my yard. We have also spotted deer, foxes, possums, flying squirrels, gray squirrels, chipmunks, rabbits, and raccoons. I have always valued bio-diversity and hate that many bird populations are threatened. When I travel, I get a neighbor kid to keep my feeders full.