Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DFW

(54,381 posts)
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 08:15 AM Jun 2017

Now HERE'S a welcome headline I did expect to see, but nowhere near this soon

Based on Trump's childish behavior and the resolute support he still has from his fanatics in the States, I expect Marine LePen's support to gradually ebb.

Instead, just a few weeks after the French presidential election, the International New York Times today has a big front page headline saying, "Far Right In Retreat In France."

WOW, that didn't take long! I didn't expect to see that headline until December, and on page ten.

Now, if Hillary were to show up to speak at some event somewhere (ANYwhere), I suspect a crowd would show up no matter where it was. In contrast, the article mentions, "This past week in Soissons.......Ms. Le Pen was greeted by a few dozen somber National Front activists in a drab somber meeting hall. Even the hecklers didn't bother....."

And here's the awful part--if OUR election had been fairly held, what just happened to Le Pen would have also been Trump's fate.

The fact that Trump is there at all is scary, and his fanatic base is there because they feel that having "won," they have the right to go around shouting at people and hurting them--not one or two deranged individuals, but thousands of them all across the country, shouting at strangers in shopping centers, hitting them, disrupting theater events, etc. and it will get worse.

Now, there are NO greater critics of the French political scene than the French themselves. What have they grasped that so many Americans seem unable to figure out?

38 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Now HERE'S a welcome headline I did expect to see, but nowhere near this soon (Original Post) DFW Jun 2017 OP
So true, instead of people clinging to their pride and not wanting to be called wrong Trump would be YCHDT Jun 2017 #1
My dear DFW! CaliforniaPeggy Jun 2017 #2
The French had two quite recent examples... Wounded Bear Jun 2017 #16
In one word. TRUMP boston bean Jun 2017 #3
Far right in retreat in France ffr Jun 2017 #4
It's also because a lot of them are like Trump Iplayoneontv Jun 2017 #34
The French people are true patriots and hold allegiance to France 🇫🇷 but not to political parties. CottonBear Jun 2017 #5
Do the French have the Faux news channel like the U.S.? mdbl Jun 2017 #6
Good point. No, they have nothing like Fox Noise. Nor does Germany. DFW Jun 2017 #20
Fortunately, the French had the benefit of witnessing the election disaster in the US. Fla Dem Jun 2017 #7
Hello Florida Dem, I am a Florida Dem also, North Central Florida. Blue_true Jun 2017 #13
I would imagine that LittleGirl Jun 2017 #17
Does she realize that if we nuke NK, we are dead? Blue_true Jun 2017 #18
Thank you LittleGirl Jun 2017 #19
Education tempers craziness. Blue_true Jun 2017 #22
Indeed LittleGirl Jun 2017 #25
When I was a boy, I had serious differences with my next oldest brother. Blue_true Jun 2017 #26
That's a sad story. LittleGirl Jun 2017 #29
Do what you can. Tea party people are largely heartless, but we are not like them. nt Blue_true Jun 2017 #32
Yep. that's it. LittleGirl Jun 2017 #33
You mentioned alcoholism Iplayoneontv Jun 2017 #35
yes, of course LittleGirl Jun 2017 #36
With Cambridge Analytica, Putin's Web Brigades & Horse-race media, Republican Trump got bumped up. Bernardo de La Paz Jun 2017 #8
This message was self-deleted by its author Kathy M Jun 2017 #27
The article is now available at dalton99a Jun 2017 #9
LePen also benefited from a protest vote that came from people who detested her DFW Jun 2017 #38
I think too the French area beginning to see what a leader they have in macron Thekaspervote Jun 2017 #10
I really, really wish him well. Blue_true Jun 2017 #15
Not to be a Debbie Downer but watoos Jun 2017 #11
The "have-nots" in France are more spread-out than in Britain, as are the "haves" DFW Jun 2017 #23
This message was self-deleted by its author Kathy M Jun 2017 #28
That paper ballots work just fine. 58Sunliner Jun 2017 #12
Difference is GOP donors, GOP media. american_ideals Jun 2017 #14
Seems to me the whole world wants nothing to do with another IMBECILE NAMED TRUMP linnknee Jun 2017 #21
At least here in Europe DFW Jun 2017 #24
K & R malaise Jun 2017 #30
THe Russians targeted France also but the French learned from what happened to us Amaryllis Jun 2017 #31
the US is backwards compared to other countries on similar level of development/wealth etc JI7 Jun 2017 #37

YCHDT

(962 posts)
1. So true, instead of people clinging to their pride and not wanting to be called wrong Trump would be
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 08:21 AM
Jun 2017

... a fringe person

CaliforniaPeggy

(149,620 posts)
2. My dear DFW!
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 08:22 AM
Jun 2017

You're at the top of your game, and it's still very early......well, at least in California, it's early!

