Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
59 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Trump Resistance Needs a New Name (Original Post) IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 OP
"Resistance" has a long and glorious history Warpy Feb 2017 #1
Did you even read the article? His point in the article is the defeated history of "resistance"... IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #2
True, Trump lost the popular vote mvd Feb 2017 #8
I read it Warpy Feb 2017 #41
I think it's better to have something you can leverage into a longer term movement name meadowlander Feb 2017 #14
You are right... IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #20
"The real American dreamers" kimbutgar Feb 2017 #3
I guess Jerry Brown's mostly done with it Brother Buzz Feb 2017 #4
I Pluribus Unum KittyWampus Feb 2017 #5
I think this is why Democrats lose. While Trump and Republicans are stripping us of rights every day Trust Buster Feb 2017 #6
You make a good point, but names ARE important...and Resist is lame IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #7
And I think not keeping our eye on the ball is lame. The Tea Party hung teabags from their hats Trust Buster Feb 2017 #11
So you think if they were reported in the media as the Tea Bags, or the Immoral Minority, they would IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #15
I watched a group of toothless idiots funded by the Koch machine seize power over our government. Trust Buster Feb 2017 #18
The definition is basically mvd Feb 2017 #22
If all we do is "resist" we will always be fighting the power over us.... Sad you don't get it IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #26
And you enjoy thinking up cute jingles. That'll show em. Trust Buster Feb 2017 #46
You degrade yourself by marginalizing this discussion IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #49
Go with whatever name you wish. I will continue to embrace "RESIST." Trust Buster Feb 2017 #50
That's true bdamomma Feb 2017 #9
I use it mvd Feb 2017 #10
I just ordered two custom tee shirts with an understated "Resist." on the chest. It's perfect. Trust Buster Feb 2017 #12
Yeah, I really have no problem with it mvd Feb 2017 #13
Do you guys not get the impotence of "resist" as a word??? IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #16
Because Rethuglicans saw the term "Black Lives Matter" as a sign of strength ? Rethuglicans are Trust Buster Feb 2017 #19
Actually, yes IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #23
I find it a bit presumptuous to redefine the purpose of the millions that have protested the past Trust Buster Feb 2017 #24
I'm not telling you how to feel IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #28
While not in love with Resist, knowing the story of dem4decades Feb 2017 #27
La Resistance was an appropriate name for a guerrilla insurgence in an occupied land. IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #29
Actually... Idoru Feb 2017 #33
Exactly! IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #34
If by "the right puts a lot of thought into shit like this" you mean a CNBC host on the floor of Trust Buster Feb 2017 #57
+1 uponit7771 Feb 2017 #54
"Fuck Trump" or "The Fuck Trump Movement" both work fine. briv1016 Feb 2017 #17
I like "The Resistance" OhioBlue Feb 2017 #21
And you think "resist" adequately conveys our very real majority or our intention to return power? IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #25
I looked up the definition: OhioBlue Feb 2017 #32
+1 uponit7771 Feb 2017 #55
The Tired of Your Shit Party Afromania Feb 2017 #30
Take the Congress. GaYellowDawg Feb 2017 #31
I suggest "SURGE UPWARD" IndianaDave Feb 2017 #35
Reminds me of the Atlanta Falcons slogan: RISE UP IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #37
Thanks for your insight. IndianaDave Feb 2017 #39
Constitution Protectors. I heard we need to spin positive with "protector" instead of "protesters" NightWatcher Feb 2017 #36
I think it needs a little more teeth and hook, but you've got the idea! :) IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #38
Happy to further the discussion. I'm definitely open to improvements and replacements. IndianaDave Feb 2017 #40
how about The Judean People's Front? 0rganism Feb 2017 #42
That's hilarious. I LOVE that movie! IndianaDave Feb 2017 #48
I like Indivisible. susanna Feb 2017 #43
I also like Indivisible LeftInTX Feb 2017 #45
To be fair, I can't take credit for the name! susanna Feb 2017 #51
Indivisible is great! IamFortunesFool Feb 2017 #47
The Patriots LeftInTX Feb 2017 #44
Football and rah rah Republicanism ruined that one. Warpy Feb 2017 #52
I know... LeftInTX Feb 2017 #59
Message auto-removed Name removed Feb 2017 #53
My suggestion, "PEOPLE POWER" b/c we, the people, ARE the power. AgadorSparticus Feb 2017 #56
How 'bout "WE're the Power!" jmg257 Feb 2017 #58

Warpy

(111,277 posts)
1. "Resistance" has a long and glorious history
Fri Feb 3, 2017, 11:58 PM
Feb 2017

and everybody knows what it means. I think it's just fine. We're resisting the destruction of our country.

