Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

babylonsister

(171,065 posts)
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 04:19 PM Jun 2017

Charles P. Pierce: Okay, So You Kick Nancy Pelosi Out. Then What?

http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/news/a55791/nancy-pelosi-replacement/


Okay, So You Kick Nancy Pelosi Out. Then What?

Before you start calling for her exit, name some logical replacements.
By Charles P. Pierce
Jun 21, 2017


In my time on this earth, I've seen Republican propaganda turn a decent centrist like Michael Dukakis into a signatory of the Port Huron statement. I've seen it turn a decorated war hero like John Kerry into a Francophone poltroon. I've seen it turn a radical centrist/Rockefeller Republican like Bill Clinton into a dope-smoking refugee from the Monterey Pop Festival. I've seen kindly old Tip O'Neill turned into a Thomas Nast cartoon, and I've seen Barack Obama turned into an Islamic Kenyan holy man. I've seen an audience created for every one of these manufactured creations, and I've seen that audience respond to them as if they had the firmest basis in reality.

So you will pardon me if I'm dubious of the notion that congressional Democrats have to rid themselves of Nancy Pelosi because she was so easily demonized in that Georgia special election. If it wasn't her, it would have been somebody else. To paraphrase the editor in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, if there's a conflict between the person and the legend, slander the legend.

Steve M is right on the button here. The Republicans have one brand and one brand only: Democrats suck. The articles of their electoral faith begin and end with, how best can they piss off the liberals who rent space in their heads, and how do they convince the rubes that pissing off the liberals is an actual policy prescription to stave off the economic and cultural forces that are keeping the rubes up at night? As Steve points out, you have to dig pretty deep in today's coverage to discover that Karen Handel has no public stance on the vastly unpopular healthcare bill, or that she has no clear opinion on giving gozillionnaires another huge tax cut. (Yeah, I'm pretty sure I know what those opinions are, too.) She ran against a caricature of a non-candidate as a nonentity and she won. Nice work if you can get it.

Which brings us back to Nancy Pelosi. Most of the voices calling for her to go are coming from younger Democrats, a lot of them allied with the Berniecrat wing of the party. (Ironically, the Republicans ran ads tying Jon Ossoff to Sanders, that socialist menace. Plus ca change…) I am charmed to my bones by the faith these young folks have that Pelosi's replacement would be someone dedicated to single-payer healthcare, the $15 minimum wage, and hanging banksters from lamp posts. More than likely, it would be someone like, say, Tim Ryan from Ohio, who talks the salt-o'-the-earth talk about economic anxiety, but who flipped on abortion in 2015, when it became convenient to do so, and who won an NRA endorsement in his first campaign. This development would not be to their liking.

Moreover, I've yet to see anyone who could wrangle the House caucus in this dark time for Democrats better than Pelosi has. She kept the caucus unanimous against that abomination of a healthcare bill. She's a manifestly better legislative strategist than Paul Ryan. Whether or not she is to blame for the failure of the Democrats to maintain a House majority after 2006 is an impossible question. Legislative leaders' having to bear the brunt of electoral losses beyond their home districts is a fairly flexible standard. If you want to make the case that the age of the Democratic congressional leadership makes the emergence of new faces more difficult, I'll listen to that argument, but leave Bernie Sanders out of it, because you sound like a fool.

