General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsActual Headline: "CA Farmers Supported Trump, But Now Fear Losing Field Workers"
MERCED, Calif. Jeff Marchini and others in the Central Valley here bet their farms on the election of Donald J. Trump. His message of reducing regulations and taxes appealed to this Republican stronghold, one of Mr. Trumps strongest bases of support in the state.
As for his promises about cracking down on illegal immigrants, many assumed Mr. Trumps pledges were mostly just talk. But two weeks into his administration, Mr. Trump has signed executive orders that have upended the countrys immigration laws. Now farmers here are deeply alarmed about what the new policies could mean for their workers, most of whom are unauthorized, and the businesses that depend on them.
Everythings coming so quickly, Mr. Marchini said. Were not loading people into buses or deporting them, thats not happening yet. As he looked out over a crew of workers bent over as they rifled through muddy leaves to find purple heads of radicchio, he said that as a businessman, Mr. Trump would know that farmers had invested millions of dollars into produce that is growing right now, and that not being able to pick and sell those crops would represent huge losses for the state economy. Im confident that he can grasp the magnitude and the anxiety of whats happening now.
Ed.:
EDIT
Mr. Marchini, the radicchio farmer, said he felt similarly after seeing generations of workers on his family farm send their children to college and join the middle class. Mr. Marchinis family has farmed in the valley for four generations and he grew up working side by side with Mexican immigrants. He said that no feasible increase in wages or change in conditions would be enough to draw native-born Americans back into the fields. It was the other conservatives, he said, who were out of touch about how to deal with foreign workers. If you find a way to get in here, theres a need for what you do.
Ed. No, it was you, DUMBFUCK! YOU VOTED FOR THIS!!
EDIT/END
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/09/us/california-farmers-backed-trump-but-now-fear-losing-field-workers.html?_r=0
Ohioblue22
(1,430 posts)wtf is wrong with people . he assumed that frump was just going after "those" people well you gambled and lost . if losing your farm teaches you to never vote republicon again it will be worth it
Roy Rolling
(6,917 posts)A can't-miss partnership with underwear gnomes.
MoonRiver
(36,926 posts)TheBlackAdder
(28,208 posts).
That's part of the game plan, to force farm consolidation.
Force the farmers out of business so the large multinationals can amass millions of more acres.
It's a tactic that has worked really well for them in Central and South America and in Africa.
.
MoonRiver
(36,926 posts)TheBlackAdder
(28,208 posts).
They never realized that these tactics are how these large firms acquire such farmland inventory.
Soon, they will be predated into history.
.
MoonRiver
(36,926 posts)Renew Deal
(81,861 posts)It wouldn't surprise me if someone called.
Vinca
(50,276 posts)Solly Mack
(90,769 posts)Cheer "Build that Wall" all the while needing the labor provided by the very people that wall is meant to keep out.
How fucking dumb do you gotta be to not put that together?
RobinA
(9,893 posts)Repub thing and has been since long before Trump. It's why they seemingly vote against their own interests all the time. It seems to be built into the mindset.
Solly Mack
(90,769 posts)But to whine about it...that takes some nerve.
lpbk2713
(42,759 posts)This is something mouth breathers don't do well.
Solly Mack
(90,769 posts)The man couldn't see beyond his own potential profits from the lack of regulations.
Idiot.
livetohike
(22,145 posts)groups. Impeachment day can't get here fast enough.
Buns_of_Fire
(17,181 posts)DinahMoeHum
(21,794 posts)DetlefK
(16,423 posts)About 10 years ago, a south-eastern US-state (forgot which one) tried outlawing the use of illegal immigrants as farm-hands. Result: The farms almost went bankrupt because illegal immigrants were the only people willing to work in those conditions for that money. And the state hastily repealed the law.
The farmer in the article is an adult. He is responsible for what he does. He is responsible for his political decisions. And, oh what irony, he's voting for the "Party of Personal Responsibility".
