Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
45 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
E X A C T L Y. (Original Post) kpete Jul 2017 OP
+1 liberal N proud Jul 2017 #1
K&R... spanone Jul 2017 #2
Thank you, kpete! SalviaBlue Jul 2017 #3
Right the fuck there! Iggo Jul 2017 #4
But, but............. MyOwnPeace Jul 2017 #5
K&R. nt tblue37 Jul 2017 #6
Incorrect, wrong, and he isn't a doctor snooper2 Jul 2017 #7
This message was self-deleted by its author LittleGirl Jul 2017 #13
When profit is you main focus, not healthcare onit2day Jul 2017 #17
Well, not exactly Mountain Mule Jul 2017 #26
In Canada our taxes pay for healthcare robbob Jul 2017 #28
😪 it's a sin, what private profit does. BlancheSplanchnik Jul 2017 #30
Had the same experience living in Ontario as a teenager B Stieg Jul 2017 #41
So the Swiss, instead of paying their government through taxes, luvtheGWN Jul 2017 #45
I had no idea Hartmann had a PhD. In fact I don't think he finished college. YOHABLO Jul 2017 #8
He has a Ph.D. from Looneytunes U. ucrdem Jul 2017 #12
Ha ha ha. progressoid Jul 2017 #29
He has an honorary degree... Trial_By_Fire Jul 2017 #16
in homeopathy snooper2 Jul 2017 #18
What he claims, I believe, is mostly true. So it would have been better to have said "most". YOHABLO Jul 2017 #38
We're supposed to be the party that respects facts and data.... ehrnst Jul 2017 #9
Nonsense. You're cherry picking. Look at Germany onit2day Jul 2017 #19
Nonsense. The meme didn't say "Germany" ehrnst Jul 2017 #27
Germany (2012), hospitals: 833 public, 1,040 private non-profit, 1,356 private for-profit. ucrdem Jul 2017 #40
Exactement! Mme. Defarge Jul 2017 #10
They probably also don't graduate their MD's with $300K of debt. Barack_America Jul 2017 #11
+1,000!!! AgadorSparticus Jul 2017 #14
K & R cate94 Jul 2017 #15
Thom Hartmann 100% correct Timmygoat Jul 2017 #20
The lobbyists for Big Pharma and Insur Co. are basically killing us help with help from the GOP. BigmanPigman Jul 2017 #21
Just the way Republicans want it... LakeArenal Jul 2017 #22
Yup...we have had generations of people live and die with this system so Bromwell Jul 2017 #23
I've worked for both for and non profit healthcare orgs mcar Jul 2017 #24
They also have better outcomes. Mickju Jul 2017 #25
TickTickTickTickTickTick. Oh I wish benld74 Jul 2017 #31
"For Profit" and "health care" should Lifelong Protester Jul 2017 #32
Dr Thom? Please spare me. GeorgeGist Jul 2017 #33
EXACTLY is right. nt Honeycombe8 Jul 2017 #34
Thom Hartmann has owned for profit businesses IronLionZion Jul 2017 #35
TRUTH southerncrone Jul 2017 #36
that isn't the entire reason dsc Jul 2017 #37
This turns out to be mostly false. ucrdem Jul 2017 #39
When I lived in Australia, they called it . . . MrModerate Jul 2017 #44
k and r...nt Stuart G Jul 2017 #42
And, frighteningly, tens of thousands of medical billing clerks . . . MrModerate Jul 2017 #43

MyOwnPeace

(16,937 posts)
5. But, but.............
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 12:50 PM
Jul 2017

ain't that socialism?
How else am I supposed to support those against my own self-interest?

Response to snooper2 (Reply #7)

 

onit2day

(1,201 posts)
17. When profit is you main focus, not healthcare
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 02:23 PM
Jul 2017

It becomes self evident. Medicare operates at 3% overhead and if everyone had it it would cover dental vision hearing and psy. Nothing is perfict but single payer is the next best thing from it.