If you're proposing to replace Pelosi, prepare for the inevitable result. The pressure on the replacement—from Republicans, certainly, but also from the elite political media—to work "on a bipartisan basis" with the zombie-eyed granny starver and his band of cutthroats, or to find "common ground" with the folks down at Camp Runamuck, is going to be well-nigh overwhelming. And that's not even to mention the both-siderist frenzy that will erupt during the fight to elect a new leader. Dems In Disarray is a Beltway classic. This would be its loudest revival performance in years. And, in any case, if you're demanding that Pelosi be dumped because of her usefulness as a Republican cartoon, aren't you already pretty much admitting defeat?
64 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Charles P. Pierce: Okay, So You Kick Nancy Pelosi Out. Then What? (Original Post) babylonsister Jun 2017 OP
MAXINE WATERS !!! Oh wait she's female too, sigh. Me thinks dems need to deal with our own demons... YCHDT Jun 2017 #1
Maxine Waters is hated by the right... Else You Are Mad Jun 2017 #4
K&R!!!!!! secondwind Jun 2017 #2
Getting rid of Nancy Pelosi would be a major mistake Gothmog Jun 2017 #3
Tom Perez gets a pass. GeorgeGist Jun 2017 #5
HaHaHa Alice11111 Jun 2017 #42
Perfect Me. Jun 2017 #6
Nancy's just fine where she is, thank you. BannonsLiver Jun 2017 #7
Not irreplaceable but experienced Proud Liberal Dem Jun 2017 #10
Exactly. BannonsLiver Jun 2017 #17
Yep not fooled Jun 2017 #39
They have simple minds. They only know how to take a side. Baitball Blogger Jun 2017 #8
K&R mcar Jun 2017 #9
Post removed Post removed Jun 2017 #11
Of Course Me. Jun 2017 #13
Fortunately BainsBane Jun 2017 #15
AMEN!!! BadgerMom Jun 2017 #12
Thanks BabSis. Who the HELL are the trolls out today at DU trying to dump Nancy P? Hekate Jun 2017 #14
Is everyone who disagrees with you a troll? bluedigger Jun 2017 #23
No. Ignorance and stupidity in mass quantities tends to set me off, and it's here today. Hekate Jun 2017 #25
There Wasn't Just One Trolling Speaker Pelosi Me. Jun 2017 #28
Some were/are playing tag team, too. I think one put me on ignore; I don't know how I can go on Hekate Jun 2017 #46
One Has To Ask What's The Agenda For The Swarm Me. Jun 2017 #47
One does indeed Hekate Jun 2017 #48
They From The New Group Put Together BY Tim Ryan & Krystal Ball Me. Jun 2017 #51
there is another thread bashing Nancy. What is going on here. trueblue2007 Jun 2017 #60
Isn't it interesting how the Democrats they so despise BainsBane Jun 2017 #16
Or black people, murielm99 Jun 2017 #20
Just another coinkydink Hekate Jun 2017 #27
Just a coinkydink, I'm sure Hekate Jun 2017 #26
I wish I could rec this a thousand times. GoCubsGo Jun 2017 #18
Thank you, Charlie. Paladin Jun 2017 #19
Yeah, let's just get rid of everyone the Repubs don't like. Then, we will all be Repubs Alice11111 Jun 2017 #44
I'd LOVE to see Franken go for it in 2020. (nt) Paladin Jun 2017 #56
I think he is...and he would be a great Pres Alice11111 Jun 2017 #63
Nancy Pelosi LVNVblue Jun 2017 #21
Some "Democrats" want the "Democratic Establishment" to Progressive dog Jun 2017 #22
Tim Ryan. Tim Ryan. Tim Ryan War Pigs Jun 2017 #24
So you are advocating no women in leadership in the Democratic party? DURHAM D Jun 2017 #31
no not at all. Nancy has all those labels on her partly due to her longevity in the War Pigs Jun 2017 #32
One of the up and coming Democratic women murielm99 Jun 2017 #35
I certainly will murielm99!! War Pigs Jun 2017 #38
Telegenic Me. Jun 2017 #49
What the heck are you even talking about, War Pigs? "California elitists"? Hekate Jun 2017 #55
I have lived in SoCal and take virtually all my vacations there and in Northern Baja War Pigs Jun 2017 #57
"Nancy P has been in the crosshairs a long time" and she's still standing. Remarkable record. Hekate Jun 2017 #59
It's a very important point, that letting the damage Republicans try to do, say to Pelosi, or JCanete Jun 2017 #29
The fact that Republicans are so desperate to get rid of Nancy Pelosi octoberlib Jun 2017 #30
Where is all this ousting Nancy nonsense coming from? Egnever Jun 2017 #33
A couple Congressional Democrats of course octoberlib Jun 2017 #43
The New Group Formed By Tim Ryan & Krystal Ball Me. Jun 2017 #50
I propose a Democratic propaganda machine meow2u3 Jun 2017 #34
The problem is that they have much more propaganda infrastructure MrPurple Jun 2017 #37
.... hadEnuf Jun 2017 #41
I second Tim Ryan and they should have done it in January MrPurple Jun 2017 #36
K&R smirkymonkey Jun 2017 #40
Palomino! Never forget! blogslut Jun 2017 #45
I'm with Nancy. dchill Jun 2017 #52
How many DUers live in Pelosi's district? If you don't you can't vote to kick her out. wasupaloopa Jun 2017 #53
No one wants to vote her out of office, but to possibly have the party select a different leader MrPurple Jun 2017 #54
If she is in the House she will lead the Dems wasupaloopa Jun 2017 #58
It's an amazing swarm we have today, upaloopa. Hekate Jun 2017 #61
On The Last Word tonight it was said by Robert wasupaloopa Jun 2017 #62
Brilliant! Pacifist Patriot Jun 2017 #64

Me.