And oh boy do I ever agree about the awful part. Would that our election had had the same result. We would be living in a much calmer, SANER world.

I suspect that the French are wise because they have a much better educational system: one that is not run by right-wing Republicans!

Great to see you!



Wounded Bear

(58,656 posts)
16. The French had two quite recent examples...
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 10:06 AM
Jun 2017

We failed to take the Brexit lesson seriously, the French got Brexit AND Trump as lessons of what could go wrong.

They had an unfair advantage.

ffr

(22,670 posts)
4. Far right in retreat in France
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 08:33 AM
Jun 2017
And here's the awful part--if OUR election had been fairly held, what just happened to Le Pen would have also been Trump's fate.

The fact that Trump is there at all is scary, and his fanatic base is there because they feel that having "won," they have the right to go around shouting at people and hurting them--not one or two deranged individuals, but thousands of them all across the country, shouting at strangers in shopping centers, hitting them, disrupting theater events, etc. and it will get worse.
Which is what I remind the righties here. Don't go pretending you're the majority. You won on a technicality and because you're easily duped. You're mindless drones, doing whatever Fox Noise tells you. We've always been the majority, even on election day. You're the minority. So don't get cocky.

What I also love to bring up with 45's flagging poll numbers, is that he's at 35% approval WITH 24/7 RW media cheerleading, something Nixon didn't have in the day. Think about it.

CottonBear

(21,596 posts)
5. The French people are true patriots and hold allegiance to France 🇫🇷 but not to political parties.
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 08:38 AM
Jun 2017

The French government policy is against fake news propaganda and limits partisan election polls. The people seem to be well educated and informed about the issues. Plus, they use 100% paper ballots. They probably have the most fair elections of any country.

mdbl

(4,973 posts)
6. Do the French have the Faux news channel like the U.S.?
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 08:48 AM
Jun 2017

Maybe that's why - they aren't AS misinformed.

DFW

(54,381 posts)
20. Good point. No, they have nothing like Fox Noise. Nor does Germany.
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 10:55 AM
Jun 2017

Germany still has laws on the books that restrict free speech. No Nazi, or overtly Nazi-like propaganda is permitted. Fox doesn't stand a chance of getting a permit in Germany. Even if Fox DID get a permit in France, their premises would go up in flames within days, as the French are not timid in expressing their views in bold terms. Even newspapers that lean rightward in France would be bashed as "libbrul" by the American Republicans.

As for "Republicans," the mainstream center-right party in France adopted that name last year. They got completely shut out of the second round of the presidential election this year. In Germany, several decades ago, an ex-SS officer wanted to form a neo-Nazi party. Since the Nazi label is still forbidden here, he had look around for another name to call his nasty little movement. He found a perfect name right in the good old USA: "Die Republikaner."

When I mention that to our Republicans, they immediately whine, "you are calling us Nazis!" Nonsense. I said no such thing. I only pointed out that I find it highly unfortunate that a bunch of Neo-Nazis in Germany, led by a REAL former Nazi, found our Republicans so to their liking that they decided adopt their name.

Fla Dem

(23,668 posts)
7. Fortunately, the French had the benefit of witnessing the election disaster in the US.
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 08:56 AM
Jun 2017

They saw with their own eyes what would happen if they didn't go to the polls and vote. They saw the revelations of the Russian interference in our elections. They responded and defeated the far RW LePen. If only our electorate had the advance knowledge of what we know now, I would like to think our outcome would have been different.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
13. Hello Florida Dem, I am a Florida Dem also, North Central Florida.
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 09:50 AM
Jun 2017

You're exactly right. If the French had voted several months before us, LePen would have done much better. Another factor in France that wasn't mentioned that I think is important in the result is France's population is something like 15% Muslim, our's is 3% Muslim. Who would vote for an idiot that was clear that she hated you simply for being you?

The French also had time to see how a disastrous amateur like Trump led, how he blotched the simplest world affairs issues. All considered, they wanted none of that. I would like to think that if we had voted second and watched an elected Marine LePen screw up France and international relations for months, we would have gotten a different result here. But I am not totally sure about that. We have more race hatred filled idiots and people that believe that minorities have no right to compete for jobs and good lives, many believe that LGBTQ people don't deserve even basic human rights that everyone should have, people that believe that women are inferior to men in all respects.

LittleGirl

(8,287 posts)
17. I would imagine that
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 10:30 AM
Jun 2017

most Americans, right wing ones the least, don't have the slightest clue who Le Pen is. World affairs?

My sister asked me about N. Korea once.
I asked, what about them?
She said, just nuke 'em.
That's her solution to world affairs.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
18. Does she realize that if we nuke NK, we are dead?
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 10:38 AM
Jun 2017

China and Russia, who DO have nuclear ICBMs that can reach us won't be happy about all their citizens dying from our nuclear fallout from North Korea. Not to mention that there won't be a South Korea and all of our 7,000 troops there will long be dead before China and Russia nuke the US mainland.

