Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

davidn3600

(6,342 posts)
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:08 PM Jul 2016

Hotel clerk fired after calling 911 on Muslim man she thought might be a terrorist

AVON, Ohio - A hotel clerk who told her family she thought a guy speaking Arabic was a terrorist was fired and may even face criminal charges.

A prosecutor is reviewing whether to pursue charges against an Ohio hotel clerk who raised suspicions that an Emirati businessman dressed in traditional clothing could have links to terrorism.

Businessman Ahmed al-Menhali was detained by police at gunpoint last week at an Avon hotel before police determined he wasn't a threat. Police responded to 911 calls from the clerk's family expressing fears that al-Menhali could have ties to the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS.)

The clerk's sister told police he was "pledging his allegiance or something to ISIS."

Al-Menhali's treatment became front-page news in the United Arab Emirates, which has since warned its citizens to avoid wearing traditional garments abroad.


http://www.cbsnews.com/news/ohio-hotel-clerk-fired-may-face-charges-false-isis-accusation/

Here's the problem....the police and the FBI will constantly say, "If you see something, say something."

Is it better to report and be wrong or not report and be wrong? The clerk over-reacted. But are we going to start prosecuting everyone who reports something and turns out to be wrong?

Plus in this case, sound more like the police over-reacted and they're trying to pass the blame.
48 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Hotel clerk fired after calling 911 on Muslim man she thought might be a terrorist (Original Post) davidn3600 Jul 2016 OP
Dressing funny and speaking a different language isn't a cause for suspicion... Humanist_Activist Jul 2016 #1
This message was self-deleted by its author rjsquirrel Jul 2016 #2
Sloppy headline phrasing. The reports (even this article!) all say her *family* called 911, tblue37 Jul 2016 #3
Plenty of blame to go around Xipe Totec Jul 2016 #4
But...but...but...He had the diaper on the hayd an' a fan belt on the diaper!!!111 jpak Jul 2016 #5
I thought Muslims wore turbines on their heads progree Jul 2016 #45
Most Fairfield Inns are franchised. At the risk of sounding as bad as the "family", tonyt53 Jul 2016 #6
If the clerk didn't call, and he was a terrorist...people would be outraged about that too. Kang Colby Jul 2016 #7
You do realize that the recent ISIS killers, or the Orlando killer, wore jeans, don't you? tonyt53 Jul 2016 #8
Oh, for sure. Kang Colby Jul 2016 #11
Let's put it this way... I don't like the color of your hair, I think it is equated to evil. liberal N proud Jul 2016 #12
Not good, I agree. Kang Colby Jul 2016 #14
It needs to be scrapped liberal N proud Jul 2016 #15
Just a few weeks ago DU was filled with posts expressing support Kang Colby Jul 2016 #16
Gun owners are different. It's quite OK to condemn the entire demographic based on the actions Francis Booth Jul 2016 #38
All LaCross players certainly. Katashi_itto Jul 2016 #40
As nasty a lot as they come. n/t Francis Booth Jul 2016 #42
And what if Aladdin has a bicycle? Or a swimming pool? Nt Tommy_Carcetti Jul 2016 #19
Hell, in that case I would call the fuzz myself. Kang Colby Jul 2016 #20
"If you go out in public dressed like Aladdin" anigbrowl Jul 2016 #22
Post removed Post removed Jul 2016 #26
Oh, you're the last person in the world give someone sit but you'll cover for someone else who does anigbrowl Jul 2016 #29
Do you feel better now? Kang Colby Jul 2016 #30
No, because I've had to process a fresh round of idiocy from you anigbrowl Jul 2016 #32
You and I largely agree. Kang Colby Jul 2016 #37
You have been more patient than I uppityperson Jul 2016 #43
"SJW types"? I must be getting old. I googled that and all sorts of weird stuff came up. ck4829 Jul 2016 #33
Social Justice Warrior Kang Colby Jul 2016 #35
It's always easy to take the obvious option after the fact The2ndWheel Jul 2016 #23
As a kid who hung out with the "trenchcoat mafia" at our high school and college... moriah Jul 2016 #41
See something say something is flawed liberal N proud Jul 2016 #9
People who knew the Columbine boys and didn't say anything were vilified davidn3600 Jul 2016 #18
But the opportunity to misuse it is too great liberal N proud Jul 2016 #46
see something say nothing just walk on by DustyJoe Jul 2016 #10
Yup. Kang Colby Jul 2016 #13
'Merican Stasi Rules - not White, nor GOP, not Xtian = Terrorismz jpak Jul 2016 #17
Good to know not everyone has given into paranoia and enabling ck4829 Jul 2016 #27
Neighbors also said this about Ariel Castro after the fact, turned out their stories were fishy ck4829 Jul 2016 #31
Dunno why people have to be fired over every mistake treestar Jul 2016 #21
Nobody wearing a thawb is a terrorist; they pay people to do that for them Recursion Jul 2016 #24
There's a difference between "See something, say something" and "See a Muslim, say something" ck4829 Jul 2016 #25
Watching Fox News is not a criminal offense. rug Jul 2016 #28
Maybe it should be liberal N proud Jul 2016 #48
This clerk would lose her mind seeing all the Arabs in full dress at universal studios kimbutgar Jul 2016 #34
It's because the clerk was ignorant .. as most people are in the U.S. of Muslims. YOHABLO Jul 2016 #36
terrorists don't wear traditional islamic clothing JI7 Jul 2016 #39
A brown person in different clothse isn't the "Something" the cops were referring to, k? uponit7771 Jul 2016 #44
Plus in this case, sound more like the police over-reacted and they're trying to pass the blame malaise Jul 2016 #47
 