Mountain Mule

(1,002 posts)
26. Well, not exactly
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 05:04 PM
Jul 2017

From your link to Wiki: Swiss are required to purchase basic health insurance, which covers a range of treatments detailed in the Swiss Federal Law on Health Insurance... It is therefore the same throughout the country and avoids double standards in healthcare. *** Insurers are required to offer this basic insurance to everyone***, regardless of age or medical condition. ***They are not allowed to make a profit off this basic insurance***, but can on supplemental plans.

The insured person pays the insurance premium for the basic plan up to 8% of their personal income. If a premium is higher than this, ***the government gives the insured person a cash subsidy to pay for any additional premium***.

robbob

(3,538 posts)
28. In Canada our taxes pay for healthcare
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 06:17 PM
Jul 2017

If you are poor or not earning very much money essentially you are paying nothing and are still fully covered for medical care and regular check ups with your doctor. If you are middle-class you might be paying 1 or 2 thousand a year. If you are extremely wealthy (in the multi millionnaire class), you might be paying 10,000 or more to help support the healthcare system.

I have been a student, an unemployed person, a working musician, and a successful computer programmer and at all times my health care needs were fully covered.

I am semi retired now and last year I had a bit of a scare with some chest pain's and shortness of breath. I was admitted to emergency in Ottawa, spent the night there and had multiple tests done at that time which didn't show any problems. Total cost for my nights stay in the hospital? Zero.

Because of the nature of my complaint I was immediately scheduled for multiple tests to determine the health of my heart. Over the next month I had three test done and met with the cardiologist. Thank God nothing was wrong, it appears that it was just a stress related anomaly.

Total cost to me for these tests and the meeting with a specialist? Absolutely nothing. A small minor health care issue that could've easily bankrupted an uninsured American was taken care of professionally, quickly, and for free. The state of health care in your country is a disgrace and a joke. It's time for America to join the rest of the free world in providing healthcare to ALL its citizens.

B Stieg

(2,410 posts)
41. Had the same experience living in Ontario as a teenager
Tue Jul 11, 2017, 05:02 AM
Jul 2017

Never saw a bill for any medical care over the two years my family lived there on my "student" visa (I was playing junior hockey).
And my mom, brother and I weren't even "landed immigrants."

luvtheGWN

(1,336 posts)
45. So the Swiss, instead of paying their government through taxes,
Tue Jul 11, 2017, 12:21 PM
Jul 2017

pay the insurance companies directly, with no shopping around for the lowest premiums, no co-pays, no deductibles, I assume.

We folks up here in the GWN pay through our taxes, for medical coverage -- doctor visits, specialist visits, surgeries (but not for medically unnecessary surgeries such as plastics). Most employers provide supplemental health benefits (vision, dental, drugs, physical therapy etc.) as part of the employment package for full-time employees. Us retirees (depending on the company) may or may not have the same benefits package, and if not, many of us pay for supplemental out of our own pockets (but many do not). Our health insurance companies are extremely "healthy" and in fact some have even bought up American companies (SunLife purchased John Hancock several years ago, for example). So the pols who issue the dire warning that insurance companies will go out of business if universal health insurance is brought in are talking through their hats. And oh yes, pharma companies are restricted in their advertising here. An ad for Cialis or Viagra may show up on TV or in magazines, but you'd never know from the ad exactly what either of them are for. It's quite funny, actually -- a man and a woman in separate bathtubs on a beach -- WTF!!!!!!!!

One quibble I have is that our medicare for all does not cover dental, and since our entire gastroenterology system starts in the mouth, I think it's a big mistake not to cover that part of our anatomy.

The GOP likes to spread many lies about our healthcare system, and never differentiates between waiting lists for elective or non-life-threatening conditions and those -- heart, stroke, cancer, and other life-threatening conditions -- where you automatically go to the head of the line. Gee, could that be why we Canucks can expect to live longer than Americans (according to statistics)?

 

ehrnst

(32,640 posts)
9. We're supposed to be the party that respects facts and data....
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 01:27 PM
Jul 2017

Not factual. And he's not a Dr.

Ireland has a two tier system with public and private payers - which help to relieve costs on the government for the rest of the population.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_the_Republic_of_Ireland

In Israel, in the area of medications for serious illnesses, private insurance companies give access to a wider range of than the official "basket of medications", as the Israeli government is not financially capable of covering all medications.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Israel#Private_healthcare

Just because it confirms your bias doesn't make it true. We have facts on our side, so we don't need alternative facts.