If he loses his farm, it's because he deserves it.
Wait, don't tell me. I know his reasoning: "Trump is the only candidate bold enough to tell the truth. But he won't do what he promises to do."
n2doc
(47,953 posts)So he wanted to be able to poison his croplands with massive pesticides, drain whatever aquifers there are for short-term benefits, probably also reduce wages and make working conditions worse, but still keep his no-rights immigrant labor force. Such a moral person.
I heard a woman on Tom Ashbrook who voted for trump but her farm needed the migrant workers. He asked why she voted for him and she said "I'm pro-life".
They thought they could be like cafeteria Catholics.
Phoenix61
(17,006 posts)Cafeteria Catholics...I like that. I call them cherry picker Christians.
hatrack
(59,587 posts).
radhika
(1,008 posts)JeffErson Beauregard Sessions.
Keeping our fields, service firms and factories free of workers.
ohheckyeah
(9,314 posts)Blue_true
(31,261 posts)Grammy23
(5,810 posts)Once the crack down started taking place and the undocumented workers went into hiding or left the states for safer places, it started dawning on these numbskulls that they were "poo pooing in their mess kits".....to utilize an old phrase. Farmers in Mississippi, Alabama and Georgia had a meltdown when there were NO WORKERS to pick tomatoes, peaches or process catfish. And the local out of work white folks had no interest or intention of grabbing those newly available jobs. So tomatoes rotted and farmers got a chance to rethink their position on what to do about undocumented workers.
Elections have consequences and when someone talks about deporting 11 million people that you rely on for your business, you should believe them and consider how that might impact your ability to do business. Dumbasses....
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)Craziness. Millions of dollars worth of crops rotted in fields.
BamaRefugee
(3,483 posts)the dumb ignorant redneck losers (and I say that as someone who lived in Georgia and graduated High School there)
http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/georgias-new-immigration-law-leading-to-crops-rotting-in-farmers-fields/
bighart
(1,565 posts)Fast Walker 52
(7,723 posts)I guess that's why they are idiots...
HAB911
(8,904 posts)Vogon_Glory
(9,118 posts)Mr. Marchini, you voted for a party of out-of-touch conservatives. You voted for a tantrum-throwing man-baby whose Lack of curiosity far surpasses Shrub's and a slate of suburban Cowboys who think that ground water comes out of a faucet and whose economic illiteracy would have pole-axed both Adam Smith and Alexander Hamilton.
You had MONTHS of forewarning, yet you voted for Thump and the Republicans anyway.
YOU. REALLY. SHOULD. HAVE. KNOWN. BETTER.
AgadorSparticus
(7,963 posts)DownriverDem
(6,228 posts)WTF???? Just wait you idiot trumpsters. Gone will be Social Security as we know it, Medicare as we know it, Medicaid as we know it (senior go on Medicaid when they have spent down their funds) and ObamaCare which is the ACA that you like.
Why in the hell didn't you take the repubs at their word? Now that they totally control it all you question what they will do? WTF???
jmg257
(11,996 posts)yet here it is in black and white.
underpants
(182,826 posts)A Republican Congressman wanted a border checkout reopened. Terrorsts you know. So it was reopened and they started catching farm hands sneaking into the country - some in Commercial trucks.
Suddenly there was a shortage of people to pick crops. The Western Growers Association made the necessary calls to elected officials they just happened to know and *POOF* border crossing was closed. Traffic just flowed through like before.
Coventina
(27,121 posts)rickford66
(5,524 posts)Coventina
(27,121 posts)These people are incapable of learning.
packman
(16,296 posts)Then depend on someone else to fix it so they can bitch about the fix - can't win with them.
muntrv
(14,505 posts)Ilsa
(61,695 posts)and purchasers of fresh produce will be paying $5 for a head of nonorganically-grown lettuce. Thanks, Trump!