Humanist_Activist

(7,670 posts)
1. Dressing funny and speaking a different language isn't a cause for suspicion...
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:13 PM
Jul 2016

Shit, are we supposed to assume that every person speaking Spanish is making a drug deal? Sounds bigoted, possibly even racist and/or xenophobic, doesn't it?

Response to davidn3600 (Original post)

tblue37

(65,394 posts)
3. Sloppy headline phrasing. The reports (even this article!) all say her *family* called 911,
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:21 PM
Jul 2016
not the clerk herself. I can certainly see why she should be fired, but it is her father and sister who should be subject to criminal charges--unless the clerk actually did tell them he pledged allegiance to ISIS (which she claims she neevr said).

jpak

(41,758 posts)
5. But...but...but...He had the diaper on the hayd an' a fan belt on the diaper!!!111
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:25 PM
Jul 2016

He a terrorism!!!1111

We gotta figure out what's going on!!!111

yup

progree

(10,908 posts)
45. I thought Muslims wore turbines on their heads
Thu Jul 7, 2016, 04:27 AM
Jul 2016
Why do Muslim men wear turbines on their head?
They look uncomfortable and hot. Not much of a fashion statement either.
https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20061031150600AA0efV3

 

tonyt53

(5,737 posts)
6. Most Fairfield Inns are franchised. At the risk of sounding as bad as the "family",
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:27 PM
Jul 2016

what was the country of origin of the family? Also, given the country the guest was from, wouldn't he likely have been speaking his native language? How could the family member know what the guy was saying.

 

Kang Colby

(1,941 posts)
7. If the clerk didn't call, and he was a terrorist...people would be outraged about that too.
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:28 PM
Jul 2016

If you go out in public dressed like Aladdin, people might indeed call the fuzz. I'm not saying it's right or whatever, but it's not surprising in the wake of Orlando.

 

tonyt53

(5,737 posts)
8. You do realize that the recent ISIS killers, or the Orlando killer, wore jeans, don't you?
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:34 PM
Jul 2016

Same as with Paris last year, the killings in CA, the killers all dressed like everybody else.

 

Kang Colby

(1,941 posts)
11. Oh, for sure.
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:37 PM
Jul 2016

No doubt.

But when you constantly hear the "if you see something, say something" public safety message - people will report things that *they* think are suspicious. So this clerk sees some dude in his cultural outfit and the clerk thinks he or she hears something about "ISIS". Next thing you know, the cops are involved.

liberal N proud

(60,335 posts)
12. Let's put it this way... I don't like the color of your hair, I think it is equated to evil.
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:39 PM
Jul 2016

So I call the police and turn you in because we don't like your kind.

Try that on and think about it for a while. You of course are perfectly innocent, but that doesn't matter, because you are convinced in a trial of public paranoia.

 

Kang Colby

(1,941 posts)
14. Not good, I agree.
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:45 PM
Jul 2016

But unless you want to scrap the public safety message "see something, say something"...then it is what it is.

 

Kang Colby

(1,941 posts)
16. Just a few weeks ago DU was filled with posts expressing support
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:53 PM
Jul 2016

for banning gun ownership based on whether or not someone was included on a secretive government list. Willing to toss out due process protections for a piece of legislative security theater.