We don't need self conscious wit defining us. What we're actually about will do nicely.

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
2. Did you even read the article? His point in the article is the defeated history of "resistance"...
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:02 AM
Feb 2017

The connotations of an exploited proletariat... the implication of an angry minority. He's right. Words are powerful. Names even more so... TEA PARTY... MORAL MAJORITY... We need something that can stand against those. "The Resistance" is weak.

mvd

(65,174 posts)
8. True, Trump lost the popular vote
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:29 AM
Feb 2017

We can't be in the minority. Though we ARE in the minority in the Senate and House and do not hold power in any branch of government.

Warpy

(111,277 posts)
41. I read it
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 02:14 AM
Feb 2017

I just thought it was silly. "Resistance" doesn't imply a minority, at all. It simply states things have gotten bad enough to resist because we've been outgunned and outspent and that's the damned truth.

meadowlander

(4,399 posts)
14. I think it's better to have something you can leverage into a longer term movement name
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:37 AM
Feb 2017

It's not just about resistance to everything Trump does. It's about presenting a positive vision of the direction we want to be moving towards and the values that we all share and want to protect. If the Tea Party was just the "Resistance" party they would have dissolved already.

Really it's a movement about fairness, equality, justice, courage, kindness, looking out for each other, not just "resistance".

What about a "Good Neighbors" movement?

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
20. You are right...
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:50 AM
Feb 2017

But while "Good Neighbors" conveys our positive message, it still sounds like it would get beat up by the neighborhood bully. We need something that conveys solidarity, and strength, and vision.

kimbutgar

(21,163 posts)
3. "The real American dreamers"
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:09 AM
Feb 2017

The America that you can inspire to the dream of "having the American dream"

The America where you can make it if you try regardless of your sex, race or religion.

The America where there is justice for all.

The America that will accept what is on the Statue of Liberty

Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses, yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore,
Send these, the homeless, tempest tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door.

The America where you can get a first class education.

The America where you can get Liberty and justice for all.

The America that we care about our fellow Americans.

The America where there is a separation of church and state.

The America that adheres to the laws of our constitution.


Brother Buzz

(36,444 posts)
4. I guess Jerry Brown's mostly done with it
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:11 AM
Feb 2017
About We The People


Who We Are

We The People is a membership association led by the former Governor of California and current mayor of Oakland, Edmund G. Brown, Jr., better known as Jerry Brown.

We The People Legal Foundation, Inc. is a c(3) tax deductible, non-profit corporation dedicated to strengthening the practice of democracy and the ability of people to shape the places where they live.


Where We Are

We The People is headquartered in Oakland, California. For more information contact us at 510-836-DARE. Directions to We The People.


What We Do


Through lectures, seminars, and the Radio Show, We The People has brought together philosophers, artists and activists to discuss and plan ways to work change: Bob Thurman talked about Tibet and monasticism, Helen Caldicot and nuclear physicist Ted Taylor discussed the connection between nuclear energy and nuclear weapons, Earth First! reported on their efforts to stop the destruction of ancient redwood groves, former DEA agents told us about government drug involvement, Ina May Gaskin made a presentation on midwifery, Aitken Roshi spoke on Buddhism and peace activism and Ernest Callenbach talked on ecotopia and voluntary simplicity. We also had a study group that met weekly to explore the writings of Martin Buber, the author of I and Thou. Laura Cutler put together a School of Sustainability which offered a five month course in ecological living. Father Matthew Fox spoke on the reinvention of work and conducted a "Techno Mass" as part of his new University of Creation Spirituality. For six weeks in the summer of 2000 and again in the Spring of 2001, philosopher, historian, and social critic, Ivan Illich was a resident scholar. He and his friends and colleagues from around the world held public lectures and seminars on the recovery of civic virtues in modern time called "The Oakland Table."

......


And I had the pleasure of listening his daily radio program, "We The People" on KPFA for years during my arduous commute back in the day, although there were times I wanted to call his program "I the Person"

http://www.wtp.org/
 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
6. I think this is why Democrats lose. While Trump and Republicans are stripping us of rights every day
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:24 AM
Feb 2017

democrats are preoccupied with jingles. WHAT UTTER NONSENSE !!!!!! It's "RESIST." - Learn it and love it. We have bigger fish to fry......Geez.....