My condolences on your sister. I am fortunate, all of my family are either moderates or progressives and NONE voted for Trump. Hang in there, maybe your sister's kids will turn out to be progressives, one can hope.

LittleGirl

(8,287 posts)
19. Thank you
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 10:51 AM
Jun 2017

My sister's kids are great and her youngest just provided her with her 8th grandchild this week.

They are not political like their mother. She's been brainwashed by O'reilly and hannity for two decades so she's hopeless. Her kids are educated, but Christians, which is okay for me. I don't believe anymore. They are the future. My sister will be dead in a few years from alcoholism so I'm just hoping she's long gone before she can corrupt her grand kids. She's moving to FL in a few months and I hope to never to see her again.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
22. Education tempers craziness.
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 11:18 AM
Jun 2017

My family are mostly Christians, but I am a Deist. I suggest that you reconsider never wanting to see your sister again, you have bonds to her that you can't break, don't let actions now torture you long after she is dead. Turn the other cheek, ignore or undo her worst actions, but I suggest that you endear the bond of blood that you two share.

LittleGirl

(8,287 posts)
25. Indeed
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 11:34 AM
Jun 2017

but even my 84 yr old Mother doesn't want much to do with her either. She has burned all of those bridges. I am my best self if I have to see her, which lately is once every 4 yrs or so.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
26. When I was a boy, I had serious differences with my next oldest brother.
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 11:57 AM
Jun 2017

He was a wild child and undisciplined, with strife with my parents. I was serious about education and a calm child.

I remember being home from college on break. My brother stopped by the house, still wild and undisciplined, with hangerons around him. He found me reading something in my room, I think I was a college freshman at that time. He hung around working to drive a conversation with me, but I was so upset about his behavior that I didn't want to talk much. He finally embraced me and I gave a half hearted embrace back. I didn't recognize it then, but he was very proud of me, I was in college on my way to becoming and engineer, my brother admired that. A week later, just before I was set to return to college, my mom and my went to the local morgue to identify my brother's remains, he was changing a tire on a car, was struck by another car driven by a kid returning to the same college I attended, my brother died of shock beside an interstate highway before EMT could reach him.

My advice to you is you can't erase bonds of blood, regardless of how much you want to in the present. Don't let your future be what I deal with. That night in my room was the last time I would see my brother alive, I will never be able to undo not being warmer toward him and realizing that under his bravado, he was proud that I had chosen a path different from the one he chose.

LittleGirl

(8,287 posts)
29. That's a sad story.
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 12:28 PM
Jun 2017

Thanks for sharing it.

My father died when I was 15 and that was 42 yrs ago. He raised her like his own even though he wasn't her father. Dad married Mom when my sister was about 3. We never discussed politics at home when I lived there. Fox spews ruined my sister and one of my brothers (sort of). My brother and I still communicate but it's difficult because of the political divide in our family. He and my sister are tea party people. So we are pleasant toward each other but like my sister, I haven't seen him in 4 yrs either. I live out west and just moved back from Europe 3 months ago. They all live in the midwest, Pence state. My Mother is heartbroken that politics has divided our family. She's on our side.

Iplayoneontv

(77 posts)
35. You mentioned alcoholism
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 11:56 PM
Jun 2017

I'm not trying to be mean but I am seriously curious about the # of Trump voters that are alcoholics or drug abusers because I saw a lot of opiate addicts supporting Trump.

I'm just wondering if that matters or it's something else like where they live.

LittleGirl

(8,287 posts)
36. yes, of course
Sun Jun 18, 2017, 01:44 AM
Jun 2017

she lives in the Pence state so anything republican is good and everything liberal is bad.
She hated Mr Clinton and I remember that even though I wasn't involved in politics back then.
She's a lost cause.

Bernardo de La Paz

(49,002 posts)
8. With Cambridge Analytica, Putin's Web Brigades & Horse-race media, Republican Trump got bumped up.
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 08:57 AM
Jun 2017

Artificially boosted above his natural appeal, which is showing up in his dismal disapproval ratings.

Response to Bernardo de La Paz (Reply #8)

dalton99a

(81,488 posts)
9. The article is now available at
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 09:10 AM
Jun 2017
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/16/world/europe/marine-le-pen-france.html
Le Pen Loses Luster, Signaling Far Right’s Retreat in France, and Maybe Beyond
By ADAM NOSSITER | JUNE 16, 2017

SOISSONS, France — Just this spring, Marine Le Pen’s presidential campaign drew vast crowds who enthusiastically embraced her National Front’s stridently nationalist, anti-immigrant vision of France.