Francis Booth

(162 posts)
38. Gun owners are different. It's quite OK to condemn the entire demographic based on the actions
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 11:57 PM
Jul 2016

of a very, very small percentage.

They're the only demographic that this applies to.

Oh, and men. All men are potential rapists. We don't say it, but we really know we're talking about white men, amirite?

 

anigbrowl

(13,889 posts)
22. "If you go out in public dressed like Aladdin"
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 10:25 PM
Jul 2016

You sound just like the various people I have met over the years that thought it would be OK to queer-bash me because I had long hair, looked too femme etc.. I would like to pose to you the same questions that I posed to them: who the fuck do you think you are? What do you think gives you the right to tell other people how they should present themselves?

If you're going to throw out bigoted opinions like this, then please change your fucking avatar. The rainbow flag does not have a stripe for bigots.

Response to anigbrowl (Reply #22)

 

anigbrowl

(13,889 posts)
29. Oh, you're the last person in the world give someone sit but you'll cover for someone else who does
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 11:09 PM
Jul 2016

So you're a coward basically. Oh, it's just your opinion that Middle Eastern clothes look like Aladdin costumes? Well it's just my opinion that you're a xenophobic bigot that chooses to hitch a ride on other people's bigotry while claiming to be above such things yourself.

 

Kang Colby

(1,941 posts)
30. Do you feel better now?
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 11:15 PM
Jul 2016

Yeah, Aladdin was middle eastern so indeed his outfit was inspired by middle eastern garb.

I have nothing against foreign folks, but you know damn well had this clerk kept his or her mouth shut about a real terror threat people would be screaming about that too.

See something say something = racist

See something don't say something = politically correct response if nothing happens otherwise you are deemed an irresponsible coward.

People are getting too caught up about the dudes costume, the clerk thought the man was on the phone talking about ISIS. Why do you leave out that fact?

 

anigbrowl

(13,889 posts)
32. No, because I've had to process a fresh round of idiocy from you
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 11:38 PM
Jul 2016

'the clerk thought the man was on the phone talking about ISIS'

Unless it turns out that the clerk is a fluent Arabic speaker, I think we can safely discount the clerk's supposed insight into the content of the conversation, because a Middle Eastern person speaking Arabic is suggestive of nothing more than one Arab having a telephone conversation with another Arab.

See, if you hear someone saying 'I'm a pissed-off Muslim, I feel like bringing down some divine wrath on this sinful world using this AR-15 I just bought' then you might well be correct to suspect the person is a radical Islamist. But if you just hear someone speaking Arabic, and you're not fluent in that tongue yourself, then for all you know they're debating whether to get take-out or cook dinner at home, or some other quotidian business or domestic matter.

If I see an orthodox Jew speaking Hebrew, should I assume he's plotting a takeover of the international banking system? That's a stupid question of course, but it's the same sort of stupidity you are bending over backwards to make excuses for.

Just so we're clear, here's some other instances where you should be wary of jumping to conclusions:

* You hear someone speaking Spanish - but they're probably not planning to smuggle people illegally over the Mexican border

* You see someone in a gay-pride t-shirt giggling with another person in a gay-pride t-shirt. Although this looks very suspicious to some chances are they are not conspiring to ass-rape anyone

* You see people attending a mosque on a Friday - but they're probably not calling for 'death to America' even though you saw some people in Iran doing that once on TV

I can't believe I'm having to explain these basic concepts to someone on DU. Frankly I think you'd be happier among a bunch of Trump supporters, who share your disdain of 'political correctness.'

 

Kang Colby

(1,941 posts)
37. You and I largely agree.
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 11:55 PM
Jul 2016

I never said I was supportive of the nonsense, I just understand how something like this happens.

ck4829

(35,077 posts)
33. "SJW types"? I must be getting old. I googled that and all sorts of weird stuff came up.
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 11:38 PM
Jul 2016

Weird crazy stuff that doesn't sound like it was written by people who would consider themselves "SJW types" at all. I hope to be enlightened.

The2ndWheel

(7,947 posts)
23. It's always easy to take the obvious option after the fact
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 10:36 PM
Jul 2016

Say something, and you're wrong, and what, are you scared of your own shadow? Just leave people be. How do you leave the house each day?

Don't say something, and you're wrong, and what, are you not observant? Don't you pay attention to what other people say and do? How do you leave the house each day?