TBA
(825 posts)Her FIL owns a construction company and hires almost exclusively undocumented Mexican workers. Loves them. "They work so hard!"
dalton99a
(81,515 posts)SHRED
(28,136 posts)Good people don't do this to others and their country.
TrekLuver
(2,573 posts)increase wages and included perks just to attract workers. The article also stated how no Americans wanted to work in the fields...that is out. So I CANNOT understand anyone who relies on foreign workers supporting this man.
hollowdweller
(4,229 posts)I have had several friends who did migrant work.
Here is the thing: They had to shop around to find places that paid enough.
The problem is we have gotten used to cheap agricultural goods.
If you look at what food cost as a percentage of income over time it is a very small percentage of income now due to cheap labor and factory farms.
It was more expensive when we had US labor and smaller farms.
The thing about agricultural work and some other jobs.
We do not value hard work in this country.
My friends who did this sort of work when not working exercised all the time. It was like being an athlete or model or something. With the piece rate there is a definite skill set needed for each crop to be able to harvest efficiently and make any money.
Also like an athlete there is a limited number of years you can do the work. Several friends went back to school to become nurses in their 40's.
So I think you could have US workers do that job. You'd just have to up the pay.
Also it is not fair to have Mexicans or whomever do the job and no make any money either.
Diremoon
(86 posts)When there are no people to pick the crops, they will rot in the fields, and prices at the grocery store will skyrocket. When sweeping tariffs are applied to country's that we import food from, those foods will be un affordable or unavailable.
It seems that no single group of people lacks the ability to "connect the dots" as much as the people that vote republican. We laugh at republicans for their inability to see the consequences of their actions. But we are all victims of what they do.
progressoid
(49,991 posts)When food gets more expensive and lawns don't get mowed, maybe people will wake up.
3_Limes
(363 posts)produce imported from Mexico will be our salvation. Which will be great for Mexican agriculture. The people who used to come here will be able to work there. So in a way, trump is doing something about the immigration issue.
SHRED
(28,136 posts)Many farms in El Centro, CA have moved operations across the border according to my friend who grew up there and who's family worked the fields.
SHRED
(28,136 posts)...Call it, 'Dumbfuckistan'.
Nitram
(22,813 posts)was going to go after immigrants. They all deserve Darwin Awards for voting against their own interests.
BumRushDaShow
(129,080 posts)all sorts of things about this mentally ill man. If anything, there was nothing "fake" about his bizarre campaign behavior because that is who he is. They erroneously thought it was all a ruse to sound folksy or something, but it was not. He is completely unhinged.
Butterflylady
(3,544 posts)ever heard of critical thinking? Guess not.
SHRED
(28,136 posts)...should face prison time and their corporations heavily fined.
Period.
This includes hiring maids, nannies, and laborers from Home Depot parking lots.
hunter
(38,317 posts)Labor laws should be aggressively enforced, and the minimum wage raised to a comfortable living wage.
Then it wouldn't matter where people came from.
Presumably, everyone who works here is making this nation a better place.
Otherwise our economic system is a cruel farce.
SHRED
(28,136 posts)It needs to be followed to help prevent exploitation.
Illegal hiring leaves workers vulnerable and unprotected.
How does it not?
northoftheborder
(7,572 posts)No one seems to make this point. It's always No Immigrants or Amnesty for Immigrants; ENFORCE THE LABOR LAWS Maybe the industrial food corps will make less profit, but everyone else, all the consumers and the workers will benefit, and the whole country more healthy economically.
SHRED
(28,136 posts)...I was not disparaging workers either legal or undocumented.
My beef is with those who hire illegally.
northoftheborder
(7,572 posts)hunter
(38,317 posts)When undocumented workers are caught on their farms, in their factories, in their homes, they know nothing.
No sir, we didn't know this labor contractor hired undocumented workers, never.
And then the contractor vanishes into the mist, only to reappear later under a new name.
griloco
(832 posts)progressoid
(49,991 posts)calimary
(81,304 posts)There is no golden-tower solution here, REGARDLESS what you were told/sold. It appears you might be in for a golden shower, instead.