This week in Soissons, a somnolent provincial town far from the gaudy cast-of-thousands extravaganzas of the campaign, Ms. Le Pen was greeted by a few dozen somber National Front activists in a drab meeting hall. Even hecklers didn’t bother: Just a handful of weak-voiced protesters quickly dispersed.

Ms. Le Pen’s party, crushed by Emmanuel Macron’s 66 percent in the presidential runoff in May, fared dismally in last Sunday’s legislative elections. The National Front will most likely confirm these losses in a second round of voting this Sunday. And each day brings new revelations of internal backbiting and squabbles over strategy within the Front.

It is a head-spinning turnabout that reflects, at least for now, the fizzling of Ms. Le Pen’s fortunes in France. The National Front’s retreat also adds to the impression that far-right populism is losing its appeal more broadly.

DFW

(54,381 posts)
38. LePen also benefited from a protest vote that came from people who detested her
Sun Jun 18, 2017, 04:37 AM
Jun 2017

There were interviews with people whose sentiments were solidly center-left who didn't like "any of the above," and voted for LePen in the first round to "shake things up and get the parties off their asses." Once she advanced to the second round, however, and it was either/or, they felt they had made their point and left her high and dry, since she didn't represent their true political stance at all.

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
15. I really, really wish him well.
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 10:00 AM
Jun 2017

I want him to solve the handful of issues that France with style and aplomb. Him succeeding will be the death knell to rightwing populism worldwide.

Hollande was a disappointment. He came
in riding on the hopes of progressives worldwide and squandered that with lackadaisical leadership and a string of embarrassing affairs.

 

watoos

(7,142 posts)
11. Not to be a Debbie Downer but
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 09:34 AM
Jun 2017

I agree 100% that Macron is 100% better than LePen. LePen isn't a Trump clone, she is a David Duke clone.
Just remember this, the labor candidate lost too, Macron is a neoliberal and I will hold off on commenting whether his neoliberal policies help the 99% in France. If Macron fails, economically, LePen will still be lurking to step back in.

Excellent article a couple of days ago by Matt Taibbi in The Rolling Stone about how the 1% have controlled the narrative into Republicans vs Democrats, or in essence a 50/50 split. The big lie that the country, whether it be the U.S. or France is centrist and the voices of the 99% are unrealistic or naïve is a lie perpetrated by the 1%. Taibbi states that the real fight isn't right vs left but the haves vs the have nots. The have nots have a lot more votes than the haves and when they realize they are being conned they will win elections. I like to look at Britain instead of France where the experts were shocked that nut job Corbyn won 40% of the vote. Just a reminder that although Macron is 100% better than LePen he is one of those centrists, the labor candidate finished 3rd in France. People are waking up. slowly.

DFW

(54,381 posts)
23. The "have-nots" in France are more spread-out than in Britain, as are the "haves"
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 11:27 AM
Jun 2017

Macron got plenty of the votes that traditionally would have gone left, not because they were willing to get conned, but because the left had failed them so poorly. Hollande acted like exactly that which he was: an unconcerned bureaucrat. If you have weak (or no) ideology and no ideas, you become a bureaucrat.

Macron, in part because he was young, dynamic and steered away from ideology, got the "how-could-he-be-worse?" vote. Mélenchon left the Socialists years ago and went for a farther-left movement, even though Marchais had been discredited long ago, and got a commensurate percentage in the first round. Even my most leftist friends in France didn't vote for him in the first round. Labor in France is, with good reason, highly skeptical of politicians who claim to be their champions just a little too loudly, as they are the ones who least follow up when they have a chance to prove it. For that matter, the French right can pretty much say the same thing about their own leaders, which is why Macron was able to project the image of a champion of a center that isn't even there.

I'm only in Britain maybe once every two years, and know the place far less than France, where I am about once a week.

Response to watoos (Reply #11)

american_ideals

(613 posts)
14. Difference is GOP donors, GOP media.
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 09:51 AM
Jun 2017

In France the right threw their support to the centrist candidate instead of the autocrat.

In the US the right backed the autocrat to the hilt. The GOP backed the autocrat to achieve their agenda- destroy government to give tax cuts to the rich. The GOP did that because the party has been purchased by about 10 billionaire families: Koch, Walton, Adelson, Mercer, Scaife, Olin. Billionaires and corporations have also created right wing think tanks and media that incite hate to achieve their goals of destroying government.

So that's the difference between the US and France. The GOP in America is autocratic and wants to destroy government, and they use political donations and right wing media to pursue this goal.

Amaryllis

(9,524 posts)
31. THe Russians targeted France also but the French learned from what happened to us
Sat Jun 17, 2017, 12:42 PM
Jun 2017

and took preventive measures.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Now HERE'S a welcome head...