Say something, and you're right, you can look at yourself in the mirror. Don't say something, and you're right, well there's really no story there, that's just another day. There's no winning if you're wrong.

moriah

(8,311 posts)
41. As a kid who hung out with the "trenchcoat mafia" at our high school and college...
Thu Jul 7, 2016, 12:40 AM
Jul 2016

... as in, they liked trenchcoats and dusters and didn't care about the funny looks even after Columbine....

None of them got the cops called on them just for dressing a certain way.

liberal N proud

(60,335 posts)
9. See something say something is flawed
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:34 PM
Jul 2016

It quickly becomes malicious against those one does not like.

Prosecutors claim they will not prosecute a crime without sufficient evidence, now throw in see something and you have the potential for hate fled indictment and retaliation incidents.


A local blog was discussing this, it was quite mixed and messed up.

 

davidn3600

(6,342 posts)
18. People who knew the Columbine boys and didn't say anything were vilified
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:59 PM
Jul 2016

Same with a lot of the other mass shooters and terrorists. Some people who knew Omar Mateen and heard him making homophobic remarks said they were scared to report it because he was muslim and they didnt want to be viewed as Islamophobic.

When those events occur, people ALWAYS ask the question, "Why didn't anyone notice or say anything?" The media will ask that question over and over and over again when an incident happens.

liberal N proud

(60,335 posts)
46. But the opportunity to misuse it is too great
Thu Jul 7, 2016, 07:41 AM
Jul 2016

Between paranoia fed by the propaganda and maliciousness, it is very easy to tread on others civil liberties.

First if someone is speaking another language, it does not mean they are a terrorist or if they are not dressed like you are, they are not a terrorist.
Second, the law enforcement still has an obligation to review all the facts before acting. They need to make sure that someone's Islam phobia isn't the cause of the alert or did they really see them or hear them planning something.

If you see or hear someone say they are going to kill people is a little different than seeing someone wearing traditional middle eastern attire.

DustyJoe

(849 posts)
10. see something say nothing just walk on by
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:36 PM
Jul 2016

Just like the San Bernadino neighbor and the Florida co-workers with mateen.
Afraid to say anything because they feel they will pay the price, and they were probably right.

It's not worth it to say anything, jot down anything that might look important after the fact, but the old mantra of "didn't see or hear nothing" has kept a lot of people out of trouble.

Not worth losing a job or having cops in your face for. Why be viewed as a snitch, bigot or scare monger. CAIR will probably have this woman up on hate crime charges.

The age of the good samaritan died long ago.

 

Kang Colby

(1,941 posts)
13. Yup.
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 09:43 PM
Jul 2016

Add the WDBJ7 shooter to that list where political correctness cost lives. He was a gay black guy that was allowed to run around like a nut at work and people were too scared to do shit about it. Had the authorities pulled him in on an involuntary committment, people would have screamed racism. Hell, the shooter screamed racism every chance he got.

Same thing with the Charleston shooter, his friends including his black friend knew something was up but they said "oh, those nutty statements were just a joke."

ck4829

(35,077 posts)
31. Neighbors also said this about Ariel Castro after the fact, turned out their stories were fishy
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 11:15 PM
Jul 2016
http://www.cnn.com/2013/05/08/justice/ohio-police-investigation/index.html

Sounds like a self-examined rosy retrospection in all these cases, "I could have been a hero, if it wasn't for...". They're not lying, but they are affected by their biases.

treestar

(82,383 posts)
21. Dunno why people have to be fired over every mistake
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 10:11 PM
Jul 2016

How will they learn from that? Will it be tough to get another job? If so, aren't they just going to get bitter? Now if we think she really did it out of hatred of Muslims and there are a lot of potential customers who are Muslims, that might be one thing.

Recursion

(56,582 posts)
24. Nobody wearing a thawb is a terrorist; they pay people to do that for them
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 10:38 PM
Jul 2016

The stupid just gets too thick to deal with sometimes.

kimbutgar

(21,157 posts)
34. This clerk would lose her mind seeing all the Arabs in full dress at universal studios
Wed Jul 6, 2016, 11:53 PM
Jul 2016

In California. Last year we went and saw so many people dressed in Arab attire. In the Middle East areas it is so hot in August they come to Los Angeles to cool off. I loved some of the women's hajabs.

malaise

(269,038 posts)
47. Plus in this case, sound more like the police over-reacted and they're trying to pass the blame
Thu Jul 7, 2016, 07:44 AM
Jul 2016

Both the clerk and the police are racist morons

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Hotel clerk fired after c...