(35,454 posts)
6. Perfect
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 04:44 PM
Jun 2017

And, in any case, if you're demanding that Pelosi be dumped because of her usefulness as a Republican cartoon, aren't you already pretty much admitting defeat?

BannonsLiver

(16,387 posts)
7. Nancy's just fine where she is, thank you.
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 04:46 PM
Jun 2017

But I would take exception with a bit of this. Pierce seems to be suggesting she's irreplaceable. Truth is, everyone's replaceable. Life would go on. The Democratic Party would not cease to exist. That said, I hope she is speaker again ASAP.

Proud Liberal Dem

(24,412 posts)
10. Not irreplaceable but experienced
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 04:55 PM
Jun 2017

Now is the time we need to maximize the assets we have left, not blithely throw them away. We need to be smart about this, not stupid.

Baitball Blogger

(46,709 posts)
8. They have simple minds. They only know how to take a side.
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 04:51 PM
Jun 2017

If it's not Nancy Pelosi, it's someone else.

I suggest Nancy Pelosi get a PR person who is familiar with Republican gaslighting and defaming tactics and try to turn it around.

Response to babylonsister (Original post)

Me.

(35,454 posts)
13. Of Course
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:08 PM
Jun 2017

She and HRC are both Dems, why wouldn't she back another Dem? It's not reasonable to expect otherwise.

BainsBane

(53,032 posts)
15. Fortunately
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:10 PM
Jun 2017

That isn't your decision to make.

How about all the politicians who endorsed Bernie. Should they go too? Or is backing the winning candidate now a crime?

Hekate

(90,686 posts)
14. Thanks BabSis. Who the HELL are the trolls out today at DU trying to dump Nancy P?
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:10 PM
Jun 2017

Godsdamn they are fools, as Chaz Pierce says.

bluedigger

(17,086 posts)
23. Is everyone who disagrees with you a troll?
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:35 PM
Jun 2017

There are about a half dozen separate threads defending Pelosi in GD, and one (that I saw) calling for her replacement, with all of 9 recs. That seems more like a poorly received idea to me than it does a concerted effort at trolling. People can disagree and throw ideas out there still, can't they? Even if they're bad. Or is this the kind of "discussion" board where we all agree all the time?

Hekate

(90,686 posts)
25. No. Ignorance and stupidity in mass quantities tends to set me off, and it's here today.
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:44 PM
Jun 2017

Not amusing.

I'll be back later.

Hekate

(90,686 posts)
46. Some were/are playing tag team, too. I think one put me on ignore; I don't know how I can go on
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 08:19 PM
Jun 2017

Me.

(35,454 posts)
51. They From The New Group Put Together BY Tim Ryan & Krystal Ball
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 08:30 PM
Jun 2017

She has a book out doncha know with a message that's a version of BS's spiel

BainsBane

(53,032 posts)
16. Isn't it interesting how the Democrats they so despise
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:13 PM
Jun 2017

and want removed from office, and even hidden from public view, are all women?

murielm99

(30,741 posts)
20. Or black people,
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:20 PM
Jun 2017

like Cory Booker. Or anyone who shows strong leadership and electability for 2018 and 2020.

I am more disturbed by the people on the left who are doing this than I am by repiggie or MSM criticism. I expect that kind of horseshit from them. I won't say more, or someone will alert.

Alice11111

(5,730 posts)
44. Yeah, let's just get rid of everyone the Repubs don't like. Then, we will all be Repubs
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 07:41 PM
Jun 2017

The fact that they don't like her indicates she is effective. I expect them to take on Al Franken shortly too, as he would be a strong opponent against trump.

LVNVblue

(9 posts)
21. Nancy Pelosi
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:21 PM
Jun 2017

is just one of the shiny objects that the republicans like to vilify. If not her, like Charlie says, it will be anyone who replaces her. He is also right about Pelosi's ability as Speaker--she is very, very good (unlike the Munster lookalike). Since when do we listen to the republican spin anyways? Sheesh

Progressive dog

(6,904 posts)
22. Some "Democrats" want the "Democratic Establishment" to
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:31 PM
Jun 2017

fail and they have been trying to push the establishment leaders out.
Nancy Pelosi is a leader of that establishment, so they are willing to help the liars push her out.