Crowman2009
(2,497 posts)secondwind
(16,903 posts)Crowman2009
(2,497 posts)I've had to get a new username since I couldn't get into my old Crowman1979 account anymore.
fleur-de-lisa
(14,625 posts)catbyte
(34,402 posts)months that he would do..."
This level of stupidity just drives me nuts.
Mariana
(14,858 posts)"He's just saying that to get votes."
smirkymonkey
(63,221 posts)Lie in it.
nolabels
(13,133 posts)Unless you lived nearby a populous metropolitan area before the GOP began implementing that thirty-year assault plan to assimilate in corporate media, then you were mostly put out in the dark. Sucked up to dial up and Rush and Hannity on your AM.
Lanius
(599 posts)yet they still are able to get the necessary information to make informed choices. Although it would be nice if by "investing in infrastructure" that meant not only rebuilding roads and bridges but bringing high-speed Internet to the rural areas in the richest nation on Earth.
nolabels
(13,133 posts)The Millers and Smiths down the road are Republican Fox devotes and so damn it, Honey, we are going to have to be also.
Back in sticks everybody has to look after each and that indicates being on talking terms (or even friends) with those nieghbors acres away
smirkymonkey
(63,221 posts)I was referring to the farmer. There is no excuse for him voting for hate, not anything. I don't get it.
nolabels
(13,133 posts)It doesn't make sense to me to hate on others just to be reciprocal. There is no way to heal the world but there is enough time to try and understand it.
SHRED
(28,136 posts)Is it that difficult to use the guest worker/green card program?
Why are they, or anyone, hiring illegally besides the cheapness of exploitation that is?
progree
(10,908 posts)at the time of the election and for generations in my family. (I gave it away to PopulationConnection.org in December).
But yes, the area is full of RW douchebags.
renate
(13,776 posts)I'd never heard of Population Connection, so I just looked it up--it does important work and gets four out of four stars on Charity Navigator.
I bet it was hard to give up the land that had been in your family for so long, but it was in the name of a good cause. How incredibly generous of you!
progree
(10,908 posts)I've been living in Minnesota for 39 years. I inherited it in 2004 when my father passed. Fortunately the farmer who was leasing it continued to lease it and he has done a great job. I got 20% of the crop check, he got the rest since he puts in his labor and expertise and hired harvesters (a very big expense) etc -- anyway a standard crop share deal according to several sources.
But it was just too much worrying about water and nitrates and other things ... its a job for somebody living around there, not someone in Minnesota who doesn't know shit about farming.
It was appraised at $495,000 and Population Connection put it on the market for $499,500. It was taken off the market a week later after getting 3 offers, but I haven't heard from since... that was about 2-3 weeks ago.
I didn't actually give away $half a million -- since I got a charitable gift annuity back. All in all I figure I gave away between 100 K$ and 150 K$ after considering avoided capital gains taxes, charitable tax deduction, the value of the annuity, the selling costs I avoided, and so on.
On Edit - Population Connection was formerly know as ZPG - Zero Population Growth.
SledDriver
(2,059 posts)Enjoy your glass of Lib tears...
You have only yourself to blame...
no sympathy
world wide wally
(21,744 posts)33taw
(2,443 posts)NeoPrius
(2 posts)Everyone here will agree that Trump is a disaster. Politics aside if farmers suffer from the Orange Idiot's policies, the country as a whole suffers. Maybe instead of lashing out at them the party could use this opportunity to educate them on the real issues here. Give them the facts. Make an attempt to show them truth in the hopes they'll absorb that knowledge. We have the chance to sway minds here. Why not take that chance?
Lanius
(599 posts)then they'll never learn.
33taw
(2,443 posts)raccoon
(31,111 posts)33taw
(2,443 posts)They do not give a damn about the impact to their country or the lives they impact.
ismnotwasm
(41,988 posts)Speechless
Jake Stern
(3,145 posts)A politician who has kept virtually all of his campaign promises.