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
11. And I think not keeping our eye on the ball is lame. The Tea Party hung teabags from their hats
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:31 AM
Feb 2017

and held signs proclaiming "Gubment, keep your damn hands off my Medicare". And they frickin won. It's not the name, it's the emotion and perseverance. "RESIST." is just fine.

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
15. So you think if they were reported in the media as the Tea Bags, or the Immoral Minority, they would
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:38 AM
Feb 2017

Last edited Sat Feb 4, 2017, 09:54 AM - Edit history (1)

still have achieved the success they did? Of course they would not. Psychological warfare is part of this game, Friend. "Resistance" is a weak word and a weaker name. Period.

You'd think a party that suffocated itself with identity politics would understand this...

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
18. I watched a group of toothless idiots funded by the Koch machine seize power over our government.
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:46 AM
Feb 2017

They spit on John Lewis and the Black Caucus on the steps of the capital. They obstructed this country's business for eight years after the 2008 financial fraud. If facts mattered, they would not control the whole of Washington. "RESIST." is the perfect phrase. I RESIST what Tinker Bell and the Rethuglicans wish to do to this country. I RESIST it with every ounce of my body. Their behavior is totally unacceptable and I will RESIST. American Fascism.

mvd

(65,174 posts)
22. The definition is basically
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:54 AM
Feb 2017

"To fight against something" or "to try to stop/prevent something" (from Webster online). Personally I think it fits. I respect others who want something different, but we are certainly not taking Trump's fascism laying down or meekly. So the word does fit.

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
26. If all we do is "resist" we will always be fighting the power over us.... Sad you don't get it
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:04 AM
Feb 2017

Enjoy your stubborn "resistance". Let me know when you feel oppressed enough to actually fight, and not just resist.

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
49. You degrade yourself by marginalizing this discussion
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 02:57 AM
Feb 2017

We're not thinking up jingles. We are working to activate our side and fight the opposition with their own weapons, on a level field. Your smug dismissal and stubborn combativeness is exactly the type of empty activism and pseudo intellectualism that has ruined this party. You don't want to actually effect change, you just want to be right. If you were serious, you'd engage in debate, not just cling to your perspective and hurl insults. Sound familiar?

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
12. I just ordered two custom tee shirts with an understated "Resist." on the chest. It's perfect.
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:34 AM
Feb 2017

I can wear it anywhere this spring and summer and everyone will know exactly what I mean. No need to rebrand the truth.

mvd

(65,174 posts)
13. Yeah, I really have no problem with it
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:36 AM
Feb 2017

It is short and sweet. I just like brainstorming for ideas.

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
16. Do you guys not get the impotence of "resist" as a word???
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:43 AM
Feb 2017

It has the connotation of somebody covering their face while they take repeated body blows... they didn't "fight", they "resisted". Psychologically it is weak language and this translates subliminally... It confirms the oppositions impression of us as overly sensitive adult coloring book enthusiast with loose morals.

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
19. Because Rethuglicans saw the term "Black Lives Matter" as a sign of strength ? Rethuglicans are
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:48 AM
Feb 2017

pigs and half of America is asleep. RESIST. !!!!

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
23. Actually, yes
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:55 AM
Feb 2017

That's part of why they fear it and seek to discredit it so much. Black Lives Matter is a great name for their movement.

I see you still obviously haven't read the article I linked to, nor have you offered any reasonable rebuttal to my assertion that "resist" is weak as a word and even more so as a name. You lack vision beyond the emotion of the moment...just like your word, "resist". You are right that half of America is asleep....

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
24. I find it a bit presumptuous to redefine the purpose of the millions that have protested the past
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:00 AM
Feb 2017

two weeks. They showed up to RESIST. It will always be RESIST. to me. That fits my mood perfectly. I will accept no other term and the pioneer protesters will not either IMO. Come up with a cute name if you wish. It is a free country. Just don't tell my how I should feel about this insanity. RESIST. !!!

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
28. I'm not telling you how to feel
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:17 AM
Feb 2017

I am just making the point that "resist" is, psychologically speaking, weak language. I won't debate it with you anymore. You are not the enemy, and I shouldn't waste any more time working to convince you of something you'll obviously never admit. Enjoy your t shirts!

dem4decades

(11,297 posts)
27. While not in love with Resist, knowing the story of
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:11 AM
Feb 2017

The French Resistance I couldn't disagree with you more.