 

ehrnst

(32,640 posts)
27. Nonsense. The meme didn't say "Germany"
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 06:00 PM
Jul 2017

The meme said "No other country in the developed world," not "many other countries in the developed world, such a Germany..."

Read it again. I'm not cherry picking, I'm just pointing out incorrect generalizations.

As I said - we're supposed to be the party of facts, respecting data. Why not just use facts?

And Thom Hartmann isn't a doctor, either.


Barack_America

(28,876 posts)
11. They probably also don't graduate their MD's with $300K of debt.
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 01:30 PM
Jul 2017

The other part of this is our for-profit higher education system.

Timmygoat

(779 posts)
20. Thom Hartmann 100% correct
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 02:37 PM
Jul 2017

I am originally from the UK, have lived in other European countries, never seen anyone worried about the cost of health care, it is either -no cost, or a small fraction of the cost, different European countries have slightly different approaches, but they are all pretty good. Canada is pretty good too. I was astonished when I first learned about the cost of US healthcare, and that people make a profit from illness. The cost of administration is all that happens in many country, the doctors are paid a good salary but do not expect massive salaries like in the US.
I think stockholders in the large insurance companies are like vultures picking the bones of the sick.

Bromwell

(123 posts)
23. Yup...we have had generations of people live and die with this system so
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 03:28 PM
Jul 2017

Most Americans don't even question it. Its just "the way it is".

mcar

(42,372 posts)
24. I've worked for both for and non profit healthcare orgs
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 03:30 PM
Jul 2017

This is absolutely correct. Profit has no business in healthcare.

IronLionZion

(45,516 posts)
35. Thom Hartmann has owned for profit businesses
Mon Jul 10, 2017, 09:42 PM
Jul 2017

I'd like to get universal medicare for all too but posting complete BS on an image isn't going to get it for us.

It's going to take a bit more effort. Getting people to vote, winning elections, the ramming it through with a simple majority because we no longer need 60 votes to pass controversial legislation. And a Dem president to sign it into law. And some good messaging to get people to want it and understand why it's good for our country

Here's a good bill to start with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Health_Care_Act

dsc

(52,166 posts)
37. that isn't the entire reason
Tue Jul 11, 2017, 12:32 AM
Jul 2017

Insurance companies are certainly a part of the reason we pay more. But we pay close to twice as much and insurance only takes about 25%. Hospitals are a big problem. Medical supply and drug companies are a big problem. Guns are also a big problem (one study said LA paid more for care of gun patients than it spent on its entire Medicaid program).

ucrdem

(15,512 posts)
39. This turns out to be mostly false.
Tue Jul 11, 2017, 03:46 AM
Jul 2017

With the exception of Canada, for-profit private health insurance remains almost universally present in developed countries, including those with universal-access health care schemes, to deliver supplemental, elective, expedited, and/or alternative care, including Australia, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden, and Switzerland, whose health-care outcomes are analyzed in this November 2015 Canadian study:

https://www.fraserinstitute.org/sites/default/files/for-profit-hospitals-and-insurers-in-universal-health-care-countries.pdf

That took a lot longer to explain than to find in google. Maybe Dr. Thom needs to brush up in Facebookology?


 

MrModerate

(9,753 posts)
44. When I lived in Australia, they called it . . .
Tue Jul 11, 2017, 08:16 AM
Jul 2017

"Extras cover." It gets you slightly more comfortable treatment and adds things like dental, wellness treatment, etc. Its cost is modest (maybe AUD 200/month for a family), and is often included in people's pay packets as a recruiting tool.

But it's a relatively small segment of the market compared to primary care, in which insurance companies have nearly no impact.

 

MrModerate

(9,753 posts)
43. And, frighteningly, tens of thousands of medical billing clerks . . .
Tue Jul 11, 2017, 08:13 AM
Jul 2017

Whose profession is threatened, but whose work adds no value and keeps the blood flowing for the ghouls.

They'll need to be retrained to useful work when the insurance companies are forced out of healthcare funding.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»E X A C T L Y.