War Pigs

(252 posts)
24. Tim Ryan. Tim Ryan. Tim Ryan
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:39 PM
Jun 2017

no more wealthy California elitist labeling- red meat for the nutjobs. Notice how little women occupy leadership positions in the GOP?? He's newer, somewhat moderate and from the midwest and telegenic and well spoken

DURHAM D

(32,609 posts)
31. So you are advocating no women in leadership in the Democratic party?
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:56 PM
Jun 2017

I think you took a wrong turn somewhere.

War Pigs

(252 posts)
32. no not at all. Nancy has all those labels on her partly due to her longevity in the
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 06:11 PM
Jun 2017

spotlight. I trust the judgement of women more than men and I'm from the military and manufacturing environments. The voters we are losing are those middle class, midwestern, middle age men- especially in the rust belt states that decide these elections. Blame hate radio and faux news/ A good 1/3 of union households are voting rethug which sickens me and would have my father and grandfather spinning in their graves. We need Ohio, etc back. The west coast is solidly ours thankfully

murielm99

(30,741 posts)
35. One of the up and coming Democratic women
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 06:19 PM
Jun 2017

in a leadership position is from the district right next to mine. She is midwestern and from a rust belt area.

She was mentored by Durbin, and is someone I have known well for a long time. Her name is Cheri Bustos. Google her.

War Pigs

(252 posts)
38. I certainly will murielm99!!
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 06:44 PM
Jun 2017

politics is about branding and marketing- and the old saying about perception being reality. Obama came out of virtually nowhere to the national scene and gave grumpy mccain and the shrilla from wasilla a good old fashioned butt whippin'

Hekate

(90,686 posts)
55. What the heck are you even talking about, War Pigs? "California elitists"?
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 08:58 PM
Jun 2017

Are you saying that because the GOP has demonized Californians, that no more should be in leadership? That's beyond belief. Has it escaped your notice that a new wave of up and coming leadership is coming feom California? And that *already* the GOP is trying to silence and demonize them?

I'll tell you this: the day I let the GOP determine who I back is the day I'll be kicking up daisies.

War Pigs

(252 posts)
57. I have lived in SoCal and take virtually all my vacations there and in Northern Baja
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 09:50 PM
Jun 2017

people are confusing my opinion of the west coast (I would live there tomorrow!!) with how it is portrayed by the trumptards in the rest of the country due to the rwnj propaganda machine. all I am saying is if we change leadership that Nancy Pelosi has been in the crosshairs a long time.

 

JCanete

(5,272 posts)
29. It's a very important point, that letting the damage Republicans try to do, say to Pelosi, or
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:53 PM
Jun 2017

Hillary Clinton, be the reasons that we abandon our leadership is letting the GOP and the corporate media manipulate our party. Sometimes the damage is done though. Clinton basically stood over the grenade for 15 or so years. Maybe sometimes you need to thank them for their sacrifice and realize they took too effective a hit. Maybe not, I'm conflicted on that point. I'm not conflicted on whether or not they should be entirely vilified by us for at least a huge portion of their unpopularity being manufactured. This is one area where I do not agree with the general consensus at TYT, which conveniently forgets that fact when they talk about the unpopularity of people like Clinton. They shouldn't forget that, because it should be part of their argument. Why do Dems keep playing by the rules laid out for them by corporations who have their hands all over our political system, and coming back for more abuse, rather than calling out the game as rigged?

Those are some of the reasons I want a different direction than Clinton or Pelosi have presented us, but I"m okay with either of them adjusting to different expectations, assuming they can.

As suggested in the article, I wouldn't be surprised if should Pelosi get ousted, we got a conserva-dem as the response. Someone less liberal than Pelosi, just more folksy, and as some have suggested, male. Of course our job would be to demand that that not happen, but yeah, people clamoring for a change about "who not" rather than "who" are making a huge mistake.

octoberlib

(14,971 posts)
30. The fact that Republicans are so desperate to get rid of Nancy Pelosi
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 05:54 PM
Jun 2017

says a lot about how effective she is, imo. And if we replaced her they'd vilify that person, too. It's all they've got.

octoberlib

(14,971 posts)
43. A couple Congressional Democrats of course
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 07:37 PM
Jun 2017

A Democratic lawmaker who supported House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) during her last leadership challenge now says "you'd have to be an idiot" to believe Democrats can take the House back from Republicans with her leading the party.

Rep. Filemon Vela told Politico on Wednesday that Pelosi's leadership makes a Democratic majority in the lower chamber impossible.