To be fair to this farmer and others who didn't believe he'd actually do the more extreme shit, up until now virtually all politicians chucked their campaign promises out the window as soon as they uttered "So help me God." Bush almost immediately broken his promise to not engage in regime change. Obama could never seem to find his comfortable walking shoes.
Generic Other
(28,979 posts)hollowdweller
(4,229 posts)save them enough money so they can hire us citizens at 15 an hour to do the work.
If I was Mexico I'd pay their migrants for a season to "Strike" against the US over this whole thing.
rainbow4321
(9,974 posts)You couldn't drive down a backstreet/highway without seeing huge ass "FARMERS FOR TRUMP" BANNERS along the fields.
I had lunch in a small town's restaurant/golf clubhouse one day and there were 2 older men/farm owners who I overheard bitching that they might have to pay their field workers $15/hour once the CA law went into full effect. As they set on the cool breeze blown covered patio overlooking the golfing holes in the middle of the day ordering their second round of beers..no doubt while the workers that they were complaining about were out in the 100 degree heat, working 12+ hours a day, 6 or 7 days a week picking the crops belonging to these assholes.
radhika
(1,008 posts)He's an exploiter and a BS artist.
Trump ran for nearly two years debasing Mexicans and other immigrants. Rapists, murderers, etc. He emphasized the Wall, and how Mexico was to pay for it like a vassal state receiving dictates from the liege lord.
Perhaps this plantation owner somehow deluded himself that HIS workers would get a pass until HIS crops were in....but he totally did not give a *&(* about any other workers in any other industries who might be affected.
Hope he pays for standing firm with the Big Orange Ugly.
rainbow4321
(9,974 posts)There was a local CA article not long ago that said a large percentage of the Central Valley's crops went to countries that were included in TPP. Bye bye TPP, bye bye crop sales.
So they screwed themselves twice over..field workers AND crop sales.
Bucky
(54,020 posts)Like "no one could have forseen that electing a stubborn megalomaniac who rants about deporting all undocumented foreigners could lead to their being a shortage of migrant workers in agriculture." It's weird how those unintended consequences just sneak up on you sometimes, huh?
djg21
(1,803 posts)At $7.00 a head. Too fucking bad.
BeyondGeography
(39,374 posts)while we were being laughed at for the reverse? Good times.
Lanius
(599 posts)You remember, during the election, when Trump supporters were saying they didn't take what he said literally but they took him seriously? Well, this is what happens when you vote for someone you don't take literally, or at least someone you don't believe will do what they say they are going to do. These idiots didn't think Trump was really going to repeal the ACA or deport all the immigrants who do jobs Americans won't do, and now they're going to pay for it.
HassleCat
(6,409 posts)It's the perfect Republican welfare program. The taxpayers build dams and canals, and the irrigation water is provided nearly free to grow crops in the desert.
still_one
(92,217 posts)How about that, the person wo gets the most votes win
GoCubsGo
(32,086 posts)Wait until they find out that their rude awakening will be never-ending. "Just talk", eh? Like Maya Angelou said, when people tell you who they are, believe them.
Coventina
(27,121 posts)"You fixed the sheets and blankets! Now go take a nap!"
ProfessorPlum
(11,257 posts)That people who didn't want Trump and voted against him took the horrible things he was saying very seriously. And the people who voted for him didn't really believe him.
TrekLuver
(2,573 posts)ProfessorPlum
(11,257 posts)Even evil Spock doesn't understand it
jpak
(41,758 posts)yup
raccoon
(31,111 posts)lpbk2713
(42,759 posts)Certainly no mouth breathers who get their news from Faux.
Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin
(108,023 posts)Still you, and eventually the rest of us, will face higher food costs thanks to the orange haired shit gibbon.
kentuck
(111,101 posts)Any immigrant that can show that he/she has worked in America for two years should automatically become a citizen, notwithstanding any external legal matters.
alarimer
(16,245 posts)I fear these "make America great again" voters don't realize that things will get worse for all of us if he continues to do these things. There is a reason we have cheap vegetables. If these farmers had to pay people minimum wage, they would sell a whole lot less lettuce.
BamaRefugee
(3,483 posts)Imagine how much hatred and venom his family had to endure four generations back, from the original Central Valley settlers, the Greenwoods, and the Sloats, and the Smiths et al, good strong ANGLO-SAXON STOCK, as God intended!
I'm sure Marchinis and others of their ilk were threatened with being run out of the territory many times, to go back WHERE THEY BELONGED.
Ironic, ain't it.
workinclasszero
(28,270 posts)Out of business.
Foo Fighter
(743 posts)If they thought his pledge to crack down on immigration was "mostly just talk", what about the rest of the promises he made on the campaign trail? Did they think he would carry through on some of them (IOW, those that they agreed with) but not others (those they didn't agree with)? Sorry, but it's a package deal so they have to take the bad with the worse (because there is no "good" in this administration).
The farmers are acting like they're the victims here. Sorry, but this is what you voted for. The victims here are the immigrants, not the farmers.
Dawson Leery
(19,348 posts)The right must learn to live with their choices.
ADM or Cargill could always buy them up. Maybe Glencore?
DonCoquixote
(13,616 posts)What through this exact same story to repeat in Florida. Here in Florida, many of the workers in the orange groves and Strawberry Fields are Mexican. Many of them have their kids in school, who as natural born American citizens, often wind up forming small businesses or becoming professionals. Many of them going to the military. It is one thing to make California angry, as that state will be hard blue. However, this band will go ahead and cut straight to the profit margins of Florida citrus barons, exactly the sort of people who donate to political candidates.
Pretty soon, Florida will have the Strawberry Festival. It is one of the largest festivals in the South, the sort of place where Kenny Rogers or Shania Twain will go ahead and play the stadium where a few hours ago some local band played. However, while this vessel is very much one of the few remnants of old Florida before Disney, even the area around the festival grounds shows the immigrant influence. For example, there are a whole bunch of Mexican restaurants right around the festival grounds, ones that get their produce from the same market that the old server diners like Fred's market did. Last year the festival wound up booking, in addition to reliable country chestnuts, Mexican bands: ones that ranged from the Tejano ones (think Selena) to mariachi ones. Of course, the vessel operators just saw that as the festival growing, which it did. They even had an announcement, calling this "Hola Plant city", even though the announcer did pronounce the Spanish and a very old Florida Southern accent, people were happy to be welcome.
The reason I'm serving you this slice of Central Florida culture is to show that even in Plant City, Florida, one of the few areas in central Florida that is a strong bastion of the original Dixie Florida culture, the Mexicans have woven themselves into the economy. Now, if Mr. Trump decides to go ahead and start purging Mexicans, the truth is some people were really going to feel the impact are going to be the old Southerners. It will not just be that there will be no more Mexicans to pick the oranges and strawberries, although that will be a big part of it, but a lot of the small businesses that help keep the mall rents reasonable and the bank loans coming will be gone. Of course, those of us who understand the game that Trump and his handlers were really playing will know the true score, namely that the northern banks will come in and pick people off, selling Florida land to carpetbaggers like the one who owns a compound in Florida called Mir a Lago. Seriously, with all the complaining about New York bankers coming down here and messing up Florida, I'm still amazed at the fact that Donald Trump, who is a living example of the very worst aspects of New York, especially all the real estate industry which many Florida natives consider a bane of their existence.
In any case, listen for many stories exactly like the opinion piece showed, but look for them in Florida especially, because for all the talk about making Trump voters see things our way, that will be a prime opportunity, because once they see Trump and his friends gladly putting Florida native meat on the same plate as the Mexican American meat, they will realize they are in trouble.