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
29. La Resistance was an appropriate name for a guerrilla insurgence in an occupied land.
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:25 AM
Feb 2017

But the connotations of the word in French are not exactly the same in English.... Nor are we a conquered people relegated to insurgent tactics. Also, the French Resistance did not give themselves that name. They fought back by whatever means they could and the moniker was ascribed to them by onlookers. In that sense, a movement of singular purpose without a name because they had common cause, is a fantastic model and analogy. I would rather we fight our oppressors as a nameless force than capriciously narrow the movements scope and future by naming it "The Resistance".

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
34. Exactly!
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:44 AM
Feb 2017

There is a reason billions of dollars are spent annually by businesses on branding and marketing strategies! We have to level the playing field. We have to use comparable tools and weapons as our opponents or we'll forever be doing the same bayonet charges that got us here in the killing field of their cannon fodder.

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
57. If by "the right puts a lot of thought into shit like this" you mean a CNBC host on the floor of
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 10:11 AM
Feb 2017

the Chicago mercantile exchange blurting out the term "Tea Party", then I strongly disagree that the right puts a lot of thought into anything.

OhioBlue

(5,126 posts)
21. I like "The Resistance"
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 12:52 AM
Feb 2017

To me, it is the good side, fighting oppression. It invokes an image of a group of independent thinkers coming together and resisting the power and those that are either brain washed or only looking out for their own self interests.

We may have gotten 3 million more votes in the Presidential election, but we don't have the governmental power. They right has the executive and legislative branch and is looking to take control of the judicial branch. They have control of the majority of governorships and State legislatures.

What is happening now isn't just a change in party Presidents. It is an oppressive regime coming to power that is being enabled and supported by the right wing that has embedded itself as a majority in Federal and State elected officials. In Feb. of 2017, it is the resistance..... I would concede that our efforts need to morph into more than resistance and take back power. Local races in 2017, State and Congressional in 2018 and Presidential in 2020.

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
25. And you think "resist" adequately conveys our very real majority or our intention to return power?
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:01 AM
Feb 2017

Cause it doesn't... It conveys that we will whine and have a bunch of intellectual circle jerks. It implies that we are in the minority. It implies we aren't willing to ACTUALLY fight. It implies that we're not fully serious. Look up the definition of the word and then tell me that it is the name of a powerful political movement.

OhioBlue

(5,126 posts)
32. I looked up the definition:
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:36 AM
Feb 2017

Resistance - the refusal to accept or comply with something; the attempt to prevent something by action or argument.

It is already the resistance. It is already being branded as such.

I'm fine with it for now. I don't share your fears about it making us look weak or like whiners. We are resisting the absolutely deplorable regime.

Again, I will concede that it should evolve and I expect it to. But in the here and now, we are the resistance.

GaYellowDawg

(4,447 posts)
31. Take the Congress.
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:29 AM
Feb 2017

You really want effective resistance against Trump, you take the goddamn Legislative branch. There is no more important goal. We need to be identifying candidates, funding them, and running them.

Take the Congress. Everything else is secondary, so name your organization after your goal.

IndianaDave

(612 posts)
35. I suggest "SURGE UPWARD"
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:51 AM
Feb 2017

It conveys ACTION, DIRECTION and a COMMUNITY which recognizes that we are currently going in the wrong direction. I would be interested in knowing what other DU folks think about this. - Thanks - Dave

IamFortunesFool

(348 posts)
37. Reminds me of the Atlanta Falcons slogan: RISE UP
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 01:56 AM
Feb 2017

Surge implies a temporary excess and a temporary pinnacle... I would suggest something with a more permanent connotation of power.

Thank you for your contribution!

This is a subject we ALL should be kicking around in earnest.

susanna

(5,231 posts)
43. I like Indivisible.
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 02:23 AM
Feb 2017

We can't be divided. That is what they are trying to do.

I like We The People, but due to three words it is not as impactful (to me, anyway). I could get used to it, though.

Resistance is fine for a time but yes, I agree that it will need to evolve forward so why not discuss it now?

Interesting thread, I enjoyed all the thoughts here!

susanna

(5,231 posts)
51. To be fair, I can't take credit for the name!
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 03:09 AM
Feb 2017

It is already out there on Twitter and around the country in small bands. I belong to a small tribe

There is even a document about it, and it can be found here:

https://www.indivisibleguide.com/

I just like the idea and name. Do I agree with everything about it? No. Can we build on it? Yes. This is where my comment came from.

Thank you both for the feedback (there were two who responded, and I don't want to neglect anyone).

Response to IamFortunesFool (Original post)

jmg257

(11,996 posts)
58. How 'bout "WE're the Power!"
Sat Feb 4, 2017, 10:16 AM
Feb 2017

take on "where the power lies"

'deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed"

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Trump Resistance Need...