“I think you’d have to be an idiot to think we could win the House with Pelosi at the top,” Vela said. The two-term Texas Democrat supported Pelosi over Rep. Tim Ryan (D-Ohio) during leadership elections at the end of last November.


Rep. Kathleen Rice (D-N.Y.) joined Vela's criticism of Pelosi.

"There comes a time when every leader has to say, 'For the good of the order and for the betterment of the party, it’s time for me to step aside.' And I wish that that would happen right now," Rice said. "This is not a personal thing. I want to get back in the majority."

http://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/338835-dem-lawmaker-youd-have-to-be-an-idiot-to-think-dems-can-win-house-with


I don't know if they started it but they're not helping.

Me.

(35,454 posts)
50. The New Group Formed By Tim Ryan & Krystal Ball
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 08:28 PM
Jun 2017

Want their male economic message to reign supreme

meow2u3

(24,764 posts)
34. I propose a Democratic propaganda machine
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 06:14 PM
Jun 2017

We can't win with the facts and logic alone. We MUST appeal to the emotions of the average voter and that means hitting repukes where they live--right in their twisted minds!

If they want to demonize us, two can play that game, especially given the fact that they can't take what they dish out.
If they want to turn decorated war heroes into poltroons with their propaganda, we can turn captains of industry as cannibalistic savages with ours.
If they want to turn our first female Speaker of the House into a magical witch who can be in two places at once, we can turn their turtle-faced Senate Majority leader into a rabid spawn of Satan.
If they want to turn our first black President, who would have been a moderate Republican 30 years ago, into a Kenyan Islamic terrorist, we can turn a real estate hustler-turned-traitor "president" into a depraved serial child killer.
If they want to turn a level-headed, brilliant woman into a freakin' criminal, we can turn a son of a preacher-turned-Senator into a vicious wild animal.
If they want to target our voters, especially young people and minorities, for disenfranchisement with their voter suppression measures, we can target their voter base: conservative Christianists likewise.

Enough turning the other cheek and taking the high road when they have no sense of decency. AFAIC, the gloves are off and this is WAR!!!

MrPurple

(985 posts)
37. The problem is that they have much more propaganda infrastructure
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 06:38 PM
Jun 2017

We don't have an equivalent of Fox News, AM radio, the platform of right wing internet/social media. The right claims that that's the counterpoint to the "liberal" mainstream media, but the MSM actually has journalistic standards of fairness. CNN even bends over backwards to present false equivalence.

MrPurple

(985 posts)
36. I second Tim Ryan and they should have done it in January
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 06:34 PM
Jun 2017

Last edited Wed Jun 21, 2017, 08:50 PM - Edit history (1)

I have no hate for Nancy Pelosi, but it's rebranding. After presenting the same face for 14 years, it's reasonable to change up. Tim Ryan presents really strongly on tv. I've seen him on the Bill Maher panel a couple times. As a younger, meat and potatoes Ohio guy, he'd be a significant image change. To fight through gerrymandering & voter suppression to take back the House, we can't afford any drags on perception.

Rightly or wrongly, Nancy Pelosi has been demonized in much the way Hillary was. She's had her day and it's been 6 1/2 years since we lost the House majority. Maybe keep her on in a leadership role, but it's hard not to acknowledge that some rebranding could help. Bill Clinton was a "new look" Democrat in 1992, so was Obama in 2008. It would be helpful to have a new look carrying our message forward for 2018. A lot of the people that we need to pick up have negative perceptions of Democrats as usual. Those perceptions may be incorrect, but we have to address the marketplace we live in.

 

wasupaloopa

(4,516 posts)
53. How many DUers live in Pelosi's district? If you don't you can't vote to kick her out.
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 08:39 PM
Jun 2017

She passed the most progressive agenda but the Repubs controlled the Senate during Obama's first term.


So if you can't vote her out what are you talking about?

 

wasupaloopa

(4,516 posts)
58. If she is in the House she will lead the Dems
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 09:59 PM
Jun 2017

No one here can make a list of the things she did to get kicked out of leadership.

I would not put my trust in people who have nothing to offer but "let's have a change" without any real ideas about what to change and what to change to.

 

wasupaloopa

(4,516 posts)
62. On The Last Word tonight it was said by Robert
Wed Jun 21, 2017, 11:15 PM
Jun 2017

Costa that Dems in the House do not want to replace Pelosi

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Charles P. Pierce: Okay...